EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Competition for phosphate (nucleotides, lipids, apatite, ocean)

Nucleotide backbones and lipid heads need phosphate, while apatite locks it in insoluble mineral and the ocean scavenges it.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

boundaryInside: dissolved orthophosphate in surface waters (the contested part of the pool) and each taker's taking layer: precipitation with Ca2+ into apatite, adsorption onto iron (oxy)hydroxide surfaces in vent plumes, dilution and burial in the ocean, and esterification into nucleotides and phospholipid heads. Outside: phosphorus already locked in crustal rock until weathering releases it, phosphorus in stars and meteorites (supply, not contest), and what nucleotides and lipids do once formed.
compete fnsfn:resource-denial-attrition
nested levelBuilt from phosphorus (as phosphate, the pool), two mineral/ocean takers and two organic takers. Embedded in early Earth's hydrosphere and its lakes, within the slow global phosphorus cycle; it feeds gate:abiogenesis without being part of it.
scalemolecular

Measures (10) published science

phosphate in most natural watersmicromolar (rivers and surface waters 1 uM or less)
phosphate used in prebiotic experimentsabout 1 molal
carbonate-rich lake phosphate, steady stateup to ~0.1 molal
carbonate-rich lake phosphate, evaporating without inflow>1 molal
Mono Lake phosphate~1 mM
Searles Lake phosphate5-17 mM
Goodenough and Last Chance Lakes total phosphoruscan exceed 50 mM
modern ocean: sinking particulate P removed by burialapproximately 1 %
apatite content of phosphoriteas much as 80 %
winner ratio, open water vs needed (outcome measure)micromolar available vs ~molal used: about six orders of magnitude

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (5)

Sits inside / holds (3)

Trades with (valence) (8)

expressed by (1)

floor filled by (1)

same pair (1)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

aqueous solution

  1. L1: Water carrying dissolved orthophosphate; sodium, potassium and ammonium phosphates are water-soluble, most others only slightly or insoluble
  2. L2: Mineral uptake: precipitation with Ca2+ as apatite down to micromolar; adsorption onto iron (oxy)hydroxide surfaces
  3. L3: Organic uptake: phosphate esterified into nucleotides and phospholipid heads, needing about a molal in experiments
  4. L4: Calcium as the switch: where carbonate takes the calcium, phosphate accumulates (Mono Lake ~1 mM, Searles 5-17 mM)
  5. L5: Outcome: micromolar in most natural waters (rivers 1 uM or less); up to ~0.1 molal, and >1 molal on evaporation, in carbonate-rich closed lakes

rock and mineral surfaces

  1. L1: Apatite-bearing rock: apatite is the most abundant primary phosphorus mineral in the crust; tectonic uplift exposes phosphorus-bearing rock at the surface
  2. L2: Weathering: apatite dissolved by natural acids from soil microbes and fungi, by carbonation and other chemical weathering, and by physical erosion, releasing phosphorus in soluble form
  3. L3: Surface binding: phosphate adsorbs to the charged surfaces of Fe and Al (oxy)hydroxides (goethite) and to clay edges, and precipitates onto calcite in calcareous soils
  4. L4: Burial: iron-oxide-bound phosphorus transformed to vivianite, and phosphate associated with calcium carbonate, buried in lake and marine sediments
  5. L5: Rate control: release by weathering restricts phosphorus availability; high pH lowers oxyhydroxide adsorption capacity and soil organic matter competes for the sites; late in soil development released P re-precipitates into rock
  6. L6: Geologic loop: phosphorus-rich deposits form in the ocean, and over time geologic processes bring ocean sediments back to land for renewed uplift and weathering

water cycle (evaporation and runoff)

  1. L1: Surface water in oceans, lakes, rivers and ponds moving between reservoirs
  2. L2: Evaporation: solar energy heats surface water, which absorbs latent heat of vaporisation and goes to vapour
  3. L3: Separation: the evaporative phase separates water molecules from salts and other particles left in the liquid
  4. L6: Runoff and transport: flowing water carries minerals across the land and reshapes it by weathering, erosion and deposition; lakes and ponds receive detrital input from weathering of apatite-bearing rock

Who fills each layer

Sources (9) published science

Toner & Catling, A carbonate-rich lake solution to the phosphate problem of the origin of life, PNAS 117(2), 883-888 (2020; online Dec 2019) (author PDF with supplement)
Hydrothermal vent (Wikipedia, rev 1375986573, 2026-09-21) (behind its links)
Phosphorus cycle (Wikipedia, rev 1380436327, 2026-10-15) (behind its links)
Abiogenesis (Wikipedia, rev 1380994702, 2026-10-19) (behind its links)
Nucleotide (Wikipedia, rev 1374824034) (behind its links)
Phosphate (Wikipedia, rev 1381496932, 2026-10-22) (behind its links)
Apatite (Wikipedia, rev 1379065129, 2026-10-07, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Phospholipid (Wikipedia, rev 1380950544, 2026-10-19) (behind its links)
Weathering (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)