← all systems · see it in The System
Einstein synchronisation
'a convention for synchronising clocks at different places by means of signal exchanges': 'a light signal is sent at time tau1 from clock 1 to clock 2 and immediately back ... Its arrival time back at clock 1 is tau2. This synchronisation convention sets clock 2 so that the time tau3 of signal reflection is defined to be tau3 = tau1 + 1/2 (tau2 - tau1)'. 'Its principal value is for clocks within a single inertial frame.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the rule that sets a distant clock by a light round trip, and the simultaneity slices it yields when it is consistent. Outside: the clocks and light themselves, and frames where it is not transitive (rotating frames). |
| nested level | The convention part of a clock lattice in one inertial frame; it builds the global time function and the simultaneity slices. Field scale, epoch 1 (it rides on light and the causal structure; the human convention is its rung-11 idea). |
| scale | field |
Measures (5) published science
| fraction of the round trip assigned to the outward leg | 1/2 (tau3 = tau1 + (tau2 - tau1)/2) fraction |
| consistency conditions | 4: (a) stay synchronised; (b1) reflexive, (b2) symmetric, (b3) transitive count |
| dates | Poincare 1898 (conventionality of simultaneity) and 1904 (crossed optical signals); Einstein 1905; von Laue 1911 (consistency); Minguzzi and Macdonald 2003 (round-trip theorem); Malament 1977 years |
| Laue-Weyl round trip | L/c for a closed path of length L, c independent of the path time |
| characteristic clock: the round-trip time of the signal between the two clocks | tau2 - tau1 proper time of clock 1 |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-049 Is 'at the same time' a convention, or fixed by the structure of spacetime?
booked: The map treats distant simultaneity as a convention (Einstein synchronisation) and keeps Malament's opposing argument alongside.
the other reading: B: fixed by causal structure (Malament 1977, 'derived from demanding a symmetrical relation of causal connectability'; 'Whether this settles the issue is disputed')
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (12)
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Einstein synchronisation gain
- Simultaneous hyperplane via sys:spacetime · Einstein synchronisation gain
- Lattice of synchronized clocks via sys:spacetime · Einstein synchronisation gain
- Inertial observer (inertial frame of reference) via sys:spacetime · Einstein synchronisation gain
- Global Positioning System (a realised clock lattice) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Einstein synchronisation even
- Sagnac effect via sys:spacetime · Einstein synchronisation loss
- Slow clock transport via sys:spacetime · Einstein synchronisation even
- Speed of light via sys:electromagnetic-field · Einstein synchronisation gain
- Relativity of simultaneity via sys:electromagnetic-field · Einstein synchronisation gain
- Born coordinates frame (Langevin observers) via sys:spacetime · Einstein synchronisation even
- Two-way speed of light via sys:electromagnetic-field · Einstein synchronisation gain
- Coordinate time via sys:spacetime · Einstein synchronisation even
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (16)
- Lattice of synchronized clocks
- Photon
- Simultaneous hyperplane
- Inertial observer (inertial frame of reference)
- Rotating frame of reference
- Ideal clock
- Global Positioning System (a realised clock lattice)
- Slow clock transport
- One-way speed of light
- Sagnac effect
- Measuring rod
- Speed of light
- Relativity of simultaneity
- Born coordinates frame (Langevin observers)
- Two-way speed of light
- Coordinate time
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
wired (2)
Notes published science
- You cannot measure the one-way speed of light without first assuming it: 'it is meaningless to measure a one-way velocity prior to the synchronisation of distant clocks'; such experiments really check a round trip.
- On a spinning disk, synchronising clocks all the way around leaves a gap that 'depends on the direction used': the Sagnac effect, which GPS has to correct for.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
simultaneity built by the convention (spacetime)
- L1: Clocks at rest in one inertial frame: 'Its principal value is for clocks within a single inertial frame'
- L2: Consistency: (a) 'clocks once synchronised remain synchronised'; (b1) reflexive, (b2) symmetric, (b3) transitive; guaranteed by 'No redshift' and 'Reichenbach's round-trip condition'
- L3: A global time function: 'Given (a), if (b1)-(b3) hold then the synchronisation allows us to build a global time function t. The slices t = const. are called "simultaneity slices"'
- L4: Where it fails: 'In rotating frames, even in special relativity, the non-transitivity of Einstein synchronisation diminishes its usefulness'; around a rotating disk the result 'depends on the direction used' (Sagnac effect, Ehrenfest paradox); 'The Global Positioning System accounts for this effect'
synchronising light signals (electromagnetic field)
- L1: The signal: 'a light signal is sent at time tau1 from clock 1 to clock 2 and immediately back, e.g. by means of a mirror'; it returns at tau2
- L2: The setting: clock 2 is set so that the reflection time is tau3 = tau1 + 1/2 (tau2 - tau1) = 1/2 (tau1 + tau2)
- L3: What the round trip guarantees: 'Laue-Weyl's round-trip condition' holds iff the convention is consistent and 'the one-way speed of light ... is a constant all over the frame' (Minguzzi and Macdonald 2003); 'experiments claiming a measure of the one-way speed of light can often be reinterpreted as verifying the Laue-Weyl's round-trip condition'
Who fills each layer
- L1: Relativity of simultaneity
- L2: Relativity of simultaneity
- L3: Coordinate time, Two-way speed of light
Sources (5) published science
Relativity of simultaneity (Wikipedia, rev 1375748088, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched 2026-10-28 with tools/wme/wme-paced.sh) (behind its links)
Coordinate time (Wikipedia, rev 1376379559, 2026-09-23; via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Speed of light (Wikipedia, rev 1381043372, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache): distance measurement section (behind its links)
Born coordinates (Wikipedia, rev 1362303886, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)