← all systems · see it in The System
Spanish American wars of independence
The series of conflicts, 1808-1833 as the encyclopedia dates them, through which the Spanish monarchy's mainland American kingdoms broke away and new states formed: first the Crown's breakup after Napoleon's 1808 invasion of Spain (juntas in Spain and America ruling in the absent king's name), then from 1810 wars over how to rebuild the lost unity (the Cortes of Cádiz's pan-Hispanic state, Ferdinand VII's restored absolutism, and Patriot congresses and armies), ending with the defeat of royalist armies (Ayacucho, 1824), the last royalist bastions and Spanish reconquest attempts. Walked as one system with its wars booked as competitions (QUEUE-BRIEF addendum 7); its causes, its kind of war (independence or civil war), its span, its death toll and its economic effect stay contested.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 25 September 1808 (the Central Junta; infobox) or 1809 (Chacaltaya; Chuquisaca, La Paz, Quito juntas) |
| born precision | day (contested: C-2309) |
| boundary | Inside: the juntas, congresses and constitutions of Spanish America, the Patriot and royalist armies and guerrilla bands fighting on the American mainland, the recruits they drew on, and the Crown's and Cortes's American war effort, 1808-1833. Outside: Napoleonic France and the Peninsular War in Spain (the trigger), Britain, the United States, Portugal-Brazil, Haiti and Russia (outside powers that acted on it), and the states it left behind after 1825-1836. Cuba, Puerto Rico and the Philippines stayed royalist and are outside except where plots touched them. |
| end precision | day |
| ended at | 29 September 1833 (Ferdinand VII's death ends reconquest plans) |
| nested level | Built from people (creoles, peninsulars, mestizos, castas, Indigenous communities, the enslaved), cabildos, juntas, armies and congresses; embedded in the Atlantic Revolutions and the Napoleonic Wars, and in the Spanish monarchy whose American part it dissolved. |
| scale | social |
Measures (37) published science
| Span (as the encyclopedia's infobox dates it) | 25 September 1808 to 29 September 1833 dates |
| Military campaigns, strictly | Chacaltaya 1809 to Tampico 1829 dates |
| News lag from Spain to Spanish America (1814) | three weeks to nine months time |
| Total dead (infobox) | 1,000,000 (600,000 New Spain; 400,000 New Granada) people |
| Total dead, Mexican War of Independence (infobox) | 250,000 to 600,000 people |
| Royalists killed (infobox) | 150,000 people |
| Patriot strength (infobox) | 130,000; 6,500 British volunteers; 3,000 American sailors (100 vessels) people |
| Spain's total deployment (infobox) | 30,000 soldiers |
| 1815 expedition | 10,500 troops, nearly 60 ships troops; ships |
| Morillo's expedition: useful men left of those landed (August-December 1815) | 3,000 of 6,000 (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.5 in about four months) men |
| Reinforcement Morillo said he needed | about 4,000 more men |
| Expeditionary deaths in the San Fernando hospital | 96 (June-December 1816); 72 (1817) deaths |
| European share of royalist armies | about a tenth overall; about half of expeditionary units once deployed fraction |
| European share of royalist forces at three battles | Maipú a quarter; Carabobo about a fifth; Ayacucho under 1% fraction |
| Royalist army in Venezuela by caste, 1820 | 843 white, 5,378 casta, 980 Indigenous soldiers |
| British Legions | upwards of 6,000 men |
| Men from the British Isles serving, 1819 peak | around 10,000 men |
| British Legion losses crossing the Andes (1819) | a quarter fraction |
| Andean passes crossed by Bolívar | nearly 4,000 m |
| Deputies at the Cortes's opening session (24 September 1810) | 104, of whom 30 for overseas territories; 1 of 36 American deputies arrived in time |
| Battle of Ayacucho strengths | Patriots 5,780-8,500; royalists 6,906-9,310 soldiers |
| Battle of Ayacucho casualties | Patriots 979 killed and wounded; royalists 2,500 killed and wounded, 2,000-3,000 captured soldiers |
| Bajío famine of 1785-86 | over 85,000 casualties, no large rebellion people |
| Effect of drought on rebellion before 1808 | +1.6 percentage points per one within-district SD fall in PDSI (more than half the baseline) |
| Effect of drought on rebellion after 1808 | +5 to +13 percentage points per one within-district SD fall in PDSI |
| Insurgency where elites lost the alcabala | 26 to 31 percentage points more likely |
| Insurgency per SD of the 1808 drought | +15 to +21 percentage points |
| Enslaved share of population c. 1800 | Venezuela 12% (112,000); Colombia 8% (61,000); Peru 3% (about 40,000); Ecuador 5,000 people |
| Freedom certificates in Almarza's 1817 protocol | 68 certificates, about 134 people freed (April-October 1817) certificates; people |
| Abolition dates | Chile 1823; Mexico 1829; most others by the early 1850s years |
| Mexican output fall in the 1810s war (short run) | 50% percent of output |
| Mexican output per head 1800-1860 (Coatsworth) | about -0.6% a year percent per year |
| Mexican output per head 1800-1840 (Salvucci) | +21% (0.5% a year) percent |
| Mexican public internal debt 1823-1848 | up nearly 40%; deficits up to 40% of spending percent |
| Spanish rule kept in the Caribbean islands | Cuba and Puerto Rico until 1898 years |
| Spain's renunciation of continental sovereignty | 1836 year |
| Gran Colombia and the Central American federation | collapsed after a decade or two years |
Open contentions (8) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2303 What caused the Spanish American wars of independence?
booked: The map lists the causes and rules none.
the other reading: Enlightenment ideas and the Atlantic examples as the driving cause; creole grievance against the Bourbon reforms as the cause; peasant subsistence crisis and local grievance (Tutino; Van Young) as the cause of mass mobilisation; Pérez Vejo: a problem of political legitimacy, not at origin economic, social or ethnic conflict - C-2304 How many died in the Spanish American wars of independence?
booked: The map keeps the toll contested.
the other reading: 250,000 to 600,000 for Mexico alone (Mexican War of Independence infobox); no open demographic study read - C-2305 What did independence do to Latin American economies?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: Coatsworth: Mexican output per head fell about 0.6% a year 1800-1860; Salvucci: output per head rose about 21% 1800-1840; Prados de la Escosura: GDP per head rose in the half century after emancipation; Iberian institutions not to blame - C-2306 Why did many Indigenous people fight for the Spanish king?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: the colonial and republican sources' negative portrayal, which the review says hides their real aims; allegiance as a banner for local grievance, discarded as quickly as taken up (encyclopedia, general) - C-2307 What did freeing slaves to fight mean?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: 'nothing more than a strategy to persuade enslaved people to join the Republican cause' (the common reading she contests); a tool to forestall more radical collective action (also Vergara Sierra) - C-2308 Were early juntas loyal to the king or a mask for independence?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: the 'mask of Ferdinand VII': loyalty claimed strategically to prepare the masses; Pérez Vejo: whether a mask or not, they had to wear it; a mere mask 'quite improbable' - C-2309 When did the Spanish American wars of independence begin and end?
booked: The map keeps the spans side by side.
the other reading: 1809/1810-1825 (Chuquisaca or the junta wave to Bolivia); to Ayacucho 1824 ('in Peru ... the end'); to 1826 (Callao, Chiloé); to 1836 (Spain's renunciation) - C-2310 Were they civil wars or wars of independence?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: wars of national liberation (the nationalist historiography); civil wars within one society (Pérez Vejo; 'a revolutionary civil war' for Mexico); localized civil wars that spread as secessionist wars
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (15) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- United States (the country across time) via sys:international-system · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- Indigenous peoples of the americas via sys:human · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- Catholic Church via sys:human-society · Spanish American wars of independence mixed
- Spanish Empire via sys:human-society · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- Nationalism via sys:human-society · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- Atlantic slave trade via sys:slavery · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- United Kingdom via sys:international-system · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- Portuguese Empire via sys:international-system · Spanish American wars of independence mixed
- Haitian Revolution via sys:human-society · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- Yellow fever via sys:yellow-fever · Spanish American wars of independence loss
- Age of Enlightenment (the 17th-18th-century intellectual movement: its ideas, its networks of salons, academies, letters and print, and its effects on states and revolutions) via sys:printing-press · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- Russian Empire via sys:ocean · Spanish American wars of independence even
- Colonialism via sys:state · Spanish American wars of independence gain
- Peninsular War (Napoleonic Spain) via sys:human-society · Spanish American wars of independence gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (7)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Cabildos (town councils), the monarchy's basic cellular units
- The juntas of 1808-1810 and the congresses that followed
- Patriot armies (Army of the Andes, Gran Colombia's army, the Mexican insurgents, the Army of the Three Guarantees) and guerrilla bands
- Royalist armies, expeditionary and American
- Cortes of Cádiz and the Spanish Constitution of 1812
- Notaries (escribanos) and their protocol books
Sits inside / holds (4)
- Spanish Empire
- French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars
- Atlantic revolutions
- The first wave: the Americas (1775-1830s)
expressed by (21)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Evade Detection
- Overcome Barrier
- Neutralize Defenses
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Divide & Isolate
- Cascade Induction
- Reactive Response
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (17)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Law (rules and law)
- Ocean
- City
- Maize (and other crops the peoples domesticated)
- Catholic Church
- Nationalism
- Age of Enlightenment (the 17th-18th-century intellectual movement: its ideas, its networks of salons, academies, letters and print, and its effects on states and revolutions)
- The Andes and the Pacific coast
- Cabildos (town councils), the monarchy's basic cellular units
- The juntas of 1808-1810 and the congresses that followed
- Patriot armies (Army of the Andes, Gran Colombia's army, the Mexican insurgents, the Army of the Three Guarantees) and guerrilla bands
- Royalist armies, expeditionary and American
- Cortes of Cádiz and the Spanish Constitution of 1812
- Notaries (escribanos) and their protocol books
- Guerrilla warfare
Kinds (6)
- Mexican War of Independence
- Venezuelan War of Independence
- Argentine War of Independence
- Chilean War of Independence
- Peruvian War of Independence
- Ecuadorian War of Independence
Notes published science
- In 1817, on the steaming banks of the Arauca river, an exiled royal notary wrote 68 freedom certificates that freed about 134 enslaved people, mostly women and children, signed in the name of the guerrilla leader Páez. For 300 years only the king could grant freedom; by accepting these papers, the enslaved were in effect recognising the new republic (src:vergara-sierra-2023-escribano-of-babel).
- A famine in Mexico's Bajío killed over 85,000 people in 1785-86 and started no big revolt. After Napoleon removed the Spanish king in 1808, drought's effect on rebellion jumped about tenfold, and districts whose elites had lost their sales-tax business in the 1770s were 26-31 points more likely to rise (src:garfias-sellars-2018-state-building-backfires).
- Spain's 1815 army lost half its men to the 'infernal climate' within four months of landing: 6,000 arrived, 3,000 were fit by New Year (src:daza-villar-2019-malaria-fiebre-amarilla). Each loss was filled with a local recruit, so by the final battle at Ayacucho fewer than 1% of the king's soldiers were European (src:wp:spanish-american-wars-of-independence).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the Spanish American wars of independence as historians describe them: the monarchy's American kingdoms, their peoples and cities, through the crisis of the Crown, juntas, armies and congresses, to the sovereignty of new states (reader's view; periods in `periods`)
- L1: The world it touches: the monarchy's American kingdoms (New Spain, Peru, New Granada, Río de la Plata and the captaincies), their cities, countryside and peoples, the Bajío and the Andes, the Atlantic to Spain and Napoleon's Europe beyond
- L2: The doors: the cabildos, 'the monarchy's basic cellular units', the ports where news and troops landed, the recruiting promise
- L3: Routing: sovereignty reverts to the peoples; juntas form in city after city on Hispanic law; rivalries route loyalties; news takes three weeks to nine months
- L4: Integration: juntas, armies and guerrilla bands formed; localized civil wars
- L5: Institutions: the Central Junta, Regency and Cortes of Cádiz, the restored king; Patriot congresses and armies; the old bureaucracy destroyed
- L6: Meaning: legitimacy, from dynastic-religious to national; the mask of Ferdinand VII; Spanish, American or patria; liberal or absolutist
- L7: Purpose and action: sovereignty decided; new states on the old boundaries; the nations as the wars' consequence
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Juntas, cabildos and congresses: the bodies that claimed to govern (Caracas, Buenos Aires, Bogotá, Santiago, Chilpancingo, Angostura, Cúcuta), and the itinerant republic of La Emigración
- L5: The armies and guerrilla bands of both camps, conventional and irregular: Army of the Andes, Bolívar's army, Mexican insurgents, Boves's llaneros, the expeditionary army, the republiquetas
- L5: The monarchy's governing bodies: the Supreme Central Junta (1808), the Regency and the Cortes of Cádiz (1810-1814), the restored king (1814), the Trienio Liberal (1820-1823)
- L6: Meaning: who has the right to rule in the king's absence, then where power itself comes from; the mask of Ferdinand VII; being Spanish, American or of one's patria; liberal against absolutist
- L7: Purpose: sovereignty reconstituted, as independent states (declared 1811-1825), a pan-Hispanic constitutional monarchy, or the restored absolute king
way in: Disease: malaria, yellow fever, smallpox, dysentery
- L1: Epidemics common in population and troops
- L2: Unseasoned troops lost to tropical diseases
- L3: Hospitals: more than 600 sick in one Santa Fe hospital when the royal troops arrived (May 1816)
- L4: Morillo: the 'infernal climate' left 3,000 useful men of 6,000
way in: Forces from Spain: expeditions, ships and reinforcements
- L1: A navy collapsed in the war against Napoleon; expeditions arrive in small groups
- L2: 1815: 10,500 troops and nearly sixty ships, Spain's largest New World force
- L3: The soldiers spread across Venezuela, New Granada, Quito and Peru
- L4: Once deployed, Europeans only about half of the expeditionary units
way in: Harvests: drought, maize and food prices
- L1: The 1808 drought and maize failure in New Spain
- L2: Crop prices rise; peasants' opportunity cost of rebelling falls
- L3: While the state was strong, famine did not become rebellion (1785-86)
- L4: Hidalgo's peasant army, fed by years of bad harvests
way in: Ideas: the Enlightenment, popular sovereignty and the Atlantic examples
- L1: Enlightenment ideas of popular sovereignty behind the Atlantic Revolutions
- L2: An enlightened sociability: societies, newspapers, academies
- L3: The Hispanic Enlightenment was Catholic and conservative
- L4: Free trade and physiocratic ideas spread to the empire; a homegrown Spanish American Enlightenment
- L5: The constitutions written in Spain and America during the wars
way in: Indigenous communities: land, protections and a way of life
- L1: Pueblos and resguardos shaped over three centuries (Pasto)
- L2: Protections under traditional Spanish law, threatened by liberal policies
- L3: Alliances with guerrillas in Upper Peru's back country
- L4: Pasto: hostility to the republic in defence of a way of life
way in: Money: church mortgages, situados, war chests
- L1: The 1804 Consolidation calls in church mortgages on elite haciendas
- L2: Spanish American money pays Spain's armies (lost after Ocaña)
- L3: Colonial rule ran no deficits: surplus moved between colonies (situados)
- L4: Bolívar takes Bogotá and its treasury (1819)
way in: Neighbours: rival cities and provinces
- L1: Major cities and their regional rivalries
- L2: Juntas sought their province's independence from the old capital
- L3: The vanished central authority begins a long balkanization
- L4: Peru stays royalist from rivalry with Río de la Plata
way in: Outside powers: Britain, the United States, Haiti, Portugal, Russia, France
- L1: Britain wanted Spanish rule ended and the markets opened
- L2: Aid from Curaçao and Haiti; the British Legions
- L3: British diplomacy blocked aid to Spain
- L4: Recognition: the US in 1822, Portugal in 1821, Britain in 1825
way in: Recruits: the peoples of the Americas as a common pool
- L1: Almost all troops of both sides recruited in the Americas, from native communities above all
- L2: Promises made at enlistment by both sides
- L3: The captured joined the enemy
- L4: The armies reflect the local population: Venezuela's royalists in 1820
way in: Terrain and seasons: the Andes, the llanos, the rains
- L1: Flooded plains and Andean passes near 4,000 m
- L2: The plains' extreme seasons move whole displaced communities
- L3: The tropical climate an enormous difficulty for moving armies
- L4: San Martín's crossing of the Andes 'turned the tables'
way in: The Bourbon reforms: kingdoms renamed colonies, offices to peninsulars, taxes centralised
- L1: The Crown's reforms recast the 'kingdoms' as 'colonies'
- L2: Royal offices again filled with outsiders, almost all peninsulars
- L3: The alcabala's centralisation cut local elites' rents and seeded divisions with the Crown
- L4: Local militias and defence financing in local hands
way in: The Crown's crisis: abdication, juntas in Spain, the Central Junta, the Cortes, the restored king
- L1: Napoleon forces the abdications at Bayonne and installs Joseph Bonaparte (1808)
- L2: The news lands in the viceregal and provincial capitals and their cabildos
- L3: Sovereignty reverts to the peoples and their cabildos, by the contractual theory of the monarchy (Suárez)
- L4: Elections for the Central Junta and the Cortes; later, after 1814, 'wait and see'
way in: The enslaved: enlistment and the claim to freedom
- L1: Slavery c. 1800: Venezuela 12% enslaved (112,000), Colombia 8%, Peru 3%
- L2: Both sides recruit the enslaved
- L3: For 300 years only the king could sanction freedom, through his officials and notaries
- L4: The enslaved weigh the promises; many distrust slaveowning liberators
way out: Armies that did not disband: militarism and caudillos
- L1: Power fragmented, resources and men mobilised
- L5: Armies among the stabler institutions; society militarised
- L7: The caudillos
way out: Borders: the old administrative units become states (uti possidetis)
- L1: Venezuela's territory today is still the Captaincy General of 1810
- L5: Constitutions name the colonial unit: Ecuador 1830, 'the limits of the old Kingdom of Quito'
- L6: Uti possidetis as the principle that demarcated national communities, histories and geographies
- L7: States on the old administrative boundaries
way out: Campaigns and battles
- L1: Battles decided on the ground: Ayacucho, 9 December 1824
- L4: Convergence on Peru after Riego's rebellion
- L5: Armies raised and moved: the crossings of the Andes (1817, 1819)
way out: Declarations of independence, constitutions and new states
- L1: Upper Peru's independence proclaimed at Sucre, 6 August 1825
- L5: The 1812 Constitution as the basis of Mexican and Central American independence; Córdoba keeps it in force
- L7: Venezuela, New Granada and Paraguay declare (1811); Río de la Plata (1816), Chile (1818), Mexico (1821), Central America (1821), Bolivia (1825)
way out: Economies: the trade bloc broken, output lost, a new place in world markets
- L1: Trade among the new nations below colonial levels; Valdivia's depression; Mexican output halved in the 1810s
- L3: Spanish America joins world markets as raw-material exporter
- L7: Over half a century GDP per head rose (contested)
way out: Freedom for the enslaved: letters, free-womb laws, abolitions
- L1: After the wars, children born free brought up and sold as slaves
- L5: Immediate freedom letters notarised in the llanos (1817)
- L7: Río de la Plata ends the slave trade and passes a free-womb law (1813); Peru and Colombia (1821); Chile abolishes (1823); Mexico (1829)
way out: Recognition abroad
- L1: Britain recognises after Ayacucho (1825); Spain renounces continental sovereignty (1836)
- L5: Portugal recognises first (1821), to secure its annexation
- L7: The US recognises five states (1822)
way out: Violence against civilians and forced displacement
- L1: Massacre at the Alhóndiga de Granaditas; Spaniards displaced and later expelled
- L5: Bolívar's decree of war to the death