← all systems · see it in The System
Penrose singularity theorem
'If the space-time contains a non-compact Cauchy hypersurface Sigma and a closed future-trapped surface, and if the convergence condition (6) holds for null u, then there are future incomplete null geodesics' (Senovilla and Garfinkle, modern form of Penrose 1965). Its general relativistic reading 'predicts a gravitational singularity in black hole formation' (Wikipedia).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the forced future incompleteness of some null geodesics leaving a closed future-trapped surface, given the null convergence condition and a non-compact Cauchy hypersurface. Outside: what kind of singularity results ('the proof does not say what type'), the cosmological (Hawking) version, whether it is hidden (cosmic censorship), and quantum gravity. |
| nested level | One build (null, forward, black-hole) of the Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems; built from trapped surfaces, null focusing and Cauchy surfaces on a Lorentzian spacetime. |
| scale | field |
Measures (5) published science
| published | 1965 (Phys. Rev. Lett. 14, 57); the finding made in 1964 year |
| ingredients | 3 (energy condition, global structure, trapping) count |
| Nobel Prize in Physics (Penrose, half) | 2020 year |
| Hawking-Penrose generalisation | 1970 (Proc. Roy. Soc. London A314, 529) year |
| characteristic clock: focusing time | a converging congruence reaches a caustic 'within a proper time of at most (D - 1)/|theta_0|' (timelike form; affine parameter for light) proper time / affine parameter |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-082 Do real singularities exist inside black holes and at the Big Bang?
booked: The map uses the classical singularities of general relativity, and keeps the quantum-gravity theories that remove them alongside. The universe's starting time is a reference point, not necessarily a real event.
the other reading: quantum gravity removes it (regular black holes, fuzzballs)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Null geodesic
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface)
- Achronal boundary
- Future-trapped surface
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (9)
- Null energy condition (NEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Penrose singularity theorem gain
- Black-hole event horizon via sys:spacetime · Penrose singularity theorem even
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface) via sys:spacetime · Penrose singularity theorem gain
- Gravitational singularity via sys:spacetime · Penrose singularity theorem even
- Achronal boundary via sys:spacetime · Penrose singularity theorem gain
- Hawking singularity theorem via sys:spacetime · Penrose singularity theorem even
- Geodesic focusing via sys:electromagnetic-field · Penrose singularity theorem gain
- Future-trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Penrose singularity theorem gain
- Lightlike ray (future or past) via sys:spacetime · Penrose singularity theorem gain
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (12)
- Black hole
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Null geodesic
- Black-hole event horizon
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface)
- Gravitational singularity
- Achronal boundary
- Geodesic focusing
- Cosmic censorship hypothesis
- Future-trapped surface
- Lightlike ray (future or past)
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Penrose's key new idea was purely local: a closed surface whose outgoing light is already converging. Find one, and the theorem says the spacetime must end somewhere, no matter how lopsided or spinning the collapse.
- Spin does not save a collapsing star: 'the additional angular momentum only pulls the star together more strongly'.
- The proof never finds the singularity; it only shows that light cannot go on forever, and leaves open what stops it.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Penrose singularity theorem (own: null incompleteness forced from a closed trapped surface, spacetime)
- L1: Light from a closed future-trapped surface T: the two families of null geodesics orthogonal to it, both initially converging ('a sphere where all the outgoing (and ingoing) light rays are initially converging')
- L2: Focusing: with the null convergence condition the null Raychaudhuri equation drives both families to caustics at finite affine parameter
- L3: Compact boundary: the boundary of the future of T is generated by null segments from T that 'have to terminate ... at or before the caustics', so it is compact (or 'comes from nowhere')
- L4: The contradiction: assuming complete null geodesics, that compact boundary would map onto a non-compact Cauchy hypersurface; so 'there are future incomplete null geodesics'
- L5: Reach: deviations from spherical symmetry cannot prevent the Oppenheimer-Snyder-type singularity; incompleteness 'inside any black hole'; spin 'only pulls the star together more strongly'
- L6: Limits: it does not say what type of singularity occurs; the Cauchy hypersurface is not guaranteed (Penrose found plane waves admit none); global hyperbolicity of real spacetimes ties to strong cosmic censorship
light focused by collapsing matter (gravitational field)
- L1: Collapsing matter and radiation: 'all matter and energy is a source of gravitational attraction in general relativity'
- L2: Light rays 'always focused together by gravity, never drawn apart', which 'holds whenever the energy of matter is non-negative'
- L3: A trapped surface forms inside the horizon and the interior 'necessarily has a singularity somewhere'
Sources (4) published science
Raychaudhuri equation (Wikipedia, rev 1378594562, via WME cache) (behind its links)