← all systems · see it in The System
Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time
'A related mental arrow arises because one has the sense that one's perception is a continuous movement from the known past to the unknown future. This phenomenon has two aspects: memory (we remember the past but not the future) and volition (we feel we can influence the future but not the past)' (Arrow of time). Physicists 'refer to the direction of our memory as the "psychological arrow of time"' (Mlodinow and Brun, citing Hawking 1985); 'past, present, and future are not properties of four-dimensional spacetime but notions describing how individual IGUSes process information' (Hartle).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Psychological (perceptual) arrow |
| born at | about 540 Ma (early Cambrian; limited associative learning); unlimited associative learning by the middle Cambrian in arthropods and vertebrates |
| born precision | tens of Myr° (the source gives 'probably' and a round date) |
| boundary | Inside: the one-way orientation of a remembering and acting system's time: records only of the past (formed against a prepared state, held, erased at an entropy cost), the present window, the order of episodes (time cells), the forward face (sweeps ahead, planning, the felt openness of the future), the brain's own irreversibility, and the timeline as pictured and spoken. Outside: the thermodynamic, causal, radiative and cosmological arrows that set or feed it; the brain that carries it; the scientific idea of it (rung 11). |
| nested level | A kind of arrow of time carried by nervous systems (rung 7): built from memory traces, time cells, episodic memory and volition; set by the thermodynamic arrow (rung 1). Wide reading (any memory system, Mlodinow and Brun; Hartle's IGUS includes robots) would reach records in rocks and machines (C-011). |
| scale | organism |
Measures (16) published science
| human present window (tau) | of order 0.1 s |
| theta rhythm | 6-10 Hz |
| decoding frame for forward sweeps | 40 ms per frame |
| time cells during encoding | 79 of 509 pyramidal neurons (27 patients) |
| time cells during retrieval | 60 of 509 pyramidal neurons |
| subjects with time cells | 25 of 26 subjects with at least one isolated pyramidal cell |
| encoding interval per item | 1.6 s |
| entropy production, motor task vs rest | 20 times the resting value |
| entropy production, high vs low working-memory load | about 2 fold (2-back vs 0-back) |
| entropy produced per physical response | 0.07 ± 0.03 bits |
| subjects in the whole-brain irreversibility study | 590 healthy adults (Human Connectome Project fMRI, 100 cortical parcels, repetition time 0.72 s) |
| first associative learning | about 540 million years ago (early Cambrian, limited associative learning) |
| unlimited associative learning in molluscs | about 250 million years after arthropods and vertebrates (which had it by the middle Cambrian) |
| scrub-jay worm-cache interval | 120 h (then peanuts cached; tested 4 h later) |
| oddball subjective time dilation | 30-50% (initial studies); around 10% or less (later) % longer perceived duration |
| vicarious trial and error first identified | 1931 year (Gentry, in Muenzinger's laboratory) |
Open contentions (2) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-102 Is the arrow of time set by cosmic expansion tied to the arrow set by rising entropy?
booked: The map treats them as tied, since expansion toward heat death keeps both pointing the same way, and keeps the view that they would part in a contracting universe alongside.
the other reading: no link to the cosmological arrow - C-361 Why do we remember the past and not the future?
booked: The map follows the view that the memory arrow comes from the thermodynamic arrow through forming and erasing records, and keeps the causal and radiation explanations alongside.
the other reading: from the causal arrow (the encyclopedia: 'a consequence of the causal arrow'); or partly from the radiative arrow (Hartle: retarded radiation is 'one reason')
Cross-scale patterns seen here (10) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- causal ceiling (structural)
The robot cannot remember the future partly because radiation is retarded: all it receives comes along its past light cone, so 'it receives no information about it'. - same role, different builds (structural)
Holding information about another time is done by footprints, craters, fission tracks, photographic film, flash drives, computer RAM and brains; Rovelli lists 'footsteps, impact craters, memories in brains and computers, fossils, gravitational waves'. The shared job in plain words: keeping a mark of - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
The front-back timeline: many languages put the future ahead and the past behind; Aymara puts the past ahead (observed) and the future behind (unobserved), in words and gestures. One mapping of time onto the body's front-back axis, sign reversed. - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (structural)
Before: time-symmetric laws and time-symmetric (Type-2) memories that can tell of past or future. The cut: initialising a memory to its ready state raises global entropy. After: Type-3 memories that only ever tell of the past, and with them the epistemic and psychological arrows. - templating (structural)
Time cells reuse the place-cell module: same theta-phase precession, same field-like firing ('Like place cells ... time cells reliably fire at specific and consistent moments'), offered as 'a unifying physiological mechanism for the representation of both spatial and temporal contexts'. Forward swee - outside-to-inside (partial)
Memory moves outward: humans keep 'external memory' (photographs, books, digital storage) beside the brain's internal memory, and a history book is part of the collective schema. Inside first, outside later. - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Each memory reads 'past' locally, but the direction is fixed by the thermodynamic arrow of the surroundings: reversing a robot's psychological arrow would need reversing 'the thermodynamic arrow, not only of the robot, but also of the local environment'; generically every memory aligns where that ar - who opens the door (partial)
A record needs a receiver prepared ahead of time: the film in its initialised state, the pendulum near rest, the retina before the photon; the memory's ready state is the door, set before the event addresses it. - lightning (surface)
The oddball and fear effects: an unexpected or threatening stimulus seems to last longer (30-50% at first report, about 10% or less later), an 'alerting' function; retrospective rather than in the moment (Stetson et al., per the encyclopedia). - nested ladder (surface)
Four kinds of temporal representation (relative distance, temporal relativities, temporal map, past-or-future).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (9) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Causal arrow of time via sys:thermal-energy · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time gain
- Nervous system via sys:electrochemical-gradient · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time gain
- Language (human language) via sys:mental-representation · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time even
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions) via sys:mental-representation · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time gain
- Thermodynamic arrow of time via sys:thermal-energy · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time gain
- Cosmological arrow of time via sys:gravitational-field · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time gain
- Radiative arrow of time via sys:electromagnetic-field · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time gain
- Time via sys:spacetime · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time gain
- Entropy via sys:thermal-energy · Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Episodic memory
- Hippocampus (memory)
- Time cells (hippocampus and entorhinal cortex)
- Volition (the future side)
- Specious present (the present window)
- Time-asymmetric (Type-3) memory
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Nervous system
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)
- Arrow of time
expressed by (6)
- Templating / Standardization
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Offline Simulation & Replay-Guided Planning
floor filled by (20)
- Causal arrow of time
- Photon
- Nervous system
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Language (human language)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Thermodynamic arrow of time
- Entropy
- Episodic memory
- Hippocampus (memory)
- Time cells (hippocampus and entorhinal cortex)
- Volition (the future side)
- Specious present (the present window)
- Temporal representation
- Mental timeline
- Mental time travel
- Entorhinal cortex
- Default mode network
- Retina (eye and retina)
represents (1)
Kinds (2)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- The brain has its own measurable arrow of time: at rest it nearly obeys detailed balance (it would look much the same run backwards), but in a motor task its entropy production jumps about 20-fold, and doubling working-memory load doubles it (Lynn et al. 2021, 590 people).
- To build a robot that remembers the future you would have to reverse the thermodynamic arrow not only in the robot but in its surroundings too: Hartle's 2004 answer to 'why don't we remember the future?'
- Speakers of Aymara put the past in front of them and the future behind, in words and in gestures, because the past is what you can see; most languages do the reverse, and none puts time on a left-right line, though English speakers picture past-left, future-right, probably from the direction of writing.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
psychological arrow as held in mind: the present, the fixed past, the open future and the timeline (mental representation)
- L1: The present as experienced: the specious present (James: 'the short duration of which we are immediately and incessantly sensible'); for human IGUSes a present of order 0.1 s; the robot's conscious focus on its newest register
- L2: Memory and volition: we remember the past but not the future, we feel we can influence the future but not the past; the future felt as 'open', the past as 'fixed'
- L3: Four kinds of temporal representation: relative distance (how long ago), temporal relativities, a temporal map, and past or future as such; animals show some (scrub-jays use elapsed time)
- L4: The timeline in space: back-front in many languages (future ahead) but reversed in Aymara (past ahead, observed); no language uses left-right, though English speakers associate past-left, future-right, probably from writing direction
- L5: Shared and named: the history book as part of the schema of the collective IGUS; physicists' name for the direction of memory, the 'psychological arrow' (Hawking 1985)
psychological arrow in hippocampal and cortical circuits: time cells, sequences, forward sweeps and irreversible dynamics (electrochemical gradient)
- L1: Spikes of pyramidal neurons in the human hippocampus and entorhinal cortex (509 recorded in 27 patients during free recall); in the retina, spike trains of groups of neurons
- L2: Time cells fire within preferred time fields relative to the start and end of an interval; ramping cells (more in entorhinal cortex) carry a complementary kind of time signal
- L3: Theta-phase precession, shared with place cells; sequences of time-cell firing specific to task context; theta rhythm 6-10 Hz
- L4: Temporal context for episodic memory: a consistent time signal at encoding (higher rho) predicts temporal clustering of recalled items; 'what' linked to 'when' for mental time travel
- L5: Forward sweeps: at difficult choice points hippocampal theta sequences sweep ahead of the rat to the goal, alternating between options when unsure and aligning when sure (vicarious trial and error); imagination reuses perceptual circuits
- L6: Whole-brain irreversibility: neural dynamics break detailed balance, nearly balanced at rest and strongly broken in demanding tasks; the arrow of time in brain signals measures non-reversibility (default mode network orchestrating its hierarchy); the retina breaks detailed balance even when its input does not
psychological arrow's input: retarded light from past events (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Retarded radiation: light from the cosmic background, stars and nearby happenings reaches the receiver along its past light cone; all other carriers are similarly retarded
- L2: Absorption: a photon absorbed by the retina is a record formed with an entropy increase; the receiving surface was built ahead of time
psychological arrow: records formed, kept and erased (thermal energy)
- L1: A memory system set apart from what it records, colder and slow to thermalise, waiting in a prepared (initialised, 'ready') state: Rovelli's damped pendulums among hot balls; the unexposed film
- L2: Record formation: an interaction leaves the memory out of equilibrium, correlated with the event (crater, fission track, photographic grain, photon absorbed in the retina); entropy rises with most realistic records
- L3: Holding: a long thermalisation time keeps the trace; the exposed film stays stable, so its state can tell of events far in the past; low entropy turned into available information
- L4: Erasure and re-initialisation: entropy must rise when a record is erased (the robot's last register at each step); initialising a memory to a known state raises global entropy, so the ready state is a past state
- L5: Alignment: an irreversible processor's psychological arrow is congruent with the thermodynamic arrow (Hartle); generically any memory's arrow aligns with it, even a reversible non-dissipative memory (Mlodinow and Brun); Type-3 memories give only the past (Wolpert and Kipper)