← all systems · see it in The System
Weakly isolated horizon
'The pair (Delta, [l]) is said to constitute a weakly isolated horizon (WIH) provided Delta is an NEH [a null, non-expanding S^2 x R surface obeying an energy condition] and each null normal l^a in [l] satisfies (L_l D_a - D_a L_l) l^b = 0' (Ashtekar-Krishnan 2004, Definition 2). Booth: H null, theta(l) = 0, -T_ab l^a future causal, and the pull-back of L_l omega_a vanishes. It models 'black holes which are themselves in equilibrium, but in possibly dynamical space-times' and is 'sufficient to capture the notion of a black hole in equilibrium in applications ranging from black hole mechanics to numerical relativity'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the null surface, its vanishing expansion, the chosen class of null normals and the time-independence of the rotation one-form, with the horizon mass, spin and laws that follow. Outside: the possibly dynamical spacetime around it, radiation nearby that does not cross, and the asymptotic region where the radiated energy is booked. |
| nested level | A non-expanding horizon plus a class of null normals; parent kind of the isolated horizon; generalises the Killing horizon by dropping the spacetime symmetry; the equilibrium end state of dynamical horizons. |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| dimension and signature | 3, null (intrinsic metric (0,+,+)) count / type |
| WIH structures on one NEH | infinitely many ('a given NEH Delta admits an infinite number of WIH structures') count |
| symmetry classes | 3 (Type I four-dimensional group, Type II two-dimensional, Type III one-dimensional) count |
| horizon mass | M_Delta = (1/(2 G R_Delta)) sqrt(R_Delta^4 + 4 G^2 J_Delta^2), R_Delta = (a_Delta / 4 pi)^(1/2) mass |
| surface gravity | kappa(l) = l^a omega_a, constant on the horizon; scales as kappa(cl) = c kappa(l) 1/length |
| characteristic clock: none | time-independent by definition (area, intrinsic metric and omega_a Lie-dragged by l) |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Weakly isolated horizon. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
The laws of black-hole mechanics (zeroth and first) are carried by a global build (Killing horizon of a stationary spacetime) and by a quasi-local one (the WIH, which needs only its own intrinsic geometry, with radiation possibly right outside). - templating (structural)
The Kerr horizon's mass formula recurs: the WIH horizon mass, derived from a Hamiltonian framework on the horizon alone, has 'the same' dependence on area and angular momentum 'as that in the Kerr space-time', and the zeroth law of Killing horizons (constant surface gravity) recurs without any space
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (10) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon gain
- Gravitational wave via sys:gravitational-field · Weakly isolated horizon even
- Isolated horizon via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon even
- Killing horizon via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon gain
- Kerr-Newman spacetime via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon gain
- Non-expanding horizon (NEH) via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon gain
- Black hole thermodynamics via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon even
- Type I (spherically symmetric) weakly isolated horizon via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon gain
- Type II (axisymmetric) weakly isolated horizon via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon gain
- Surface gravity (of a horizon) via sys:spacetime · Weakly isolated horizon gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (5)
- Spacetime
- Black hole
- Type I (spherically symmetric) weakly isolated horizon
- Type II (axisymmetric) weakly isolated horizon
- Surface gravity (of a horizon)
floor filled by (12)
- Isolated horizon
- de Sitter spacetime
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Gravitational wave
- Null geodesic
- Killing horizon
- Kerr-Newman spacetime
- Non-expanding horizon (NEH)
- Black hole thermodynamics
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Surface gravity (of a horizon)
- Numerical relativity
represents (1)
Kinds (5)
- Isolated horizon
- Non-expanding horizon (NEH)
- Type I (spherically symmetric) weakly isolated horizon
- Type II (axisymmetric) weakly isolated horizon
- Type III WIH
Notes published science
- A black hole can be in perfect equilibrium while the spacetime right outside it is still churning with radiation: the definition only looks at the horizon's own geometry.
- The zeroth law (constant surface gravity) turns out to be exactly the condition that makes the standard action principle for gravity well defined when a horizon is an inner boundary.
- The horizon mass that numerical relativists read off a settled hole is the starting mass minus everything the gravitational waves carried away to infinity.
- The zeroth law holds on a weakly isolated horizon 'even if highly distorted and rapidly rotating': the condition that defines the horizon is the same as kappa being constant.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
radiation around the horizon (gravitational field)
- L1: A possibly dynamical exterior: 'there can exist spacetimes which are both dynamic and non-spherical right outside a spherical isolated horizon' (Booth); Robinson-Trautman examples have 'radiation arbitrarily close to Delta' (Ashtekar-Krishnan)
- L2: Settling: 'one expects the back-scattered radiation falling into the black hole to become negligible at late times'; in numerical simulations 'the backscattering effects typically become smaller than the numerical errors rather quickly after the formation of the black hole' (Ashtekar-Krishnan)
- L3: Bookkeeping at infinity: 'M_ADM - M_Delta equals the energy radiated across future null-infinity', so M_Delta 'is the mass that is left over after all the gravitational radiation has left the system' (Ashtekar-Krishnan)
weakly isolated horizon (own, null non-expanding surface with a fixed class of normals)
- L1: A null three-surface Delta, topology S^2 x R, with degenerate intrinsic metric q_ab of signature (0,+,+); future-directed null normals l; the stress-energy satisfies '-T^a_b l^b is future-causal' (Ashtekar-Krishnan Definition 1)
- L2: Non-expanding: Theta(l) = 0, 'equivalent to requiring that every cross-section of Delta be marginally trapped'; the area is 'constant in time'; with the energy condition the shear and T_ab l^a l^b vanish, so 'there are no matter flows across H' and the intrinsic metric is time-independent (Ashtekar-Krishnan; Booth)
- L3: The weak isolation condition: an equivalence class [l] (normals up to a positive constant) with (L_l D_a - D_a L_l) l^b = 0, i.e. the rotation one-form omega_a is time-independent; this 'is equivalent to constancy of surface gravity' kappa = l^a omega_a (zeroth law), even for highly distorted, rapidly rotating horizons; the electric potential is constant too; the Palatini action is well defined iff these zeroth laws hold (Ashtekar-Krishnan)
- L4: Horizon quantities from the horizon alone: angular momentum J_Delta = -(1/8 pi) closed integral of (omega_a phi^a) epsilon; first law delta E = (kappa/8 pi G) delta a + Omega delta J for a live time translation; horizon mass M_Delta = (1/2 G R_Delta) sqrt(R_Delta^4 + 4 G^2 J_Delta^2), R_Delta = (a_Delta/4 pi)^(1/2), the Kerr dependence derived rather than postulated (Ashtekar-Krishnan); in the non-rotating case the first law is 'a necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of a consistent Hamiltonian evolution' (Ashtekar-Fairhurst-Krishnan)
- L5: Instances and use: event horizons of stationary black holes (Kerr-Newman, with or without Lambda); Kastor-Traschen multi-black-hole event horizons 'are WIHs'; cosmological horizons of Reissner-Nordstrom-de Sitter; the late 'end portion' of a collapse's event horizon 'to an excellent approximation'; in numerical relativity a world tube of marginally trapped surfaces with zero shear 'is a WIH' and its mass and spin follow from J_Delta = -(1/8 pi G) closed integral of phi^a R^b K_ab d^2V; symmetry classes Type I (spherical), II (axisymmetric), III (no rotational symmetry)
Who fills each layer
- L1: Type I (spherically symmetric) weakly isolated horizon, Type II (axisymmetric) weakly isolated horizon
- L2: Type I (spherically symmetric) weakly isolated horizon
- L3: Surface gravity (of a horizon), Type II (axisymmetric) weakly isolated horizon
- L4: Type II (axisymmetric) weakly isolated horizon
- L5: Type I (spherically symmetric) weakly isolated horizon, Type II (axisymmetric) weakly isolated horizon