← all systems · see it in The System
Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy)
In relativistic classical field theories of gravitation, particularly general relativity, an energy condition is a generalization of the statement 'the energy density of a region of space cannot be negative' in a relativistically phrased mathematical formulation; mathematically, the energy conditions are essentially restrictions on the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the matter tensor, imposed eventwise.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Energy condition |
| boundary | Inside: the inequalities on the matter tensor's observer-measured density (rho = T_ab X^a X^b), its null limit (T_ab k^a k^b), the trace of the tidal tensor, and the causal character of the energy flux, pointwise or averaged along curves. Outside: the matter itself (sys:stress-energy), the geometry the theorems are about, and global features such as closed timelike curves, which eventwise conditions 'have no hope of ruling out'. |
| nested level | Built from its kinds (null, weak, strong, dominant and their averaged and quantum versions), all read off the stress-energy tensor; embedded in stress-energy as its sign structure and in the gravitational field through the Raychaudhuri focusing it feeds. Field scale, rung 1, below the first fold. |
| scale | field |
Measures (10) published science
| standard pointwise energy conditions in common use | 4 (null, weak, dominant, strong) count |
| Hawking-Ellis algebraic types of stress-energy | 4 (types I-IV); types III and IV violate every standard condition when nontrivial count |
| strong-condition threshold for a barotropic fluid | w >= -1/3 (false vacuum w = -1) dimensionless |
| Casimir energy density between parallel plates | -(pi^2/720) hbar / d^4 energy density (d = plate separation) |
| consequences listed per condition (Curiel) | NEC 17, WEC 11, SEC 7, DEC 14, SDEC 2, ANEC 6, ASEC 2, AWEC 0 count of theorems |
| violations listed per condition (Curiel) | NEC 10, WEC 8, SEC 15, DEC 3, ANEC 4, AWEC 6, ASEC 5 count of cases |
| semi-classical bound scale | zeta hbar N / L^4, zeta of order unity energy density |
| trace energy condition believed reasonable | 1950s and 1960s decades |
| textbook statement (Hawking and Ellis, The Large Scale Structure of Space-Time) | 1973 year |
| characteristic clock: proper time (or affine parameter) along the observer curve over which focusing runs and averaged conditions integrate | integral from 0 to infinity in s (timelike) or lambda (null, affine) |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same shape, opposite sign (partial)
The strong condition is 'obeyed by all normal/Newtonian matter' (gravity attracts, rho + 3p >= 0) and broken by a false vacuum (w = -1, gravity repels): one inequality, two signs, and our universe now sits on the repelling side. - templating (partial)
One generic condition stands in for 'the innumerable substances which could be introduced into spacetime' (Geroch and Horowitz): the same test is applied to every content's tensor. - lightning (surface)
Once a congruence converges with the condition holding, the -theta^2 term drives it on to a caustic: a runaway that no ring restores (the premise of the singularity theorems).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (11) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Casimir effect via sys:quantum-vacuum · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) loss
- Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0) via sys:stress-energy · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) even
- Scalar-field stress-energy (Klein-Gordon field as a source) via sys:stress-energy · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) even
- Null energy condition (NEC) via sys:stress-energy · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) even
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) even
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch) via sys:gravitational-field · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) loss
- Dark energy via sys:quantum-vacuum · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) loss
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) even
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature) via sys:stress-energy · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) even
- Traversable wormhole via sys:stress-energy · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) loss
- Trace energy condition (TEC) via sys:stress-energy · Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Weak energy condition (WEC)
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
Sits inside / holds (21)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Gravitational field
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Weak energy condition (WEC)
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
- Flux energy condition (FEC)
- Strengthened dominant energy condition (SDEC)
- Averaged dominant energy condition (ADEC)
- Quantum dominant energy condition (QDEC)
- Trace energy condition (TEC)
- Determinant energy condition (DETEC)
- Quantum weak energy condition (QWEC)
- Trace-of-square energy condition (TOSEC)
- Quantum flux energy condition (QFEC)
- Averaged null energy condition (ANEC)
- Averaged strong energy condition (ASEC)
- Euclidean strong energy condition
- Averaged weak energy condition (AWEC)
- Quantum null energy condition (QNEC)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (25)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0)
- Scalar-field stress-energy (Klein-Gordon field as a source)
- Gravitational field
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Dark energy
- Black hole
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Phantom dark energy (phantom energy; hypothesised)
- Casimir effect
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Weak energy condition (WEC)
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
- Traversable wormhole
- Quantum weak energy condition (QWEC)
- Hawking-Ellis type I stress-energy
- Averaged null energy condition (ANEC)
- Geodesic focusing
- Spacetime event
- Trace energy condition (TEC)
- Determinant energy condition (DETEC)
- Trace-of-square energy condition (TOSEC)
- Hawking-Ellis type II stress-energy
represents (2)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- the idea of Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy), as held by science
Kinds (19)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Weak energy condition (WEC)
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
- Flux energy condition (FEC)
- Quantum dominant energy condition (QDEC)
- Trace energy condition (TEC)
- Determinant energy condition (DETEC)
- Quantum weak energy condition (QWEC)
- Trace-of-square energy condition (TOSEC)
- Quantum flux energy condition (QFEC)
- Averaged null energy condition (ANEC)
- Averaged strong energy condition (ASEC)
- Averaged weak energy condition (AWEC)
- Averaged flux energy condition
- Quantum inequality
- Quantum strong energy condition (QSEC)
- Quantum null energy condition (QNEC)
- Quantum energy inequality
Notes published science
- A condition retired by a star: the trace energy condition 'for several decades in the 50s and 60s ... was believed to be a physically reasonable condition', until stiff equations of state for neutron-star matter; 'one should perhaps take the energy conditions as provisional'.
- The universe breaks the condition that proves its own beginning: the strong condition carries the cosmological singularity theorems (Hawking 1965-66, Geroch 1966) and has the longest violation list (15 in Curiel), headed today by dark energy.
- Weakest is strongest: the averaged null condition, perhaps 'the weakest of the usual energy conditions', is 'the strongest energy condition in terms of proving theorems', and it survives the Casimir plates that break all four pointwise ones.
- Gravity's energy has a floor: under ordinary energy conditions the total is never negative, and only empty flat spacetime has exactly zero.
- The simplest way to let a star shine in general relativity is to let the Schwarzschild mass slowly decrease along outgoing light rays; the energy condition then forbids the reverse.
- Two papers, two routes, one answer: Hayward's theorem says inner trapping horizons are Lorentzian (timelike) when the null energy condition holds; Faraoni's FLRW formula says the cosmological apparent horizon is timelike for -1 < w < 1/3. Our dust-plus-Lambda universe sits inside both.
- Free fall has a built-in deadline: if a cloud of dust starts converging at rate theta_0, its world lines must cross within (D - 1)/|theta_0| of proper time, unless something violates the strong energy condition.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
energy conditions in the scientific record (written record)
- L1: Stated in the texts: Hawking and Ellis (1973) section 4.3, Wald (1984) section 9.2, Carroll (2004) section 4.6, Poisson (2004) section 2.1; each in geometric, physical and effective forms
- L2: Premise in theorems: 'One would of course have to impose some restriction on the stress-energy of matter in order to obtain any singularity theorems ... It is the energy condition which intervenes to make this subject simple' (Geroch and Horowitz 1979, quoted)
- L3: Confrontation with matter: lists of consequences and violations per condition (Curiel: NEC 17 consequences and 10 violations, SEC 7 and 15); Casimir plates and dark energy as experimentally backed violations
- L4: Revision: the trace condition, believed reasonable in the 1950s and 60s, 'has now largely been abandoned'; averaged, nonlinear and semi-classical conditions added; 'the status of the energy conditions as fundamental physics should still be considered provisional'
energy conditions on the matter tensor (stress-energy)
- L1: Observers and rays at each event: a unit timelike vector field X (a family of ideal observers) gives the mass-energy density rho = T_ab X^a X^b; a null vector field k gives nu = T_ab k^a k^b, 'a kind of limiting case of the mass-energy density'; -T^a_b X^b is the momentum they measure
- L2: The inequalities on the eigenvalues: Hawking-Ellis type I (one timelike, three spacelike eigenvectors) gives NEC rho + p_i >= 0; WEC adds rho >= 0; SEC adds rho + sum p_i >= 0; DEC |p_i| <= rho; type II needs f > 0; nontrivial types III and IV violate every standard condition
- L3: A partial order among the conditions: DEC implies WEC implies NEC; SEC implies NEC; 'the SEC does not imply the WEC'; 'There is no strict ordering on the set of energy conditions, at best a partial ordering'; NEC, WEC, SEC are linear (sums of satisfying tensors satisfy them), the DEC is not
- L4: Averaging and bounding: averaged versions hold 'only on average along the flowlines' (ANEC: integral of T_ab k^a k^b along a null geodesic with affine parameter >= 0); semi-classical versions bound the violation (rho >= -zeta hbar N / L^4); 'quantum inequalities suggest that a suitable averaged energy condition may be satisfied'
- L5: Geometry seam: through the field equations a condition becomes a convergence condition on R_ab, which the Raychaudhuri equation turns into focusing of geodesic congruences; this premise yields singularity theorems, horizon formation, the area theorem, the no-hair theorem, positivity of mass
- L6: Failure regime: dark energy and inflation break the strong condition; the Casimir vacuum breaks all the pointwise conditions; phantom fluids (w < -1) and traversable wormholes break the null condition; semi-classical vacuum polarization near an evaporating black hole gives type IV stress-energy
Who fills each layer
- L1: Dominant energy condition (DEC), Null energy condition (NEC), Strong energy condition (SEC), Weak energy condition (WEC), Averaged strong energy condition (ASEC), Averaged weak energy condition (AWEC), Flux energy condition (FEC), Quantum flux energy condition (QFEC)
- L2: Dominant energy condition (DEC), Null energy condition (NEC), Strong energy condition (SEC), Weak energy condition (WEC), Determinant energy condition (DETEC), Flux energy condition (FEC), Hawking-Ellis type I stress-energy, Hawking-Ellis type II stress-energy, Hawking-Ellis type III stress-energy, Hawking-Ellis type IV stress-energy, Trace energy condition (TEC), Trace-of-square energy condition (TOSEC)
- L3: Dominant energy condition (DEC), Null energy condition (NEC), Strong energy condition (SEC), Weak energy condition (WEC), Averaged null energy condition (ANEC), Averaged strong energy condition (ASEC), Averaged weak energy condition (AWEC), Determinant energy condition (DETEC), Euclidean strong energy condition, Flux energy condition (FEC), Quantum flux energy condition (QFEC), Trace-of-square energy condition (TOSEC)
- L4: Null energy condition (NEC), Strong energy condition (SEC), Weak energy condition (WEC), Averaged dominant energy condition (ADEC), Flux energy condition (FEC), Quantum weak energy condition (QWEC), Quantum null energy condition (QNEC)
- L6: Dominant energy condition (DEC), Null energy condition (NEC), Strong energy condition (SEC), Weak energy condition (WEC), Averaged dominant energy condition (ADEC), Averaged null energy condition (ANEC), Determinant energy condition (DETEC), Flux energy condition (FEC), Quantum dominant energy condition (QDEC), Trace energy condition (TEC), Trace-of-square energy condition (TOSEC)