← all systems · see it in The System
Russian Revolution
The revolutions of 1917 in the Russian Empire and the civil wars that followed, as historians describe them: a period of political and social change starting in 1917 in which Russia abolished its monarchy (the February Revolution, 23 February-3 March 1917 O.S.), lived eight months under a Provisional Government contested by the soviets, saw the Bolsheviks take power through the Petrograd Soviet's Military Revolutionary Committee (25 October O.S. / 7 November 1917), dissolve the Constituent Assembly, make a separate peace (Brest-Litovsk, 3 March 1918) and win a multi-sided civil war against the Whites, the Greens, anarchists, national movements and foreign intervention, ending in the founding of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (30 December 1922). Walked as the political and social process, with its wars booked as competitions (QUEUE-BRIEF addendum 7); its span, causes, character (coup or popular revolution) and tolls stay contested.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 23 February 1917 O.S. (8 March 1917 N.S.) |
| born precision | day (start contested: 1914, the 'continuum of crisis') |
| boundary | Inside: the revolutionary process in the former Russian Empire, 1917-1922: the popular movement's committees and soviets, the parties, the Provisional Government and then the Bolshevik state (Sovnarkom, the Cheka, the Red Army), their decrees, insurrections, terror, requisitions, treaties and wars. Outside: the old regime it took apart (the monarchy, the estates, the old army), the Central Powers and the Allies, the White movement and the other sides of the civil war (booked as takers in the contests), and the long legacies that run on it. |
| end precision | day (end contested: 1921, 1922, 1923) |
| ended at | 30 December 1922 (the Union founded); infobox end 25 October 1922 |
| nested level | Built from people, committees, soviets, parties, armies and print; a period of Russia's history; one revolution of the revolutionary wave of 1917-1923 after the First World War; a part of human society's acts. |
| scale | social |
Measures (43) published science
| Span (encyclopedia infobox) | 8 March 1917 to 25 October 1922 (5 years, 3 months and 8 days) dates |
| Civil war span (Sumpf) | winter 1917-1918 to spring 1921 (Wrangel defeated 10 November 1920; Tambov July 1921) dates |
| February Revolution, duration | about eight days |
| Kornilov's defeat to the seizure of power | about seven weeks (31 August to 25 October 1917 O.S.) |
| Kronstadt rising to the NEP decree | 26 February 1921 to 21 March 1921: about three weeks |
| Constituent Assembly's only sitting | 13 hours (18-19 January 1918) |
| Bolshevik membership | 24,000 (February 1917) to 200,000 (September 1917) members |
| Constituent Assembly vote | 41 million voters; SRs 370 of 707 deputies, Bolsheviks 175 |
| Losses under Brest-Litovsk (encyclopedia) | 34% of population, 54% of industrial land, 89% of coalfields, 26% of railways percent |
| Losses under Brest-Litovsk (Sumpf) | 800,000 km2; 26% of pre-war population, 32% of agricultural production, 23% of industrial output, 75% of coal and iron km2 and percent |
| Russian losses to end of October 1916 | 1.6-1.8 million dead, 2 million prisoners, 1 million missing (nearly 5 million) men |
| Draftees by end of 1917 | about 15.5 million (84-88% peasants) men |
| Grain reaching the market | 12.4% (1909-1913) to 7.4% (1915) percent of grain and fodder crops |
| Food riots | almost 20 (1915); 288 (1916) incidents |
| Budget deficit | 40% (1914), 76% (1915), 78% (1916) percent |
| Paper share of money | 69.5% (early 1914), 82% (end 1914), 100% (late 1916) percent |
| Ruble value, February to October 1917 | 30 to 6-7 pre-war kopecks |
| Currency emissions 1917 | 3 billion rubles March-June; 2.3 billion July-August |
| Locomotives in service, end 1914 to end 1917 | nearly 20,000 to 9,200 locomotives |
| Share of wagons and locomotives ordered abroad that arrived | about one third fraction |
| Requisition goals met (Food Supply Army and kombeds, 1918) | 10% percent of set goals |
| Food brought into Kaluga, last months of 1917 | bag men almost 49 million kg; officials 19 million kg |
| Red Army strength | 360,000 (July 1918), 800,000 (November 1918), 1.5 million (May 1919), 5.5 million (late 1920) men |
| Volunteers for the Red Army, early 1918 | 20,000 against 300,000 hoped for men |
| White armies' rank and file at most | 270,000 south, 150,000 Siberia, 20,000 north-west, 10,000 north men |
| Former Tsarist officers in the Red Army | 50,000 officers |
| Peasants in the Red Army | 83.4% (end 1918); 75% of peasant origin by the end of the war (Gilley) percent |
| Red Army desertions and returns | 917,000 deserted at least once; nearly 380,000 back by July 1919 men |
| Green rebels | 2 to 3 million (about 500,000 arrested by the Cheka) people |
| Red Army troops sent to Tambov | 130,000, against about 30,000 rebels men |
| Party purge, 1919 | nearly 150,000 excluded (one third); 160,000 recruited in Party Week members |
| Real national income per head | fell one fifth 1913-1917; halved 1917-1919; 1918 alone -38.8% change |
| Real money wages at the end of the Civil War | about 4% of prewar percent of prewar |
| Excess deaths, Great War and Civil War | 13 million (Markevich and Harrison); 12 million (Boiarskii); 13.8 million (Maksudov) deaths |
| Civil war casualties (encyclopedia) | 7 to 12 million, mostly civilians casualties |
| Red Terror deaths | no consensus: from 12,733 (Latsis, Cheka executions 1917-1920) and 50,000 to 140,000-200,000 executions plus 400,000; up to 2 million (Volkov, all repression) deaths |
| Typhus deaths 1918-1922 | some 2 to 3 million deaths |
| Famine deaths, 1921-1922 | an estimated five million deaths |
| Pogrom victims 1918-1920 | about 150,000 people |
| Émigrés | 200,000 in Berlin alone; 80,000 to France people |
| Union republics, 1922 to 1940 | 4 founding republics; 16 by 1940 |
| Effective population size through 1918-1922 | census totals affected; genetic effective size not qualitative |
| Women's suffrage march, March 1917 | 40,000 participants people |
Open contentions (10) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2171 What was 'dual power' in 1917?
booked: The map keeps the readings open.
the other reading: dual power: formal authority with the government, the levers with the Soviet (Peeling's standard characterisation; the encyclopedia); not dual power: the Soviet recognised the government and saw itself as a pressure group (Read); in the provinces a multitude of powers (Badcock, Hickey, Figes via Peeling) - C-2175 What caused the 1921 Russian famine?
booked: The map lists the causes and rules none.
the other reading: severe drought, especially in the Volga; war communism's requisitioning; the world war's continued effects and the civil war; the Entente blockade and embargoes; rail systems that could not distribute food - C-2213 Was October 1917 a coup or a popular revolution?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: a coup by a minority that turned Russia into a totalitarian dictatorship ('totalitarian' / traditionalist school; dominant again since 1991); a genuinely popular revolution (revisionists, 'history from below'); a proud effort of the working class (Soviet-Marxist); power 'found lying in the streets' (Read's commentator) - C-2214 Why did Soviet Russia become a one-party state?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: the start of communist authoritarianism: the Bolsheviks lost the election and banned the opposition (Western historians, Service); wartime conditions imposed it (some scholars); the coalition with the Left SRs, outdated voter rolls and the Congress of Soviets as an alternative democracy (Trotskyist historians: Novack, Cliff) - C-2224 How many died in the Red Terror?
booked: The map keeps the ranges.
the other reading: 12,733 Cheka executions 1917-1920 (Latsis, 'too low' per Mawdsley); 50,000 (Chamberlin) or 140,000 (Leggett), thought more plausible by Mawdsley; 140,000-200,000 executions plus 400,000 in prisons and suppressions; up to 2 million as the whole repressive policy (Volkov); 1,766,188 deaths from Bolshevik policies (Saroléa via Melgunov, 1924) - C-2228 Who ordered the killing of the Romanovs?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: ordered by Lenin and Sverdlov (Radzinsky, Volkogonov; never confirmed); local Bolshevik officials' initiative; an option pre-approved in Moscow as White troops approached - C-2229 How badly did Russia fight in the Great War?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: Russia's Great War an 'unrelieved catastrophe culminating in ignominious collapse' (the older view); revisionist: Russia's struggles very similar to the other powers'; the first, not the only, great power to collapse (Stone via Petrone); the wartime economy held up through 1915 and better than thought; the civil war worse (Markevich and Harrison) - C-2230 How many died in the Russian Civil War?
booked: The map keeps the ranges.
the other reading: 7 to 12 million civil war casualties, mostly civilians (encyclopedia); 13 million excess deaths for the Great War and Civil War together (Markevich and Harrison), between Boiarskii's 12 million and Maksudov's 13.8 million; Red Army 939,755 killed and missing, Whites 650,000 (encyclopedia); 300,000 killed in action and 450,000 dead of disease (Urlanis) - C-2231 What caused the Russian Revolution?
booked: The map lists the causes and rules none.
the other reading: the war unleashed it (Read: 'did a great deal to unleash the Revolution'); half a century of incubation: an anachronistic political system holding back new forces (Read); the spontaneous popular movement in Petrograd (early accounts); the elites: six of seven front commanders' telegrams forced the abdication (newer interpretation, Read); urban food shortage from a town-country drift (Markevich and Harrison), the railway bottleneck (Cvetkovski), inflation (Marks); German funding via Parvus (critics on the right; historians divided, little evidence); grievance then greed for power (Markevich and Harrison after Collier and Hoeffler) - C-2232 When did the Russian Revolution begin and end?
booked: The map keeps the spans side by side.
the other reading: 1917-1921 (Sumpf: the civil war over with the Bolsheviks' total victory in summer 1921); to 1923 (the last White area, Ayano-Maysky, given up when Pepelyayev capitulated); from 1914 (Holquist's 'continuum of crisis', 'seven years' war'); 1917-1923 (the October Revolution article's 'broader Russian Revolution of 1917–1923')
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (13)
- Peasantry
- February Revolution (1917)
- October Revolution (1917)
- Russian Civil War (1917/1918-1921/1922)
- Petrograd Soviet of Workers' and Soldiers' Deputies
- Russian Provisional Government (March-October 1917)
- Bolsheviks (from 1918 the Russian Communist Party)
- Military Revolutionary Committee
- Council of People's Commissars (Sovnarkom)
- Cheka
- Red Army
- Socialist Revolutionary Party (and the Left SRs)
- Mensheviks
Sits inside / holds (5)
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945)
- Russia
- Russian Empire
- Revolutions of 1917 1923
Trades with (valence) (21)
- Cold War via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution even
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- Medicine (the field it serves) via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- Climate system (climate) via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution loss
- Mass media via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- Money via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution mixed
- Democracy via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- Farming (agriculture) via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution mixed
- European Jews (victims of the Holocaust) via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution mixed
- Nationalism via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution mixed
- Allies of World War I via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution mixed
- Railways (and canals and turnpikes) via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945) via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution mixed
- German Empire via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution mixed
- French Revolution via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- Russian Empire via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- Epidemic typhus (and cholera) via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution loss
- White movement via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution gain
- Chinese Communist Revolution via sys:human-society · Russian Revolution even
- Women's suffrage · Russian Revolution gain
expressed by (22)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Evade Detection
- Speed
- Precision Attack
- Neutralize Defenses
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Leverage Host/Amplification
- Divide & Isolate
- Reactive Response
- Technique-Based Identification (a.k.a. Technique-Based Detection)
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Deterrence
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (21)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Climate system (climate)
- Mass media
- Farming (agriculture)
- Soviet Union
- Peasantry
- Socialism
- Nationalism
- Railways (and canals and turnpikes)
- The electrical telegraph
- Russian Empire
- Petrograd Soviet of Workers' and Soldiers' Deputies
- Russian Provisional Government (March-October 1917)
- Bolsheviks (from 1918 the Russian Communist Party)
- Military Revolutionary Committee
- Council of People's Commissars (Sovnarkom)
- Cheka
- Red Army
- Soldiers' committees
- Factory committees
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
Notes published science
- In the last months of 1917, people walking out to the villages with sacks, the 'bag men', brought almost 49 million kilograms of food into Kaluga province while the officials brought only 19 million: the self-help network beat the state at feeding the towns two and a half to one (src:golubinov-2018-food-russian-empire).
- The civil war shows up in the census but not in the genes: a study of Russian, Tatar and Bashkir genomes found that the wars of 1918-1922 and the 1921 famine cut the population counts but left no mark on the genetic 'effective population size', while the Mongol invasion of the 1230s still does (src:yunusbaev-2020-effective-population).
- The economy fell hardest before the heaviest fighting: output per head halved between 1917 and 1919, with a 38.8% drop in 1918 alone, which Markevich and Harrison read as war communism's policies doing more damage than the war itself, a collapse as deep as the defeated Confederacy's, except that 'it happened to the winners, not the losers' (src:markevich-harrison-2010-national-income).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the Russian Revolution as historians describe it: the empire's peasants, workers, soldiers and sailors, its bread, money and war, through committees, soviets and parties, to the seizure of power, the civil war and the Soviet state (reader's view; historians' periods in `periods`)
- L1: The world it touches: the Russian Empire's peasant majority (about 15.5 million drafted by 1917, 84-88% peasants), its towns and overcrowded factories, its land and grain, its paper money, and the Eastern Front
- L2: The doors in: food lines and strikes; village, factory, regimental and battleship committees; elections of deputies
- L3: Routing: committees linked locally and regionally (army and front committees), railways and telegraph, the press
- L4: Integration: the soviets and the government weigh the streets, the front and the provinces; 'a multitude of powers' outside Petrograd
- L5: Institutions (the board): the popular movement, the soviets and their Military Revolutionary Committee, the parties, the Provisional Government and then Sovnarkom, the Cheka and the Red Army
- L6: Meaning: peace, bread, land and all power to the soviets; narod against burzhui; Marxism, nationhood and the revolution's symbols
- L7: Purpose and action: power declared, held and built: Soviet power (25 October 1917), the one-party dictatorship, the civil war won, the Union of 30 December 1922
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The popular movement: committees, crowds, strikes and local soviets of peasants, workers, soldiers and sailors
- L5: The Petrograd Soviet, the Congress of Soviets and its executive (VTsIK), the Military Revolutionary Committee; bottom-up in 1917, top-down by 1919
- L5: The parties: Bolsheviks, Socialist Revolutionaries (and Left SRs), Mensheviks, Kadets, anarchists
- L5: Government: the Provisional Government (March-October 1917), then Sovnarkom, the commissariats, the Cheka and the Red Army's command
- L6: Meaning: the slogans (peace, bread, land, all power to the soviets), narod against burzhui, Marxism, nationhood, the revolution's symbols; the historians' rival readings
- L7: Purpose: power: declared (25 October 1917), held (one party, the Terror, the civil war won) and built into a state (the Union, 30 December 1922)
way in: Bread and the food supply
- L1: Grain reaching the market fell from 12.4% to 7.4% of crops by 1915; in 1921 drought on top of war and requisition
- L2: The queue: about forty hours a week in food lines; starvation real in 1917
- L3: Food riots (almost 20 in 1915, 288 in 1916) and 'bag men' self-supply
- L4: Women's Day bread demonstrations bring out over 50,000 strikers, 23 February 1917 O.S.
way in: Epidemic and famine
- L1: Typhus: some 2 to 3 million lives, 1918-1922
- L2: Among the poor, the displaced, prisoners and troops
- L4: Lenin: 'Either the louse will defeat socialism, or socialism will defeat the lice'
way in: Foreign powers
- L1: Western relief with two aims: relieve suffering and stop Bolshevism; the cordon sanitaire
- L2: The sealed train: Germany lets Lenin through
- L3: Allied landings and support for the Whites, for zones of influence
- L4: Recognition and relief read as legitimacy
way in: Ideas: Marxism and the theory of revolution
- L1: Lenin since 1914: turn the imperialist war into a civil war
- L2: A semi-capitalist country suffices
- L3: The April Theses: all power to the soviets
- L4: The Mensheviks' dogma: a bourgeois revolution first
way in: Money, prices and the state's finances
- L1: Deficits of 40%, 76%, 78% (1914-1916) covered in part by the printing press
- L2: Coins hoarded; by late 1916 all money paper
- L3: Peasants withdraw from the money economy or hold back grain; inflation swallows wage gains
- L4: Ministers read the 'nervousness of the population'
way in: Morale and mood
- L1: The slaughter at the front and the burdens of daily life
- L2: Despair that the slaughter would ever end
- L3: The Okhrana reads rage at 'the burdens of daily existence'
- L4: Elation after February; disillusion by 1921 (Kronstadt)
way in: Press, slogans and propaganda
- L1: Newspapers: most Russians knew the war only from them
- L2: The party press: shut down after the July Days
- L3: Getting ideas across to the masses
- L4: Support concentrated in the cities and northwest units; hardly known across 90% of the country
way in: Railways and telegraph
- L1: A supply bottleneck of deficient infrastructure; locomotives from nearly 20,000 to 9,200
- L2: Railway workers carry the news of the coup in the capital
- L3: The railway telegraph seized in February; Kornilov's troops stopped by railwaymen; the telegraph offices seized in October
- L4: The Soviet's control of post, telegraph and railroads
way in: The empire's nations
- L1: A multiethnic empire: 'an agglomeration of diverse ethnicities'
- L2: Forced displacement and refugee committees structure national identities
- L3: National revolutions: Finns, Poles, Ukrainians in the forefront
- L4: Demands for autonomy weighed in Moscow (Stalin, Pravda 1918)
way in: The factory and the city
- L1: Concentrated, overcrowded industry: 40% of workers in factories of 1,000+; 16 people per apartment
- L2: Factory committees
- L3: Strikes for the eight-hour day and wages, renewed as inflation ate the gains
- L4: Striking workers elect deputies to the Soviet
way in: The land and the village
- L1: Land should belong to those who work it
- L2: Village and parish committees
- L3: Encroachment, then a veto on estates; later Green rebellions of 2-3 million against requisition
- L4: Land seizures in September-October 1917, ratified by the Decree on Land
way in: The war and the front
- L1: Losses: by October 1916 nearly 5 million men dead, captured or missing
- L2: Soldiers and sailors: discipline and peace, 'their lives hung on these questions'
- L3: Army and front committees linked regionally
- L4: The Petrograd garrison and Order No. 1: orders obeyed only with the Soviet's approval
way out: Crowds, strikes, mutiny and insurrection
- L1: Government buildings and the Winter Palace taken
- L5: The Military Revolutionary Committee takes the strong points
- L7: The decision to rise (Central Committee, 10 October)
way out: Decrees: peace, land, the new order
- L1: Universal health care attempted; the clinics under-funded
- L5: The Congress of Soviets approves the decrees and Sovnarkom
- L7: The Decree on Land ratifies the peasants' seizures
way out: Nationalities policy and the Union
- L5: Key functions centralised in Moscow
- L6: Indigenisation: patronage of national cultures as a temporary means
- L7: The Declaration and Treaty creating the USSR, 30 December 1922
way out: Propaganda, political education and symbols
- L3: Posters to reach the illiterate
- L5: The PUR: reading lessons, theatre, cinema
- L6: The hammer and sickle
way out: The Cheka and the Red Terror
- L1: Decossackization; hostages; arrests (2,000 Mensheviks in 1921)
- L5: The Cheka's detachments, tribunals and special prisons
- L7: Terror decreed after the attempts on Lenin and Uritsky's killing
way out: The New Economic Policy
- L1: Recovery not full by 1928
- L5: 21 March 1921: tax in kind replaces requisition
- L7: Lenin announces the end of war communism
way out: The Red Army and the civil war
- L1: The fronts: Siberia, the south, the north-west, Poland; the émigrés' flight
- L3: Desertion and its control: 917,000 deserted at least once
- L5: Conscription by class; 50,000 former Tsarist officers under commissars
- L7: A regular army, against the party's own suspicion of standing armies
way out: The separate peace
- L1: Lands with 34% of the population and 89% of coalfields lost
- L7: Brest-Litovsk signed in an abysmal military position
way out: War communism: requisition and nationalisation
- L1: Requisitions like an army occupying enemy territory
- L5: The Food Supply Army and kombeds; prodrazverstka from January 1919
- L7: The regime's dependence on the countryside for food and soldiers
way out: World revolution
- L1: A revolutionary wave to 1923; only Mongolia's revolution kept power
- L7: Trotsky: socialism in Russia needs world revolution