← all systems · see it in The System
Two-way speed of light
The round-trip speed of light, 'from the source to a mirror and back again to the detector' (One-way speed of light): 'It is only possible to verify experimentally that the two-way speed of light (for example, from a source to a mirror and back again) is frame-independent, because it is impossible to measure the one-way speed of light ... without some convention as to how clocks at the source and at the detector should be synchronized' (Speed of light).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: light over a closed path, emitted and received at one clock, its value, isotropy and frame independence, and the round-trip conditions it satisfies. Outside: the one-way speed (convention-dependent), the synchronisation conventions built on it, and light in matter. |
| nested level | The measurable variant of the speed of light; it underlies Einstein synchronisation (which sets the one-way speed equal to it) and every round-trip ranging and resonator measurement of c. |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| speed of light in vacuum (defined) | 299792458 m/s |
| two-way isotropy (modern experiments) | within 6 nm/s |
| two-way anisotropy bounds | about 10^-17 (Eisele et al. 2009; Herrmann et al. 2009); about 10^-18 (Nagel et al. 2015) dimensionless |
| Michelson-Morley 1887 path length; expected drift | 11 m; about 0.4 fringe m; fringe |
| Essen cavity resonance (1950) | 299792.5 +/- 3.0 km/s |
| characteristic clock: the round trip itself, e.g. light from the Moon to Earth (one leg) | 1.3 s (1.255 s at mean surface-to-surface distance) |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-049 Is 'at the same time' a convention, or fixed by the structure of spacetime?
booked: The map treats distant simultaneity as a convention (Einstein synchronisation) and keeps Malament's opposing argument alongside.
the other reading: B: fixed by causal structure (Malament's argument; 'Whether this settles the issue is disputed', Einstein synchronisation)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Two-way speed of light. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
One synchronisation, several builds: Einstein's light round trip, slow clock transport ('The same synchronisation is achieved by transporting a third clock from clock 1 to clock 2 slowly'), and Reichenbach's and Laue-Weyl's round-trip conditions; all rest on an isotropic two-way speed. - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Only closed paths give convention-free results: the two-way speed of light and time dilation on closed paths are measurable outright, while their one-way and one-leg versions need a synchronisation convention.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (8) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Moon (Earth's natural satellite) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Two-way speed of light gain
- Electromagnetic field via sys:electromagnetic-field · Two-way speed of light gain
- Minkowski spacetime via sys:electromagnetic-field · Two-way speed of light gain
- Einstein synchronisation via sys:electromagnetic-field · Two-way speed of light even
- Speed of light via sys:spacetime · Two-way speed of light even
- Clock transport via sys:spacetime · Two-way speed of light even
- One-way speed of light via sys:spacetime · Two-way speed of light even
- Velocity time dilation via sys:spacetime · Two-way speed of light even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (11)
- Photon
- Electromagnetic field
- Moon (Earth's natural satellite)
- Minkowski spacetime
- Einstein synchronisation
- Proper time (its parameter)
- Speed of light
- One-way speed of light
- Radar
- Michelson-Morley experiment
- Optical resonator
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- Nobody has ever measured light's speed in one direction alone; every measurement is a round trip read on one clock, and Einstein's convention simply defines the one-way speed to match.
- Rotating resonators show the round trip is the same in every direction to about one part in 10^18 (2015).
- Michelson and Morley floated their interferometer on a sandstone block in a trough of mercury so it could turn with almost no friction.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
round-trip ranging and resonators (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Electromagnetic waves sent out and returned: radar pulses, laser pulses to the Moon and spacecraft, standing waves in a cavity.
- L2: Ranging: 'the distance to the target is half the round-trip transit time multiplied by the speed of light'; Lunar Laser Ranging and spacecraft distances 'by measuring round-trip transit times'.
- L3: Resonators and interferometers: c = lambda f from a cavity's resonance (Essen 1950: 299,792.5 +/- 3.0 km/s); rotating orthogonal resonators compare two directions (Eisele et al. 2009, Herrmann et al. 2009: about 10^-17; Nagel et al. 2015: about 10^-18).
- L4: Delays it sets: light from the Moon takes 1.3 s (1.255 s at mean surface-to-surface distance); Apollo 8 ground control 'had to wait at least three seconds for the answer to arrive'.
two-way speed of light (own: light over a closed path timed by one clock)
- L1: A light signal sent from a clock over a closed path and back: 'a light signal is sent at time tau1 from clock 1 to clock 2 and immediately back, e.g. by means of a mirror. Its arrival time back at clock 1 is tau2'.
- L2: Timed by one clock: 'What can however be experimentally measured is the round-trip speed from the source to a mirror and back again to the detector'; Laue-Weyl round-trip condition: 'The time needed by a light beam to traverse a closed path of length L is L/c, where L is the length of the path and c is a constant independent of the path'.
- L3: Isotropy: Michelson and Morley's motion 'was found to always be nil (within observational error). Modern experiments indicate that the two-way speed of light is isotropic (the same in every direction) to within 6 nanometres per second'; Hughes-Drever and rotating resonators 'put stringent limits on the possible two-way anisotropy'.
- L4: Frame independence: 'It is only possible to verify experimentally that the two-way speed of light ... is frame-independent'; 'The invariance of the speed of light has been verified by experiments such as the Kennedy-Thorndike experiment and the Ives-Stilwell experiment'.
- L5: The one-way split: 'By adopting Einstein synchronization for the clocks, the one-way speed of light becomes equal to the two-way speed of light by definition'; experiments 'are consistent with anisotropic one-way light speed as long as the two-way light speed is isotropic'; 'Only when time dilation is measured on closed paths, it is not conventional and can unequivocally be measured like the two-way speed of light'.