← all systems · see it in The System
Bianchi identities
Identities satisfied by the curvature of any connection: 'The first Bianchi identity takes the form D Theta = Omega ^ theta. The second Bianchi identity takes the form D Omega = 0 and is valid more generally for any connection in a principal bundle'; in tensor notation R_abmn;l + R_ablm;n + R_abnl;m = 0. 'The contracted Bianchi identities are used to derive the Einstein tensor in the Einstein field equations'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the first (algebraic) and second (differential) Bianchi identities of a connection's curvature (and torsion), their contracted form nabla G = 0, and what they do inside the field equations (the 10 -> 6 count and local conservation of stress-energy). Outside: the curvature tensors themselves, the field equations, and the matter whose conservation they guarantee. |
| nested level | Field scale, rung 1, below the first fold. Identities of the curvature of spacetime's connection (Riemann tensor), used by the Einstein field equations (their part, floors 3-4 of that walk). |
| scale | field |
Measures (7) published science
| independent components of each symmetric 4 x 4 tensor in the field equations | 10 count |
| Bianchi identities in the field equations | 4 count |
| independent field equations after the identities | 6 count |
| gauge-fixing degrees of freedom left to the metric (coordinate choice) | 4 count |
| independent components of a curvature tensor obeying the symmetries and first identity | n^2 (n^2 - 1) / 12 count (n = dimension) |
| first derivations of the contracted identities: Voss; Ricci-Curbastro; Bianchi | 1880; 1889; 1902 year |
| characteristic clock: none given in the sources (an identity at each event, not a process) | n/a |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-077 Does spacetime twist (carry torsion) inside spinning matter?
booked: The map follows general relativity, where spacetime has no torsion, and keeps Einstein-Cartan theory's torsion inside spinning matter alongside.
the other reading: Riemann-Cartan: torsion inside spinning matter enters the first identity (D Theta = Omega ^ theta)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Bianchi identities. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (partial)
Local conservation of energy-momentum, built two ways: in curved spacetime by the Bianchi identity through the field equations ('This conservation law is a physical requirement. With his field equations Einstein ensured that general relativity is consistent with this conservation condition'); in fla - templating (partial)
The second identity D Omega = 0 'is valid more generally for any connection in a principal bundle': one identity for the Riemann curvature of spacetime and for every bundle curvature.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (9) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Einstein constraint equations via sys:gravitational-field · Bianchi identities even
- Weyl tensor (Weyl curvature tensor) via sys:spacetime · Bianchi identities even
- Contracted Bianchi identities via sys:spacetime · Bianchi identities gain
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature) via sys:stress-energy · Bianchi identities even
- Torsion tensor (of an affine connection; Einstein-Cartan gravity) via sys:spacetime · Bianchi identities even
- Ricci tensor via sys:spacetime · Bianchi identities even
- Einstein field equations via sys:gravitational-field · Bianchi identities gain
- Riemann curvature tensor via sys:spacetime · Bianchi identities even
- Einstein tensor via sys:spacetime · Bianchi identities even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (16)
- Einstein field equations
- Einstein constraint equations
- Weyl tensor (Weyl curvature tensor)
- Contracted Bianchi identities
- Metric connection
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Torsion tensor (of an affine connection; Einstein-Cartan gravity)
- Metric tensor
- Ricci scalar (scalar curvature)
- Ricci tensor
- Killing vector field
- Affine connection
- Riemann curvature tensor
- Einstein tensor
- Principal bundle
- Cotton tensor
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
wired (2)
Notes published science
- Ten equations, but only six are independent: four Bianchi identities are built in, and they are exactly what forces matter to conserve energy and momentum.
- Energy conservation in curved spacetime is not added by hand: it falls out of a geometric identity that every curved space obeys. Einstein built the field equations so the two would match.
- Four of the ten Einstein equations are not new information at all; they are the Bianchi identities, and the four freedoms they leave are just the freedom to choose coordinates.
- Named after Bianchi (1902), but Aurel Voss had them in 1880 and Ricci-Curbastro in 1889.
- Four of the ten Einstein equations never move anything forward in time: they are a test every snapshot of the universe must pass, and once passed the other six keep it passed forever (the Bianchi identities do the bookkeeping).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Bianchi identities (own: identities of the curvature of a connection)
- L1: A connection omega on a principal bundle and its curvature form Omega = d omega + (1/2)[omega ^ omega] = D omega; on the frame bundle the torsion Theta = d theta + omega ^ theta = D theta; 'the Riemann curvature tensor in Riemannian geometry can be considered as a special case'
- L2: First (algebraic) Bianchi identity: D Theta = Omega ^ theta; for zero torsion R(u, v)w + R(v, w)u + R(w, u)v = 0, R_a[bcd] = 0; 'discovered by Ricci'; with the antisymmetries and interchange symmetry 'the first three identities form a complete list of symmetries of the curvature tensor', leaving n^2(n^2 - 1)/12 independent components; 'If there is nonzero torsion, the Bianchi identities involve the torsion tensor'
- L3: Second (differential) Bianchi identity: D Omega = 0, in tensor form R_abmn;l + R_ablm;n + R_abnl;m = 0 (R_ab[cd;e] = 0); 'valid more generally for any connection in a principal bundle'
- L4: Contracted Bianchi identities: nabla_rho R^rho_mu = (1/2) nabla_mu R, equivalently nabla_mu G^mu-nu = 0; 'named after Luigi Bianchi, although they had been already derived by Aurel Voss in 1880, and independently by Gregorio Ricci-Curbastro in 1889' (Bianchi 1902)
- L5: Constraint count in the field equations: 'Each tensor has 10 independent components. The four Bianchi identities reduce the number of independent equations from 10 to 6, leaving the metric with four gauge-fixing degrees of freedom, which correspond to the freedom to choose a coordinate system'
- L6: The Weyl part: 'Taking traces of the usual second Bianchi identity of the Riemann tensor eventually shows that nabla_a C^a_bcd = 2(n - 3) nabla_[c S_d]b', with S the Schouten tensor; the right side is the Cotton tensor up to a factor
conservation of stress-energy (gravitational field)
- L1: Matter, radiation and fields as the stress-energy tensor T on the right of the field equations G + Lambda g = kappa T
- L2: The contraction gives G^alpha-beta_;beta = 0 for every metric; 'Using the EFE, this immediately gives nabla_beta T^alpha-beta = 0, which expresses the local conservation of stress-energy. This conservation law is a physical requirement. With his field equations Einstein ensured that general relativity is consistent with this conservation condition'; 'The (contracted) Bianchi identities automatically ensure the covariant conservation of the stress-energy tensor in curved spacetimes'
- L3: An ordinary conservation law where there is a symmetry: 'In terms of the densitized stress tensor contracted on a Killing vector xi, an ordinary conservation law holds: d_mu(sqrt(-g) T^mu_nu xi^nu) = 0'
- L4: Why the field equations have this left side: 'David Lovelock has shown that, in a four-dimensional differentiable manifold, the Einstein tensor is the only tensorial and divergence-free function of the g_mu-nu and at most their first and second partial derivatives'
Who fills each layer
- L2: Einstein tensor, Covariant derivative
- L3: Contracted Bianchi identities
- L4: Einstein tensor
- L6: Weyl tensor (Weyl curvature tensor)