← all systems · see it in The System
Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr)
A stable circular orbit of a test particle in the equatorial plane of a rotating (Kerr) black hole, orbiting against the hole's rotation: the family of outer balance radii, each a minimum of the effective potential, from far out (where the classical Kepler circle is recovered) down to the retrograde ISCO, r_ms = (GM/c^2)(3 + Z2 + sqrt((3 - Z1)(3 + Z1 + 2 Z2))) with the positive sign ('The equatorial ISCO in the Kerr metric depends on whether the orbit is prograde (negative sign in r_ms) or retrograde (positive sign in r_ms)', ISCO article). As the spin grows the inner edge is pushed out: r_ms -> 9GM/c^2 = 4.5 R_S as chi -> 1 ('The retrograde radii hence increase towards r_ms -> 9GM/c^2 = 4.5 R_S'). At zero spin both kinds coincide with the Schwarzschild stable circles, r > 6GM/c^2 = 3 R_S.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the equatorial circular timelike geodesics counter-rotating with the hole that sit at a minimum of the effective potential, r > r_ms(retrograde). Outside: the retrograde ISCO itself (the marginal edge, its own walk), the bound and unbound unstable retrograde circles inside it, every prograde orbit and all non-circular or non-equatorial paths. |
| nested level | A family of equatorial circular timelike geodesics of the Kerr geometry, the retrograde branch of the stable circles; its inner edge is set by the hole's mass and spin chi = 2a/R_S = cJ/(M^2 G). Field scale, epoch 1. |
| scale | field |
Measures (7) published science
| inner edge (retrograde ISCO) | r_ms = (GM/c^2)(3 + Z2 + sqrt((3 - Z1)(3 + Z1 + 2 Z2))) <= 9GM/c^2 = 4.5 R_S |
| inner edge at zero spin (both kinds) | 6GM/c^2 = 3 R_S |
| inner edge at maximal spin (chi -> 1) | 9GM/c^2 = 4.5 R_S |
| MAXI J1659-152: share of explored parameter space requiring negative spin | about 95% fraction |
| MAXI J1659-152 outburst (the spectra come from its rising phase) | roughly 65 days, begun 2010 September 25 |
| equatorial ergosurface (the counter-rotation ban) | r_E = 1 + sqrt(1 - a^2 cos^2 theta) = 2 at theta = pi/2 (natural units) GM/c^2 |
| characteristic clock: radial oscillation about a stable circle | omega_r^2 = (1/m)[d^2V/dr^2] (Schwarzschild form; omega_r slightly below omega_phi; the Kerr value is not given in the sources read) rad/s |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-109 Has a black hole been seen spinning opposite to its surrounding disk?
booked: The map follows the 2020 report of MAXI J1659-152 as the first clear case, and keeps a less clear earlier case alongside.
the other reading: B: not clearly: Swift J1910.2-0546 left as 'retrograde spin or truncated disk'
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same shape, opposite sign (structural)
One spin, mirrored edges: the prograde stable family reaches in to GM/c^2, the retrograde one is held out beyond 9GM/c^2; the same split runs through the ISCO, marginally bound and photon orbits. - templating (structural)
The same restoring well (a potential minimum, a stable radial oscillation) recurs on every circle of the family at every spin; only the edge moves.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (7) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Prograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr) via sys:gravitational-field · Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr) even
- Black hole via sys:electromagnetic-field · Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr) mixed
- Kerr spacetime via sys:spacetime · Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr) even
- Ergosphere via sys:spacetime · Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr) even
- Retrograde ISCO of a rotating hole via sys:electromagnetic-field · Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr) even
- Stable circular orbit via sys:gravitational-field · Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr) gain
- Retrograde bound unstable circular orbit (Kerr) via sys:gravitational-field · Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr) even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (9)
- Black hole
- Kerr spacetime
- Ergosphere
- Geodesic
- Retrograde ISCO of a rotating hole
- Angular momentum
- Stable circular orbit
- Frame dragging
- Retrograde bound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
wired (3)
Notes published science
- The ergosphere is a closed door for this whole family: counter-rotation is forbidden there, and the retrograde circles never come closer than 6GM/c^2, three times the ergosurface (Kerr metric; ISCO article).
- A spinning hole pushes counter-rotating gas out: its stable circles start at up to 9GM/c^2 = 4.5 R_S, and one X-ray binary (MAXI J1659-152) may be showing exactly that (contested).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
counter-rotating disc gas on retrograde stable circles (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Gas of a disc orbiting against its hole's spin: X-ray spectra of the rising phase of the roughly 65-day outburst of MAXI J1659-152 (begun 2010 September 25), XMM-Newton and RXTE
- L2: The edge farther out: 'the ISCO for a particle orbiting retrograde can be as far out as about 4.5 r_s'; the energy released by the edge also depends on spin ('between 5.7% and 42% ... depending on the black hole's spin')
- L3: Spin sign read out: broad iron line plus continuum fitting; for about 95% of the explored parameter space 'the spin of the black hole has to be negative' (contested: Swift J1910.2-0546 'retrograde spin or truncated disk')
retrograde stable circular orbit (own, the counter-rotating outer balance radii on the gravitational field)
- L1: A test particle on an equatorial circle, angular momentum opposed to the hole's, in the Kerr geometry; two constants of motion, 'the energy E, and the component of the orbital angular momentum parallel to the spin of the black hole L_z'
- L2: The balance: each circle sits at a minimum of the effective potential (the outer root r_outer in the Schwarzschild form, 'always greater than 3 r_s'); the family runs out to large r, where the classical circle is recovered
- L3: Restoring: 'A small radial deviation from a circular orbit of radius r_outer will oscillate stably' (Schwarzschild form; outside r_ms the Kerr circles are the stable ones)
- L4: Placement of the inner edge by spin: pushed outward, r_ms = (GM/c^2)(3 + Z2 + sqrt((3 - Z1)(3 + Z1 + 2 Z2))); r_ms -> 9GM/c^2 = 4.5 R_S as chi -> 1 ('The retrograde radii hence increase towards r_ms -> 9GM/c^2 = 4.5 R_S'); never inside the ergosphere, where counter-rotation is forbidden
- L5: The inner edge: the retrograde ISCO, below which 'Bound circular orbits are still possible ... but they are unstable'; at the edge 'Any infinitesimal inward perturbations to this orbit will lead to the particle spiralling into the black hole'