← all systems · see it in The System
Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle)
'Kaluza-Klein theory is an attempt at creating a unified field theory of gravitation and electromagnetism based on the idea of a fifth dimension of space beyond the conventional four-dimensional spacetime of general relativity. According to this proposal, there are three dimensions of space and one of time but with an additional spatial dimension in the shape of a tiny circle.' 'It is not supported by experiments, but is a precursor to supergravity and modern string theory.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Kaluza-Klein theory |
| boundary | Inside (projected): a five-dimensional spacetime whose fifth dimension is compact; its 15-component metric holding the four-dimensional metric, the electromagnetic potential and a scalar; the cylinder condition; the field equations and geodesics of five-dimensional general relativity; the tower of massive modes. Outside: the strong and weak forces (they need at least eleven dimensions), fermions ('introduced in an artificial way'), the four-dimensional observers and experiments that test it, and the human idea of it (idea:kaluza-klein-theory). |
| nested level | A projected model of spacetime structure: the first higher-dimensional unification. Variant of sys:unified-interaction (classical gravity + electromagnetism); its stage is sys:five-dimensional-spacetime; its compact circle is the prototype of sys:compact-extra-dimensions; its descendants are eleven-dimensional supergravity and string theory. |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (11) published science
| Nordstrom's earlier five-dimensional unification | 1914 date |
| Kaluza's paper sent to Einstein / published | 1919 / 1921 (Sitzungsber. Preuss. Akad. Wiss. Berlin, 966-972) date |
| Klein's compactification and quantum interpretation | 1926 (Nature 118, 516; Z. Phys. 37, 895-906) date |
| components of the five-dimensional metric | 15 count |
| radius of Klein's circle | ~10^-30 cm; 23 Planck lengths (Planck length ~10^-33 cm) |
| experimental upper bound on a compact extra dimension (1998 review) | below 1 am = 10^-18 m |
| first-mode mass with r sqrt(phi) ~ Planck length | ~10^19 GeV (Planck mass) against 0.5 MeV for the electron: 'some twenty-two orders of magnitude' |
| electron-mass prediction error (Weinberg 2005, via Wikipedia) | a factor of about 10^18 ratio |
| fine-structure constant estimate from the first mode | alpha ~ 4 dimensionless |
| dimensions needed to hold the Standard Model gauge groups (Witten) / allowed with one graviton (Nahm) | at least 11 / at most 11 count |
| characteristic clock: Klein's standing waves around the fifth dimension, p_5 = h/lambda_5 with lambda_5 ~ 10^-30 cm (no period given in the sources) | lambda_5 ~ h G^(1/2)/(c q) length (wave) |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
- Dilaton (projected model; hypothetical scalar)
- Five-dimensional spacetime (Kaluza-Klein)
- Compact extra dimensions
- Metric tensor
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Dilaton (projected model; hypothetical scalar)
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
- Unified interaction (fundamental forces merged into one at high energy)
Trades with (valence) (7)
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything) via sys:spacetime · Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle) gain
- Unified interaction (fundamental forces merged into one at high energy) via sys:spacetime · Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle) gain
- Dilaton (projected model; hypothetical scalar) via sys:spacetime · Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle) gain
- Five-dimensional spacetime (Kaluza-Klein) via sys:spacetime · Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle) gain
- Compact extra dimensions via sys:spacetime · Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle) gain
- Supergravity (projected model: the gauge theory of local supersymmetry) via sys:spacetime · Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle) gain
- Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea) via sys:mental-representation · Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle) even
floor filled by (14)
- Superstring theory (projected model; supersymmetric string theory)
- Supergravity (projected model: the gauge theory of local supersymmetry)
- Photon
- Gravitational field
- Electromagnetic field
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
- Dilaton (projected model; hypothetical scalar)
- Five-dimensional spacetime (Kaluza-Klein)
- Compact extra dimensions
- Metric tensor
- Kaluza-Klein tower (standing waves)
- Cylinder condition
- Type IIA supergravity (projected model)
- Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea)
represents (5)
- Five-dimensional spacetime (Kaluza-Klein)
- Compact extra dimensions
- Gravitational field
- Electromagnetic field
- the idea of Kaluza-Klein theory, as held by science
Kinds (4)
- Unified interaction (fundamental forces merged into one at high energy)
- Induced-matter five-dimensional spacetime (Wesson)
- Compactified Kaluza-Klein theory
- Projective Kaluza-Klein theory
Notes published science
- Kaluza's photon is just empty five-dimensional space seen from four dimensions: light falls out of geometry with no matter added.
- Klein's circle is 23 Planck lengths around, and that tiny size is what made the theory fail: the first excited mode weighs a Planck mass instead of an electron's.
- Eleven is both the most dimensions that allow a single graviton and the fewest that can hold the Standard Model's forces, which is how Kaluza's idea led to eleven-dimensional supergravity.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
electromagnetism read from the fifth dimension (Kaluza-Klein, projected)
- L1: The U(1) circle fibre of a circle bundle over spacetime; 'the size of the loop acts as a coupling constant between the gravitational field and the electromagnetic field'.
- L2: The potential A_mu frames the four-dimensional metric; 'the five-dimensional stress-energy tensor comprises the four-dimensional stress-energy tensor framed by the vector 4-current'.
- L3: Maxwell's equations and the Lorentz force from geometry: 'the photon appeared in four dimensions as a manifestation of empty five-dimensional spacetime'.
projected model: gravity in five dimensions, one compact circle
- L1: Projected: a five-dimensional spacetime, coordinates x0 through x4, the fifth a circle; Klein: radius ~10^-30 cm, 'the radius of the circular dimension is 23 times the Planck length'.
- L2: The 15-component metric: g~_mu nu = g_mu nu + phi^2 A_mu A_nu, g~_5 nu = phi^2 A_nu, g~_55 = phi^2; ds^2 = g_mu nu dx^mu dx^nu + phi^2 (A_nu dx^nu + dx^5)^2.
- L3: The cylinder condition: 'no component of the five-dimensional metric depends on the fifth dimension' (Kaluza); Klein: it arises if the fifth coordinate has a circular topology (fields Fourier-expanded) and a small scale (higher modes too heavy to see).
- L4: Five-dimensional Einstein equations give the four-dimensional Einstein equations, Maxwell's equations and a scalar equation; five-dimensional geodesics give the four-dimensional geodesic equation and the Lorentz force. Group view: the fifth dimension is the circle group U(1); 'gauge symmetry is the symmetry of circular compact dimensions'; the 'Kaluza miracle': the bundle's scalar curvature is constant on each fibre.
- L5: The tower: standing waves in the compact dimension have masses M_n = n h/(R c); Klein's charge quantization q_n = n sqrt(16 pi G)/(r sqrt(phi)) and alpha ~ 4; but m_n = |n|/(r sqrt(phi)) puts the first mode at the Planck mass, ~10^19 GeV, 'rather than 0.5 MeV': 'some twenty-two orders of magnitude' (Overduin and Wesson); 'off by a factor of about 10^18' (Wikipedia, citing Weinberg 2005).
- L6: Tests: 'No experimental or observational signs of extra dimensions have been officially reported'; compact size 'below the attometer (1 am = 10^-18 m) scale'; LHC data (December 2010) 'severely constrains theories with large extra dimensions'. Descendants: eleven-dimensional supergravity (1980s) and ten-dimensional superstrings.
Sources (5) published science
J. M. Overduin and P. S. Wesson, Kaluza-Klein gravity, Phys. Rep. 283 (1997) 303; arXiv:gr-qc/9805018 (read: sections 1-3 and the compactified approach) (behind its links)
Dilaton (Wikipedia, rev 1346020498, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)