← all systems · see it in The System
Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame)
The frame 'of Lemaitre observers, who fall in from rest at spatial infinity': the static frame of the Schwarzschild vacuum boosted radially until its acceleration vanishes, a nonspinning inertial frame whose integral curves are radial timelike geodesics; 'this frame is obtained from Lemaitre coordinates'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Lemaitre observers |
| boundary | Inside: the infalling frame f0..f3 along the radial geodesics it covers, its synchronous time tau and flat slices, and what its observers read. Outside: the static frame it is boosted from, the Schwarzschild geometry, its horizon and central singularity, and any chart used to write it (Schwarzschild, Painleve, Lemaitre). |
| nested level | Field scale, rung 1, below the first fold. One nonspinning inertial family of observers (a frame field) of the Schwarzschild vacuum. |
| scale | field |
Measures (7) published science
| Lemaitre frame vector f0 (static polar chart) | f0 = (1/(1-2m/r)) d_t - sqrt(2m/r) d_r geometric units |
| tidal tensor, Lemaitre observers | E11 = -2m/r^3, E22 = E33 = m/r^3 geometric units |
| horizon crossed | r = 2m (r = r_s = 2GM/c^2) geometric units |
| infall speed at each point | equal to the escape velocity from that point speed |
| Lemaitre coordinates introduced | 1932 year |
| Painleve; Gullstrand (related chart) | 1921; 1922 year |
| characteristic clock: Lemaitre time tau, the proper time of each infalling observer | tau along rho = const |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-027 Do black holes really have event horizons?
booked: The map follows general relativity: black holes have event horizons. Hawking's 2014 suggestion of apparent horizons only is kept alongside.
the other reading: collapse makes apparent horizons but no event horizons
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (1)
Trades with (valence) (5)
- Schwarzschild spacetime via sys:spacetime · Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame) gain
- Euclidean space via sys:spacetime · Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame) gain
- Black-hole event horizon via sys:spacetime · Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame) loss
- Geodesic via sys:gravitational-field · Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame) gain
- Static observers (Schwarzschild) via sys:spacetime · Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame) gain
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (10)
- Nonspinning inertial (NSI) frame
- Gravitational field
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Event horizon
- World line
- Euclidean space
- Black-hole event horizon
- Lorentz boost
- Geodesic
- Static observers (Schwarzschild)
represents (1)
Kinds (2)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Lemaitre observers fall at exactly the escape velocity at every radius, the 'raindrop' observers whose time coordinate Gullstrand-Painleve coordinates share.
- Slice the black-hole exterior along their clocks and each slice is flat Euclidean space, 'a remarkable and rather special property': most spacetimes do not allow it.
- Lemaitre (1932) showed the Schwarzschild-radius singularity is just that static coordinates 'cannot be realized with material bodies inside the Schwarzschild radius'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Lemaitre frame (own: radially infalling free-fall observers)
- L1: Four orthonormal vector fields f0..f3: the static frame boosted 'in the e1 direction by an undetermined boost parameter', set so the acceleration vanishes; f0 = (1/(1-2m/r)) d_t - sqrt(2m/r) d_r, f1 = d_r - (sqrt(2m/r)/(1-2m/r)) d_t; f0 'leans inwards, as it should'
- L2: Free radial fall from rest at infinity: 'the covariant derivatives of all four basis vectors ... vanish identically, our new frame is a nonspinning inertial frame'; the curves rho = const 'are timelike geodesics with tau the proper time along these geodesics', 'freely falling particles which start out with zero velocity at infinity. At any point their speed is just equal to the escape velocity from that point'
- L3: A shared time and flat space: 'The Lemaitre coordinate system is synchronous, that is, the global time coordinate of the metric defines the proper time of co-moving observers'; in the Painleve chart the slices T = T0 'turn out to be locally isometric to flat three-dimensional euclidean space! (This is a remarkable and rather special property of the Schwarzschild vacuum)'
- L4: Tides read in free fall: E[Y]11 = -2m/r^3, E[Y]22 = E[Y]33 = m/r^3: 'a different tensor from the one we obtained above, because it is defined using a different family of observers', with the same components ('again a rather special property of the Schwarzschild vacuum')
- L5: Where the frame runs: 'not defined on the entire exterior region'; it follows the observers 'as they fall through the event horizon at r = 2m'; the Lemaitre chart 'is not geodesically complete': outward radial light rays traced back all reach r = r_s as tau -> -infinity
free fall through the horizon (gravitational field)
- L1: Radial free fall in the field of a spherical mass: bodies released 'with zero velocity at infinity', at every point moving at the local escape velocity
- L2: Crossing r = r_s: Lemaitre (1932) 'was the first to show that this is not a real physical singularity but simply a manifestation of the fact that the static Schwarzschild coordinates cannot be realized with material bodies inside the Schwarzschild radius'; the metric in Lemaitre coordinates 'is non-singular at the Schwarzschild radius'
- L3: To the centre: 'The radially falling bodies reach the Schwarzschild radius and the centre within finite proper time'; inside, light emitted inward or outward 'both end up at the origin'; 'a genuine gravitational singularity at the center ... cannot be removed by a coordinate change'