← all systems · see it in The System
Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea)
Kar and Sahdev (1995): 'Evolving Lorentzian wormholes with the required matter satisfying the Energy conditions'; non-static wormholes that 'exist for a finite (but arbitrarily small or large) time interval and represent evolving geometries', modelled as a static wormhole metric multiplied by a time-dependent conformal factor, so that 'the throat radius expands or contracts'. Related constructions: dynamic wormholes between FRW regions (Hochberg and Kephart 1993), inflating wormholes (Roman 1993), dynamic wormholes as trapping horizons (Hayward 1999).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Evolving Lorentzian wormhole |
| born at | November 1992 (Hochberg and Kephart, Roman preprints); named "evolving Lorentzian wormholes" by Kar and Sahdev in June 1995 |
| born precision | month |
| boundary | Inside: the family of non-static wormhole solutions (a shape function times a time-dependent factor), their throats, threading matter and energy-condition behaviour, as held in the papers and by the relativists who use them. Outside: the static wormhole kinds, the cosmological backgrounds they are set in, and the physical world (no evolving wormhole is observed). |
| nested level | An idea held by science (rung 11); its projected content is a variant of the Lorentzian wormhole on an FRW-like background. |
| representation | True |
| scale | social |
Measures (10) published science
| WEC bound for the exp(omega t) wormhole | b0^2 omega^2 >= 1/2 dimensionless (8 pi G = c = 1) |
| lifetime of the sin(omega t) wormhole universe | pi/omega time |
| throat-to-horizon condition in flat FRW | b0 R(tau) must exceed c tau up to an O(1) factor length |
| FRW exponent n for the embedded wormhole | 1/2 (radiation), 3/2 (dust) dimensionless |
| time to WEC violation for a Planck-born FRW-like wormhole | a few Planck times |
| throats of a dynamic wormhole | generically two (one per null congruence), one in the static limit count |
| idea timeline (publications read) | 1992 preprints; 1993 PRL/PRD; 1994 Kar; 1995 Kar-Sahdev, Wang-Letelier; 1998 Hochberg-Visser; 1999 Hayward; 2003; 2008 Cataldo; 2009 Hayward year |
| Euclidean wormhole transition amplitude scale | significant only for throats of order the Planck length (Giddings and Strominger) |
| size needed to survive to today (Kaluza-Klein case) | as large as the visible universe length |
| WEC-satisfying lifetime | finite, arbitrarily small or large (set by parameters) time |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-053 Does a traversable wormhole need exotic matter?
booked: For wormholes that change over time, the map follows the papers showing they can do without exotic matter for a finite time, and keeps the classical result that exotic matter is needed alongside.
the other reading: A: NEC violation is generic at dynamic throats and 'even temporary suspension of energy-condition violations is incompatible with the flare-out property' (Hochberg and Visser 1998); NEC violated everywhere on a generic wormhole horizon (Hayward 1999)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Scale factor (cosmology)
- Lorentzian wormhole
- Wormhole throat
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (2)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:written-record · Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea) gain
- Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle) via sys:mental-representation · Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea) gain
expressed by (6)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
floor filled by (19)
- Lorentzian wormhole
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Black hole
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)
- Phantom dark energy (phantom energy; hypothesised)
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- de Sitter spacetime
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Weak energy condition (WEC)
- Particle horizon
- Scale factor (cosmology)
- Milne universe (Milne model)
- Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle)
- Einstein field equations
- Marginally past-trapped surface
- Raychaudhuri equation
- Wormhole throat
represents (14)
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Black hole
- Phantom dark energy (phantom energy; hypothesised)
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- de Sitter spacetime
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Weak energy condition (WEC)
- Traversable wormhole
- Particle horizon
- Milne universe (Milne model)
- Lorentzian wormhole
- Marginally past-trapped surface
- Raychaudhuri equation
Kinds (8)
- Lorentzian wormhole
- Inflating Lorentzian wormhole (Roman)
- 'Wormhole universe' (bang-to-crunch)
- Wormhole with 'flashes' of WEC violation
- Wormhole in a flat FRW universe
- Evolving wormhole with compact extra dimensions
- Phantom-supported evolving wormhole
- Dynamic wormhole connecting FRW regions
Notes published science
- Let a wormhole grow or shrink with the universe and, for a while, it can be held open by ordinary matter: Kar and Sahdev (1995) found the time window can be made as long as you like, but never forever.
- In an expanding universe a wormhole's throat races the horizon; the horizon always wins unless the wormhole inflates, and a wormhole that survives to today without exotic matter would have to be as large as the visible universe.
- Black holes and wormholes may be two faces of one thing: in Hayward's framework both are trapping horizons, and the sign of the energy decides which you get, so one could in principle turn into the other.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
evolving wormhole geometry (projected model: a static wormhole rescaled by a time-dependent factor)
- L1: Metric ansatz: ds^2 = Omega^2(t)[-dt^2 + dr^2/(1 - b(r)/r) + r^2 dOmega^2], with b(r) the Morris-Thorne shape function (throat at r = b0) and Omega(t) a conformal factor; spacelike sections R x S^2 ("wormhole universes"), the analogue of a closed FRW universe's S^3
- L2: Throat in motion: 'the throat radius expands or contracts'; a dynamic throat defined as a marginally anti-trapped surface; generically two throats (one per null congruence) that coalesce into one in the static limit; for Hayward the mouths are temporal outer trapping horizons, two-way traversable
- L3: Matter and energy conditions: the WEC reduces to inequalities on rho, rho + tau, rho + p; with F(t) = 2(Omegadot/Omega)^2 - Omegaddot/Omega > 0 and a bound on (b - b'r)/r^3, the WEC holds 'for arbitrarily small or large intervals of time', but F cannot be positive everywhere, so the WEC 'must be violated somewhere'; against this, NEC violation is 'a generic property of wormhole throats' even with arbitrary time-dependence
- L4: Kinds by scale factor: exp(+/-omega t) (a Milne-like linear expansion; WEC iff b0^2 omega^2 >= 1/2); sin(omega t) (a bang-to-crunch 'wormhole universe', lifetime pi/omega); (omega t)^nu (dust and radiation FRW cases); C - omega t (Roman's inflating wormhole: WEC violated at all times); 'flashes' of violation (sin omega t + a; (t^2 + a^2)/(t^2 + b^2), asymptotically static); linear Omega for traceless matter; 2+1-dimensional exact solutions
- L5: In an expanding universe: in a flat FRW background the throat radius must exceed the horizon size c tau (up to an O(1) factor); the horizon outruns the scale factor, so WEC violation 'begin[s] at the throat and slowly spread[s] outward', within a few Planck times for Planck-born wormholes unless they inflate; with compact extra dimensions (Kaluza-Klein inflation) they can evolve to the present without violating the WEC but 'must however be as large as the visible universe today'; dynamic wormholes linking FRW regions could carry signals two ways (horizon problem)
- L6: Fates and conversions: a perturbed Morris-Thorne wormhole is unstable, 'either collapsing to a black hole or exploding to an inflationary universe'; wormholes and black holes are interconvertible (a failed negative-energy source collapses a wormhole into a black hole; negative energy irradiating a black-hole horizon could make a wormhole); enlargement or reduction; zeroth, first and second laws for the mouths
light rays through an evolving throat (projected model: null congruences and focusing)
- L1: A congruence of null rays crossing the throat (rotation set to zero; shear zero for this metric)
- L2: Focusing: if T_ab k^a k^b >= 0 and the expansion is negative anywhere, it 'has to go to -infinity at a finite value of the affine parameter'; for a static wormhole theta = 2 beta r'/r is negative on one side, so either the throat vanishes or the WEC is violated
- L3: Evolving case: theta = (2 beta / R)(Rdot + r'/r); 'as long as Rdot > |r'/r| i.e. the wormhole is opening out fast enough, theta is never negative and the fact that the bundle does not focus no longer implies WEC violation'
- L4: Read-out: the focusing argument 'is useful for picking out WEC violation, but not WEC conservation'; theta > 0 is necessary, not sufficient (the inflationary case keeps theta > 0 yet fails the WEC)
the evolving wormhole as held by science (mental representation)
- L1: Papers: Hochberg and Kephart, and Roman (preprints November 1992; PRL 70 and PRD 47, 1993); Kar (PRD, 1994); Wang and Letelier, and Kar and Sahdev (1995); Hochberg and Visser (1998); Hayward (1999, 2003, 2009); Cataldo et al. (2008)
- L2: Motive: static traversable wormholes need matter that violates the energy conditions; 'if one shifts attention to nonstatic geometries one finds that WEC violation can be avoided for arbitrarily small or large intervals of time'; and inflation as 'a natural mechanism for the enlargement of such wormholes to macroscopic size' (Roman)
- L3: Method: fix a geometry (shape function times a chosen scale factor), then derive the matter from Einstein's equations and test the energy-condition inequalities; or, 'Contrary to the standard wormhole approach', fix equations of state for the matter first and solve (Cataldo et al. 2008, phantom matter)
- L4: Dispute: finite-time WEC satisfaction (Kar and Sahdev; Wang and Letelier: 'obey the weak and dominant energy conditions') against 'the violation of the NEC is a generic property of wormhole throats' and 'even temporary suspension of energy-condition violations is incompatible with the flare-out property of dynamic throats' (Hochberg and Visser); Hayward: NEC 'violated everywhere on a generic wormhole horizon'
- L5: Open work the authors left: whether 'flashes' of violation satisfy averaged conditions ('we have not carried out this calculation'); traversability in the comoving frame; particle creation; 'A complete theory of astrophysical wormholes based on r and t dependent scale factors ... will be reported elsewhere'