← all systems · see it in The System
Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS)
'A closed, spacelike, two-surface for which the outgoing null expansion theta(l) = 0' (Booth, following Hayward's terminology); in Senovilla's table of outer-trapped surfaces theta+ = 0 is the 'null dual or M+TS (or MOTS)'. No condition is put on the ingoing expansion. It is 'the primary building block' of the quasilocal horizons, and in numerical relativity 'black holes are widely identified with outermost marginally trapped surfaces'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: one closed spacelike two-surface, its two null normal directions (outgoing l, ingoing n) and the vanishing of the outgoing expansion. Outside: the slice it sits in, the tube (MOTT) it sweeps out in time, the trapped surfaces 'just inside' it when it is stable, and the black hole and event horizon it marks. |
| nested level | Built from null normals (null geodesics) on a closed spacelike surface; a kind of the trapped-surface family (the marginal, outer case); stacked in time it makes marginally outer trapped tubes, which include dynamical, isolated and trapping horizons; the outermost one on a slice is the numerical 'apparent horizon'. |
| scale | field |
Measures (7) published science
| dimension | 2 (closed spacelike surface) count |
| defining condition | theta(l) = 0; theta(n) unrestricted condition |
| final black-hole mass from apparent-horizon data (Pretorius run, high resolution) | 1.90 M0 (low 1.77, medium 1.85) M0 (mass of one initial hole) |
| final spin parameter from horizon data | 0.70 (low 0.74, medium 0.73) dimensionless a |
| energy radiated from the drop in horizon mass | around 5% of 2 M0 fraction |
| GW150914 remnant (inspiral-merger-ringdown with NR relations) | M_f = 68 +/- 4 M_sun (62 +/- 4 source frame), a_f = 0.67 +0.05 -0.07, 90% confidence M_sun; dimensionless |
| characteristic clock: orbital angular velocity of the evolved binary | 0.023 / M0 (merged within about one orbit) 1/M0 |
Open contentions (2) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-027 Do black holes really have event horizons?
booked: The map follows general relativity: black holes have event horizons. Hawking's 2014 suggestion of apparent horizons only is kept alongside.
the other reading: B: collapse makes apparent horizons but no event horizons - C-106 When a black hole forms in a simulation, does its horizon really jump, or is it one surface weaving back in time?
booked: The map follows the simulations' description of a horizon that jumps as new ones form, and keeps the single-weaving-surface reading alongside.
the other reading: B: one (or a few) marginally trapped tubes 'weaving backwards and forwards in time', seen piecewise by the slicing (Booth 2005)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
One job (saying where a black hole is) done by a quasilocal surface found on each slice (outermost MOTS) and by the global event horizon, which 'can be (approximately) located, but only retroactively after a simulation is complete'. - seed (structural)
One strictly stable MOTS on one slice unpacks into a whole tube through the later slices (existence theorem).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (13) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Outer trapped surface (OTS) via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) gain
- Weakly outer trapped surface (WOTS) via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) gain
- Outer untrapped surface via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) gain
- Weakly outer untrapped (weakly +-untrapped) surface via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) gain
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) gain
- Apparent horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) even
- Gravitational wave via sys:gravitational-field · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) loss
- Trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) even
- Trapping horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) even
- Dynamical horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) gain
- Isolated horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) even
- Untrapped surface via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) gain
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
- Null geodesic
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (20)
- Trapped surface
- Outer trapped surface (OTS)
- Weakly outer trapped surface (WOTS)
- Outer untrapped surface
- Weakly outer untrapped (weakly +-untrapped) surface
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Photon
- Black hole
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Event horizon
- Apparent horizon
- Binary black hole
- Gravitational wave
- Null geodesic
- Trapping horizon
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
- Untrapped surface
represents (1)
Kinds (6)
- Apparent horizon
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Trapped surface
- Weakly outer trapped surface (WOTS)
- Weakly outer untrapped (weakly +-untrapped) surface
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
wired (2)
Notes published science
- The black holes in the simulations behind gravitational-wave templates are not event horizons at all: codes track the outermost MOTS on each slice, because the event horizon can only be found 'retroactively after a simulation is complete'.
- Pretorius 2005 weighed the merged hole by its horizon area and spin alone (Smarr formula): about 1.9 M0, so about 5% of the mass left as waves.
- A strictly stable MOTS on one slice guarantees a whole tube of them through later slices, for as long as it stays strictly stable.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
horizon mass and spin read from a MOTS (gravitational field)
- L1: The surface's area A and angular momentum J, read on the apparent horizons of an evolving binary ('calculated from apparent horizon (AH) properties')
- L2: Smarr formula: M = sqrt(M_ir^2 + J^2/(4 M_ir^2)), M_ir = sqrt(A/16 pi); final hole M_f about 1.9 M0 with a about 0.70 (high resolution); the jump from initial to final horizon masses 'suggests around 5%' radiated
- L3: Checked against the waves: for GW150914 the remnant's mass and spin from inspiral and from post-inspiral phases 'are mutually consistent with the binary black-hole solution in general relativity'
marginally outer trapped surface (own, closed spacelike two-surface)
- L1: A closed spacelike two-surface with outgoing (l) and ingoing (n) null normal directions, inside a spacelike slice of a foliation Sigma_t
- L2: The defining condition: outgoing null expansion theta(l) = 0, with no condition on theta(n) (Booth Table 1: MOTS, 2-dimensional, closed topology)
- L3: Stability: the stability operator L_v, 'defined by delta_psi v theta = L_v psi'; a strictly stable MOTS has positive principal eigenvalue; strictly stably outermost (SSO) means trapped surfaces 'just inside' S0
- L4: Propagation: 'given a strictly stable MOTS S0 in Sigma0 ... there is an open marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT), adapted to the reference foliation, which contains S0'; under energy conditions the MOTT is 'locally achronal, spacelike or null'; a null MOTT with the energy condition is an isolated horizon
- L5: Use as a black-hole marker: numerical relativity identifies black holes with outermost MOTSs; 'Event horizons can be (approximately) located, but only retroactively'; MTSs lie inside any event horizon (asymptotically flat), so the inside can be excised; the numerical 'apparent horizon' 'sometimes seen to discontinuously jump as new horizons form around old'
outgoing light at a MOTS (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Light rays leaving the surface along its outgoing and ingoing null normals
- L2: Outgoing rays 'instantaneously parallel' on the surface (theta+ = 0): neither spreading nor converging; diverging just outside and converging just inside when it is outer (Hayward's FOTH reading)
Who fills each layer
- L2: Outer trapped surface (OTS), Outer untrapped surface
- L3: Weakly outer trapped surface (WOTS)
- L4: Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT), Weakly outer untrapped (weakly +-untrapped) surface
- L5: Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT), Outer trapped surface (OTS), Weakly outer trapped surface (WOTS)