← all systems · see it in The System
End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released
The Late Ordovician mass extinction (LOME), sometimes referred to as the end-Ordovician mass extinction or the Ordovician-Silurian extinction, is the first of the 'big five' major mass extinction events in Earth's history, occurring roughly 445 million years ago. Extinction was global, eliminating 49-60% of marine genera and nearly 85% of marine species, traditionally in two pulses (LOMEI-1 at the Katian-Hirnantian boundary, LOMEI-2 in the later Hirnantian); diversity gradually recovered to pre-extinction levels over the first 5 million years of the Silurian. Walked here as a release: the crisis, what failed, who survived and why, and the radiation that refilled the space.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the marine biosphere and the Earth-system processes that struck it from the late Katian through the Hirnantian into the Rhuddanian (about 445 to 440 Ma): the Gondwanan ice and the sea-level fall it caused, ocean cooling and the polar-front shift, the Hirnantian-Rhuddanian ocean anoxia and euxinia, the losers (endemic shelf faunas, the Foliomena fauna, the Hirnantia fauna, conodonts, Cambrian-type faunas), the survivors and their refugia, and the Silurian refilling (sponge grounds, atrypid brachiopods, crinoids, the first radiations of jawed vertebrates). Outside: the GOBE build-up before it, the later Silurian events (Ireviken, Mulde, Lau), the land (only rare spores of small plants) and the organisms' own body machinery, which belongs to their walked owners. |
| nested level | A turning point inside the Ordovician-Silurian boundary of Paleozoic Earth: it ends the Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event's 'cascading' rise and opens the Silurian, which 'has been viewed by some palaeontologists as an extended recovery interval'. Built from its stages (late Katian, Hirnantian, Rhuddanian), its drivers (Late Ordovician glaciation, Hirnantian-Rhuddanian anoxic event; contested volcanism, gamma-ray burst, metals, impact), its losers and survivors. Embedded in sys:paleozoic-earth, at the top of sys:ordovician-period and the base of sys:silurian-period. |
| scale | ecological |
Measures (33) published science
| timing of the extinction | roughly 445 Ma |
| timing of the extinctions (Ordovician article) | approximately 447-444 Ma |
| timing (vertebrate study) | about 445 to 443 Ma |
| Hirnantian Stage: start (GSSP Wangjiawan, FAD Normalograptus extraordinarius) | 445.2 +/- 0.9 Ma |
| Hirnantian Stage: end = base of Silurian (GSSP Dob's Linn, Akidograptus ascensus) | 443.1 +/- 0.9 Ma |
| Hirnantian Stage: duration | about 2.1 Myr |
| Rhuddanian Stage: start (Silurian article stage table, older chart value) | 443.8 Ma |
| Aeronian Stage: start (Silurian article stage table) | 440.8 Ma |
| zircon dates bracketing the Hirnantian (Dob's Linn: Hartfell / Birkhill shales) | 445.7 +/- 2.4 / 438.7 +/- 2.1 Ma |
| characteristic clock: crisis span (the Hirnantian, bracketed by both pulses) | about 2.1 Myr |
| characteristic clock: Hirnantian glacial peak | approximately 0.5 to 1.5 Myr |
| characteristic clock: survivors evolving into near-copies of the pre-extinction species | within two or three Myr |
| characteristic clock: recovery to pre-extinction diversity | over the first 5 Myr of the Silurian |
| biodiversity rebound delayed by (capture-recapture curve) | at least 35 Myr |
| Ordovician Radiation phase before the extinction | 15 Myr |
| slow accumulation separating the Cambrian and Ordovician radiations | 50 Myr |
| global anoxia duration (Hirnantian-Rhuddanian) | more than 3 Myr |
| marine genera lost / marine species lost | 49-60% / nearly 85% |
| marine families lost | around 100 (about 49% of genera) families |
| brachiopod and bryozoan families lost | one third fraction |
| trilobite genera / families lost (Katian to Silurian) | about 70% / 50% |
| crinoid genera lost | about 70% |
| bryozoan genera lost | over a third fraction |
| global sea-level drop | approximately 80 (estimates more than 50 to more than 100) |
| Ordovician sea level (infobox) | 180 m; rising to 220 m in Caradoc and falling sharply to 141 m in end-Ordovician glaciations m above present |
| glacial pulses recorded in North African seismic sections | five pulses |
| atmospheric CO2 before the glaciation | from 7,000 to 4,400 ppm |
| euxinia relative to today | probably one or two orders of magnitude more prevalent ratio |
| anoxia proxy thresholds (FeHR/FeT oxygenated below; FePy/FeHR euxinic above) | 0.38; 0.8 ratio |
| GRB hypothesis: distance; duration; ozone stripped; phytoplankton biomass killed | within 6,000 light-years; about 10 s; half; 20% to 60% |
| rate of a dangerously near GRB | two or more per billion years per Gyr |
| sponge species after the extinction (Zhejiang sites) | over 75 species |
| Ordovician meteorite flux vs today (not tied to the extinction) | about 100 times ratio |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (16)
- Earth in the Paleozoic era (Cambrian to Permian)
- Sponge (Porifera)
- Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life)
- Jawed vertebrate (gnathostome)
- Trilobites (yielding, then diversifying)
- Planktonic graptolites
- Hirnantian Stage (445.2 +/- 0.9 to 443.1 +/- 0.9 Ma)
- Rhuddanian Stage (first stage of the Silurian; from 443.1 +/- 0.9 Ma)
- Late Ordovician (Hirnantian) glaciation on Gondwana
- Epicontinental (shelf) seaways
- Late Ordovician warm-water endemic shelf faunas (loser, pulse 1)
- Foliomena fauna (deep dysoxic brachiopods; loser, pulse 1)
- Hirnantia fauna (cold-water brachiopods; with the Mucronaspis trilobite fauna)
- Brachiopods
- Conodonts (stem-cyclostome jawless vertebrates)
- Hirnantian-Rhuddanian ocean anoxic event (HOAE)
Sits inside / holds (4)
- Hydrosphere (Earth's planetary water, above all the early ocean)
- Earth in the Paleozoic era (Cambrian to Permian)
- Ordovician Period (486.85 +/- 1.5 to 443.1 +/- 0.9 Ma)
- Silurian Period (443.1 +/- 0.9 to 419.62 +/- 1.36 Ma)
Trades with (valence) (20)
- Cyanobacterium (Cyanobacteria, phylum Cyanobacteriota) via sys:redox-gradient · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life) via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Ocean currents (the ocean circulation) via sys:biogeographic-connectivity · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released mixed
- Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event (GOBE) via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Dioxygen (O2) via sys:redox-gradient · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Bacterium (bacterial cell) via sys:redox-gradient · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released even
- Ozone layer (ozone shield) via sys:electromagnetic-field · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Atmosphere of Earth via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Sponge (Porifera) via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released loss
- Jawed vertebrate (gnathostome) via sys:ocean-currents · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released loss
- Franklin large igneous province and continental flood basalts via sys:redox-gradient · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Planktonic graptolites via sys:redox-gradient · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released mixed
- Late Ordovician (Hirnantian) glaciation on Gondwana via sys:water-cycle · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Epicontinental (shelf) seaways via sys:water-cycle · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Hirnantia fauna (cold-water brachiopods; with the Mucronaspis trilobite fauna) via sys:thermal-energy · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released mixed
- Brachiopods via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Conodonts (stem-cyclostome jawless vertebrates) via sys:ocean-currents · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Gamma-ray burst via sys:electromagnetic-field · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Phytoplankton (and the planktonic food base) via sys:electromagnetic-field · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
- Early land plants and microphytoplankton (CO2 drawdown) via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released gain
expressed by (4)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (2)
slides to (5)
- Jawed vertebrate (gnathostome)
- Cold-water vs warm-water faunas for shelf ecospace (cooling; flips at deglaciation)
- Bloom decay vs benthos for dissolved oxygen (Hirnantian-Rhuddanian anoxia)
- Cyanobacteria vs eukaryotic algae for fixed nitrogen
- Survivors and newcomers for the vacated Silurian ecospace (the release)
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- The same move killed twice in opposite directions: cooling wiped out the warm-water specialists, and the cold-water Hirnantia fauna that took their place was wiped out when the warmth came back. 'Just as the species were adapting, however, the climate changed again.'
- A continent as a lifeboat: 'a relict warm-water fauna continued to persist because South China blocked the transport of cold waters'. And the animals that died from too much oxygen: the DDO graptolites, 'well adapted to anoxic conditions', died when the glacial ocean was oxygenated.
- The extinction may have made us: after it, 'parallel, endemic radiations of jawed ... vertebrates in isolated refugia' gave the first definitive appearances of most major vertebrate lineages (Hagiwara & Sallan 2026). Sponge meadows (over 75 species) were the first to take the empty seafloor, and held the mud still so the shelled animals could settle back.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
atmospheric carbon dioxide and climate
- L1: Atmospheric CO2 falls from 7,000 ppm to 4,400 ppm before the glaciation
- L2: Drawdown routes: land plants and microphytoplankton, silicate weathering of the uplifting Appalachians and Caledonides, organic-carbon burial, volcanic phosphorus fertilising algae, a hypothetical Katian LIP sink
- L3: Exposed carbonate platforms weathered, 'a positive feedback loop of inorganic carbon sequestration'; marked d13C excursions
- L4: Greenhouse to icehouse: the Hirnantian glaciation, its glacial peak brief (approximately 0.5 to 1.5 Myr)
- L5: Rival cooling triggers: sulphur aerosols and volcanic winters starting 'a runaway ice-albedo positive feedback loop'; impact winter; true polar wander; a temporary planetary ring shading the Sun
gamma rays, ozone and ultraviolet (hypothesis)
- L1: A gamma-ray burst from a hypernova within 6,000 light-years: 'a nearly impulsive energy input of order 10 s'
- L2: Half the ozone stripped almost immediately; ozone dissociates and its oxygen atoms react with nitrogen to form nitrogen dioxide, a dark aerosol that cools
- L3: NO2 rains out as nitric acid; nitrates enhance wetland productivity and carbon sequestration, consistent with the d13C excursion
- L4: Intense solar extreme ultraviolet at the surface of clear, oligotrophic Ordovician oceans
- L5: 20% to 60% of total phytoplankton biomass killed; planktonic groups and shallow-water species harder hit than seabed and deep-water ones
ice and sea level (glacioeustasy over Gondwana)
- L1: Vast, shallow Ordovician seas: the highest sea levels of the Paleozoic (180 m, rising to 220 m in the Caradoc)
- L2: Ice caps form on Gondwana as it drifts over the South Pole (North Africa, northeastern South America); glaciation 'locks up water from the world-ocean'
- L3: Sea level falls approximately 80 m worldwide (estimates more than 50 m to more than 100 m); to 141 m in the end-Ordovician glaciations
- L4: Epicontinental seaways drained; the habitat of many endemic communities eliminated; genera with large shares of their ranges truncated hit hardest
- L5: Interglacials free water: seas return 'carrying diminished founder populations', then withdraw again with the next pulse (five glacial pulses in North African strata); deglaciation floods the shelves and the cold fauna dies
ocean circulation and dispersal between refugia
- L1: Bottom-water formation shifts from low to high latitudes; increased deep-ocean currents and bottom-water oxygenation; the breakdown in circulation brings up abyssal nutrients
- L2: South China blocks the transport of cold Gondwanan water, so a relict warm-water fauna persists on the Yangtze Platform
- L3: Relict populations hold on in deeper or isolated refugia (Lazarus taxa); brachiopod survivors endemic to one palaeoplate or one locality
- L4: Parallel, endemic radiations of jawed and related jawless vertebrates in isolated refugia; a post-extinction low-diversity 'gap'
- L5: Ranges expand; Silurian faunas among the most cosmopolitan of the Phanerozoic; 'the challenges of oceanic dispersal likely further delayed the dominance of jawed gnathostomes for millions of years'
ocean temperature and the polar front
- L1: An intense greenhouse ocean; 'most shallow sea habitats in the Ordovician were located in the tropics' and the biota were adapted to it
- L2: Cooling: 'the southward shift of the polar front severely contracted the available latitudinal range of warm-adapted organisms'
- L3: Thermal tolerance as the filter: extinction risk set by the maximum palaeolatitude at which a genus had been sampled; exclusively tropical taxa died beyond the model's expectation
- L4: Cold-water Hirnantia brachiopod fauna and Mucronaspis trilobite fauna spread over outer shelves at lower latitudes
- L5: Deglacial warming: the Hirnantia and Mucronaspis faunas are finished off in the second pulse and replaced by Silurian-style warm-water assemblages
seafloor substrate in the recovery
- L1: Depauperate, anoxic seafloor of the earliest Rhuddanian left by the crisis
- L2: Sponges colonise it: over 75 sponge species, many with soft tissue, at contemporaneous Zhejiang sites; 'conditions of ecological collapse increase the particulate food sources for sponges'
- L3: Sponges stabilise the sediment surface
- L4: Sessile suspension feeders (brachiopods, corals, bryozoans) recolonise; atrypids first to rediversify in the Rhuddanian (Oslo a hotbed), pentamerides delayed to the Aeronian
- L5: Diversity back to pre-extinction levels over the first 5 Myr of the Silurian (encyclopedia), or a rebound delayed by at least 35 Myr (Rasmussen 2019); the Cambrian-type fauna 'unable to rediversify'
seawater redox (oxygen, sulfide, ferrous iron, nutrients)
- L1: Dissolved oxygen and a chemocline in seawater; the Ordovician ocean 'very low levels of sulfate'; glacial bottom water formed at high latitudes oxygenated the deep sea
- L2: Nutrients (nitrate, phosphate) feed cyanobacterial or algal blooms that deplete oxygen; nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria win when record-high denitrification depletes nitrate; volcanic phosphorus may start sediment phosphorus recycling
- L3: Anoxic water forms sulfide (euxinia) and ferrous iron, buries pyrite and frees toxic metals; FeHR/FeT above 0.38 and FePy/FeHR above 0.8 mark anoxia and euxinia
- L4: The Hirnantian ocean anoxic event: black shale 'the dominant oceanic sediment at all latitudes and depths', ferruginous then euxinic, possibly more than 3 Myr through the Rhuddanian; the top of the water column may have stayed oxygenated
- L5: Second pulse in every region and environment; a third interval in Baltican shelves with a Lilliput effect; thallium shows two rapid excursions of vacillating (de)oxygenation tied to the extinctions
Who fills each layer
- L1: Gamma-ray burst
- L2: Cyanobacterium (Cyanobacteria, phylum Cyanobacteriota)
- L5: Ocean currents (the ocean circulation)