← all systems · see it in The System
Quantum sum over causal sets
The quantum dynamics proposed for causal set theory: 'A CST dynamics is given by the measure triple (Omega, A, mu) where A is an event algebra and mu is either a classical or a quantum measure'; in its continuum-inspired form 'the quantum partition function is Z = sum over c in Omega of exp(iS(c)/hbar), where S(c) is an action for causal sets', the natural choice being the Benincasa-Dowker action 'which limits to the Einstein-Hilbert action in the continuum'. Wikipedia: 'One approach to developing a quantum dynamics for causal sets has been to apply an action principle in the sum-over-causal sets approach.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Quantum sum over causal sets (Benincasa-Dowker action) |
| boundary | Inside: the sample space of causal sets (past-finite for cosmology, fixed cardinality n for a unimodular-type dynamics with the Einstein-Hilbert action, or dimensionally restricted such as 2-orders), the causal set action, the quantum measure or decoherence functional, and the resulting partition function and expectation values. Outside: the classical stochastic growth models (CSG, a 'half way house'), the kinematics (geometric reconstruction of manifold-like causal sets), and phenomenology. |
| nested level | The dynamics part of causal set theory; it sums over causal sets (sys:causal-set) with weights from a discrete action that limits to the Einstein-Hilbert action; it generalises classical sequential growth by replacing probabilities with a quantum measure. |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (9) published science
| size of the sample space of n-element causal sets | ~ 2^(n^2/4) to leading order count |
| onset of the Kleitman-Rothschild regime (uniform measure, MCMC) | n ~ 90 elements |
| size of the 2-order sample space | ~ n!/2 count |
| 2d asymptotic regime reached | n ~ 80 elements |
| simulation size with updated algorithms | n ~ 300 elements |
| order of the 2d phase transition | first order (finite-size scaling, Glaser et al. 2018) class |
| observed cosmological constant (for the everpresent-Lambda argument, unimodular kinematics) | ~ 2.888 x 10^-122 Planck units |
| Sorkin prediction of Lambda (1987-1991, before 1998) | ~ 10^-120 Planck units |
| characteristic clock: none (a sum over whole histories; the growth sibling counts stages) | no value given stage |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
- Causal set (causet; hypothetical discrete spacetime)
- Benincasa-Dowker action
- Quantum measure (decoherence functional)
Sits inside / holds (2)
- Causal set theory (causal sets programme; walked as a projected model)
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
Trades with (valence) (5)
- Causal set theory (causal sets programme; walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Quantum sum over causal sets gain
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical) via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum sum over causal sets gain
- Classical sequential growth (CSG) dynamics via sys:spacetime · Quantum sum over causal sets gain
- Causal set (causet; hypothetical discrete spacetime) via sys:spacetime · Quantum sum over causal sets gain
- Einstein-Hilbert action via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum sum over causal sets gain
floor filled by (11)
- Causal set theory (causal sets programme; walked as a projected model)
- No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical)
- Causal set (causet; hypothetical discrete spacetime)
- Benincasa-Dowker action
- Quantum measure (decoherence functional)
- Quantum sequential growth (QSG)
- 2d causal set quantum gravity (2-orders)
- Kleitman-Rothschild poset
- Bilayer poset
- Einstein-Hilbert action
- Ising spins on a causal set
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
- Causal set theory (causal sets programme; walked as a projected model)
- Quantum sequential growth (QSG)
- 2d causal set quantum gravity (2-orders)
Notes published science
- In 2d causal set quantum gravity a smooth spacetime appears as one phase of a sum over all orders, with a first-order transition to a crystal-like non-manifold phase, much like an Ising magnet; and the smooth phase comes with a negative cosmological constant generated by the dynamics.
- The no-boundary wave function computed on causal sets, in its low-temperature phase, grows from a single element to a large antichain fast, with every element linked to all of its immediate past, rudiments of an early universe.
- Sorkin's causal-set argument put the cosmological constant at about 10^-120 in Planck units years before the 1998 observation (observed: about 2.888 x 10^-122).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
quantum sum over causal sets (projected model)
- L1: Sample space Omega of locally finite posets: past-finite countable causal sets (cosmology), fixed cardinality n (unimodular-type), or dimensionally restricted (2-orders); |Omega_n| grows to leading order like 2^(n^2/4)
- L2: The action: the d-dimensional Benincasa-Dowker action S_BD(c), built from retarded nonlocal operators that approximate Box - R/2 on causal sets approximated by curved spacetimes; it 'limits to the Einstein-Hilbert action in the continuum'
- L3: The weights: Z = sum over c of exp(iS(c)/hbar), or a quantum measure obeying the quantum sum rule mu(a u b u c) = mu(a u b) + mu(a u c) + mu(b u c) - mu(a) - mu(b) - mu(c), from a decoherence functional (Hermitian, biadditive, normalised, strongly positive)
- L4: The entropy problem: non-manifold-like Kleitman-Rothschild posets ('approximately just three moments of time') dominate Omega_n; the uniform-measure onset of that regime is near n = 90 (Henson et al. 2017); bilayer posets (the next subdominant class) are 'strictly suppressed' by the BD action when the parameters mu lambda_0 satisfy a stated inequality (Loomis and Carlip 2018, Eq. 86)
- L5: Results in 2d (2-orders, beta analytically continued): a first-order phase transition from a continuum phase at low beta to a non-manifold-like phase at high beta (Surya 2012; Glaser et al. 2018); the continuum phase corresponds to a negative cosmological constant; the no-boundary wave function peaks on small antichains at low beta and jumps to antichains of about n/2 at high beta; asymptotic already near n = 80; n near 300 now simulable
- L6: Matter: Ising spins s_i = +-1 on the elements coupled along links, S_I(j) = j sum s_i s_k L_ik (Glaser 2018); phase structure 'substantially richer'