← all systems · see it in The System
Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone)
Goldstone bosons or Nambu-Goldstone bosons are bosons that appear necessarily in models exhibiting spontaneous breakdown of continuous symmetries; they are excitations of the field in the broken symmetry directions, massless if the symmetry is not also broken explicitly. If it is explicitly broken as well they are not massless but typically remain relatively light (pseudo-Goldstone bosons).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the long-wavelength fluctuation of the order parameter along each broken generator, one spinless mode per generator. Two cases here: (1) in the electroweak sector, three of the four Higgs-doublet components, which would be massless Goldstone bosons but, because the symmetry is gauged, are absorbed as the longitudinal polarisations of W+, W- and Z and are not observable; (2) in QCD, the pions (and the pseudoscalar octet), pseudo-Goldstone bosons of the chiral-flavour symmetry broken by the quark condensate, made light rather than massless by the small quark masses. Outside: the unbroken directions (the photon; the Higgs boson; the diagonal flavour SU(3)). |
| nested level | A mode of a field, not an independent building block. The would-be ones are part of the Higgs field and end up inside the massive weak bosons. The pions are quark-antiquark mesons riding on the QCD vacuum condensate, and as virtual particles they model the nuclear force between nucleons. Same shape in condensed matter: phonons, magnons. |
| scale | subatomic |
Measures (12) published science
| number of Goldstone bosons | one per broken generator (internal symmetries) |
| would-be Goldstone bosons eaten in the Standard Model | 3 (W+, W-, Z) |
| electroweak crossover temperature | 159.5 +/- 1.5 GeV |
| electroweak symmetry breaking epoch | ~10^-12 s after the Big Bang |
| W and Z masses (approximate) | around 80 GeV/c^2 |
| quark condensate | ~ -(250 MeV)^3 MeV^3 |
| pion decay constant f_pi | ~93 MeV |
| charged pion mass | 139.57018 +/- 0.00035 MeV/c^2 |
| neutral pion mass | 134.9 MeV/c^2 |
| charged pion mean life | 2.6033 +/- 0.0005 x 10^-8 s |
| hadron epoch onset (quark epoch ends) | ~10^-6 s after the Big Bang |
| history (dates from the Higgs mechanism, Goldstone boson refs, Meson and Chiral symmetry breaking articles) | Nambu 1960 (BCS context); Goldstone 1961-62; Anderson 1962; Brout-Englert, Higgs, Guralnik-Hagen-Kibble 1964; Yukawa meson 1934-35, pion discovered 1947; Nambu Nobel 2008 years |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- partner-becomes-part (structural)
Because the electroweak symmetry is gauged, the would-be Goldstone bosons 'are absorbed by the three gauge bosons', giving them 'a mass and the associated necessary third polarization degree of freedom': the mode stops being a separate particle and becomes part of the W and Z. - same toolkit, independent builds (structural)
Goldstone's theorem: one gapless mode per broken generator, built separately in unconnected systems: the would-be ones of the electroweak Higgs doublet, the pions (pseudo, chiral QCD), phonons (fluids, solids, superfluids) and magnons (magnets: a ferromagnet has 1, an antiferromagnet 2).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (10) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Electroweak interaction via sys:higgs-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) loss
- Atomic nucleus via sys:residual-strong-force · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) even
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) even
- Higgs field via sys:higgs-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) mixed
- W boson via sys:weak-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) loss
- Quark via sys:strong-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) mixed
- Z boson via sys:weak-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) loss
- Quark condensate (chiral condensate) via sys:strong-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) gain
- Moduli space of vacua (vacuum manifold) via sys:higgs-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) gain
- SU(3) colour gauge group via sys:strong-field · Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
Sits inside / holds (4)
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (19)
- Weak field
- Strong (colour) field
- Higgs field
- Electroweak interaction
- W boson
- Z boson
- Higgs boson
- Atomic nucleus
- Photon
- Residual strong force (nuclear force)
- Quark
- Muon neutrino
- Muon
- Pion (pi meson)
- Kaon (K meson)
- Quark condensate (chiral condensate)
- Gauge boson
- Moduli space of vacua (vacuum manifold)
- Quantum field theory
Kinds (7)
- Pion (pi meson)
- Kaon (K meson)
- Phonon
- Magnon
- Eta meson (pseudo-Goldstone boson)
- Axion
- Goldstino (Nambu-Goldstone fermion)
wired (2)
Notes published science
- The two-sided fix: gauge theory couldn't give the W and Z mass, and symmetry breaking predicted massless Goldstone bosons nobody saw. Together the two problems 'neutralise' each other, and the result is massive W/Z with no Goldstones.
- The Goldstone boson is the anti-regulator: it is precisely the direction in which the system has no restoring force, a flat valley of equally good vacua. Moving along it costs nothing, which is why it is massless.
- Eaten to give weight: three would-be particles that never appear as themselves are what give the W and Z their mass and their third way of spinning. The W's heaviness is partly made of a particle that does not exist.
- The pion, the nuclear-force carrier Yukawa predicted in 1934, turns out to be a nearly-Goldstone boson: nuclei hold together through the cheap ripple of a broken symmetry, light only because the quarks are nearly massless.
- The interaction's own breaking is a partner-becomes-part event at the bottom rung: three would-be free Goldstone bosons are taken in as the third polarization of W+, W- and Z, and that is what makes the weak force short-range.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Higgs field
- L1: Complex doublet of four components; Higgs potential lambda(|phi|^2 - Phi^2)^2 (sombrero)
- L2: Degenerate vacuum: the Goldstone mode parameterises the curve of possible degenerate vacuum states; a zero-mass eigenvalue of the mass matrix along each broken direction
- L3: Gauged case: Goldstone's argument fails because a symmetry generator is only a gauge transformation; the three would-be Goldstone bosons are absorbed by the three gauge bosons of the broken generators
- L4: W and Z massive (around 80 GeV/c^2), short-ranged; photon massless; one remaining degree of freedom is the Higgs boson
colour field / QCD vacuum
- L1: QCD vacuum with a quark condensate of about -(250 MeV)^3, induced by non-perturbative strong interactions
- L2: Chiral flavour symmetry of the light quarks (u, d, s) spontaneously broken to the diagonal SU(3); an octet of pseudoscalar Nambu-Goldstone bosons
- L3: Explicit breaking by small quark masses: pseudoscalar masses vary as the square root of the quark masses; pi+/- 139.57018 +/- 0.00035 MeV, pi0 134.9 MeV; f_pi ~ 93 MeV
- L4: Virtual pion as the modelled carrier of the nuclear force between protons and neutrons
- L5: Charged pion decays to an antimuon and a muon neutrino (weak), mean life 2.6033 x 10^-8 s
electromagnetic field (photon)
- L1: The photon: the components that do not mix with Goldstone bosons form a massless photon; zero mass, consistent with the infinite range of electromagnetism
- L2: Pions are pseudoscalars; their currents couple to the axial vector current and so take part in the chiral anomaly, the coupling through which the neutral pion decays electromagnetically
- L3: Neutral pion (135.0 MeV) decays electromagnetically in 8.5e-17 s: two photons (branching 0.98823) or the Dalitz mode, one photon plus an electron-positron pair (0.01174); odd photon numbers forbidden by C-symmetry
weak interaction (W and Z, receiving end)
- L1: W and Z bosons: massive force carriers, in contrast to the zero-mass photon of electromagnetism's infinite range
- L2: Of the four components of a Goldstone boson created by the Higgs field, three are absorbed by the W+, Z0 and W- to form their longitudinal components; the rest of the bosons' mass comes with them
- L3: The weak interaction is sensitive only to the left chirality component of fields; in beta decay a down quark turns into an up quark through an intermediate W-
- L4: Short range: the bosons' masses are far greater than a proton's, so the weak force acts over less than the diameter of a proton; charged pions decay through it (mean life 2.6033e-8 s, 99.9877% to a muon and muon neutrino)
Who fills each layer
- L2: Quark condensate (chiral condensate), Moduli space of vacua (vacuum manifold)
- L3: Pion (pi meson)