← all systems · see it in The System
Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking)
At intermediate densities we expect some other phases (labelled "non-CFL quark liquid" in the figure) whose nature is presently unknown. They might be other forms of color-superconducting quark matter, or something different.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Non-CFL quark liquid |
| born at | hypothesised: inside neutron-star cores, within seconds of the star's birth as the core drops below about 1 MeV (if any core reaches quark density) |
| born precision | unknown |
| boundary | Inside: cold (below about 1 MeV) deconfined quark matter of up, down and strange quarks at densities between the transition from nuclear matter and the onset of CFL pairing, electrically and colour neutral in bulk, in beta equilibrium. Outside: nuclear matter below (a hybrid star's mantle), CFL quark matter above (if the core is dense enough), and the hot quark-gluon plasma above the pairing critical temperatures. |
| nested level | A labelled region of the conjectured QCD phase diagram (quark matter at intermediate density); its candidate fillings are colour-superconducting phases or something else. Built from u, d, s quarks and gluons (with neutralising electrons); would be embedded in neutron-star (hybrid-star) cores. |
| scale | subatomic |
Measures (18) published science
| strange quark current mass (review) | about 90 MeV |
| light quark current masses (review) | 5 or less MeV |
| quark chemical potential where hadrons melt into quark matter | around 400 (inter-quark separation below 1 fm) MeV |
| nuclear matter boundary | mu = 310, T close to zero MeV |
| Fermi-momentum splitting (lowest order) | Ms^2/(4 mu), growing as density falls MeV |
| CFL gap that closes the non-CFL window | about 100 (no window); a 25 MeV gap leaves a window |
| stress thresholds (review's 25 MeV example) | gCFL onset Ms^2/mu about 2 Delta = 50 MeV; CFL unfavoured against unpaired at about 4 Delta = 100 MeV; single-flavour only when Ms^2/(mu Delta) about 10 or more |
| pairing critical temperature scale | of order 100 MeV (10^12 K), the QCD scale |
| single-flavour pairing critical temperature | perhaps a few MeV; more typically eV to many keV |
| neutron-star core temperature after birth | below 1 MeV within seconds; through keV over millions of years |
| characteristic clock: quark matter in a compact star | cubic kilometres for millions of years |
| neutrino cooling era | about a million years |
| direct Urca emissivity, unpaired quark matter (reference values) | about 4 x 10^25 x (T/10^9 K)^6 at alpha_s 0.5, Ms^2/mu 100 MeV, mu 500 MeV erg cm^-3 s^-1 |
| rigidity relative to the crust | 20 to 1000 times more rigid ratio |
| millisecond X-ray pulsar spins (13 known) | 270 to 619 Hz |
| fastest known pulsar (at the review's writing) | 716 Hz |
| hybrid-star maximum mass (generic CSS equation of state) | above 2 solar masses for reasonable parameters M_sun |
| species near the Fermi surface | 9 (3 colours x 3 flavours); 9 x 9 pairing matrix count |
Open contentions (3) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-298 What makes some neutron stars cool so fast?
booked: The map allows that they may hold a certain kind of quark matter, and keeps ordinary dense matter cooling just as fast alongside.
the other reading: baryonic matter with direct Urca (dense nuclear matter, hyperons) does the same - C-299 Where do sudden pulsar spin-ups ('glitches') start: in the crust or in a crystalline core?
booked: The map follows the standard view that glitches start in the crust, and keeps a crystalline quark core as a possible site.
the other reading: the standard crustal locus (neutron superfluid pinned to nuclei), itself questioned by Link 2007 - C-305 Is there a density range where a certain kind of quark matter can exist in neutron stars?
booked: The map allows that such a window may exist, and keeps the calculations that leave no window alongside.
the other reading: no window: a CFL gap near 100 MeV carries CFL down to nuclear matter; weak-coupling NJL leaves no 2SC window
Cross-scale patterns seen here (8) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
One job, keeping some pairing when the quarks' Fermi surfaces are pulled apart, met by unlike builds: a kaon condensate ('bend rather than break'), gapless pairing, pairs with momentum in a crystal, single-flavour pairing, a gluon condensate, mixed phases ('Another way for a system to deal with a st - lightning (partial)
Glitches: tension stored in pinned vortices discharges in a sudden avalanche that speeds up the crust; a rigid crystalline quark core 'provides all the necessary conditions' to be where some start. - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
The homogeneous gapless phases sit at an unstable point: an imaginary Meissner mass means small fluctuations grow, 'an instability towards spontaneous breaking of translational invariance', so lower states (crystals, currents) must take their place. - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Crystalline (LOFF) pairing, 'first proposed in condensed matter physics' (Fulde-Ferrell 1964, Larkin-Ovchinnikov 1965), is predicted again in quark matter and sought in cold trapped atoms: three unrelated fermion systems, same parts (attraction plus mismatched Fermi surfaces), same proposed answer. - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Neutrality of the whole bulk fixes the electric and colour chemical potentials ('large volumes of matter must be electrically and color-neutral'); each flavour then reads its own Fermi momentum, and the readings no longer close into one shared surface (the stress). - who opens the door (partial)
Pinning sites for superfluid vortices would be laid down by the crystal itself: vortices sit 'along the intersections of the nodal planes of the underlying crystal structure', where the condensate already vanishes. - nested ladder (surface)
Thresholds in the stress Ms^2/mu against the gap: bend (K0 condensate), then gapless onset (about 2 Delta), CFL unfavoured against unpaired (about 4 Delta), single-flavour only (Ms^2/(mu Delta) about 10). - same shape, opposite sign (surface)
CFL is an insulator in the rotated charge; gCFL a conductor, 'the analogue of an insulator to metal transition at which a band that was unfilled in the insulating phase drops below the Fermi energy'.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (17) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Electron via sys:electromagnetic-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) even
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) even
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
- Neutrino via sys:weak-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) loss
- QCD matter (quark matter and its phase diagram) via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
- Neutron star via sys:gravitational-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
- Gluon via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
- Kaon (K meson) via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) even
- Nuclear matter via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:mental-representation · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) even
- Colour-flavour-locked quark matter via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
- Up quark via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
- Down quark via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
- Strange quark via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) loss
- Neutron star superfluid interior via sys:gravitational-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) mixed
- Strange matter via sys:strong-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) even
- Hybrid star via sys:gravitational-field · Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
Sits inside / holds (2)
floor filled by (20)
- Electron
- Photon
- Neutrino
- Neutron star
- W boson
- Gluon
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Up quark
- Down quark
- Strange quark
- Neutron star superfluid interior
- Cooper pair
- Hybrid star
- 2SC quark matter (two-flavour colour superconductor)
- Crystalline colour superconductor (LOFF)
- Meson supercurrent phase (curCFL-K0)
- Colour-spin-locked (single-flavour) quark matter
- Gluon-condensed 2SC phase
- Gapless CFL (gCFL)
- Polarised trapped Fermi gas (cold atoms)
represents (1)
Kinds (12)
- QCD matter (quark matter and its phase diagram)
- Quark matter
- 2SC quark matter (two-flavour colour superconductor)
- Crystalline colour superconductor (LOFF)
- Meson supercurrent phase (curCFL-K0)
- Colour-spin-locked (single-flavour) quark matter
- Gluon-condensed 2SC phase
- Gapless CFL (gCFL)
- Gapless 2SC (g2SC)
- Mixed (charge-separated) quark phase
- Unpaired quark matter (normal Fermi liquid)
- Strongly coupled diquark or hexaquark condensate
Notes published science
- Squeeze quark matter hard enough and quarks pair up like electrons in a superconductor; at middling densities the strange quark is too heavy to keep in step, and physicists still do not know which of a dozen candidate arrangements takes over.
- One candidate is a crystal that is also a superfluid: pairs with momentum form a lattice 20 to 1000 times more rigid than a neutron star's crust, a possible place where some pulsar glitches begin.
- Inside such matter the photon survives by mixing with a gluon into a new 'rotated photon', an MeV-scale echo of how the ordinary photon was born from electroweak mixing in the first instants of the universe.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
degenerate quark Fermi seas: BCS pairing at mismatched Fermi surfaces (degenerate matter)
- L1: A degenerate Fermi liquid of quarks: near the Fermi surface the quarks are almost free (asymptotic freedom)
- L2: BCS: with any attraction, pairs form near the Fermi surface and condense (the review's 'inevitability' argument)
- L3: Mismatch: cross-species pairs survive only while the stress is below the gap; at the Chandrasekhar-Clogston point a two-species system jumps to the unpaired phase; gaplessness sets in at delta-mu = Delta
- L4: Non-BCS answers: Cooper pairs with nonzero momentum, each flavour keeping its own Fermi momentum, only rings of the Fermi surface paired (LOFF; first proposed for metals); cold trapped atoms test the same stress
electromagnetic field: rotated photon, conduction and the star's magnetic field
- L1: Photon field and the quarks' electric charges
- L2: Rotated photon: in many phases the photon mixes with one gluon into a new massless combination (an MeV-scale echo of electroweak mixing)
- L3: Conduction: 2SC conducts (ungapped blue and strange quarks), neither superfluid nor electromagnetic superconductor; gCFL conducts where CFL insulates; many single-flavour phases and gluon-condensed 2SC are electrical superconductors
- L4: Response: single-flavour phases appearing late could significantly affect the star's magnetic field dynamics
gravity: the neutron-star core as the piston (gravitational field)
- L1: Gravity compresses the core past nuclear density and holds it while it cools: the only known piston
- L2: Whether the core reaches quark matter is unknown (critical density unknown); a non-CFL window exists only if the CFL gap is small (25 MeV in the review's example; none at about 100 MeV)
- L3: A crystalline core would be rigid (shear moduli 20 to 1000 times the crust's) and superfluid; vortices expected along the crystal's nodal-plane intersections
- L4: Readouts: (some) glitches might start in the core; a deformed rigid core would radiate gravitational waves (LIGO limits); r-mode spin limits constrain viscosities; hybrid-star masses above two solar masses allowed
strong (colour) field: quark Cooper pairing under stress
- L1: Gluon exchange: the quark-quark strong interaction is powerfully attractive in some channels; at high density the coupling is weak and confinement never arises
- L2: Nine species near the Fermi surfaces (red, green, blue x up, down, strange): a 9 x 9 colour-flavour matrix of pairing patterns, each breaking different symmetries
- L3: Stress: neutrality, beta equilibrium and the strange-quark mass split the flavours' Fermi momenta (about Ms^2/4mu), more as density falls; every BCS pattern suffers
- L4: The region itself: phases 'whose nature is presently unknown'. Candidates: 2SC (u-d of two colours; strange and blue unpaired), crystalline LOFF (CubeX, 2Cube45z), meson supercurrent (curCFL-K0), single-flavour pairing (colour-spin locking), gluon condensation, secondary pairing; mixed phases disfavoured; or a strongly coupled diquark or hexaquark condensate; gapless g2SC and gCFL are unstable
- L5: Symmetry and stability: gluons made massive (colour Meissner); 2SC breaks SU(3) colour to SU(2) red-green; gapless phases carry an imaginary Meissner mass (chromomagnetic instability), cured in crystalline phases or by a gluon condensate
weak interaction: beta equilibrium, electrons and neutrino cooling
- L1: The weak interaction equilibrates flavour over the star's long life; neutrinos escape, so lepton number is not held
- L2: Beta equilibrium and neutrality fix each flavour's chemical potential; electrons present (mu_e = Ms^2/4mu) but unimportant for neutrality
- L3: Direct Urca in phases with unpaired quarks (crystalline, single-flavour, unpaired): emissivity rising as T^6, about 4 x 10^25 erg cm^-3 s^-1 at the review's reference values, against T^15 in CFL
- L4: Cooling: about a million years of neutrino cooling of an isothermal interior; stars too cold for their age (3C58, CTA1, SAX J1808.4-3658) may hold non-CFL quark matter or baryonic alternatives