← all systems · see it in The System
Natural selection
Natural selection is the differential survival and reproduction of individuals due to differences in the relative fitness endowed on them by their own particular complement of observable characteristics. It is a key law or mechanism of evolution which changes the heritable traits characteristic of a population or species over generations.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | with the first replicators (RNA-world hypothesis); not dated in the sources read |
| born precision | bracket only |
| boundary | Inside: the differential survival and reproduction of individuals in a population that varies heritably; the agents in the environment that cause it (predators, pathogens and parasites, climate, competitors and limited resources, mates, people, social partners, the organism's own gametes and genome); the fitness differences they make; the response of the population (allele frequencies, trait means, sweeps and their genome signatures); and what accumulates from it (adaptation, and with reproductive isolation new species). Outside: how variation is made and handed on (heredity, mutation, recombination), chance change in allele frequencies (genetic drift), and the organisms' own physiology between reproductions. |
| nested level | a process carried by every population of reproducing individuals with heritable variation; a mechanism of evolution |
| scale | organism |
Measures (23) published science
| characteristic clock: peppered moth, first dark moth caught to nearly all dark in industrial Manchester | 50 years |
| characteristic clock: one pass of the selection loop | 1 generation |
| selection coefficient against melanic peppered moths (daily survival) | 0.091 (95% CI 0.028-0.157) per day |
| selection against melanics per generation | 0.1-0.2 s per generation |
| moths released in the Majerus predation experiment | 4864 over 6 years moths |
| median absolute linear selection gradient |beta| in the wild | 0.16 standardized gradient |
| median absolute quadratic selection gradient |gamma| in the wild | 0.10 standardized gradient |
| selection estimates reviewed | over 2,500 from 63 studies of 62 species (1984-1997) estimates |
| harvest-driven phenotypic change relative to natural and other human-driven change | >300% and 50% faster rate |
| harvest-driven trait change | almost 20% decline in size traits; nearly 25% shift in life history |
| MEGA-plate resistance gain | 10,000-fold (trimethoprim); 100,000-fold (ciprofloxacin) MIC fold |
| MEGA-plate adaptation time | 10 (TMP); 12 (CPR) days |
| MEGA-plate step size | 10 fold per step |
| LTEE span | 12 populations, >25 years, 60,000 generations |
| lactase-persistence haplotype frequency and length (northern European-derived) | ~77%; >1 Mb frequency; megabases |
| timing of strong selection at lactase | 5,000-10,000 years ago |
| new mutations per human diploid genome per generation | ~70 (mu about 1.1 x 10^-8 per site) mutations |
| genome-wide deleterious mutation rate U (human) | 2.2 (0.35 amino-acid changing) per diploid genome per generation |
| juvenile ash removed by selection under ash dieback | 31 % of juveniles |
| SDS detection power and window | ~2% selection; ~75 generations; mean tip 2000-3000 years |
| sickle-cell cohort | 3,959 persons (Gabon) |
| fixation probability of a new beneficial allele (branching process) | about 2s/sigma^2 probability |
| Hypolimnas bolina suppressor of Wolbachia male-killing: spread time on Samoa | 5 years |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-776 Is natural selection driven more by other living things or by the physical environment?
booked: The map records both kinds of driver, as the sources show, and keeps the arguments for either one being primary alongside.
the other reading: Red Queen: biotic conflict has primacy over abiotic forces (Van Valen; Brockhurst 2014); precipitation and evapotranspiration predict global variation in selection (Siepielski 2017; a published comment and reply exist, titles only read) - C-790 Does natural selection act on whole groups?
booked: The map notes that group selection, if it happens, acts on groups, and that how much it happens is still debated.
the other reading: the gene-centred view of the modern synthesis denied community or group selection; 21st-century evolutionists are less dismissive (Darwin's social species) - C-798 How much genetic variation is neutral, and how much is shaped by selection?
booked: The map records that some variation is neutral and drifts, and keeps both the neutral theory and the evidence that many mutations are slightly harmful alongside.
the other reading: Kimura's neutral theory: neutral variation accounts for a large fraction of observed diversity; many mutations in non-coding DNA have deleterious effects; a majority of human mutations are slightly deleterious - C-802 Did birds cause the rise and fall of dark peppered moths?
booked: The map follows the 2012 analysis that bird predation was the major cause, and keeps the other proposed factors alongside.
the other reading: in the 1990s other factors (migration, physiological differences between genotypes) were argued to play a substantial role; bats were suggested as agents (Majerus found no colour difference in bat predation) - C-812 Is natural selection a cause in itself, or the result of other processes?
booked: The map keeps both readings: selection as the outcome of inheritance, variation and struggle, and selection treated as a cause in its own right.
the other reading: the 20th-century modern synthesis treated natural selection as if it were itself a causal mechanism, its agency attributed to selfish genes or to the environment - C-814 Is selection that favours the average more common than selection that pushes change?
booked: The map records the claim that it is far more common, and keeps the large review finding no evidence for that alongside.
the other reading: across >2,500 wild estimates, no evidence that stabilizing selection is stronger or more common than disruptive selection; quadratic selection typically weak (Kingsolver 2001)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring)
- Gene pool
- Struggle for existence
- Fitness (biology)
- Evolution (biological evolution across time)
- Learning against fixed (unlearned) behaviour across generations
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Habitat and ecosystem
- Evolution (biological evolution across time)
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring)
Trades with (valence) (24)
- Bacterium (bacterial cell) via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection gain
- Predators (Cambrian and later) via sys:predator · Natural selection gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human · Natural selection mixed
- Pathogens (the agents the rule names) via sys:pathogen · Natural selection mixed
- Climate system (climate) via sys:climate-system · Natural selection gain
- Mutation via sys:dna · Natural selection gain
- Habitat and ecosystem via sys:ecosystem · Natural selection gain
- Organism (the living thing, as biology describes it) via sys:organism · Natural selection gain
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring) via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection gain
- Gene pool via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection gain
- Evolution (biological evolution across time) via sys:ecosystem · Natural selection gain
- Genetic drift via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection loss
- Enzyme via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection even
- Meiosis via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection gain
- Ratio and proportion: comparing two quantities by how many times one contains the other, the practice of keeping proportions, and the structure it works on via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection gain
- Personality via sys:sensory-environment · Natural selection even
- Biodiversity via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection gain
- Biology (the field) via sys:mental-representation · Natural selection even
- Learning via sys:genealogy · Natural selection even
- Human migration via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection gain
- Air pollution via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection even
- Human development (the lifespan) via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection even
- Prime numbers (the practice of number theory that finds, proves and uses them, and the structure of the primes it works on) via sys:gene-pool · Natural selection gain
- Intelligence via sys:dna · Natural selection gain
expressed by (6)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Reactive Response
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (19)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- DNA and genes
- Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping)
- Predators (Cambrian and later)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Pathogens (the agents the rule names)
- Climate system (climate)
- Mutation
- Habitat and ecosystem
- Species and populations (all members related through one pedigree)
- Organism (the living thing, as biology describes it)
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring)
- Gene pool
- Evolution (biological evolution across time)
- Fitness (biology)
- Genetic drift
- Protein domain (and the tertiary fold it builds)
- Biology (the field)
- Child development
Kinds (16)
- Stabilizing selection
- Directional selection
- Disruptive selection
- Sexual selection
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Selection biology
- Purifying (negative) selection
- Balancing selection
- Frequency-dependent selection
- Viability (survival) selection
- Fecundity selection
- Ecological selection
- Kin selection
- Group selection
- Gametic selection
- Harvest selection
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Moth colour is only 'selected' by animals that can see it: in Michael Majerus's six-year experiment, birds hunting by sight picked off dark moths about 9% faster per day than pale ones on clean bark, but bats, which hunt by sound, ate 419 moths with no difference by colour at all. (src:cook-2012-peppered-moth)
- On a 1.2-metre agar plate laid out in tenfold steps of antibiotic, E. coli stalls at each step until one mutant can cross, then floods the next band; in about 10 days it reached 10,000 times the starting resistance. And the front is not led by the fittest: fitter mutants that appear behind it stay trapped. (src:baym-2016-mega-plate)
- One adaptive step can be paid for in lives: under ash dieback, natural selection removed an estimated 31% of the young ash in one English wood, and the survivors' generation is measurably more resistant than their parents. (src:metheringham-2022-ash-dieback)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
natural selection: from a varying population to adaptation (reader's view)
- L1: A population of reproducing individuals whose traits vary heritably, living in its environment (heredity's top floor nests here)
- L2: Phenotypic variation: traits differ, genotypic and phenotypic, in every population
- L3: The agents of selection meet the traits: predators, pathogens, climate, competitors, mates, people, social partners (the struggle for existence)
- L4: Fitness components: survival (viability), fecundity, mating success
- L5: Fitness differences: differential survival and reproduction (relative fitness, selection coefficient s)
- L6: The response: allele frequencies and trait means change (Price: Cov(w,z)); directional, stabilizing, balancing; sweeps
- L7: Adaptation and new species: the population accumulates information about its environment
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Fitness differences: differential survival and reproduction summed over the life cycle; fitness is reproductive success, defined on average for a genotype; relative fitness w and the selection coefficient s (median wild |beta| 0.16)
- L6: The response: where fitness covaries with heritable value the population changes; the Price equation splits change into selection, Cov(w,z), and transmission, E(wΔz); allele frequencies move (directional to fixation, stabilizing, balancing), sweeps carry linked alleles
- L7: Adaptation: populations accumulate information about the environment; traits come to fit it (mean fitness rising without bound in the LTEE); with reproductive isolation, new species
way in: Climate and the abiotic world: rain, evapotranspiration, fluctuating seasons
- L1: Precipitation, potential evapotranspiration and the North Atlantic Oscillation (temperature explained little)
- L2: Traits that meet the climate through food and water: finch body size and two beak traits
- L3: Episodes: selection frequent in both Daphne Major finches, unidirectional to oscillating, episodic to gradual (1972-2001)
- L4: Selection coefficients whose direction and size are set by fluctuating environments
way in: Competitors and limited resources: the struggle for existence
- L1: A limited supply of food, water or territory; carrying capacity K in dN/dt = rN(1 - N/K)
- L2: Competitive traits: r-selected many offspring in empty niches, K-selected strong competitors in crowded niches
- L3: Competition: an interaction in which the fitness of one is lowered by the presence of another; on the antibiotic plate, lineages block each other by exhausting a region
- L4: Relative fitness under limited carrying capacity: a variant must out-compete the less fit to accumulate replications
way in: Mates: the other sex's choices and same-sex rivals (sexual selection)
- L1: The choosing sex and the rivals: intersexual choice and intrasexual (male-male) competition
- L2: Displays and weapons: the peacock's plumage, stags' antlers; widowbird females prefer tails longer than occur
- L3: Competition for mates; mate choice
- L4: Mating success: on average selection on mating success stronger than on survival
way in: Pathogens and parasites: biotic enemies that infect (malaria, ash dieback, coevolving bacteria)
- L1: Enemies in the environment: P. falciparum malaria in Gabon; the invasive fungus behind ash dieback; Serratia coevolving with nematodes
- L2: The host trait: sickle-cell heterozygosity; polygenic ash resistance read on 7,985 loci; outcrossing against selfing
- L3: Infection and death: selection eliminated 31% of juvenile ash; coevolving pathogens drove obligately selfing worms extinct
- L4: Viability: malaria continues to exert strong selective pressure for the sickle allele (3,959 people); a polygenic adaptive change in one generation
way in: People: harvest, antibiotics, pollution, farming (human-induced selection)
- L1: People's actions on other species' world: fishing, hunting, plant harvest; antibiotics in clinical use; soot; dairy farming
- L2: Targeted traits: humans take large, reproductive-aged adults; resistance to the drug; lactase persistence
- L3: Episodes: misuse of antibiotics selected resistance; on the MEGA-plate, tenfold steps of drug
- L4: Only increasingly resistant mutants enter the next band; harvest selection outpaces natural agents by >300%; lactase among the strongest signals in the genome
way in: Predators: hunters that kill by what they perceive (birds hunting moths by sight)
- L1: Predators in the habitat: nine bird species ate peppered moths at the Cambridge site
- L2: The prey's exposed trait: colour on its resting background (35% rest on trunks), camouflage measured with avian vision models
- L3: The encounter: 4864 moths released over six years; about 26% of disappearances seen as bird predation; bats (three pipistrelle species) ate 419 moths with no difference by colour
- L4: Viability: daily survival of melanics 91% of that of typicals (s = 0.091 per day)
way in: Social partners and kin (social species)
- L1: Conspecifics in social plants and social animals
- L2: Social traits: alarm signals, sentinels, grooming, hunting in concert
- L3: Kin selection and intragenomic conflict: gene-level selection
- L4: Selection adapts each individual for the benefit of the whole community (Darwin); inclusive fitness (Hamilton 1964)
way in: Variation supply: heritable variation handed on by heredity (standing variation and new mutation)
- L1: The population's gene pool as heredity hands it on (heredity's top floor: the lineage and the population)
- L2: Standing variation: genotypic and phenotypic variation in every population; selection often acts on preexisting variants
- L3: New variation: about 70 new mutations per human diploid genome per generation; mutator lineages arise (at least six times on one antibiotic plate); single new alleles such as the cortex transposon behind melanism
- L4: Fitness effects of the new variants: a majority of human mutations slightly deleterious, a deleterious rate U about 2.2 per diploid genome per generation, some neutral (neutral theory), a few beneficial
way in: Within the organism: gametes, zygote compatibility and the genome's own parts
- L1: The organism's own gametes, zygotes and genome
- L2: Gamete survival, zygote formation; selfish genetic elements (intragenomic conflict)
- L3: Gametic selection on gamete survival; compatibility selection on zygote formation
- L4: Sub-components of fecundity selection
way out: Adapted organisms in the world: camouflage, resistance, beaks, tails
- L1: The organisms acting in their world, and so changing the agents' world (enemies coevolve)
- L2: The organisms' phenotypes in the next generation (more resistant ash; dark or pale moths)
- L7: Traits fitted to the environment
way out: Genetic diversity: removed by purifying selection, kept by balancing selection
- L1: The variation available to the next round of selection
- L6: Purifying selection removes variation; balancing selection maintains it; mutation-selection balance
way out: New species: reinforcement and divergence to reproductive isolation
- L1: Reproductively isolated populations: new species
- L7: Natural selection can favour an increase in pre-zygotic isolation
way out: Signatures written in genomes: sweeps, long haplotypes, hitchhikers, shortened tip branches
- L1: DNA sequences in today's genomes, read by geneticists
- L3: Long common haplotypes (lactase: ~77%, >1 Mb); fewer singletons near favoured alleles (SDS)
- L6: Selective sweeps and hitchhiking; background selection the opposite
way out: The next generation's gene pool: changed allele frequencies handed back to heredity
- L1: The gene pool the next parents carry (heredity's nuclear channel L1)
- L6: Selection alters the frequencies of the different alleles
Who fills each layer
Sources (35) published science
Brockhurst MA et al. (2014) Running with the Red Queen: the role of biotic conflicts in evolution. Proc R Soc B 281:20141382. doi:10.1098/rspb.2014.1382 (PMC4240979) (behind its links)
Fitness (biology) (Wikipedia, rev 1381515956, 2026-10-23; via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Evolution (Wikipedia, rev 1381515403, 2026-10-23; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Siepielski AM et al. (2017) Precipitation drives global variation in natural selection. Science 355:959-962. doi:10.1126/science.aag2773 (behind its links)
Heredity (Wikipedia, rev 1380988270, 2026-10-19; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Kingsolver JG et al. (2001) The strength of phenotypic selection in natural populations. Am Nat 157:245-261. doi:10.1086/319193 (behind its links)
Darimont CT et al. (2009) Human predators outpace other agents of trait change in the wild. PNAS 106:952-954. doi:10.1073/pnas.0809235106 (PMC2630061) (behind its links)
Baym M et al. (2016) Spatiotemporal microbial evolution on antibiotic landscapes. Science 353:1147-1151. doi:10.1126/science.aag0822 (PMC5534434) (behind its links)
Bersaglieri T et al. (2004) Genetic signatures of strong recent positive selection at the lactase gene. Am J Hum Genet 74:1111-1120. doi:10.1086/421051 (PMC1182075) (behind its links)
Keightley PD (2012) Rates and fitness consequences of new mutations in humans. Genetics 190:295-304. doi:10.1534/genetics.111.134668 (PMC3276617) (behind its links)
Field Y et al. (2016) Detection of human adaptation during the past 2000 years. Science 354:760-764. doi:10.1126/science.aag0776 (PMC5182071) (behind its links)
Elguero E et al. (2015) Malaria continues to select for sickle cell trait in Central Africa. PNAS 112:7051-7054. doi:10.1073/pnas.1505665112 (PMC4460506) (behind its links)
Fixation (population genetics) (Wikipedia, rev 1367873005, 2026-08-05; via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Morran LT et al. (2011) Running with the Red Queen: host-parasite coevolution selects for biparental sex. Science 333:216-218. doi:10.1126/science.1206360 (PMC3402160) (behind its links)
Arnold FH 2018. Directed evolution: bringing new chemistry to life. Angew Chem. doi:10.1002/anie.201708408 (behind its links)
Meiosis (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Scott, Osmond & Otto 2018. Haploid selection, sex ratio bias, and transitions between sex-determining systems. PLoS Biol. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.2005609 (CC BY) (behind its links)
Biology (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01, revision 1380032572) (behind its links)
Dunlap AS, Stephens DW 2009. Components of change in the evolution of learning and unlearned preference. Proc R Soc B. doi:10.1098/rspb.2009.0602 (behind its links)
Nielsen R et al. 2017, Tracing the peopling of the world through genomics, Nature 541:302-310, doi:10.1038/nature21347 (PMC5772775, author manuscript) (behind its links)
Cook LM, Saccheri IJ 2013. The peppered moth and industrial melanism: evolution of a natural selection case study. Heredity 110(3):207-212 (doi:10.1038/hdy.2012.92) (behind its links)
Frank SA (2012) Natural selection. IV. The Price equation. J Evol Biol 25:1002-1019. doi:10.1111/j.1420-9101.2012.02498.x (PMC3354028) (behind its links)
Grant PR, Grant BR (2002) Unpredictable evolution in a 30-year study of Darwin's finches. Science 296:707-711. doi:10.1126/science.1070315 (behind its links)