EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Competition for dissolved calcium (carbonate against apatite)

dissolved Ca2+ precipitated either as carbonate (Ca2+ + 2 HCO3- -> CaCO3) or as phosphate (apatite)

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

born atprebiotic Earth (carbonate-rich lakes 'likely abundant'); not dated in the sources
born precisionunknown
boundaryInside: the dissolved Ca2+ of one water body (a closed-basin lake brine, its inflow, a shoreline pool), the carbonate alkalinity and the phosphate that can bind it, the salts that form (gaylussite, calcite, carbonated apatite) and which forms first. Outside: the weathering that supplies the ions, the microbes that take phosphate, the sodium salts that cap phosphate on evaporation, and the prebiotic chemistry the freed phosphate may feed.
compete fnsfn:resource-denial-attrition
nested levelBuilt from its pool (Ca2+, sys:calcium-atom) and two takers (carbonate minerals, sys:calcite; apatite, sys:apatite). Fought in carbonate-rich closed-basin lakes and, in reverse, in marine sediments where phosphate replaces carbonate. It sits inside the contest for phosphate (sys:competition-phosphate) as its switch.
scalemolecular

Measures (19) published science

residual dissolved Ca2+ in the experimental brines0.07, 0.11, 0.045, 0.033 mmol/kg
share of added Ca2+ in solid phases~99.9 %
apatite precipitation threshold (carbonate-rich brine)10 to 100 mmol/kg phosphate
phosphate cap in a stream-fed closed-basin lake<100 (<0.1 molal) mmol/kg
phosphate on evaporation without inflow>1; up to 3 in equilibrium with Na2HPO4·7H2O or ·2H2O molal
experimental phosphate at early-Earth pCO2 (0.01 to 1 bar)between 20 and 100 ('respectively') mmol/kg
phosphate in equilibrium with apatite and calcite, present-day pCO2<=1 (log pCO2 = -3.5); 10 to 100 times higher at 0.01-1 bar micromolar
Searles Lake phosphate5 to 17 mM
Mono Lake and Lake Magadi phosphate~1 mM
Lake Magadi against Searles Lake phosphateover 10 times lower in Magadi ratio
Lonar Lake phosphate~5 micromolar
Owens Lake dissolved Ca2+~1 (before ~1920); 0.05-0.2 (later) mM
Ca2+ over calcite in Na2CO3 solutions (laboratory)0.01-0.1 mM
phosphate-rich brine pH on the early Earth6.5 to 9 (about 10 at present-day pCO2) pH
calcium isotope fractionation on precipitationroughly 0.025% per atomic mass unit, lighter isotopes into calcite, aragonite and apatite % per amu
soda lake pHtypically 9 to 12 pH
phosphorite P2O5 content4% to 20% % P2O5
gaylussite to calcite conversionover 4 weeks
experimental equilibration time1 to 4 (Fig. 2A: 2) weeks

Open contentions (1) open contention

Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (6)

Sits inside / holds (3)

Trades with (valence) (10)

expressed by (1)

floor filled by (14)

represents (1)

Kinds (2)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

carbonate and phosphate minerals in marine sediment (diagenesis)

  1. L1: Limestones and mudstones as phosphate hosts; phosphate associated with calcium carbonate buried in marine sediments
  2. L2: Replacement: phosphatic beds with the textures of fine-grained limestones 'may represent diagenetic replacements of carbonate minerals by phosphates'; the phosphate is fluorapatite, often cryptocrystalline (collophane)
  3. L3: Phosphatization: phosphate-rich fluids leached from guano 'are then concentrated and reprecipitated in limestone'

closed-basin inflow and evaporation (water cycle)

  1. L1: Inflow: closed-basin lakes take weathering products 'via streams to evaporating lake brines'; weathering under CO2-rich air releases phosphate from apatites and carbonate alkalinity from other minerals
  2. L2: Evaporation: upon evaporation 'the residual carbonate alkalinity concentrates as Na–HCO3–CO3-rich brine'; seasonal wet and dry cycles, shoreline rocks wetted by waves, local pools
  3. L3: The two regimes: in hydrologic balance (inflow equals evaporation) stream calcium holds phosphate below 100 mmol/kg; with no inflow the brine has more phosphate than calcium and phosphate climbs past 1 molal

dissolved calcium in carbonate-rich lake brine (aqueous solution)

  1. L1: The pool: Ca2+ brought by stream inflow ('streams have much more Ca2+ than phosphate'); in the experiments 50-100 mmol/kg Ca2+ added slowly from gypsum to saturated Na-HCO3-CO3 brines
  2. L2: The two binders and the switch between them: carbonate alkalinity from carbonic-acid weathering, and phosphate; which salt forms 'depends primarily on the relative concentrations of carbonate' against bicarbonate, a ratio that 'also controls the pCO2 and pH'
  3. L3: Carbonate takes the calcium: high carbonate precipitates Ca2+ as gaylussite and/or calcite; phosphate blocks calcite and aragonite nucleation, so gaylussite forms first and turns to calcite by incongruent dissolution over 4 weeks; calcite is less soluble the warmer the water
  4. L4: Apatite takes the calcium: at low carbonate Na-rich carbonated apatites and calcite occur together; a fall in carbonate 'increases the solubility of calcite/gaylussite, which increases the concentration of Ca2+ in solution and causes phosphate to precipitate as apatite'; above 10-100 mmol/kg phosphate, inflowing Ca2+ precipitates apatite
  5. L5: The score: residual Ca2+ 0.033-0.11 mmol/kg, ~99.9% of added calcium in solids; phosphate conservative (1:1 with Br-), up to ~100 mmol/kg with inflow and >1 molal on evaporation, finally capped by sodium phosphate salts (Na2HPO4·7H2O or ·2H2O, up to 3 molal) because Ca2+ and Mg2+ are 'minor in carbonate-rich brines'

Sources (7) published science

Toner & Catling, A carbonate-rich lake solution to the phosphate problem of the origin of life, PNAS 117(2), 883-888 (2020; online Dec 2019) (author PDF with supplement)
Calcium (Wikipedia, rev 1380108526, 2026-10-13)
Phosphorite (Wikipedia, rev 1330264090, 2025-12-30, via Wikimedia Enterprise copy) (behind its links)
Soda lake (Wikipedia, rev 1374836232, 2026-09-14, via Wikimedia Enterprise copy) (behind its links)
Calcite (Wikipedia, rev 1369611712, 2026-08-16, via Wikimedia Enterprise copy) (behind its links)
Biomineralization (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise; lead and evolution sentences read) (behind its links)
Nucleation (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)