← all systems · see it in The System
Untrapped surface
A closed spacelike two-surface whose two future null expansions have opposite signs, theta+ theta- < 0 (Senovilla Table 3, 'untrapped'; mean curvature vector spacelike). The round two-sphere in Minkowski space is the standard case: 'the ingoing set of null rays would focus (theta(n) < 0) while the outgoing set would expand (theta(l) > 0). This is what one would intuitively expect' (Booth).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: one closed spacelike two-surface and the signs of its two null expansions (opposite). Outside: the region it encloses, the light that leaves it, the horizons it may sit outside of, and the neighbouring sign classes (trapped, marginal, weakly untrapped). |
| nested level | A sign class of closed spacelike surfaces; built from the surface and its two null normals; sits on the flat or curved spacetime geometry; the outside wall for MOTS and trapping horizons. |
| scale | field |
Measures (5) published science
| dimension | 2 (closed spacelike surface; co-dimension two) count |
| sign condition | theta+ theta- < 0 sign |
| closed trapped surfaces in flat spacetime | none (T is empty), so every round sphere there is untrapped count |
| related kinds in Senovilla's Table 3 | 7 rows (untrapped, weakly untrapped, half diverging, weakly +-untrapped, B-surfaces, null B-surfaces, null untrapped) count |
| characteristic clock: none | an instant: a surface in spacetime with no own evolution; families of them are labelled by a foliation parameter (no value given) |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (11)
- Weakly untrapped surface via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface gain
- Outer untrapped surface via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface even
- Weakly outer untrapped (weakly +-untrapped) surface via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface gain
- Weakly trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface even
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Untrapped surface even
- Minkowski spacetime via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface gain
- Trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface even
- Trapping horizon via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface even
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface even
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface) via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface gain
- Mean curvature vector via sys:spacetime · Untrapped surface gain
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (14)
- Marginally past-trapped surface
- Weakly untrapped surface
- Outer untrapped surface
- Weakly outer untrapped (weakly +-untrapped) surface
- Photon
- Apparent horizon
- Minkowski spacetime
- Trapped surface
- Null geodesic
- Trapping horizon
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS)
- Weakly trapped surface
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
- Mean curvature vector
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
- Weakly untrapped surface
- Outer untrapped surface
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
Notes published science
- The everyday case is the untrapped one: a sphere in empty flat space sends light inward converging and outward spreading, 'what one would intuitively expect'. Trapping is the strange case where both go inward.
- Horizon finders use untrapped surfaces as one wall of a vice: a MOTS is guaranteed to exist between an outer trapped surface and an outer untrapped one.
- An open puzzle Senovilla lists: nobody knows whether flat Minkowski space can hold a closed B-surface.
- Horizon finders squeeze a MOTS out of a vice: an outer untrapped surface outside, an outer trapped one inside, and a marginal surface must lie between.
- A version of the Penrose inequality using null untrapped surfaces was proposed and then fell to a counterexample.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
light from the surface (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Ingoing and outgoing light flashes leaving the surface orthogonally (its two null normal congruences)
- L2: Ingoing light converges (theta(n) < 0) and outgoing light spreads (theta(l) > 0): signals from the surface can reach far away, unlike a trapped surface where 'all signals from the surface are trapped inside a shrinking region' (Hayward)
untrapped surface (own, closed spacelike two-surface)
- L1: A closed (compact, no boundary) spacelike two-surface, 'usually topological spheres', with two future-pointing null normal directions k+ and k- (Senovilla); the two-sphere embedded in Minkowski space is the standard case (Booth)
- L2: The two null expansions theta+ and theta- and the mean curvature vector H, whose causal orientation 'provides a better and powerful characterization' of trapping (Senovilla's arrow notation)
- L3: The untrapped test: theta+ theta- < 0, H spacelike (symbol: arrow left or right) (Senovilla Table 3); ingoing light focuses, outgoing light expands, 'what one would intuitively expect' (Booth)
- L4: Neighbouring kinds: weakly untrapped (theta+ >= 0, theta- <= 0 or the reverse), half diverging or +-untrapped ('outer untrapped', theta+ > 0), weakly +-untrapped (theta+ >= 0), null untrapped ('generalized apparent horizon') and B-surfaces (theta+ theta- >= 0) (Senovilla Table 3)
- L5: Use in locating horizons: MOTS exist 'between outer trapped and outer untrapped surfaces' (Senovilla, citing Andersson and Metzger); surfaces just outside a compact marginal surface on a trapping horizon are not trapped (Hayward Theorem 6); 'there cannot be null untrapped closed surfaces embedded in spacelike hypersurfaces of Minkowski spacetime' (Senovilla)
Who fills each layer
- L1: Weakly outer untrapped (weakly +-untrapped) surface, Weakly untrapped surface
- L2: Weakly untrapped surface
- L4: Weakly outer untrapped (weakly +-untrapped) surface, Weakly untrapped surface
Sources (3) published science
Hayward, S. A. General laws of black-hole dynamics (arXiv gr-qc/9303006v3, revised 6 April 1994) (behind its links)
Booth, I. Black hole boundaries (arXiv gr-qc/0508107, 2005) (behind its links)