← all systems · see it in The System
Distinguishing spacetime
A spacetime is called distinguishing 'when it is both future and past distinguishing, that is, when each point is determined (distinguished) by its chronological future and also by its chronological past': I-(p) = I-(q) implies p = q, and I+(p) = I+(q) implies p = q.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Distinguishing spacetime (causal ladder rung 4 of 9) |
| boundary | Inside: every Lorentzian manifold (M,g) satisfying the condition (each point is determined by its chronological future and by its chronological past), together with every stronger rung of the causal ladder, which all satisfy it. Outside: Lorentzian manifolds that fail it (some of them still causal, the rung below); the dynamics of the metric (sys:gravitational-field) and whatever moves on it. |
| nested level | Rung 4 of the nine-level causal ladder of sys:lorentzian-manifold (from weakest to strongest: non-totally vicious, chronological, causal, distinguishing, strongly causal, stably causal, causally continuous, causally simple, globally hyperbolic). A condition on the manifold's causal-structure floor (lorentzian-manifold L5, spacetime L3); its stack is on sys:spacetime. |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| rungs in the causal ladder | 9 count |
| position of this class on the ladder (weakest = 1) | 4 rung |
| ladder established / collected | late 1970s (works of Carter, Geroch, Hawking, Kronheimer, Penrose, Sachs, Seifert, Wu); first collected in Beem-Ehrlich (1981) date |
| dimension of the Lorentzian manifolds classified | n0 >= 2 (physical spacetime 4) count |
| characteristic clock: proper time along causal curves (the class has no clock of its own) | arclength of each timelike curve |
| halves of the condition (past-, future-distinguishing) | 2 count |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Distinguishing spacetime. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same shape, opposite sign (structural)
Past- and future-distinguishing mirror each other (I-(p) = I-(q) implies p = q; I+(p) = I+(q) implies p = q) and can come apart in one spacetime. - nested ladder (partial)
Nine classes, 'each one of which is strictly stronger than the previous', every member of a higher rung a member of all lower ones, each gap shown by an explicit counterexample spacetime: 'the total order provided by the standard hierarchy' (Minguzzi and Sanchez), against which the isocausal ladder - same role, different builds (partial)
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): injective I+-, small neighbourhoods causal curves do not re-enter.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (14) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Causal spacetime via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines) via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime gain
- Strongly causal spacetime via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
- Causal future (absolute future) via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
- Causal past (absolute past) via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
- Chronological future I+(x) via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime gain
- Chronological past I-(x) via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime gain
- Causal space (Kronheimer and Penrose 1967) via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime gain
- Reflecting spacetime via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
- Past-distinguishing spacetime via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
- Future-distinguishing spacetime via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
- Non-imprisoning spacetime via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime gain
- Feebly distinguishing spacetime via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
- Weakly distinguishing spacetime via sys:spacetime · Distinguishing spacetime even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Causal future (absolute future)
- Causal past (absolute past)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (15)
- Causal spacetime
- Spacetime
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Strongly causal spacetime
- Causal future (absolute future)
- Causal past (absolute past)
- World line
- Spacetime event
- Chronological future I+(x)
- Chronological past I-(x)
- Reflecting spacetime
- Past-distinguishing spacetime
- Future-distinguishing spacetime
- Non-imprisoning spacetime
- Feebly distinguishing spacetime
represents (1)
Kinds (5)
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Causal spacetime
- Past-distinguishing spacetime
- Future-distinguishing spacetime
- Strongly causal spacetime
Notes published science
- An event is known by its past: in a past-distinguishing spacetime 'two points which share the same chronological past are the same point'. Its identity is the set of everything that could have reached it.
- An event is known by its past: in a past-distinguishing spacetime 'two points which share the same chronological past are the same point'.
- In a distinguishing spacetime the order alone rebuilds the geometry: J+ 'determines the metric, up to a conformal factor' (Remark 3.14). Who-can-influence-whom is enough to recover the light cones.
- Past and future can distinguish separately: remove one point and a half line from a cylinder and you get a spacetime that tells events apart by their pasts but not by their futures.
- A point is its future: in a future-distinguishing spacetime 'two points which share the same chronological future are the same point'.
- A point is its past: in a past-distinguishing spacetime 'two points which share the same chronological past are the same point'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
distinguishing spacetime (causal condition on the spacetime manifold)
- L1: The Lorentzian manifold's events and light cones (its conformal class): 'a Lorentzian manifold is a smooth manifold M, of dimension n0 >= 2, endowed with a non-degenerate metric g ... of signature (-,+,...,+)'; every causality condition depends only on the cones
- L2: The chronological future and past of each event, I+(p) and I-(p), read as set-valued maps from M into the set P(M) of its subsets
- L3: The condition: the maps p -> I+(p) and p -> I-(p) are one to one; equivalently, for any neighbourhood U of p there is a neighbourhood V of p such that no future-directed (or past-directed) causal curve from p meets V more than once
- L4: Consequences: 'in a distinguishing spacetime, J+ (as well as I+) determines the metric, up to a conformal factor' (Proposition 3.13, Remark 3.14); a continuous curve is causal iff it is totally ordered by < (Proposition 3.19); 'past (resp. future) distinguishing if and only if t- (resp. t+) is a generalized time function' (Theorem 3.51)
- L5: Place in the ladder: implies causal; strongly causal spacetimes 'are distinguishing (but the converse does not hold, see Fig. 7)'; the two halves (past- and future-distinguishing) can come apart (Fig. 6 with a vertical half line removed)
Who fills each layer
Sources (6) published science
Causal structure (Wikipedia, rev 1375920903, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Surya, S. The causal set approach to quantum gravity, Living Reviews in Relativity 22, 5 (2019), doi:10.1007/s41114-019-0023-1 (arXiv:1903.11544) (behind its links)