← all systems · see it in The System
Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
'A three-surface (or indeterminate signature), H, which can be entirely foliated with MOTSs, S_v, will be referred to as a marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)' (Booth, following Ashtekar-Krishnan); 'We call a 3-surface foliated by MOTS a marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT); an alternative terminology ... is "trapping horizon"' (Andersson, Mars, Simon). Booth Table 1: MOTT, dimension 3, 'foliated by MOTSs', no condition on theta(n), on L_n theta(l) or on signature.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the three-surface swept by the MOTS leaves S_v, one per leaf of a reference foliation. Outside: the spacetime on either side; nothing is required of the ingoing expansion, so the tube need not bound trapped surfaces. |
| nested level | Parent kind of the quasilocal horizons (Booth Table 1): marginally trapped tubes, trapping horizons, isolated and dynamical horizons are MOTTs with extra conditions. Built from MOTS; embedded in a foliated spacetime. Field scale; epoch 1 (C-011 A). |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| dimension | 3 (leaves 2) dimension |
| signature condition (null energy condition) | spacelike iff sigma(l)ab sigma(l)^ab + 8 pi T_ab l^a l^b != 0, else null condition |
| signatures allowed under standard energy conditions | locally achronal: spacelike or null signature |
| leaf topology for an outer trapping horizon with the dominant energy condition | spheres (Euler characteristic positive) topology |
| review dates | Booth arXiv v2 20 Oct 2005; Andersson-Mars-Simon arXiv v2 22 May 2007 date |
| characteristic clock: the foliation parameter v labelling its leaves | v (S_v = H intersect Sigma_t(v)) foliation parameter |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-106 When a black hole forms in a simulation, does its horizon really jump, or is it one surface weaving back in time?
booked: The map follows the simulations' description of a horizon that jumps as new ones form, and keeps the single-weaving-surface reading alongside.
the other reading: B: one tube weaving backwards in time, seen piecewise by the slicing
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
One job, marking where a black hole is, done by different builds: the event horizon (global, teleological), MOTTs and their kinds (quasilocal, non-unique), and the boundary of the trapped region. - templating (structural)
The same leaf (a MOTS) recurs in every quasilocal horizon; each kind adds one condition (theta(n) < 0, L_n theta(l) sign, signature).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (9) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Weakly outer trapped surface (WOTS) via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) even
- Schwarzschild spacetime via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) even
- Apparent horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) gain
- Trapping horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) gain
- Dynamical horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) gain
- Isolated horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) gain
- Marginally trapped tube (MTT) via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) gain
- Vaidya spacetime via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) gain
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) via sys:spacetime · Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (1)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (13)
- Weakly outer trapped surface (WOTS)
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS)
- Spacetime
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Apparent horizon
- Gravitational wave
- Trapping horizon
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Timelike membrane
- Marginally trapped tube (MTT)
- Vaidya spacetime
- Numerical relativity
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Some ways of slicing a plain Schwarzschild black hole have no apparent horizon at all, so the tube you see depends on how you cut spacetime into moments.
- The tube's shape is a flux meter: with nothing falling in it is a null, isolated horizon; the moment matter crosses it turns spacelike and grows.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
marginally outer trapped tube (own, three-surface foliated by MOTSs; spacetime)
- L1: Leaves: MOTS S_v, closed spacelike two-surfaces with theta(l) = 0, one in each leaf of the spacetime foliation ('S_v = H intersect Sigma_t(v)')
- L2: The tube: 'a three-surface (or indeterminate signature) ... entirely foliated with MOTSs'; Table 1 puts no condition on theta(n), L_n theta(l) or signature; certain Killing horizons (the x = t surfaces in Minkowski) 'are not MOTTs' because the leaves must be closed
- L3: Existence: a strictly stable MOTS S0 propagates into 'an open marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT), adapted to the reference foliation'; H exists 'at least as long as the S_v remains SSO'; where the tube turns tangent to the foliation the existence theorem fails
- L4: Signature: 'under standard energy conditions on the spacetime, the MOTT must be either locally achronal, spacelike or null'; spacelike if sigma(l) sigma(l) + 8 pi T_ab l^a l^b != 0, else null (isolated); for SSO MOTTs a transition between dynamical and isolated happens 'all at once'
- L5: Kinds by extra conditions: MTT (theta(n) < 0); trapping horizon (theta(n) != 0, L_n theta(l) != 0), future or past, outer or inner; SSO MOTTs 'do not necessarily increase in area as there no assumption was made about the sign of theta(n)'
- L6: Non-uniqueness and use: 'in general a MOTS can be distorted and so any MOTT will be highly non-unique'; apparent horizons absent from some Schwarzschild slicings; in numerical relativity MOTSs evolve into MOTTs, the 'apparent horizon' evolving smoothly or jumping 'as new horizons form around old'
matter and radiation crossing the tube (gravitational field)
- L1: Matter and gravitational radiation crossing the tube: the matter flux T_ab l^a l^b and the shear sigma(l) of the outgoing null normal
- L2: No flux, no growth: null and isolated 'if not matter is falling through' (Vaidya), spacelike and expanding otherwise; by the Raychaudhuri equation with the null energy condition L_l theta(l) <= 0