EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Fuzzy instanton (complex no-boundary saddle geometry; hypothetical)

The complex extremizing geometries of the no-boundary sum over histories: 'In general these solutions will be complex: fuzzy instantons'. 'In this regime we can therefore think of these extremizing geometries as fuzzy instantons in which there is a transition from a real Euclidean geometry at the South Pole to an asymptotically real Lorentzian geometry at large volume. The transition is not sharp as in the zero scalar field case, but rather spread out over a region.' They 'are distinct from the Lorentzian histories in the classical ensemble for which they provide probabilities'. Walked as projected structure (representation).

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

aliasesFuzzy instanton (complex saddle-point geometry)
boundaryInside: one complex 4-geometry and scalar field from the South Pole (lambda = 0, regular, Euclidean) to the boundary three-surface (lambda = 1) where a = b and phi = chi, and the perturbations on it. Outside: the classical Lorentzian history it weights, which lives 'on different manifolds'; the wave function that sums the saddles.
nested levelBuilt from a Euclidean cap, a near-de Sitter Lorentzian section, the scalar field and Lambda; embedded in the no-boundary wave function as its saddle points. A kind of gravitational instanton (complex). Rung 0, hypothesised; below the first fold.
representationTrue
scalecosmological

Measures (5) published science

boundary and regularity conditions8 real conditions for 4 real second-order equations, plus 2 real constraints; no free parameters count
lower bound on phi0 for classical histories (Lambda -> 0)1.27 phi_c0 (model units)
I_R at large phi0-> 0 as ~ 1/phi_R(0)^2 action (model units)
curvature radius of the saddle~ sqrt(3/V(phi_SP^R)) = sqrt(6)/(m phi_SP^R), larger than the Planck length when V is well below the Planck scale length (Planck units)
characteristic clock: Hubble radius of the near-de Sitter sectionsqrt(3/V) time (Planck units)

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (5)

Sits inside / holds (2)

Trades with (valence) (6)

expressed by (1)

floor filled by (12)

represents (1)

Kinds (3)

wired (1)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

complex saddle geometry: Euclidean South Pole to Lorentzian large volume (spacetime)

  1. L1: Domain and conditions: from 'the center of symmetry of the geometry on the 3-disk at lambda = 0 (called the South Pole (SP))' to the boundary at lambda = 1; regularity a(0) = 0, phi'(0) = 0 and boundary values a(1) = b, phi(1) = chi: 'eight real conditions for the four real second order equations' plus 'two real constraint conditions'.
  2. L2: No free parameters: 'there are no free parameters in the boundary conditions'; 'whether the solutions are real or complex is not up to us; it is determined by the equations and the boundary conditions'. 'there are no real extrema when the scalar field is non-zero except for special false-vacuum potentials'; Lehners adds that solutions are labelled by the scalar field at the South Pole, 'This value will be complex in general.'
  3. L3: Fuzzy transition: 'a transition from a real Euclidean geometry at the South Pole to an asymptotically real Lorentzian geometry at large volume. The transition is not sharp as in the zero scalar field case, but rather spread out over a region'; at large phi0 'only a small complex part at the SP is required to reach real b and chi at late times'.
  4. L4: Weight: the action I(b, chi) = I_R(b, chi) - iS(b, chi); relative probabilities exp(-2 I_R); the real part 'tends to a finite value at the lower bound phi_c0 that arises from the classicality condition, and it goes to zero as ~ 1/phi_R(0)^2 at large phi0'; 'the NBWF universally favors histories with phi0 near the lower bound phi_c0'.
  5. L5: Hand-off: 'The values of a and phi together with their derivatives at the boundary provide Cauchy data for the ensemble of classical Lorentzian histories'; the fuzzy instantons 'are distinct from the Lorentzian histories in the classical ensemble for which they provide probabilities through the real part of their complex action'; 'the classical histories and extremizing histories are on different manifolds'.

perturbations on the saddle geometry (gravitational field)

  1. L1: Tensor perturbations on the saddle: Lehners computes 'the wave function for tensor perturbations on a Hartle-Hawking saddle point geometry'.
  2. L2: Vacuum fixed by regularity: 'we did not have to assume the initial Bunch-Davies vacuum state ... rather, regularity at the South Pole forced us to choose this solution. Thus the no-boundary wave function automatically implies the Bunch-Davies state for perturbations.'
  3. L3: Stable and unstable saddles: 'because the Einstein equations are real, the complex conjugates of these geometries are also solutions'; on the conjugate saddle (regularity condition from a-dot = +i to a-dot = -i) 'the distribution of perturbations would be given by an inverse Gaussian' and the wave function 'is not normalisable'; 'we term such saddle points unstable, and they must be avoided'.
  4. L4: Arrow from the South Pole: Hawking, Laflamme and Lyons 'show that regularity conditions at the South Pole imply that the fluctuations in the extremizing solutions are small there and therefore increase away from the South Pole because they have nowhere to go but up'.

Sources (2) published science

Hartle, J.B., Hawking, S.W. and Hertog, T. (2008). The Classical Universes of the No-Boundary Quantum State. (arXiv:0803.1663v1, 11 Mar 2008)
Lehners, J.-L. (2023; v3 2024). Review of the No-Boundary Wave Function. (arXiv:2303.08802v3, 'Preprint submitted to Elsevier') (behind its links)