← all systems · see it in The System
Marginally trapped tube (MTT)
A three-dimensional surface foliated by closed marginally trapped two-surfaces: 'Consider 3-manifolds tau which are foliated by marginally trapped compact 2-surfaces S ... If the expansion of the other null normal n is negative, tau will be called a marginally trapped tube (MTT). If the tube tau is space-like, it is a dynamical horizon. If it is time-like, it will be called time-like membrane' (Ashtekar and Krishnan). Senovilla: 'A marginally trapped tube is a hypersurface foliated by closed marginally f-trapped surfaces.' Booth: 'an MOTT with theta(n) < 0'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Marginally trapped tube |
| boundary | Inside: one three-surface and its foliation by marginally trapped leaves (theta(l) = 0, theta(n) < 0), whatever its signature. Outside: the matter and radiation crossing it, the event horizon it approaches, the slices of a numerical evolution that cut it, and the trapped surfaces on one side of it. |
| nested level | Built from marginally trapped surfaces stacked in time; a kind of marginally outer trapped tube; sorted by signature into dynamical horizons (spacelike), timelike membranes and null (non-expanding, isolated) horizons; the quasilocal surface of a black hole in collapse and mergers. |
| scale | field |
Measures (4) published science
| dimension | 3 (foliated by closed 2-surfaces) count |
| Vaidya MTT | r = 2GM(v); signature (+,+,+) when dM/dv != 0, (0,+,+) when dM/dv = 0 radius; signature |
| condition to be null | shear of l and matter flux T_ab l^a l^b across H both vanish condition |
| characteristic clock: time to turn spacelike in numerical collapse | 'quickly becomes space-like' after an initial mixed phase (no number given) evolution time |
Open contentions (2) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-027 Do black holes really have event horizons?
booked: The map follows general relativity: black holes have event horizons. Hawking's 2014 suggestion of apparent horizons only is kept alongside.
the other reading: B: no event horizon forms - C-106 When a black hole forms in a simulation, does its horizon really jump, or is it one surface weaving back in time?
booked: The map follows the simulations' description of a horizon that jumps as new ones form, and keeps the single-weaving-surface reading alongside.
the other reading: B: one tube that turns timelike and runs backward in time (Tolman-Bondi), seen piecewise by the slicing (Booth 2005)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (1) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Marginally trapped tube (MTT). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
The black-hole boundary is built two ways in Vaidya: the event horizon, which 'originate[s] in the flat space-time region', and the MTT (DH), which 'exists only in the curved region'; 'the numerous roles played by the event horizon in equilibrium situations get split in dynamical contexts'.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (11) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Timelike membrane via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) even
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) gain
- Event horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) even
- Apparent horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) even
- Dynamical horizon via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) even
- Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) gain
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS) via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) gain
- Core of the trapped region (Z) via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) gain
- Outer untrapped surface via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) gain
- Trapping boundary via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) even
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) via sys:spacetime · Marginally trapped tube (MTT) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (1)
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (19)
- Timelike membrane
- Black hole
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- Event horizon
- Apparent horizon
- Gravitational wave
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust
- Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH)
- Non-expanding horizon (NEH)
- Vaidya spacetime
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH)
- Core of the trapped region (Z)
- Outer untrapped surface
- Trapping boundary
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
represents (1)
Kinds (6)
- Dynamical horizon
- Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH)
- Timelike membrane
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
- Non-expanding horizon (NEH)
- Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- In Tolman-Bondi dust collapse a marginally trapped tube can turn timelike and run backward in time, which may be what simulations see as an apparent horizon 'jumping' outward.
- In Vaidya collapse the event horizon starts in the flat region before anything falls in, while the dynamical horizon exists only where spacetime is already curved.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
marginally trapped tube (own, three-surface foliated by marginally trapped surfaces)
- L1: A three-dimensional surface foliated by closed marginally trapped two-surfaces S (theta(l) = 0, theta(n) < 0)
- L2: Signature sorts it: spacelike = dynamical horizon; timelike = timelike membrane; null = non-expanding (isolated) horizon; with the null energy condition 'an outer trapping horizon is spatial and an inner trapping horizon is Lorentzian'
- L3: Uniqueness: a given spacelike H carries at most one DH foliation (maximum principle); two SFOTHs tangent to the same NEH or asymptotic to the event horizon coincide; yet 'MTTs, even in spherical symmetry, are not unique' and 'any MOTT will be highly non-unique'
- L4: Evolution in collapse: Vaidya, the spherical MTT is the DH; Oppenheimer-Volkoff dust, timelike (an artefact of non-smoothness); smooth perfect fluid, spacelike at late times; numerical NS collapse and head-on collision, 'neither space-like nor time-like' at first, then 'quickly becomes space-like' approaching the event horizon; Tolman-Bondi: spacelike to timelike, 'jumping'
- L5: Black-hole surface or not: needs trapped surfaces just inside (Hayward's L_n theta(l) < 0); Senovilla's VSI spacetimes 'include MTTs (and in fact can be foliated by them) but do not contain any trapped surfaces'
matter and radiation crossing the tube (gravitational field)
- L1: Matter and gravitational radiation crossing the tube: 'H is space-like in the dynamical region where gravitational radiation and matter fields are pouring into it'
- L2: No flux, no shear: the tube is null 'if and only if the shear sigma_ab of l as well as the matter flux T_ab l l across H vanishes', 'null when it has reached equilibrium'
Who fills each layer
- L1: Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
- L2: Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT), Timelike membrane
- L5: Core of the trapped region (Z)