← all systems · see it in The System
Ethnic group
An ethnicity or ethnic group is a group of humans who identify with each other on the basis of perceived shared attributes that distinguish them from other groups.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Ethnic groups |
| born at | contested: an ethnic concept is written down by c. 480 BC (Herodotus); modernists date ethnicity to the early modern state |
| born precision | contested |
| boundary | Inside: the people who identify with each other (and are identified by others) as one group on perceived shared descent, language, customs, religion, history, region or treatment; the markers they carry and display (speech, dress, motifs, names), the norms they share, their myths of origin and history, and the ethno-political organisations that speak for them. Outside: other ethnic groups (the boundary is drawn against them), the state that classifies, counts, recognises, favours or represses groups, the economy and class order that rank them, the wider society and nation they live inside, and the individual human who carries the identity. Barth's reading, booked: the boundary, not the cultural stuff inside it, is what persists. |
| nested level | Built from people (members) and their kin lines; groups divide into subgroups or tribes and merge into panethnicities (Cohen: 'a series of nesting dichotomizations of inclusiveness and exclusiveness'). One of the groups of a human society; sits inside states (multi-ethnic states) and across their borders (transborder kin). Carried by people: human L6 identity and emotion, L7 choices (whom to marry, befriend, vote for, join). |
| scale | social |
Measures (13) published science
| census response churn, US 2000-2010 | 9.8 million of 162 million (6.1%) people |
| census response churn by group | non-Hispanic white 3%, black 6%, Asian 9%; Hispanic 13%, non-Hispanic 1% % changed |
| mean ancestry, self-described African Americans | 73.2% African, 24.0% European, 0.8% Native American % of genome |
| identity threshold by ancestry | <20% African ancestry mostly European American; >50% African American |
| other-race effect onset | about 9 months of age |
| ethnogenesis time | several generations; centuries |
| Uzbek count growth 1897-1926 | 5.37x (Kyrgyz 3.78x, Turkmen 3.04x) ratio over 30 years |
| politically relevant ethnic groups (EPR Core) | over 800 groups, 1946-2021 |
| EPR-Organizations sample | 40 countries, 1946-2013 |
| HRV boundary-crossing effect in parks (LF/HF) | β 0.65 (Muslim), 0.60 (Jewish) |
| term 'ethnic group' first recorded | 1935 (OED 1972) year |
| Bengalis (third-largest ethnic group) | roughly 300 million people |
| birthday-party networks | 18 networks, 501 students count |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2936 Where did the Angolares of São Tomé come from: escaped slaves, or survivors of a shipwreck?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: descendants of survivors of a slave-ship wreck (date and place never identified) - C-2947 What makes a group an ethnic group?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Chandra: narrowly, categories of believed common descent; Birnir: self-identification around a characteristic very hard to change; Ford and Harawa: two dimensions, attributional and relational - C-2948 When did ethnic groups first appear?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: primordialism: fixed, natural, ancient (essentialist, kinship, Geertz's perceived givens); perennialism: nations and ethnic groups immemorial (continuous) or recurring; modernist constructivism: ethnicity and ethnic pride are modern inventions tied to the nation-state; Barth and Wolf: not universal; a product of specific inter-group interactions; instrumentalism: a resource in a political strategy; Moya and Boyd: several functionally independent evolved adaptations triggered by different boundaries - C-2949 Do states make ethnic groups, or do ethnic groups make states?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Habermas, Barry: the state enforces individual equality and does not acknowledge ethnic identity; Taylor, Kymlicka: the state recognises ethnic identity and accommodates groups - C-2950 Are ethnicity and race the same kind of thing?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Grosfoguel: racial/ethnic identity is one concept; before Weber: two aspects of the same thing; US OMB: race categories social and cultural as well as ancestral
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Ethnic markers
- Myth or belief of common descent
- Subgroups and tribes
- Ethno-political organisations
- Shared norms
- Ethnic against national identification
- Ethnic groups competing for positions, wealth and power
Sits inside / holds (3)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Panethnicity
Trades with (valence) (10)
- Nationalism via sys:human-society · Ethnic group mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Ethnic group gain
- Language (human language) via sys:acoustic-wave · Ethnic group gain
- Religion via sys:human-society · Ethnic group gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Ethnic group mixed
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Ethnic group gain
- genealogy (descent as a medium) via sys:genealogy · Ethnic group gain
- Social network via sys:human-society · Ethnic group gain
- Social class via sys:human-society · Ethnic group mixed
- Culture via sys:human-society · Ethnic group gain
expressed by (11)
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Validation of Identity/Intention
floor filled by (13)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Language (human language)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- genealogy (descent as a medium)
- Social network
- Nationalism
- Culture
- Ethnic markers
- Myth or belief of common descent
- Subgroups and tribes
- Ethno-political organisations
- Shared norms
Kinds (12)
- Tribe
- Diaspora
- Ethno-linguistic group
- Ethno-national group
- Ethno-racial group
- Ethno-regional group
- Ethno-religious group
- Ethno-civic group
- Ethno-cultural group
- Ethnic minority
- Panethnicity
- Maroon community
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Ethnic identity is less fixed than a census table makes it look: when the US linked 162 million people's answers in the 2000 and 2010 censuses, 9.8 million (6.1%) had changed their race or Hispanic-origin answer, in flows that cancel out in the totals (src:liebler-2017).
- Babies sort people by accent before they can talk: infants prefer to look at someone who spoke their native language, older infants take toys from native speakers, and a foreign accent alone is enough (src:kinzler-2007).
- Crossing into another group's park is felt in the heart: Muslim and Jewish women in adjacent Israeli towns had less favourable heart-rate variability after half an hour in the other group's parks, town centres and neighbourhoods, most strongly in parks after the 2015 uprising (src:saadi-2019).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
ethnic group: people and their markers to a shared identity and claims on the state (reader's view)
- L1: People and the attributes believed shared: descent, language, customs, religion, region, history, treatment
- L2: Markers: accent, faces and dress, motifs, names: what members and outsiders actually perceive
- L3: Categorisation: self-identification and external ascription, including the state's categories
- L4: The boundary: exclusion and incorporation; nested in/out dichotomies; ties and reciprocity denser inside
- L5: Shared norms and coordination: markers tell strangers whether norms are shared
- L6: Identity and meaning: the us/them category, myths of common descent, claimed history
- L7: Collective action: organisations, claims for inclusion, autonomy or separation; mobilisation and conflict
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Shared norms and coordination: markers stand for shared norms; group-specific norms emerge
- L6: Identity: the us/them category, beliefs of common descent, claimed continuity (origin of the identity contested)
- L7: Collective action: ethno-political organisations, demands for inclusion, autonomy or separation
way in: Appearance and faces
- L1: Light from faces, bodies and dress
- L2: Face processing tuned by exposure: own-race advantage from about 9 months
- L3: Ethno-racial category: race as a designation imposed on people
- L4: Empathy gated by group: the ACC's response to pain falls for other-race faces
way in: Contact with other groups
- L1: Neighbouring and competing groups: ethnicity as a product of particular inter-group interactions
- L2: Encounters in shared and separate spaces: parks, town centres, neighbourhoods
- L3: Boundary crossing felt in the body: heart-rate variability less favourable in the other group's spaces
- L4: Reciprocity read by dyad: stronger in same-ethnicity pairs
way in: Descent and marriage
- L1: Births and marriages; endogamy over generations; uneven reproduction (a few dominant men in the Angolares)
- L2: Ancestry carried: narrow or broad, often mixed (US groups: pervasive admixture)
- L3: Descent reckoned: the belief of common descent and its myths
- L4: Identity read from ancestry, steeply and imperfectly: under 20% African ancestry mostly European American, over 50% African American
way in: History, memory and myth
- L1: Shared history and its records
- L2: Official histories commissioned (1924 Soviet commission on the Kara-Kyrgyz)
- L3: Codified language and script (Dungan: Arabic 1927, Latin 1932, towards Cyrillic late 1930s)
way in: Migration and switching
- L1: People moving: immigration, forced migration, colonisation
- L2: Contact and conflict on arrival (Park's first steps)
- L3: Acculturation, language shift, intermarriage, conversion
- L4: Membership changed: countervailing flows hidden in cross-sectional counts
way in: Motifs, dress and material symbols
- L1: Motifs and designs on barkcloth, T-shirts, cars, digital media
- L2: Presence: continual scans of where motifs appear
- L3: Recognition and classification of motifs as one's own
- L4: A coordination signal, with a variable role per motif
way in: Speech and language
- L1: Speech: language, dialect, accent
- L2: Accent heard: infants prefer native-language speakers before they speak
- L3: Ethno-linguistic category (shared language, dialect, script)
- L4: Preference for native speakers as partners and friends; a language line need not carry hostility (Quechua-Aymara)
way in: The state's categories and borders
- L1: Borders and policies: borders drawn across traditional territories; nationality policy
- L2: The category offered: the state's definition of a nationality (political unit, language, common origin)
- L3: The answer recorded: census responses, which change (6.1% between 2000 and 2010)
- L4: Official identity: determined by the state in the USSR and China; recognition or equal treatment as policy choices
way out: Claims and mobilisation
- L1: The government faced; civil conflict onset when radical claims meet it
- L4: Organisations recruit and campaign along ethnic lines
- L7: Demands: inclusion, autonomy, separation; radical claims to outbid rivals
way out: Displaying markers
- L1: Motifs on T-shirts, cars and digital media in the diaspora
- L6: Identity to be shown
way out: Exclusion and incorporation
- L1: Segregated networks; endogamous marriages
- L3: Reciprocity given more to same-ethnicity partners
- L4: Boundary kept: categories maintained despite changing membership
- L5: Norms of whom to include
way out: Passing it on
- L1: Children raised in the language and customs; motifs taught in schools
- L5: Women as cultural carriers transmit knowledge and enforce behaviours
- L6: Identity held in the family sphere
way out: Ranking groups
- L1: Social positions assigned by fixed group membership
- L5: A group's place in the hierarchy (minority vs majority)
- L7: A stronger group imposes its will (differential power)
Sources (18) published science
Ozaita, Baronchelli & Sánchez 2020, Ethnic markers and the emergence of group-specific norms, Sci Rep 10:22219, doi:10.1038/s41598-020-79222-0 (PMC7746721) (behind its links)
Bauer, Hall, Bursalıoğlu & Guy 2023, Community diversity and the other-race effect in infancy, Front Psychol 14:1214075, doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1214075 (PMC10520555) (behind its links)
Primordialism, Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise (behind its links)
ETH Zurich International Conflict Research, Ethnic Power Relations (EPR) Dataset Family 2021 (data page) (behind its links)
Windzio 2021, The 'social brain', reciprocity, and social network segregation along ethnic boundaries, Human Nature 31, doi:10.1007/s12110-020-09382-5 (PMC7882588) (behind its links)