← all systems · see it in The System
Photon surface
'A photon surface of (M, g) is an immersed, nowhere-spacelike hypersurface S of (M, g) such that, for every point p in S and every null vector k in T_pS, there exists a null geodesic gamma of (M, g) such that gamma-dot(0) = k, |gamma| in S' (Claudel, Virbhadra and Ellis 2001, Definition 2.1): light that starts tangent to it stays on it. A timelike hypersurface is a photon surface iff it is totally umbilic (Perlick-Tsupko); a photon sphere is an SO(3) x R-invariant photon surface in a static spherically symmetric spacetime, such as r = 3m in Schwarzschild.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: a nowhere-spacelike hypersurface and the light rays tangent to it, with its umbilic shape and its symmetry. Outside: the light that crosses it, the spacetime and matter that decide whether one exists, and the observers who see its trace as a shadow. |
| nested level | A sheet of spacetime built from null geodesics that never leave it; parent kind of photon spheres and (trivially) of null hypersurfaces and Killing horizons; exists in flat space, around black holes and naked singularities. |
| scale | field |
Measures (7) published science
| Schwarzschild photon sphere | r = 3m (the only SO(3) x R-invariant timelike photon surface); also r = 3m in Schwarzschild-de Sitter, independent of Lambda areal radius, G = c = 1 |
| Reissner-Nordstrom thresholds | (e/m)^2 <= 1: one photon sphere outside the horizon; 1 < (e/m)^2 < 9/8: two; = 9/8: one; > 9/8: none charge-to-mass ratio squared |
| expansion of the Minkowski hyperboloid photon surface | Theta = 2/a (3-space), 3/a (4-space) 1/length |
| null geodesics through each point lying in S | (n - 2)-parameter family (spacetime of dimension n + 1) count |
| Schwarzschild photon capture radius | Rc = sqrt(27) r_g, r_g = GM/c^2 length |
| M87* ring diameter | 42 +/- 3 microarcseconds |
| characteristic clock: area evolution of a dynamic spherical photon surface | second-order in arc length s (Theorem 3.1); the Schwarzschild sphere 'does not evolve with time' (no value) |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (1)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (9)
- Supermassive black hole via sys:electromagnetic-field · Photon surface even
- Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime via sys:spacetime · Photon surface mixed
- Minkowski spacetime via sys:spacetime · Photon surface gain
- Null geodesic via sys:spacetime · Photon surface gain
- Killing horizon via sys:spacetime · Photon surface even
- Photon sphere via sys:spacetime · Photon surface even
- Photon region of a rotating (Kerr) black hole via sys:spacetime · Photon surface even
- Naked singularity via sys:spacetime · Photon surface even
- SO(3)-invariant photon surface via sys:spacetime · Photon surface gain
floor filled by (13)
- Photon sphere
- Photon
- Black hole
- Supermassive black hole
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
- Minkowski spacetime
- Null geodesic
- Killing horizon
- Vaidya spacetime
- Null hypersurface
- SO(3)-invariant photon surface
- Naked singularity
represents (1)
Kinds (4)
Notes published science
- Flat empty space already has photon surfaces: a hyperboloid ruled by straight light lines, which the authors liken to the paths of pulsed laser beams.
- The photon sphere of a Schwarzschild hole sits at exactly 3m whether or not there is a cosmological constant, even though the two spacetimes are not conformally related; Claudel, Virbhadra and Ellis call this 'surprising'.
- Add enough charge and the photon spheres change in number: one around a charged hole, two around a slightly overcharged naked singularity, one exactly at (e/m)^2 = 9/8, none beyond.
- In the Vaidya collapse the photon surface surrounds a locally naked singularity: every slice that reaches infinity has to cut through it in a sphere.
- A spherically symmetric spacetime always has photon surfaces that respect the symmetry; a rotating one generally has none, only a photon region.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
light held on the surface (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Light rays tangent to the surface (in Minkowski 3-space the two families of ruling lines 'may be regarded as the space-time paths of pulsed laser beams')
- L2: Kept on the surface: at the Schwarzschild photon sphere 'any null geodesic starting at some point of the photon sphere and initially tangent to the photon sphere will remain in the photon sphere'; outward rays starting outside r = 3m escape, inward rays inside fall in; 'gravitational lensing will give rise to relativistic images' (Claudel-Virbhadra-Ellis)
- L3: Read out as a shadow: capture radius Rc = sqrt(27) r_g for Schwarzschild; b < Rc captured, b > Rc escapes, b = Rc on the unstable circular orbit, the lensed 'photon ring'; M87* ring 42 +/- 3 microarcseconds (EHT 2019)
photon surface (own, nowhere-spacelike hypersurface that keeps tangent light)
- L1: Null geodesics tangent to an immersed, nowhere-spacelike hypersurface S: 'for every point p in S and every null vector k in T_pS, there exists a null geodesic gamma ... such that gamma-dot(0) = k, |gamma| in S'; 'Definition 2.1 is entirely local'; S may self-intersect (Claudel-Virbhadra-Ellis)
- L2: The shape condition (Theorem 2.2): for timelike S, being a photon surface is equivalent to chi_ab k^a k^b = 0 for all null tangent k, to vanishing trace-free second fundamental form sigma_ab, so chi_ab = (1/3) Theta h_ab ('totally umbilic', Perlick-Tsupko), and to every affine null geodesic of (S, h) being one of (M, g); photon surfaces are conformally invariant; examples: Minkowski hyperboloids (Theta = 2/a in 3-space, 3/a in 4-space), light cones, Robertson-Walker models by conformal map
- L3: Symmetric kinds: G-invariant photon surfaces (Definition 2.3); any Killing horizon (G = R or S); in static spherical symmetry the SO(3) x R-invariant ones are photon spheres: Schwarzschild r = 3m, also r = 3m in Schwarzschild-de Sitter 'independent of the value of Lambda'; Reissner-Nordstrom: one outside the horizon for (e/m)^2 <= 1, two for 1 < (e/m)^2 < 9/8, one at 9/8, none above; the Einstein cylinder has none (Claudel-Virbhadra-Ellis)
- L4: Dynamic spherical symmetry: an SO(3)-invariant timelike hypersurface is a photon surface iff the area of its 2-spheres obeys a second-order equation in arc length s involving Theta^2/3 and G_ab n^a n^b (Theorem 3.1); worked for Vaidya null dust collapse to a naked singularity (Example 10)
- L5: Existence and uniqueness: subject to energy conditions a static spherically symmetric black hole 'must be surrounded by a photon sphere' and a photon sphere 'must surround a black hole, a naked singularity or more than a certain amount of matter' (Claudel-Virbhadra-Ellis); Cederbaum: a static asymptotically flat vacuum whose innermost g_tt = const surface is a timelike photon surface 'is the Schwarzschild solution'; Yoshino: static perturbations of Schwarzschild 'cannot contain a non-spherical photon surface'; so photon surfaces 'are of interest only in the case of spherical symmetry' (Perlick-Tsupko)
Who fills each layer
Sources (4) published science
Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration (2019) First M87 Event Horizon Telescope results. I. The shadow of the supermassive black hole, ApJL 875:L1, arXiv:1906.11238 (behind its links)
Perlick, V. and Tsupko, O. Yu. (2022) Calculating black hole shadows: review of analytical studies, Phys. Rep. 947:1-39, arXiv:2105.07101 (behind its links)
Event horizon (Wikipedia), accelerated particle and beyond-GR sections (behind its links)