← all systems · see it in The System
Positive energy theorem
'The positive energy theorem (also known as the positive mass theorem) refers to a collection of foundational results in general relativity and differential geometry. Its standard form, broadly speaking, asserts that the gravitational energy of an isolated system is nonnegative, and can only be zero when the system has no gravitating objects.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: asymptotically flat initial data sets (M, g, k) obeying the dominant energy condition; the energy-momentum (ADM) of each end as a vector in Minkowski space; the conclusion that it is future-causal, and the rigidity statement that zero energy means Minkowski data. Outside: data that break the dominant energy condition, spacetimes that are not asymptotically flat, and settings where it fails (non-supersymmetric semiclassical Kaluza-Klein, 'bubble of nothing'). |
| nested level | A theorem about the walked ADM mass, with the walked dominant energy condition as hypothesis, on spacelike slices of solutions of the field equations; field scale, rung 1. Not a kind of anything walked (roster: nonkind). |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| first proofs (Schoen and Yau) | 1979, 1981 (Commun. Math. Phys. 65:45, 79:231) year |
| Witten's spinor proof | 1981 (Commun. Math. Phys. 80:381) year |
| ADM energy normalisation | 1/(16 pi) (energy), 1/(8 pi) (momentum) geometrized units |
| charged bound | M >= sqrt(Q^2 + P^2) Gaussian units |
| dimensions covered | below 8 (minimal surfaces), 8 (Smale 1993), up to 11; all dimensions with tr k = 0 (Schoen-Yau preprint, 18 April 2017) |
| characteristic clock: none (a statement about one slice); the Bondi extension tracks mass along retarded time | none |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Positive energy theorem. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (partial)
Two independent proofs reach one conclusion: Schoen-Yau by variational methods and minimal surfaces (by contradiction), Witten by spinors ('logically direct'). - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
The energy of the whole is read against a global reference (Minkowski space at each end): the energy-momentum of each infinite region is 'an element of Minkowski space', and the floor case is Minkowski itself.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (6) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Positive energy theorem gain
- Dominant energy condition (DEC) via sys:stress-energy · Positive energy theorem gain
- Minkowski spacetime via sys:spacetime · Positive energy theorem gain
- Spinor via sys:spacetime · Positive energy theorem gain
- Bondi mass via sys:gravitational-field · Positive energy theorem gain
- ADM mass via sys:gravitational-field · Positive energy theorem gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (11)
- ADM mass
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Minkowski spacetime
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface)
- Einstein field equations
- Spinor
- Bondi mass
- Positivity of the Bondi mass
- Positive mass bound with charge (Einstein-Maxwell)
represents (1)
Kinds (2)
Notes published science
- The total gravitational energy of any isolated system whose matter obeys the dominant energy condition can never dip below zero, and only empty flat space sits exactly at zero.
- Two Fields Medals came partly from this one statement, proved two very different ways: by soap-film-like minimal surfaces and by spinors.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
initial data on a spacelike slice (spacetime)
- L1: A spacelike hypersurface embedded in a Lorentzian manifold with a continuous unit normal: induced metric g and second fundamental form k (a development of (M, g, k))
- L2: Gauss-Codazzi: G(nu, nu) = (R - |k|^2 + (tr k)^2)/2 and G(nu, .) = d(tr k) - div k, so the dominant energy condition is 'identical to the assertion that G(nu, .) ... is timelike or null and is oriented in the same direction as nu'
- L3: Development: 'the maximal globally hyperbolic development of the initial data set (M, g, k) has zero curvature' when the energy-momentum vanishes
positive energy theorem (own: non-negative energy of an isolated gravitating system; gravitational field)
- L1: An isolated system: an asymptotically flat initial data set (M, g, k), a Riemannian manifold with a symmetric 2-tensor; outside a compact set K each component (an end) is diffeomorphic to the complement of a closed ball in R^n
- L2: Matter hypothesis: the dominant energy condition R - |k|^2 + (tr k)^2 >= 2|div k - d(tr k)|; time-symmetric data obey it 'if and only if the scalar curvature of g is nonnegative'
- L3: Read at each end: E = (1/16 pi) lim of the sphere integral of (d_q g_pq - d_p g_qq) x^p/|x|, and P_p = (1/8 pi) lim of the integral of (k_pq - (tr k) delta_pq) x^q/|x|; (P, E) as a vector in Minkowski space
- L4: Conclusion: each end's energy-momentum is 'a future-pointing non-spacelike vector' (Witten), so E >= 0 (Schoen and Yau)
- L5: Rigidity: zero energy-momentum at any end forces one end, M diffeomorphic to R^3, and a development that is Minkowski space (Schoen-Yau 1981) or has zero curvature (Witten)
- L6: Reach and limits: Bondi mass; asymptotically AdS; Einstein-Maxwell M >= sqrt(Q^2 + P^2), equality for Majumdar-Papapetrou extremal holes; dimensions below eight by minimal surfaces, eight by Smale's 1993 result, up to 11, a 2017 preprint for all dimensions with tr k = 0; it 'fails in certain non-supersymmetric semiclassical gravity settings' (bubble of nothing)