← all systems · see it in The System
Mutation
A change in the nucleic acid sequence of the genome of an organism, virus or extrachromosomal DNA, arising from errors in replication, mitosis or meiosis, from damage to DNA that triggers error-prone repair or a copying error, or from mobile genetic elements. Kinds run from single-base substitutions and small insertions and deletions to duplications, chromosomal rearrangements and whole-genome duplication. Unlike DNA damage, a mutation is present in both strands, is not ordinarily repaired, and is copied when the cell replicates. Effects range from none to loss or gain of function; most new mutations are neutral or harmful and a few helpful. Somatic mutations pass to the descendants of one cell within a body (cancer among their effects); germline mutations pass to offspring. Mutation is the ultimate source of all genetic variation, the raw material on which selection and drift act.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | for the kind: with the first replicators (no date read) |
| born precision | lower bound only |
| boundary | Inside: the change itself and the processes that make it permanent: the agents that reach the genome (copying by polymerases, spontaneous chemistry, oxidants, ultraviolet and ionizing radiation, chemical mutagens, mobile elements, recombination, stress-regulated and programmed mutagenesis), the lesions and errors they leave, the repair and bypass that let some of them through, the fixed change in both strands, its effect on the gene product, and its fate (copied into a somatic clone or passed through the germline into a population). Outside: the DNA molecule as a whole (the medium), the repair machinery as a system of its own, selection and drift that sort mutations after they arise, and the organisms, cancers and species that carry their effects. |
| nested level | A process of the genome (sys:dna's sequence floor, L5, where a lesion that escapes repair is copied in as a mutation) and a part of evolution (sys:biological-evolution's mutation channel) and of heredity (sys:heredity's mutation channel); kinds by size, by effect, by inheritance and by cause. |
| scale | molecular |
Measures (36) published science
| human germline mutation rate per site per generation (sequencing of relatives) | 1.1e-8 per nucleotide per generation |
| new mutations per human diploid genome per generation | about 70 mutations per generation |
| human deleterious mutation rate U per diploid genome per generation | about 2.2 (0.35 amino-acid changing) mutations per generation |
| de novo mutations per human genome per generation (trio sequencing) | 50-90 mutations per generation |
| human germline SNV rate per site per generation (encyclopedia best estimate) | 1.18e-8 (about 78 per generation) per nucleotide per generation |
| paternal age effect on de novo mutations | 1.51 (95% CI 1.45-1.57) extra mutations per year of father's age |
| maternal age effect on de novo mutations | 0.37 (95% CI 0.32-0.43) extra mutations per year of mother's age |
| adult stem cell mutations per year (colon, small intestine, liver) | about 40 (about 36 per tissue) mutations per year |
| human somatic mutation rate per site per cell division | 1.02e-9 (17x the germline rate) per nucleotide per division |
| somatic mutations in a middle-aged human body | >1e16 mutations |
| microbial mutation rate per genome per replication | 0.0033 mutations per genome per replication |
| vertebrate to prokaryote per-generation mutation rate ratio | nearly 100 ratio |
| Paramecium tetraurelia base-substitution rate | about 2e-11 per site per cell division |
| RNA virus mutation rate per nucleotide per cell infection | 1e-6 to 1e-4 (DNA viruses 1e-8 to 1e-6) substitutions per nucleotide per cell infection |
| HIV mutation rate per base per generation | 3e-5 per base per generation |
| somatic hypermutation rate relative to the genome | at least 1e5 to 1e6 fold |
| DNA lesions per cell per day | 10,000 to 1,000,000 lesions per cell per day |
| oxidative DNA damage events per cell per day (humans) | 10,000 (rats 100,000) events per cell per day |
| gene duplication rate (C. elegans) | on the order of 1e-7 duplications per gene per generation |
| genes duplicated in animal genomes per million years | tens to hundreds genes per million years |
| Alu copies in the human genome | more than 1,000,000 copies |
| vesicular stomatitis virus random mutations: lethal | 39.6 (31.2 non-lethal deleterious, 27.1 neutral) % |
| E. coli gene deletions with negative fitness effect | 80 (20 positive) % |
| mutational signatures characterised (SBS, DBS, CBS, ID) | 49 SBS, 11 DBS, 4 clustered, 17 indel signatures |
| somatic mutations analysed for signatures | 84,729,690 mutations |
| share of cancer mutations from replication errors (R) | 66 (29 environment, 5 heredity; UK) % |
| cancers due to inherited genetic defects | 5-10 % |
| mutant clones per square centimetre of normal esophagus | tens to hundreds clones per cm2 |
| cells carrying NOTCH1 mutations in middle-aged and elderly esophagus | 12 to 80 (TP53 2 to 37) % |
| Arabidopsis mutation frequency inside gene bodies (relative) | reduced by half (by two-thirds in essential genes) relative to elsewhere |
| concordance of Monroe's mutation calls with a conventional pipeline | 3.7 (160 of 4,322) % |
| LTEE point mutations held by the six mutator populations | 96.5 % |
| LTEE mutations found in 264 genomes over 50,000 generations | 14,572 point mutations; 500 IS insertions; 726 small deletions and 1,132 small insertions; 267 large deletions and 45 large duplications |
| loci at which a typical human genome differs from the reference | 4.1-5.0 million loci |
| copying fidelity per site per human generation (Payment to Entropy, derived) | about 0.99999999 (1 - 1.1e-8) usable fraction per site per generation |
| range of per-generation germline mutation rates across 68 vertebrate species | 40 fold |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-736 When a system first throws away its excess energy and later learns to store it for reuse, is that one process that grew or two separate ones?
booked: The map keeps both readings side by side and rules neither. A few examples fit the 'one process that grew' reading, but it hasn't been tested.
the other reading: loss vs hand-off - C-796 What sets how fast genes mutate?
booked: The map follows the 'drift barrier' explanation, in which selection lowers mutation rates down to a limit set by population size and genome size, and keeps the proteome-size idea alongside.
the other reading: a cost-of-fidelity optimum (Drake 1991: 'a balance between the usually deleterious effects of mutation and the physiological costs'); rates kept up for adaptation (src:wp:mutation-rate) - C-799 Is evolution at the molecular level driven mostly by chance or by selection?
booked: The map records that both change gene frequencies and leaves their relative weight open.
the other reading: Kern and Hahn 2018: 'in light of modern, genome-scale data, we can firmly reject its universality'; selection the major force - C-2753 How much of cancer comes from errors made when cells copy their DNA?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: either reading - C-3377 Are mutations random?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: mutation directionless with respect to consequences / mutation bias that reduces deleterious mutations (Monroe) / regulated, possibly localised mutagenesis as evolvability (Galhardo)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (22) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Mutation. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- runaway from an unstable balance (structural)
The error threshold: below a critical length a replicator keeps its information; past it 'a runaway mutation process will destroy the information in subsequent generations' (error catastrophe, pushed in RNA viruses by ribavirin). In cancers a repair-gene mutation raises the rate, which hits more rep - same role, different builds (structural)
The job: raise the mutation rate where and when new variants are needed. Bacteria do it with the SOS regulon's error-prone polymerases (UmuDC), switched on by stress; B cells do it with a cytidine deaminase (AID) aimed at antibody genes, 10^5-10^6-fold the genome rate. Unrelated machinery, one job. - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
One slippage, two signs: in slipped strand mispairing the new strand re-anneals 'in a different spot', which 'can lead to insertions or deletions' depending on which way it slips. One point substitution and its true reversion are the same exchange run backwards. - templating (structural)
A mutation is copied by the same base-pairing template as every other base, so a change once in both strands is inherited by every descendant; and protein domains act as modules 'mixed together to produce genes encoding new proteins'. - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
Every copy of a genome pays a toll in errors: about 1.1 x 10^-8 per site per human generation (about 70 new mutations per diploid genome), 0.0033 per genome per replication in microbes, up to 10^-4 per nucleotide in RNA viruses. The toll compounds along the chain of copies: adult stem cells gain abo - trade one property for another (structural)
Fidelity is bought with energy and speed: 'a trade-off between costs of a high mutation rate, such as deleterious mutations, and the metabolic costs of maintaining systems to reduce the mutation rate'; organisms sit at different points (Paramecium 2 x 10^-11 per site per division; RNA viruses 10^-6 - who opens the door (structural)
Two kinds of door. Open field: UV joins any adjacent pyrimidines, oxidants hit any guanine. A port: in B cells AID is aimed at hotspots in the antibody genes, a door the cell opens ahead of time; mismatch repair waits on the new strand for errors. - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
The germline is kept apart from the soma, and 'without the advantages of germline protection ... the heritable per generation mutation rates for animal species would be several-fold higher'; plants, which lack a dedicated germline, blur the distinction. The without-barrier case is shown for the muta - causal ceiling (partial)
The drift barrier: 'the lower bound on the mutation rate is not set by physiological or biochemical limitations, but by the intrinsic inability of selection to push the rate any lower' (the power of drift, 1/2Ne). A limit on what selection can reach, set by population structure, not by the machinery - conservation law plus closure (partial)
Neutral diversity is about 4Neu: one relation, two unknowns. It closes only with a measured mutation rate: 'factoring out the average mutation rates ... the average Ne in these groups can be approximated'. - holding / entrainment (partial)
The cell sets when its genome mutates: in bacteria the SOS regulon times mutagenic repair, late and only if damage persists; stress responses regulate 'mutagenesis in time'. Clock-like signatures (SBS1) count a cell's divisions. - partner-becomes-part (partial)
Mobile elements that mutate and delete genes as they move have, in Alu's case, been 'recruited to perform functions such as regulating gene expression': copies of a mover become working parts of the genome, inherited with it. The gain/gain phase is not shown, so partial. - seed (partial)
Gene duplication as an arriving packet that opens combinations: 'Few dispute that gene duplication is the main source of functional diversity on the genotype level'; a spare copy plus domains as modules gives new genes. Whether a single duplication unpacks 'vast' combinatorics is not shown. - smooth to sharp in finite time (partial)
As length or error rate rises smoothly, a replicator's information is kept up to a critical value and lost beyond it (the error threshold, a finite parameter). - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (partial)
The two strands are copied and repaired alike until transcription picks one: signatures are classed by whether the mutated pyrimidine 'fell on the transcribed or untranscribed strand'. Sex is a second cut: fathers pass about four times as many new mutations per year of age as mothers. - The carry (partial)
The wait: a lesion becomes a mutation only when the next copy writes it into both strands ('mutations are replicated when the cell replicates'); a cell with one good and one mutant copy works normally until the good copy is hit too, then the change passes on (two places, one capacity). The rate of n - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
A change is a mutation only against a consensus 'normal' sequence agreed by the community; whether it is harmful or helpful is read against the conditions it meets ('a harmful mutation can quickly turn into a beneficial mutations when conditions change'). - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (partial)
Each mutational process reads its own slice of the same genome: UV the adjacent pyrimidines, oxidants guanine, deamination the methylated CpGs, AID its RGYW hotspots; the slices show as distinct signatures (81 characterised). - borrowed-then-held (surface)
Mutation supplied from outside (UV, mutagens, oxidants) and mutation the cell makes itself on purpose (AID in B cells, SOS polymerases). The order (borrowed first, held later) is not shown in the sources read. - lightning (surface)
One base can flip what follows (a 32-base deletion in CCR5, a single sickle-cell allele, a driver mutation that founds a clone), and plain chemical decay makes mutations with no held regulation, so the bare generation of variants passes the lightning test trivially. Not a stored difference released, - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (surface)
Single-base substitutions are classed into a closed 96-class space (6 substitutions by their flanking bases); every signature found sits in that space. The space is enumerated, but no empty slot was predicted with its properties before it was found, so surface. - red-queen (surface)
HIV's high mutation rate gives antigen variability that evades the immune system, which itself mutates antibody genes to bind better; both sides change. The stalemate is not shown in the sources read.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (14) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Natural selection via sys:gene-pool · Mutation mixed
- Electromagnetic field via sys:electromagnetic-field · Mutation gain
- Cell via sys:aqueous-solution · Mutation gain
- DNA and genes via sys:dna · Mutation gain
- Virus via sys:rna · Mutation gain
- Adaptive immune system via sys:dna · Mutation even
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Mutation even
- DNA repair via sys:dna · Mutation loss
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring) via sys:dna · Mutation gain
- Evolution (biological evolution across time) via sys:dna · Mutation gain
- Transposable element via sys:dna · Mutation gain
- Cancer (control lost) via sys:cell-lineage · Mutation gain
- Gene via sys:dna · Mutation even
- Genome via sys:dna · Mutation even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- DNA and genes
- DNA replication
- Transposable element
- DNA damage (lesions)
- Error-prone replication bypass (translesion synthesis)
- Mutagens (chemicals, radiation)
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring)
- Evolution (biological evolution across time)
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (8)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Risk-managed Exploration
- Redundancy & Diversity
floor filled by (25)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Sequential information (the order of units along a linear polymer)
- Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping)
- Natural selection
- Electromagnetic field
- DNA and genes
- Protein
- Cell lineage (cells descended by division from a founder cell: clones, germline and soma)
- DNA replication
- DNA repair
- sos response
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring)
- Gene pool
- Gene
- Evolution (biological evolution across time)
- Transposable element
- Genetic drift
- Cancer (control lost)
- Genome
- DNA damage (lesions)
- Error-prone replication bypass (translesion synthesis)
- Mutagens (chemicals, radiation)
- Mutational signatures (SBS, DBS, ID)
- Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID)
- Molecular clock
represents (1)
Kinds (20)
- Somatic mutation
- gene duplication
- Missense mutation
- Point mutation
- Nonsense mutation
- Frameshift mutation
- Whole-genome duplication (polyploidy)
- Insertion
- Deletion
- Chromosomal rearrangement (translocation, inversion, large deletion, fusion)
- Loss of heterozygosity
- Synonymous substitution
- Loss-of-function mutation
- Gain-of-function mutation
- Dominant negative mutation
- Conditional mutation (e.g. temperature-sensitive)
- Germline mutation (de novo when new)
- Spontaneous mutation
- Induced mutation
- Somatic hypermutation
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Your body is a mosaic: by middle age it holds more than 10^16 mutations, and in the gullet of an older person, cells carrying a mutation in the cancer gene NOTCH1 can make up most of the lining, yet that mutation is several times more common in normal tissue than in esophageal cancer (src:lynch-2010, src:martincorena-2018).
- Bacteria and your immune system solved the same problem with unrelated tools: stressed bacteria switch on sloppy copying enzymes, and your B cells aim a dedicated enzyme (AID) at antibody genes, mutating them 100,000 to 1,000,000 times faster than the rest of the genome (src:wp:sos-response, src:wp:somatic-hypermutation).
- In Lenski's 50,000-generation E. coli experiment, half the populations evolved into mutators and carried 96.5% of all the point mutations; later the load of bad mutations favoured antimutator alleles and the rate fell again (src:tenaillon-2016).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
mutation as genetics and evolutionary biology describe it: what reaches the genome, lesions and copying errors, repair and bypass, the fixed change, its effect on the gene product and fitness, its fate in cells and lineages, and new variation for evolution (reader's view)
- L1: What reaches the genome: replication in mitosis and meiosis, spontaneous decay, oxidants, ultraviolet and ionizing radiation, chemical mutagens, mobile elements
- L2: Lesions and copying errors: 10,000 to 1,000,000 lesions per cell per day; mispairs, slippage, breaks, dimers
- L3: Repair, proofreading and error-prone bypass: most damage mended; translesion synthesis and end joining write some errors in
- L4: The fixed change in both strands, copied with the cell: point, indel, duplication, rearrangement, ploidy; signatures
- L5: Effect on the gene product and fitness: synonymous, missense, nonsense, frameshift, regulatory; loss or gain of function; most neutral or harmful, a few beneficial
- L6: Fate: somatic (the descendants of one cell; clones; cancer) or germline (offspring); sorted by selection and drift in populations
- L7: New variation for evolution: new alleles and genes; differences between species; the molecular clock
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: The fixed change: a new sequence present in both strands and copied with the cell; point substitutions (transitions, transversions), insertions and deletions, duplications, rearrangements, whole-genome duplication; each process leaves its own signature
- L5: The effect on the gene product and on fitness: synonymous, missense, nonsense, frameshift and regulatory changes; loss or gain of function; most neutral or harmful, a few beneficial (the distribution of fitness effects)
- L6: The fate in cells and lineages: a somatic mutation passes to the descendants of one cell (clones, mosaics, cancer); a germline mutation passes to offspring; in a population, selection and drift raise, lower or fix it
- L7: New variation for evolution: new alleles and new genes, the raw material selection and drift act on; differences between species, read as a molecular clock
way in: Chemical mutagens (tobacco smoke, aflatoxin, aristolochic acid, alkylating agents, base analogues, intercalators)
- L1: Mutagens and environmental causes that come in contact with the gene
- L2: Adducts, alkylated and analogue bases; nitrous acid alters the bases' hydrogen bonding
- L3: Mispairing at the next copy; each agent's surviving changes form its own signature (SBS4 tobacco, SBS22 aristolochic acid, SBS24 aflatoxin)
way in: Copying: errors made by the polymerases that replicate DNA
- L1: The DNA being copied at each cell division, in mitosis and meiosis, and the germ line's many divisions
- L2: Misincorporation and slippage: a tautomeric base pairs wrongly; the new strand slips on a repeat and re-anneals out of register
- L3: Proofreading, then mismatch repair, which reads the new strand's mismatches; what escapes both is copied in
way in: Ionizing radiation (gamma, X-rays)
- L1: Gamma rays and X-rays
- L2: Double-strand breaks (also 10 to 50 per cell cycle from the cell's own life)
- L3: End joining trims and fills the ends, often leaving a mutation
way in: Mobile elements: transposons and insertion sequences that move in the genome
- L1: Transposons, a major fraction of plant and animal DNA (over a million Alu copies in humans)
- L2: An element moves and inserts, mutating or deleting a gene (in 50,000 E. coli generations, 500 insertion-sequence insertions)
way in: Oxidants: reactive oxygen species from the cell's own metabolism
- L1: Reactive oxygen species inside the cell
- L2: Oxidised bases, such as 8-hydroxydeoxyguanosine
- L3: Repair, and removal of oxidised nucleotides from the pool; when that removal is broken the line becomes a mutator
way in: Programmed mutation: somatic hypermutation of antibody genes in B cells
- L1: A B cell that recognises an antigen and divides
- L2: AID deaminates cytosine to uracil at hotspots in the variable regions
- L3: A balance of error-prone and high-fidelity repair sets what stays
way in: RNA genome copying in RNA viruses
- L1: Single- or double-stranded RNA genomes copied in infected cells
- L2: Fast copying; substitutions four times as common as indels
- L3: In viruses such as HIV, no mechanism checks the genome for accuracy (stated by the source)
way in: Recombination and rearrangement: duplications, fusions, translocations, inversions
- L1: Chromosomes during recombination and repair
- L2: Segments break and rejoin: duplications, translocations, inversions, fusions (human chromosome 2)
way in: Spontaneous chemistry: water and heat acting on the bases (deamination, depurination, tautomers)
- L1: Water and heat in the nucleus: spontaneous molecular decay of a healthy cell's DNA
- L2: Deamination (C to U, A to hypoxanthine, 5-methylcytosine to T), depurination (an AP site), tautomeric shifts
- L3: Uracil and hypoxanthine are repaired; 5-methylcytosine turned to thymine looks like a normal base and is less likely to be caught; in dividing adult stem cells this leaves a signature of methylated-cytosine deamination
way in: Stress: starvation, antibiotics and damage switching on regulated, error-prone mutagenesis
- L1: Environmental stresses on bacteria, yeast and cancer cells
- L2: Single-stranded DNA at blocked forks activates RecA, which cleaves the LexA repressor
- L3: If damage persists, late genes (umuD, umuC) switch on mutagenic repair
way in: Ultraviolet light (sunlight)
- L1: Ultraviolet light reaching the cell, longer-wave UVA included
- L2: Adjacent pyrimidines (cytosine, thymine) joined into dimers
- L3: Repair or error-prone bypass; what escapes is the UV signature, C>T at CCN and TCN (SBS7)
way out: Antibodies diversified within one life (somatic hypermutation)
- L1: The antibodies in the body fluids, matched to the antigen
- L6: B cells with better binding receptors selected
way out: Disease: inherited disorders and cancers as people meet them
- L1: The body as felt and seen: inherited disorders, cancers
- L5: A protein that plays a critical role altered
way out: Germline: a new allele handed to offspring and into the gene pool
- L1: The offspring's genome: a constitutional mutation in every cell
- L6: A de novo mutation in a germ cell (more from older fathers)
- L7: A new allele in the population
way out: New genes: duplications diverging into new functions
- L1: The genome, larger by the copy
- L4: A duplicated segment raises dosage; one copy free to change
- L7: Gene families and new functions
way out: Somatic clones: mutant cells and their descendants in a body
- L1: Tissues of mosaic cells; with accumulated drivers, cancer
- L4: The change copied into every descendant of the mutated cell
- L6: Clones selected in the tissue; some carry cancer-gene mutations
way out: The record: signatures and clock-like changes read back by geneticists
- L1: Sequenced genomes
- L4: Signatures that name the processes (tobacco, UV, ageing)
- L7: Divergence read as time (molecular clock)