← all systems · see it in The System
Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
Gravitational theories on discrete space-times built by 'discretizing the action of the theory and working out the resulting equations of motion rather than discretizing the equations of motion directly'; 'The resulting theories are free of constraints at the canonical level'. The LQG article: 'The Consistent Discretizations approach to LQG, is an application of the master constraint program to construct the physical Hilbert space of the canonical theory.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Consistent discretizations approach |
| boundary | Inside (as projected): the discrete evolution steps, the discrete Lagrangian and action, the canonical transformation from step n to n+1, Lagrange multipliers fixed by the equations of motion, unitary quantum evolution, relational time with real clocks, and the outcomes (singularity avoidance, fundamental decoherence, contact with LQG kinematics). Outside: the continuum theory it approximates, the spin-network kinematics it reaches, and the matter and black holes it is applied to. |
| nested level | A kind of canonical quantum gravity (hung under canonical LQG, C-005, as the namer booked); built on a discrete space-time lattice and, in its semi-discrete form, on holonomies and spin networks. Rung 1, hypothetical, representation: true. |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (7) published science
| off-diagonal density-matrix element at evaporation, solar-sized black hole | 10^-28 relative to initial |
| decoherence scaling for a black hole | (M_Planck / M_BH)^(2/3) factor on rho_12 |
| best clock accuracy (Ng-van Dam style estimate) | delta T ~ T_P^(2/3) T^(1/3) s |
| remnant freedom in the lapse | 2 constants |
| dimension worked in detail for the semi-discrete theory | 2+1 dimensions |
| characteristic clock: the evolution step epsilon_n (varies with evolution; differs on either side of a singularity) | epsilon_n step |
| regime scale (discrete space-time hypothesis): Planck time | ~10^-43 s |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
- Spin network (labelled graph; a state of quantum geometry)
- Holonomy (parallel transport round closed loops; its trace is the Wilson loop)
- Discrete space-time lattice (evolution steps)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (5)
- Black hole via sys:electromagnetic-field · Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model) even
- Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model) gain
- Loop quantum cosmology (LQC; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model) even
- Spin network (labelled graph; a state of quantum geometry) via sys:gravitational-field · Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model) gain
- Holonomy (parallel transport round closed loops; its trace is the Wilson loop) via sys:gravitational-field · Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model) gain
floor filled by (7)
- Black hole
- Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model)
- Spin network (labelled graph; a state of quantum geometry)
- Holonomy (parallel transport round closed loops; its trace is the Wilson loop)
- Discrete space-time lattice (evolution steps)
- Uniform discretizations
- Variational integrator
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
- Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model)
- Uniform discretizations
- Consistent discretization with continuous spatial slices
Notes published science
- Singularities dodged by bookkeeping: they 'usually do not fall on the computational grid', so the discrete universe steps over the Big Bang, coming out with a different time-step (a hook for Smolin's changing constants).
- A solar-mass black hole would be a mixed state (off-diagonal 10^-28) from clock imperfection alone before it could evaporate: the information paradox 'unobservable in practice'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
consistent discretization: gravity on a discrete space-time lattice (projected model)
- L1: Lattice: discrete evolution steps t_{n+1} - t_n = epsilon_n (possibly varying), coordinates q_n at each step; in the semi-discrete form, parallel-transport matrices V(x) along time-like links and plaquette holonomies
- L2: Discrete action: L(n, n+1) = epsilon_n L-hat, S = sum over n; stationarity gives the equations of motion; the momenta define a canonical transformation from (q_n, p_n) to (q_{n+1}, p_{n+1}) with type-1 generating function F1 = -L
- L3: No constraints: 'equations that in the continuum are constraints among the dynamical variables become evolution equations'; Lagrange multipliers (lapse) determined by the equations of motion, up to two constants (the remnant of reparameterization invariance); the diffeomorphism constraint becomes a conserved quantity that may be imposed consistently, giving diffeomorphism-invariant spin networks as physical space
- L4: Quantum evolution and time: evolution in n is a unitary transformation; a relational time from a quantum 'clock' operator gives conditional probabilities that evolve approximately by Schrödinger evolution with Lindblad-type corrections, so 'pure states evolve into mixed states'
- L5: Outcomes: singularities avoided when they do not fall on the grid (the discrete solution 'evolves through the singularity', emerging with a different lapse); black-hole coherence lost before evaporation; contact with LQG kinematics and a framework 'to implement loop quantum gravity numerically'
Sources (5) published science
Gambini and Pullin 2005, Consistent discretization and loop quantum geometry, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 101302 (arXiv gr-qc/0409057) (behind its links)
Planck units (behind its links)