← all systems · see it in The System
Civilization
A complex society characterized by the state, urbanization and standardized symbolic systems of communication (writing systems), organized around dense settlements with hierarchical classes and a division of labour, living on intensive agriculture, mining, manufacture and trade; it concentrates power, extending human control over nature and other people. Historians and archaeologists read it across time as one dimension of social complexity (scale, hierarchy, government, infrastructure, writing, texts, money) rising, stalling and falling.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | from around 3600 BCE in Mesopotamia (encyclopedia); urbanization at Caral-Supe about 3500 BCE; also 'from 7,400 years ago' for Mesopotamia |
| born precision | centuries to millennia, by definition used |
| boundary | Inside: the people of a complex society, their cities and settlement hierarchy, their state and bureaucracy, their division of labour and classes, their records (writing, texts, money) and shared culture, and the fields and works that feed them. Outside: the land, rivers and climate they draw on; neighbouring societies (nomadic pastoralists, tribes, rival civilizations) they trade, fight and mix with; the wider world system. Where the line falls is contested: by its cities (a 'society made up of cities'), by its state, by writing (the Inca kept records without it), or as the broadest cultural identity (Huntington); trade networks reached far beyond cultural or political spheres (C-869). |
| nested level | Built from people (sys:human) organized into cities, a state and classes, with writing, money and organized religion; a kind of complex human society (sys:human-society) at the top of the band-chiefdom-state ladder (Fried and Service); set in the Holocene Earth system it farms and alters, and, for many theorists, now part of one world system. |
| scale | social |
Measures (23) published science
| Average life span of a civilization (3000 BC-600 AD sample) | close to 340 years |
| Lag, cavalry to megaempire (Eurasian subregions) | three or four centuries |
| Time scale of structural pressures | decades to centuries time |
| Variance captured by PC1 (social complexity) | around three-quarters (77% in Shin's reanalysis of 285 polities) fraction of variance |
| Seshat sample (Turchin 2018) | 414 societies, 30 regions, last 10,000 years count |
| Scale Threshold (PC1) | about -2.5 PC1 score |
| Information Threshold (PC1) | about -0.5 PC1 score |
| Median house-size Gini, hunter-gatherers | 0.17 Gini |
| Median house-size Gini, horticulturalists | 0.27 Gini |
| Median house-size Gini, agricultural societies | 0.35 Gini |
| Average wealth Gini, ethnographic agricultural societies (8) | 0.44 Gini |
| Survival ratio of medieval narrative manuscripts (documents) | 9.0% (CI 7.5-10.7%) percent |
| Survival ratio of medieval narrative works | 68.3% (CI 63.2-73.5%) percent |
| Document survival range across vernaculars | 4.9% (English) to 19.2% (Irish) percent |
| Societies with declining health at the agricultural transition | 19 of 21 societies |
| Population density gain with agriculture | an order of magnitude (or greater) factor |
| Predictors tested for drivers of social complexity | 17 predictors, >100,000 combinations count |
| Past societal crises in the Seshat crisis sample | over 150 count |
| Ottoman population losses, 1580s-1630s | 50% or more in parts of the empire percent |
| EROI of petroleum | from 100:1 to about 10:1 over the past century ratio |
| Minimum EROI for a modern society (Hall) | 3:1 ratio |
| Teotihuacan population, 350 CE | about 125,000 people |
| Pueblo transformations preceded by rising instability | all but one of five transformations |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-715 How did governments first arise?
booked: The map doesn't pick an origin. It records the first city-states about 5,000-5,500 years ago and the finding that agriculture and warfare were the chief drivers, with the other theories alongside.
the other reading: surplus model (the encyclopedia) - C-744 Did the first cities need farming?
booked: The map follows the conventional view that cities followed farming surplus, specialised work and trade, and keeps the minority views alongside.
the other reading: monumental architecture before village settlement (Cradle article) - C-868 Why do civilizations collapse?
booked: The map doesn't name a single cause. It records what each study finds (population and fiscal cycles, climate acting through social stress, lost resilience, information shortfalls) with the other theories alongside.
the other reading: diminishing returns to complexity (Tainter); environmental over-exploitation (McNeely; Diamond's five causes); climate as trigger; Degroot 2021: the field 'suffers from numerous biases' and finds five pathways by which populations survived; falling energy return on investment (Homer-Dixon); the frontier's nemesis (Heather); nomadic invasions (Ibn Khaldun); failure of a creative minority (Toynbee); biological life cycles (Mommsen, Spengler); collapse is random with age (Arbesman); many 'collapses' are transformations or reorganizations (Eisenstadt; the Maya continuity) - C-869 What makes a society a civilization?
booked: The map uses the standard definition, a complex society with a state, cities and writing, and keeps the other definitions alongside.
the other reading: 'a society made up of cities' (National Geographic, via the encyclopedia); writing not required: the Inca kept records with quipu; a culture writ large; the broadest cultural identity (Huntington); Childe's conditions: 'Few of those conditions, however, are unchallenged by the records' (Cradle article); Kemp: agriculture, multiple cities, military dominance and a continuous political structure - C-870 Did civilization make people healthier?
booked: The map records the sources' findings that height and health declined with the switch to farming in most studies, and keeps the older progress view alongside.
the other reading: the older view that agriculture improved health (as Mummert 2011 reports it was first explained); civilization as progress from 'rudeness' (Ferguson 1767, via the encyclopedia); the label 'primitive' condemned by anthropologists - C-872 Do societies grow more complex in one steady process or in stages?
booked: The map keeps both: one main factor capturing about three-quarters of the variation, and growth alternating between size and information at two thresholds.
the other reading: a homogeneous single process in which all characteristics rise together (Turchin 2018's reading as Shin summarises it); phased growth: scale, then information, then scale (Shin 2020); apparent attractor basins in the data are a statistical artifact (Shin 2020)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Religion
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Money
- City
- Farming (agriculture)
- Social class
- Polities competing by warfare for territory and people
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (13)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Civilization gain
- Earth via sys:climate-system · Civilization mixed
- Soil and leaf litter via sys:pedosphere · Civilization gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Civilization gain
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with) via sys:written-record · Civilization gain
- Government via sys:human-society · Civilization gain
- River via sys:water-cycle · Civilization gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Civilization gain
- Money via sys:written-record · Civilization gain
- City via sys:sensory-environment · Civilization gain
- Market and trade via sys:human-society · Civilization gain
- Farming (agriculture) via sys:earth · Civilization gain
- Pastoralism via sys:human-society · Civilization mixed
expressed by (14)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (17)
- Neolithic Revolution (the First Agricultural Revolution)
- Earth
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
- Religion
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Government
- River
- Money
- City
- Market and trade
- Farming (agriculture)
- Taxation
- Built environment (buildings, streets, public space)
- Social class
- World system (globalization)
Kinds (25)
- River civilisation
- Human revolution
- Ancient Egypt (the civilization across time)
- Mesopotamia (the society of the land between the rivers, across time)
- Ancient Greece (the Greek city-state world across time)
- Ancient Rome
- Maritime civilization
- Ancient India (Indus Valley)
- Ancient China (the early Chinese states from the first Bronze Age state to the end of the Han, across time)
- Caral-Supe civilization
- Olmec civilization
- Arrested civilization (Toynbee)
- Central Civilization (Wilkinson)
- Industrial (and post-industrial) civilization
- Extraterrestrial (non-human) civilization
- Ancient India (Indus valley)
- Ancient China on the Yellow River
- Ancient India (the Indian subcontinent's societies from the Indus cities to the Gupta empire)
- Middle Ages
- Renaissance (European period and cultural movement, c. 14th-17th centuries)
- Sanxingdui culture (Shu)
- Aztec Empire (the Triple Alliance of Mexico-Tenochtitlan, Tetzcoco and Tlacopan, 1428-1521)
- Maya civilization (the Maya of Mesoamerica, Preclassic to the Spanish conquest and after)
- Inca Empire (Tawantinsuyu)
- Teotihuacan
Notes published science
- Civilizations seem to grow in two alternating gears: first they get bigger (more people, more land), then they stall until they invent better ways to keep track of things (writing, money, texts), and only then can they grow again. Seshat's data put the stall and the restart at two thresholds; in that sample only the Inca crossed into the bigger size in the Americas, and they were the only ones to build a recording system (the quipu) beyond memory aids (src:shin-2020).
- Of the medieval European manuscripts of knightly and heroic stories, only about 9 in 100 survive, yet about two thirds of the stories themselves do, because each story was copied into many books. Ecologists' method for counting species nobody has seen yet was used to count the lost books (src:kestemont-2022).
- Before five big transformations of Pueblo societies (AD 500-1300), the year-by-year record of tree-cutting for building got 'sluggish' for decades, the same warning sign ecologists use for lakes and forests about to tip; climate downturns alone did not explain the changes (src:scheffer-2021).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
civilization: land and people to concentrated power (reader's view)
- L1: The land and the people: a productive region (river floodplains, fertile soil, the Holocene's stable climate) and the farmers and settlers on it. Each member is a person (sys:human) whose top floor (intention and action) is this floor's input
- L2: Surplus and its capture: storable, appropriable cereal grain, levied as tribute, tax or tithe from the food producers
- L3: Settlements, monuments and infrastructure: dense cities and capitals, the settlement hierarchy, walls, roads and public works
- L4: Division of labour and social classes: specialists (soldiers, artisans, priests), a ruling elite, urban and rural commoners; wealth inequality rising with scale; exchange in markets
- L5: The state and its information systems: government with levels of hierarchy and bureaucracy; writing, texts, money and standard measures (Seshat's complexity characteristics)
- L6: Shared culture and identity: organized religion, literature, arts and science; collective memory and archives; the broadest cultural identity its people have
- L7: Concentrated power acting on nature and on other people: expansion, warfare, colonization, the transformation of land; collective action in crisis
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Division of labour, classes and exchange: the surplus supports specialists; wealth inequality grows with scale
- L5: The state and its information systems: ruling class, government and bureaucracy; writing, money and texts
- L6: Shared culture, organized religion, records and identity
- L7: Concentrated power and collective action: control over nature and other people, expansion and war, reform or breakdown in crisis
way in: Climate and environmental shocks
- L1: Climate events: the 8.2 and 5.9 kiloyear arid events, droughts, cold phases
- L2: Harvests disrupted: drought, failed harvests, famine and disease
- L3: Mediated by the society's own cultural, political and economic structures
- L4: Popular immiseration and unrest, intra-elite conflict that can block adaptation
way in: Harvest and surplus (the fields)
- L1: Farmed land: fertile floodplain soil and water for irrigation
- L2: Crops raised by intensive techniques, mostly cereals
- L3: Stored grain levied as tribute, tax or tithe
way in: Ideas and techniques from other cultures
- L1: Contact between cultures
- L2: Adopted or imposed: new technologies, religion, bureaucratic control, trade
- L5: Borrowed information systems: small societies that have writing by borrowing
way in: Long-distance trade
- L1: Goods from distant regions along the Silk Road and Indian Ocean routes
- L2: Trade networks, larger than cultural or political spheres
- L3: Markets and money settle obligations among strangers
way in: People (births and newcomers)
- L1: Farming populations, grown denser after the transition to agriculture
- L2: Settled in villages and cities; non-farmers gather in cities
- L3: Counted into the polity's scale: population, capital population and territory
way in: People's living conditions (health, immiseration, elite numbers)
- L1: Bodies of the population: stature and health, which fell as reliance on agriculture rose
- L2: Living standards depressed by rising population and unequal wealth
- L3: Elite aspirants compete for prestigious posts; frustrated elites rebel
- L4: Political stress: popular immiseration, elite overproduction and state insecurity combined
way in: Rival polities and military technology
- L1: Neighbours: rival polities and steppe horse riders
- L2: Military technologies arrive: iron weapons and cavalry
- L3: Threat read in costly armour and defences
- L4: Selection among polities: warfare weeds out poorly organized ones and favours large, centralized ones
way in: The record of the past (archives and texts)
- L1: Documents: records of the past kept for future generations
- L2: Loss: most documents do not survive (9% of medieval narrative manuscripts)
- L3: Copies: works copied into many documents survive their loss; evenness steadies the record
- L4: Read by traders and bureaucrats
- L5: Texts as stored information, one of the information-processing characteristics that let scale grow
way out: Building cities, walls and monuments
- L1: Walled cities
- L3: Cities of tens of thousands
- L5: Central government planning
way out: Spreading the civilization's culture
- L1: Other peoples displaced or assimilated
- L2: By colonization, invasion, conversion, bureaucracy and trade
- L6: The intricate culture spreads and assimilates
way out: Taxation and tribute
- L1: The cereal-growing rural population
- L2: The levy on the appropriable harvest that tax-levying elites depend on
- L5: Tax collection, easy while production per head is high
way out: War and expansion
- L1: Territory and rivals: megaempires three or four centuries after cavalry
- L5: A warrior class under the state's monopoly of violence; endemic warfare
- L7: Ever greater revenues raised to equip armies
way out: Working and exploiting the land
- L1: Forests and soils over-exploited
- L3: Intensive agriculture and public works on farmers' surplus; plow extensification
- L7: Control over the rest of nature
way out: Writing the record
- L1: Documents made, most later lost (about 40,614 medieval narrative manuscripts estimated, 3,648 surviving)
- L5: Registration and direct control of commoners: bureaucracy writes