← all systems · see it in The System
Clock transport
Carrying a clock from one place to another and comparing it with clocks that stayed put. In an inertial frame 'a portable clock can be used to disseminate time' (Ashby 2003); in the Hafele-Keating experiment four caesium-beam clocks flown 'twice around the world, first eastward, then westward' were compared with stationary clocks, and 'When reunited, the three sets of clocks were found to disagree with one another'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: a clock carried along a path (slowly or fast, high or low), the proper time it keeps on the way, and the comparison at the end. Outside: the clocks that stay behind, the inertial (Earth-centred) frame used for the bookkeeping, Earth's potential and rotation, and the clocks' mechanism. |
| nested level | Field scale, rung 1. Parent kind of slow clock transport (synchronisation) and fast transport (the flown-clock tests). |
| scale | field |
Measures (10) published science
| Hafele-Keating eastward: predicted gravitational / kinematic / total | +144 +/- 14 / -184 +/- 18 / -40 +/- 23 ns |
| Hafele-Keating eastward measured | -59 +/- 10 ns |
| Hafele-Keating westward: predicted gravitational / kinematic / total | +179 +/- 18 / +96 +/- 10 / +275 +/- 21 ns |
| Hafele-Keating westward measured | +273 +/- 7 ns |
| Maryland 1975-76 (10 km, 500 km/h, five 15-hour flights): total, velocity, gravitational | 47.1, -5.7, 52.8 (agreement about 1.6%) ns |
| NPL 1996 London-Washington round trip: measured vs predicted | 39 +/- 2 vs 39.8 ns |
| NPL 2010 round the globe: predicted vs measured | 246 +/- 3 vs 230 +/- 20 ns |
| plane tickets for the 1971 experiment | 7600 US dollars |
| slow transport once round the world (= pulse relay) | 207 ns |
| characteristic clock: the carried clock's proper time over the trip, compared with the reference clock | trip-dependent s |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (9)
- Slow clock transport round a rotating body via sys:spacetime · Clock transport even
- Earth via sys:gravitational-field · Clock transport gain
- Slow clock transport via sys:spacetime · Clock transport even
- Proper time (its parameter) via sys:spacetime · Clock transport gain
- Time dilation via sys:spacetime · Clock transport gain
- Velocity time dilation via sys:spacetime · Clock transport gain
- Gravitational time dilation via sys:gravitational-field · Clock transport gain
- Sagnac effect via sys:spacetime · Clock transport even
- Two-way speed of light via sys:spacetime · Clock transport even
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (13)
- Earth
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- World line
- Slow clock transport
- Atomic clock
- Proper time (its parameter)
- Time dilation
- Slow clock transport round a rotating body
- Hafele-Keating experiment (fast transport)
- Velocity time dilation
- Gravitational time dilation
- Sagnac effect
- Portable clock
represents (1)
Kinds (2)
Notes published science
- Hafele and Keating bought eight round-the-world plane tickets ($7600), 'including two seats on each flight for "Mr. Clock"'.
- Fly east and the clock comes home 59 ns behind; fly west and it comes home 273 ns ahead: the same planet, the same kind of trip, opposite sign.
- Einstein's 1905 test (a clock at the equator should run slow against one at a pole) fails on the real Earth: at sea level the speed and height effects cancel, so every sea-level clock ticks at the same rate.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
carried atomic clocks and their comparison (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Four caesium-beam atomic clocks aboard commercial airliners (1971); later three clocks aloft at 10 km over Chesapeake Bay with three on the ground (1975-76)
- L2: Readout: direct clock comparison on the ground before and after, and during flight 'by laser pulses of 0.1 ns duration' reflected from the plane
- L3: Against prediction: within 'the ~10% precision expected' (1971); 47.1 ns measured = -5.7 ns velocity + 52.8 ns gravitational, 'a precision of about 1.6%' (Maryland); 39 +/- 2 ns vs 39.8 ns (NPL 1996); 230 +/- 20 vs 246 +/- 3 ns (NPL 2010)
clock transport (own: a clock carried between places and compared on arrival or return)
- L1: A clock carried along a path from one place to another (on foot in the limit, or aboard aircraft), starting set against a reference clock
- L2: Kinematic part: in the Earth-centred inertial frame a clock moving eastward 'had a greater velocity (resulting in a relative time loss)', westward 'a lower velocity'
- L3: Gravitational part: 'an increase in gravitational potential due to altitude speeds the clocks up'
- L4: Comparison at the end: 'When reunited, the three sets of clocks were found to disagree with one another'; eastward -59 +/- 10 ns, westward +273 +/- 7 ns measured
- L5: The slow limit and its edge: carried so slowly that transport dilation vanishes, it synchronises clocks; round a rotating body the result is path-dependent ('207 nanoseconds' round the world, the same as a pulse relay)
Who fills each layer
Sources (7) published science
Ashby, N. (2003) Relativity in the Global Positioning System, Living Rev. Relativ. 6, 1, doi:10.12942/lrr-2003-1 (behind its links)
Einstein synchronisation (Wikipedia, rev 1372775708, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
One-way speed of light (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise copy; read: abstract, two-way passages) (behind its links)