← all systems · see it in The System
Chinese Communist Revolution
The social and political revolution in mainland China led by the Chinese Communist Party, from the party's founding (1921) or the break with the Kuomintang (1927) to the proclamation of the People's Republic of China on 1 October 1949: the party's rise from a study circle to a mass party with its own army, base-area governments and doctrine; the civil war with the Nationalists in two phases around the war with Japan; land reform and the mobilisation of the peasantry; and the founding of the new state. Walked as the revolution with its wars booked as competitions (QUEUE-BRIEF addendum 7); its span, causes and tolls stay contested.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 23 July 1921 (CCP founded); 1927 (the encyclopedia's start); 1 August 1927 (civil war begins) |
| born precision | day (start contested) |
| boundary | Inside: the Chinese Communist Party and what it built and ran, 1921-1949 (the party's organisation, the Red Army and People's Liberation Army, the soviets and base areas, the peasant associations, unions and work teams under its lead, its doctrine, land reform, propaganda and currencies) and the founding of the new state. Outside: the Kuomintang and the Republic of China it fought, Japan, the Soviet Union and the Comintern, the United States, the landlords, and the peasantry as a whole, which it drew on and acted on. |
| end precision | day (end contested: December 1949, 1950-51, or never formally) |
| ended at | 1 October 1949 (proclamation of the PRC) |
| nested level | Built from people, party branches, armies, base areas and village associations; a period of China's history; one of the twentieth century's communist revolutions; overlapping the Chinese Civil War and the Second Sino-Japanese War; part of human society's acts. |
| scale | social |
Measures (44) published science
| Forces in 1937 | Nationalists about 2.5 million; Communists about 300,000 soldiers |
| Span (dating contested) | 1921 or 1927 to 1 October 1949 (most common end); fighting to 1950-51; no peace ever signed dates |
| Civil war span | 1 August 1927 to 7 December 1949 (intermittent) dates |
| Long March duration | October 1934 to 19 October 1935 (about a year; 'over 370 days') |
| Long March distance | about 10,000 km (encyclopedia); 12,500 km (Mao's 25,000 li); about 9,000 km (Chen and Kung) |
| Long March survivors | about 8,000 of about 86,000 (First Front Army) or 100,000; under 7,000 of the original marchers people |
| Long March chain yield | 86,000 to 36,000 by the Xiang River (about 42%); to about 8,000 at Yan'an (about 9%) share surviving |
| CCP membership | 50 (early 1921; 53 or 57 in other sources), 200 (1922), 2,428 (1925), over 20,000 (after May 1925), over 300,000 or 411,000 (Jiangxi), about 40,000 (1937), 800,000 (1940), 1,200,000 (1945) members |
| CCP membership growth, 1937-1945 | 29-fold (Chen and Kung); 40,000 to 1,200,000 ratio |
| Kuomintang membership (1923) | 50,000 members |
| Haifeng peasant association (1923) | about 100,000, one-quarter of the county members |
| All-China Federation of Labor (1927) | 2.8 million members |
| Land held by landlords | some 5% of landlords held 30% of the land; average 5.77 acres per landlord family share |
| Peasants with little or no land | 50-65% percent of peasants |
| Share rents (north China) | 40%, 50% or 60% of the harvest; 80% in Shanxi sharecropping share of harvest |
| Industrial workforce (c. 1928) | 1.77 million of 400 million; unionised 0.37% people |
| White Terror deaths | 300,000 to 1,000,000 people |
| Chinese dead in the war with Japan | 20 to 25 million people |
| Forces in 1945 | CCP 1.2-1.27 million regulars plus 1.8-2.68 million militia (3-4 million); NRA about 4 million regulars and 1 million militia; KMT three times the CCP soldiers |
| Forces in 1947 | 1.12 million KMT troops destroyed in a year; CCP about two million soldiers |
| Retail prices, 1945 | 3,000% of 1937 levels percent |
| US aid to the Nationalists | $4.43 billion in two years after 1945 (Blum, via the encyclopedia); about 3.9 billion (Elleman and Paine, via Li); US$5.9 billion 1945-1949 (Mao's claim) US dollars |
| Military share of Nationalist spending (1946-1948) | about 60% percent |
| Gold yuan conversion (19 August 1948) | 1 GY for CNC$3,000,000; circulation nearly eight times the cap by October 1948; renminbi for gold yuan at 1:100,000 (1949) exchange rate |
| Gold yuan price controls | effective about two months, Shanghai only |
| Shanghai unemployment (after 1945) | 37.5% percent |
| Liberated Zone (1945) | 19 base areas; a quarter of the territory; a third of the population share |
| Japanese-held territory | at its greatest slightly over 60% percent |
| Effect of Japanese occupation on CCP growth | cadre density +5.4%; guerrilla base +10.3% percent |
| Hundred Regiments Offensive | 2,010 Japanese killed, 3,359 injured people |
| Peasants mobilised for Huaihai | 5,430,000 people |
| Settling time of a village's commitment (one case) | fully six months (Mao Mountains, Jiangsu) |
| Pingjin campaign forces | 890,000 PLA against about 600,000 KMT; 64 days; about 520,000 KMT killed, wounded or captured soldiers |
| Liaoshen casualties | over 470,000 Nationalist against about 69,000 PLA people |
| Nationalist troops lost in the three campaigns | 144 regular and 29 irregular divisions; 1.54 million veteran troops soldiers |
| Siege of Changchun civilian deaths | 150,000 (estimate); 'tens to 150 thousand' people |
| Land redistributed by June 1949 | 25 million hectares, over half the rural land; 125 million people affected |
| Landholding change in land reform | poor +240%, landless +1000%, middle +23%, rich -41%, landlords -80% percent per capita |
| Mobilisation threshold distance | 81 km from KMT forces |
| Communist soldier death records studied | 566,161 records |
| Land reform deaths 1949-1953 | 200,000 to 5,000,000 (range of estimates); about 3.5 million (estimate cited by Li) people |
| Pre-revolution elite's grandchildren: income and schooling premium | 16% more income; over 11% more years of schooling percent |
| Retreat to Taiwan | 600,000 troops and about two million refugees people |
| Old-age health after early-life war exposure | physical health -17.5%; mental health -12.1% percent |
Open contentions (10) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2157 How many members did the Chinese Communist Party have?
booked: The map keeps the counts the sources give.
the other reading: 53 founding members (Li 2024); 57 founding members (Chen and Kung); 411,000 before the Long March (Chen and Kung) against 'over 300,000' (encyclopedia) - C-2158 What caused the Chinese Communist Revolution?
booked: The map lists the causes and rules none.
the other reading: land reform and class mobilisation tied the peasants to the CCP (DeMare; Li 2024); the war with Japan made peasant nationalism (Johnson; Bianco; Chen and Kung); Nationalist failure: hyperinflation, corruption, 'rot from within' (Eastman; Mitter; Acheson; Chiang); fewer military mistakes, and Chiang antagonised too many groups; outcome uncertain until Huaihai (Westad); external causes: US aid withdrawn and Soviet support (Taylor, Cowley, Carroll; Chiang's memoir); intelligence penetration of the KMT command; leadership cohesion and propaganda - C-2159 When did the Chinese Communist Revolution begin and end?
booked: The map keeps the spans side by side.
the other reading: from 1927 (the article's opening line); only the second phase of the civil war, 1945/1946-1949 (a few historians; the civil-war article calls 1945-49 'generally referred to as the Chinese Communist Revolution'); ending with the retreat to Taiwan (7 December 1949), Hainan (1950) or Tibet (1951); not ended: no peace between the ROC and PRC ever negotiated - C-2160 How many died in the Chinese Civil War and revolution?
booked: The map keeps the ranges.
the other reading: White Terror 300,000 to one million; land reform 1949-1953: 200,000 to 5,000,000 (Fairbank's 'sober' upper end), about 3.5 million (estimate cited by Li); Siege of Changchun: 150,000, or 'tens to 150 thousand'; Jiangxi Soviet violence and Futian (2,000-3,000) - C-2198 How exploitative were Chinese landlords?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: rents exorbitant and exploitation a cause (proponents; Hinton); landlords' returns not especially high (Buck); landholding not very unequal by world standards (Li 2024 citing Elvin) - C-2203 How long was the Long March?
booked: The map keeps the distances the sources give.
the other reading: 12,500 km (Mao's 25,000 li); about 9,000 km (Chen and Kung; the CCR article); the 2003 controversy over the distance - C-2226 Does a revolution's legacy persist in places?
booked: The map keeps both findings.
the other reading: the revolution's effect on stratification persists; reversion in the third generation small (Xie and Zhang 2019); the pre-revolution elite rebounded; grandchildren earn 16% more (Alesina et al. 2021) - C-2241 Why didn't the Communists invade Taiwan?
booked: The map keeps the readings, including disease among the troops.
the other reading: schistosomiasis in the invasion units 'may have cost' the Communists Taiwan (Turner and Sapp); the Korean War and the Seventh Fleet in the Taiwan Strait (June 1950) prevented attack - C-2243 How much US aid went to the Nationalists?
booked: The map keeps the amounts given.
the other reading: $4.43 billion in two years (Blum, via the encyclopedia); about 3.9 billion overall (Elleman and Paine, via Li); US$5.9 billion 1945-1949 (Mao's claim) - C-2245 Where did Chinese warlordism come from?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: regional elites raised against the Taiping began the disintegration that led to warlordism (Michael 1949; Luo 1937); the reading exaggerates the regional elites' role (McCord 1993)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (10)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Chinese Communist Party
- Red Army / People's Liberation Army
- Chinese Soviet Republic (Jiangxi Soviet)
- Yan'an Soviet and the Liberated Zone
- Peasant associations
- All-China Federation of Labor
- Land Reform Movement (Tugai)
- The mass line
- Mao Zedong Thought
Sits inside / holds (3)
- China
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945)
- Cold War
Trades with (valence) (18)
- Nationalism via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Cold War via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Mass media via sys:mass-media · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Money via sys:money · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- United States (the country across time) via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution mixed
- Soviet Union via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Peasantry via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Taiwan via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution loss
- Imperial China (China under its dynasties, from Qin unification in 221 BC to the Qing's fall in 1912) via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution mixed
- Republic of China via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Russian Revolution via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Kuomintang (Nationalist Party) and its army via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Communist International (Comintern) via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution mixed
- Landlords and rich peasants via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Schistosomiasis (the disease) via sys:human · Chinese Communist Revolution loss
- The warlords (Beiyang government and regional armies) via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
- Empire of Japan via sys:human-society · Chinese Communist Revolution gain
expressed by (25)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Frontier Outposts / Sensing Extension
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Encirclement
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Prepositioning & Latency
- Leverage Host/Amplification
- Reactive Response
- Delay/Redirection Tactics
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Deception
- Resilience & Repair
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (19)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Mass media
- Farming (agriculture)
- China
- Peasantry
- Nationalism
- Chinese Communist Party
- Red Army / People's Liberation Army
- Chinese Soviet Republic (Jiangxi Soviet)
- Peasant associations
- All-China Federation of Labor
- The mass line
- Mao Zedong Thought
- Land-reform work team
- People's Republic of China
- Marxism-Leninism
- Class analysis and class labels
- Base area
- United Front
represents (1)
Kinds (4)
- Revolution
- Land and class mobilisation as the key
- Peasant nationalism as the key
- Nationalist failure as the key
Notes published science
- The same gift of land made peasants fight or sit out depending on how close the enemy was: in counties within 81 km of Nationalist forces, more land handed out meant more Communist soldiers fighting (and dying), because a returning landlord army would take revenge; farther away, more land meant more free-riding. The study used the death records of 566,161 Communist soldiers (src:li-2024-free-riders).
- Two currencies raced in one country, and the one that did not water itself down won: Nationalist notes were printed until the gold yuan's circulation hit nearly eight times its legal cap, while Communist trade bureaus kept their money stable by selling cloth and other essentials at fixed low prices; in 1949 the renminbi swallowed the gold yuan at 1 to 100,000 (src:wp:chinese-hyperinflation).
- A parasite may have kept Taiwan apart: in 1949-1950 an epidemic of schistosomiasis struck elite People's Liberation Army units training for the amphibious invasion, and the delay 'may have cost communist forces control of the strategic island' before the Korean War brought the US Seventh Fleet into the strait (src:turner-sapp-2024-schistosomiasis; src:wp:chinese-communist-revolution).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the Chinese Communist Revolution as historians describe it: China's land, peasants, cities and invaders, through peasant associations, cadres and base areas, to the party, its army and its doctrine, and the seizure of the state (reader's view; historians' periods in `periods`)
- L1: The world it touches: China's land and some 400 million people, around 90% subsistence farmers; landlords and tenants; the cities; foreign armies
- L2: The doors in: peasant associations, trade unions, study groups and journals, investigation reports, work teams
- L3: Routing: cadres and party branches carried into the countryside; base areas
- L4: Integration: class analysis, the mass line, party conferences (Zunyi)
- L5: Institutions (the board): the party, its army, the base-area governments, the united fronts
- L6: Meaning: Marxism-Leninism adapted to China, class struggle, peasant nationalism
- L7: Purpose and action back on the world: land reform, war, mobilisation and a new state
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The Chinese Communist Party: democratic centralism, a politburo and standing committees duplicated at every level, cadres and work teams
- L5: The army under the party: the Red Army (1927), Eighth Route and New Fourth Armies, the People's Liberation Army; party control over the military (Gutian, 1929) through political departments
- L5: Base-area governments: the Jiangxi Soviet ('a state within a state'), the Yan'an Soviet, the 19 base areas of the Liberated Zone, with their own currencies and trade bureaus
- L5: United fronts and negotiations: the First United Front (1923-27), the Second (1937-41, formally to 1945), the Chongqing talks and the Marshall Mission
- L6: Doctrine and meaning: Marxism-Leninism adapted to China (Mao Zedong Thought), class struggle, the peasantry as the revolution's main force, and anti-imperialist peasant nationalism (which weighed most is contested)
- L7: Purpose and decision: seize state power and found a new state; carry the civil war through to the end (Mao rejecting Stalin's advice to stop at the Yangtze)
way in: Agents inside the Nationalist command
- L1: The KMT's battle plans for 1947-1949
- L2: Agents placed years ahead (Xiong Xianghui from 1937)
- L3: Plans passed on; misleading reports issued inside the KMT
- L4: Warning two weeks before the Yan'an offensive
way in: American aid, troops and mediation
- L1: Over 50,000 US Marines land in north China (1945)
- L2: US equipment and training for KMT troops
- L3: The Marshall Mission's coalition talks
- L4: The CCP's reading: a war against 'US imperialists and their puppets'
way in: Defectors and prisoners
- L1: Conscripted peasants in Nationalist ranks defect, drawn by land and better treatment
- L2: Political work among captured troops; humane treatment of prisoners
- L3: Incorporated into the Communist ranks (most of 90,000 at Jinzhou)
- L4: Collapsed morale: soldiers weigh the costs of resisting
way in: Hunger, disease and losses
- L1: Famines: at least six major famines 1900-1945
- L2: Disease in the ranks: schistosomiasis in units preparing to invade Taiwan (1949-50)
- L3: Losses carried by the party: about 90% of membership lost by the end of the Long March
way in: Japanese invasion and occupation
- L1: Japan seizes Manchuria (1931) and invades China proper (1937)
- L2: The power vacuum behind the lines: villages Japan could neither garrison nor govern
- L3: Guerrilla bases draft armed villagers and KMT defectors
- L4: Survival and humiliation turn into peasant nationalism
way in: Land, rent and harvest
- L1: Farmland held mostly by landlords and rich peasants; 50-65% of peasants with little or none, renting at shares of 40-60% (whether this was exploitation is contested)
- L2: Peasant associations (Peng Pai's Haifeng, 1923) and, from 1946, CCP work teams that organise poor farmers
- L3: Struggle meetings and 'speaking bitterness' route grievances to named landlords
- L4: Class labels: landlord status defined by the share of income from exploitation
way in: Marxism-Leninism and the October Revolution
- L1: News of the October Revolution and European socialist ideas reach urban intellectuals
- L2: New Youth (from 1915), the intelligentsia's journal; a whole issue on Marxism in 1919
- L3: Study groups on Marx (Li Dazhao at Peking University)
- L4: The Leninist model chosen: a vanguard party of professional revolutionaries
way in: Money and prices in the Nationalist areas
- L1: A paper currency issued without enough backing (1935)
- L2: Prices in the markets: 3,000% of 1937 by 1945
- L3: Real wages fall; middle-class savings destroyed
- L4: Support for the Nationalists eroded
way in: Reports from the masses (investigation and the mass line)
- L1: Peasants rise in Hunan and Hubei (1926-27)
- L2: Mao sent to investigate and report
- L3: The Hunan Report: a peasant-led revolution possible and even inevitable
- L4: The mass line: theory to policy, tested in practice, revised
way in: Soviet and Comintern advisers, directives and arms
- L1: Sun-Joffe Manifesto (1923): Soviet cooperation with the KMT
- L2: Affiliation with the Comintern from the founding congress
- L3: Directives routed into the party: join the KMT as individuals (1923)
- L4: 1945-46: Malinovsky gives most captured Japanese weapons to the CCP
way in: The Nationalist army's pressure
- L1: The Shanghai massacre and the White Terror (1927 on)
- L2: Encirclement campaigns met by guerrilla tactics (three repulsed)
- L3: Breakout and retreat: the Long March, 86,000 down to 36,000 by the Xiang River
- L4: Defeat read into strategy: rural guerrilla war that wins peasant support (Zunyi)
way in: The party's own line and self-criticism
- L1: Repeated defeats of the urban line held against the leadership
- L2: Party conferences: Zunyi (January 1935)
- L3: Rectification: 'systematic remolding of human minds' (1942-45)
- L4: 'Adaptation of communism to the conditions of China'
way in: Workers and students in the cities
- L1: May Fourth protests (1919): the first mass participation beyond the elites
- L2: Trade unions: the ACFL reaches 2.8 million by 1927
- L3: May Thirtieth and the strikes route recruits into the party (membership over 20,000)
- L4: Students' anti-imperialism inflamed by US Marines (1945-46)
way out: Armed struggle
- L1: Liaoshen: over 470,000 Nationalist casualties against about 69,000
- L3: Passive defence: abandon territory to keep the army
- L5: The PLA's campaigns
- L7: The faction for a complete military take-over wins (1946)
way out: Currency and prices
- L1: The renminbi replaces the gold yuan at 100,000:1 (1 October 1949)
- L3: Essentials sold at controlled low prices to stop speculation
- L5: Shandong's Bureau of Industry and Commerce (1943)
- L7: Prudent economic control
way out: Founding the new state
- L1: Class relations transformed
- L5: Every citizen registered into one of three classes
- L6: The Five-starred Red Flag
- L7: Proclamation of the Central People's Government, 1 October 1949
way out: Land reform
- L1: 25 million hectares redistributed; 125 million people affected (by June 1949)
- L3: Trials at mass meetings; in about 10% of cases the landlord executed
- L5: Work teams organise poor farmers
- L6: Struggle by design: the masses avenge past injustices
- L7: Land to the peasants as a source of power (Mao, May 1946)
way out: Mass mobilisation
- L1: Near the front, more land redistributed means more fighting (more soldier deaths)
- L3: Huaihai: 5,430,000 peasants mobilised
- L5: Cadres organise each new village
way out: Propaganda and united-front appeals
- L1: The greatest popular support of any insurgency in modern history
- L6: 'Defenders of the nation' against 'enemies of all groups of Chinese'
- L7: The appeal for a united front against Japan
way out: Purges and coercion
- L1: The siege of Changchun: more than 150,000 civilians starved (toll contested)
- L3: The Futian incident (1930)
- L5: Violence against civilians in the Jiangxi-Fujian Soviet
- L7: Rectification convinces or coerces the leaders