EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Misner-Sharp(-Hernandez) mass

The quasi-local energy of a round sphere in a spherically symmetric spacetime: 'The Misner-Sharp spherically symmetric gravitational energy, or simply the energy, may be defined in units G = 1 by E = (1/2) r (1 - g^-1(dr, dr)) = (1/2) r + (1/4) e^f r^3 theta+ theta-' (Hayward), equivalently 1 - 2M/R = nabla^c R nabla_c R, 'an invariant quantity of the 2-space normal to the 2-spheres of symmetry'; 'The Misner-Sharp-Hernandez mass is only defined for spherically symmetric spacetimes' (Faraoni).

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

boundaryInside: the energy E assigned to each round sphere of symmetry, from the sphere's areal radius and the product of its two null expansions, with its flux law and the trapping test it sets. Outside: non-spherical spacetimes (where it is not defined), the matter whose stress-energy changes it, and the horizons it locates.
nested levelA kind of mass: the quasi-local gravitational energy of spherical symmetry. Built from the areal radius and the expansions; embedded in spherically symmetric spacetimes (FLRW, Schwarzschild, Vaidya, fluid stars). Field scale, rung 1.
scalefield

Measures (9) published science

definition (G = 1)E = (1/2) r (1 - g^-1(dr, dr)) = (1/2) r + (1/4) e^f r^3 theta+ theta- length (geometric units)
trapping thresholdstrapped E > r/2; marginal E = r/2; untrapped E < r/2 ratio
flux lawd+-E = 4 pi e^f r^2 (T+- d+-r - T+-+- d-+r) geometric units
FLRW valueM = (R^3/2)(H^2 + k/a^2) = (4 pi/3) R^3 rho geometric units
FLRW apparent horizon from R_AH = 2MR_AH = 1/sqrt(H^2 + k/a^2) length
comoving sphere in FLRWM-dot = -4 pi H R_s^3 P geometric units
regular centreE = O(r^3) order
introducedMisner and Sharp, Phys. Rev. 136 (1964) 571; Hernandez and Misner, Astrophys. J. 143 reference
characteristic clock: none of its own; E changes only as matter flows (flux law), and in vacuo stays constantnone

Open contentions (1) open contention

Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (2)

Sits inside / holds (2)

Trades with (valence) (9)

expressed by (1)

floor filled by (14)

represents (1)

Kinds (1)

wired (1)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

Misner-Sharp energy and its matter flux (stress-energy)

  1. L1: The matter of spherical symmetry, T = p r^2 dOmega^2 + T++ (d xi+)^2 + T-- (d xi-)^2 + 2 T+- d xi+ d xi-, coupled through the Einstein equations (10a-c)
  2. L2: The flux law: d+-E = 4 pi e^f r^2 (T+- d+-r - T+-+- d-+r) = 2 pi e^f r^3 (T+- theta+- - T+-+- theta-+); in FLRW M = (4 pi/3) R^3 rho, and for a comoving sphere M-dot = -4 pi H R_s^3 P
  3. L3: Under the dominant energy condition: on an untrapped sphere 'E is non-decreasing (respectively non-increasing) in any outgoing (respectively ingoing) spatial or null direction'; hence E >= 0 with a regular centre and E >= (1/2) r_0 outside a marginal sphere (the Penrose inequality for black or white holes)
  4. L4: Horizon thermodynamics: E is 'almost universally adopted as the internal energy U in horizon thermodynamics'; with the Kodama-Hayward temperature and the areal volume 4 pi R^3/3 it enters the 'unified 1st law' (Faraoni); 'although this point may be considered debatable by some'

Misner-Sharp mass (own: the quasi-local energy of a round sphere; spacetime)

  1. L1: Round spheres of symmetry: ds^2 = h_ab dx^a dx^b + R^2 dOmega^2_(2) (Faraoni), or in double-null form ds^2 = r^2 dOmega^2 - 2 e^-f d xi+ d xi- with r the areal radius (Hayward)
  2. L2: The energy: E = (1/2) r (1 - g^-1(dr, dr)) = (1/2) r + (1/4) e^f r^3 theta+ theta-; equivalently 1 - 2M/R = nabla^c R nabla_c R; 'Note that E is an invariant'
  3. L3: The trapping test: 'trapped if and only if E > (1/2) r, marginal if and only if E = (1/2) r, and untrapped if and only if E < (1/2) r'; a central singularity is trapped if E > 0 nearby; in FLRW R_AH = 2M gives R_AH = 1/sqrt(H^2 + k/a^2)
  4. L4: Limits: in vacuo E is constant, the Schwarzschild energy; at null and spatial infinity E reduces to the Bondi-Sachs and ADM energies; Newtonian limit of a perfect fluid gives 'the Newtonian mass to leading order'; small spheres give 'the product of volume and the energy density of the matter'; coincides with the Hawking quasi-local energy in spherical symmetry
  5. L5: Noether charge: the Kodama vector is divergence-free, so J^a = G^ab K_b is conserved (the 'Kodama miracle'); 'the Noether charge associated with the Kodama current is the Misner-Sharp-Hernandez energy of spacetime'

Sources (3) published science

Hayward, S. A. Gravitational energy in spherical symmetry, arXiv:gr-qc/9408002v2 (revised 6 November 1995; abstract, sections I-III read)
Faraoni, V. Cosmological apparent and trapping horizons, arXiv 1106.4427v1 (22 June 2011; arXiv version read) (behind its links)
Mass in general relativity (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched 2026-10-28): ADM and Bondi masses, BMS and SPI groups (behind its links)