← all systems · see it in The System
Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966)
'A theorem was proven by assuming a Cauchy hypersurface Sigma, letting u be the unit geodesic vector field orthogonal to Sigma on Sigma, and assuming that its expansion (5) is bounded from below by a positive constant. The Raychaudhuri equation leads then to all the geodesics tangent to u having a finite length to the past, ergo the singularity [Hawking 1966, I]. This mainly applied for non-compact Sigma, the compact case was treated in [Hawking 1966, II].' (Senovilla and Garfinkle 2015)
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: a Cauchy hypersurface whose normal geodesic congruence has expansion bounded below by a positive constant everywhere on it, the timelike convergence condition (6), the focusing to the past, and the conclusion that every normal geodesic has finite past length; non-compact (1966 I) and compact (1966 II) cases. Outside: spacetimes with no such slice (only a reconverging light cone, the 1967 form), with Lambda > 0 or with matter breaking (6). |
| nested level | A kind (the 1966 form) of the walked Hawking singularity theorem; built from the walked Cauchy surface, Raychaudhuri equation and strong energy condition; field scale, rung 1. |
| scale | field |
Measures (4) published science
| papers | Hawking 1966, Proc. Roy. Soc. London A294, 511 (I, non-compact) and A295, 490 (II, compact); improved 1967, A300, 187 (III) year |
| curvature condition | R_rho-nu u^rho u^nu >= 0 (6) |
| expansion bound | theta bounded below by a positive constant on Sigma |
| characteristic clock: none of its own; the past length of every normal geodesic is finite (no value without a model) | none |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-082 Do real singularities exist inside black holes and at the Big Bang?
booked: The map uses the classical singularities of general relativity, and keeps the quantum-gravity theories that remove them alongside. The universe's starting time is a reference point, not necessarily a real event.
the other reading: quantum gravity removes the singularity; Lambda > 0 and inflation break (6)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
Three different initial conditions do the same job of trapping the past: past-trapped surfaces (1965), an everywhere-expanding slice (1966), a reconverging past light cone (1967). - smooth to sharp in finite time (structural)
A smooth expanding slice with matter obeying (6) forces a finite past end: theta 'will reach an infinite negative value in finite affine parameter to the ... past'.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (7) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy) via sys:gravitational-field · Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966) loss
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime via sys:spacetime · Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966) gain
- Strong energy condition (SEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966) gain
- Einstein static universe via sys:gravitational-field · Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966) even
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface) via sys:spacetime · Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966) gain
- Hawking singularity theorem via sys:spacetime · Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966) even
- Raychaudhuri equation via sys:gravitational-field · Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface)
- Timelike geodesic
- Raychaudhuri equation
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (13)
- Gravitational field
- Big Bang
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
- Einstein static universe
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface)
- Timelike geodesic
- Hawking singularity theorem
- Raychaudhuri equation
- Geodesic focusing
- Hawking singularity theorem, reconverging-light-cone form (1967)
- Expanding-slice theorem, non-compact Sigma (1966 I)
- Expanding-slice theorem, compact Sigma (1966 II)
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
- Hawking singularity theorem
- Expanding-slice theorem, non-compact Sigma (1966 I)
- Expanding-slice theorem, compact Sigma (1966 II)
Notes published science
- An expanding universe can dodge this theorem by expanding everywhere but ever more weakly: Senovilla's 1990 cosmology has 'everywhere expanding Cauchy hypersurfaces' and no singularity, because no positive lower bound on the expansion exists.
- Hawking's improvement a year later was more honest about our universe: no need to assume space is expanding everywhere at once; a single point whose past light cone reconverges is enough.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Hawking expanding-slice theorem (own: past incompleteness from an everywhere-expanding Cauchy slice; spacetime)
- L1: A Cauchy hypersurface Sigma and the unit geodesic vector field u orthogonal to it: the normal timelike geodesics
- L2: The initial condition: the expansion theta = nabla_mu u^mu 'is bounded from below by a positive constant' on Sigma (an everywhere-expanding slice)
- L3: Focusing to the past: with (6), 'if theta is ... positive at some point ... theta will reach an infinite negative value in finite affine parameter to the ... past'; a timelike curve from Sigma 'maximizes the arc-length if and only if it is a geodesic (orthogonal to Sigma), without corners and without ... focal points'
- L4: Conclusion: 'all the geodesics tangent to u having a finite length to the past, ergo the singularity'; non-compact Sigma (1966 I), compact Sigma (1966 II)
- L5: Limits: improved in 1967 by the reconverging-light-cone form, 'much better adapted to what we know about the Universe (no need to assume an everywhere expanding slice)'; 'Geodesic incompleteness cannot be proven without the initial/boundary condition': globally hyperbolic spacetimes with strict (6) and 'everywhere expanding Cauchy hypersurfaces, but free of singularities' exist (Senovilla 1990), avoiding the conclusion 'because the initial/boundary condition simply fails'
matter flow focused backward (gravitational field)
- L1: Matter world lines of an expanding universe: a fluid moving along geodesic, hypersurface-orthogonal u; Raychaudhuri-Komar: positive expansion 'at an instant of time' and (6) make the density diverge 'in the finite past'
- L2: Condition (6), R_rho-nu u^rho u^nu >= 0: 'a geometric condition independent of the particular theory'; in GR with Lambda = 0 'many times called the strong energy condition'
- L3: Where it fails: 'Lambda > 0, just the wrong sign for the theorems'; scalar fields and 'inflationary cosmological models violate it'