← all systems · see it in The System
Gene
In biology the word gene has two meanings. The Mendelian gene is a basic unit of heredity; the molecular gene is a sequence of nucleotides in DNA (in some viruses RNA) that is transcribed to produce a functional RNA, which either acts itself (non-coding genes) or is translated into protein (protein-coding genes). Regulatory sequences (promoters, enhancers, silencers) are associated with a gene and control its expression; in eukaryotes most genes are split into exons and introns. Variants of a gene at a locus are alleles. The definition has changed from Mendel's factors to the present and is still argued.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | for the kind: with the first cells (no date read); for single genes: any time, e.g. the human lineage gained 689 genes since the chimpanzee split |
| born precision | lower bound only |
| boundary | Inside: one gene at its locus: the transcribed region (exons and introns, untranslated regions, cleavage and polyadenylation sites) and, as gene-associated parts, the regulatory sequences that control it (promoter, enhancers, silencers); its alleles in a population; its products only as what it specifies. Outside: the rest of the DNA and chromosome, the machinery that reads and copies it (transcription factors, RNA polymerase, spliceosome, replisome), the cell and organism that carry it, and the population forces that change its frequency. Where the boundary sits (with or without the regulatory sequences; transcript or functional product) is the contested definition itself. |
| nested level | A part of the DNA molecule (sys:dna L5, 'the sequence and the genes in it'), at a locus on a chromosome, one of the genome's genes; read by gene expression, copied by replication, passed on by heredity, its alleles sorted by natural selection and drift in a gene pool. Kinds: protein-coding and non-coding; split and unsplit; single and in operons, families and overlaps. |
| scale | molecular |
Measures (31) published science
| time to transcribe the dystrophin (DMD) gene | 16 h |
| gene turnover rate in mammals | 0.0016 gains and losses per gene per million years |
| recent gene duplication rate in the human genome | 0.009 duplications per gene per million years |
| age of the globin duplication | approximately 500 million years |
| human protein-coding genes (GENCODE, encyclopedia) | about 19,000 genes |
| human protein-coding genes by catalogue (2018) | Gencode 19,901; Ensembl 20,376; RefSeq 20,345; CHESS 21,306 genes |
| human lncRNA genes by catalogue (2018) | Gencode 15,779; Ensembl 14,720; RefSeq 17,712; CHESS 18,484 genes |
| human non-coding genes (Ensembl, encyclopedia) | 26,000 genes |
| Human Genome Project's starting estimate | 100,000 genes |
| typical mammalian protein-coding gene length (transcribed region) | about 62,000 bp |
| share of the mammalian genome in protein-coding genes (transcribed regions) | 35-40 % |
| gene size estimated in 1965 | 1500 bp |
| dystrophin gene length | 2.24 Mb |
| dystrophin muscle transcript exons | 79 exons |
| human genes alternatively spliced | 92-94 % |
| splicing error rate per intron (human) | approximately 0.7 % |
| splicing accuracy under ideal conditions | 99.999 % |
| essential genes in E. coli and B. subtilis | 250-400 genes (under 10%) |
| essential genes in mice and humans | around 2000 genes (~10%) |
| minimal genome of Syn 3 | 473 genes |
| human-lineage gene gain since the chimpanzee split | 689 gained, 86 lost genes |
| human-chimpanzee difference in gene complement | at least 6 (1,418 of 22,000) % |
| mammalian ancestral gene families | 9,990 families |
| human-specific de novo genes | ~18 genes |
| protein-coding gene sequences on Earth (estimate) | 5 million sequences |
| rice protein-coding genes | >46,000 genes |
| Mendel's average dominant:recessive ratio in the F2 | 2.98:1 ratio |
| Mendel seed-form count (F2) | 5474 round, 1850 wrinkled of 7324 seeds |
| ABO common alleles | 6 alleles |
| segregation distorters' share of gametes | more than 50 % of gametes |
| per-hand-off efficiency of splicing one intron (derived) | about 0.993 fraction correctly spliced |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-784 How much of the human genome does something useful?
booked: The map records that biochemically active regions cover far more of the genome than conserved ones, and leaves open whether the extra active regions are functional.
the other reading: function as biochemical activity vs function as selected effect - C-3362 Do new genes arise from non-gene DNA in a sudden step or along a continuum?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: proto-gene continuum (young genes intermediate) / sudden transition to function once an ORF gains a selected effect (young genes with exaggerated genic features); ORF first vs transcription first - C-3365 Is the gene the unit that natural selection acts on?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: gene-centred view (Williams, Hamilton, Maynard Smith, Dawkins; 'only genes are transmitted'); critics: too adaptationist, neglects drift (encyclopedia); confuses book-keeping with causality (Gould); multilevel selection (Wilson, Sober, Okasha, via the encyclopedia); molecular metaphors mislead at higher levels (Noble 2008); intentional language rejected (Charlesworth, via Agren & Patten 2022); 'licensed anthropomorphizing' as a middle way (Agren & Patten 2022) - C-3366 What counts as a gene?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a gene must have a shown function (Kampourakis, via the encyclopedia); a gene is an ORF both transcribed and translated (Mortola & Long, via the encyclopedia); a gene is a union of sequences encoding a coherent set of functional products (Gerstein 2007); the concept itself needs redefinition (Portin & Wilkins 2017) - C-3369 How many genes do humans have?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Gencode 19,901 / Ensembl 20,376 / RefSeq 20,345 / CHESS 21,306 (2018); about 19,000 (encyclopedia, GENCODE); 'we don't yet know how many genes we have' (Salzberg 2018) - C-3372 Are most of a gene's alternative forms functional, or copying noise?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: most isoforms functional and regulated / most low-abundance isoforms noise - C-3376 How many pea plants did Mendel grow?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: 8000 pea plants, 1857-1864 (encyclopedia, Gene) / some 28,000 pea plants, 1856-1863 (encyclopedia, Mendelian inheritance)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (20) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Gene. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- holding / entrainment (structural)
The cell sets when its genes are copied: 'a duplicate copy of every gene in the genome' before division, in S phase. Reverse cases held apart: meiotic drivers and transposons copy or spread out of step with the rest ('subverting the normal rules of replication and inheritance'). - same role, different builds (structural)
One job, keeping heritable instructions, done in DNA by most organisms and in RNA by some viruses ('Some viruses store their entire genomes in the form of RNA'); one job, a new gene, reached by duplication, transfer, fission/fusion or de novo birth ('not all orphan genes arise de novo'). - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
Enhancers and silencers: both distal sequences that act by 'binding to transcription factors which then cause the DNA to loop' to the promoter; enhancers bind activators and raise transcription, silencers bind repressors and lower it. Also gene gain and loss, run by one birth-and-death process (Demu - seed (structural)
A few discrete units unpack many combinations: Mendel described his results 'as 2^n combinations where n is the number of differing characteristics'; one gene yields several products by alternative splicing in 92-94% of human genes. Seed check: yes, the particulate gene (against blending) opens comb - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (structural)
Before: in Mendel's crosses 'it is perfectly immaterial whether the dominant character belongs to the seed plant or to the pollen plant'. After: imprinting, where a gene's maternal and paternal copies act differently because 'diploid individuals are related to most of their social partners different - templating (structural)
The gene's DNA 'is used as a template to generate a complementary mRNA', and every gene is copied before division; genes work when moved between species ('genes are easily added to bacteria'; antibiotic-resistance genes pass 'even [between] those of different species'). - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
Every hand-off from gene to product pays a toll. Signal: the average intron is mis-spliced about 0.7% of the time ('approximately 0.7%'; per-intron efficiency about 0.993, our arithmetic), so a gene with many introns loses more transcripts (the 79-exon dystrophin transcript has 78 junctions; at the - trade one property for another (structural)
Overlapping genes buy genome length ('reduction in genome size') and pay in sequence freedom ('novel evolutionary constraints on the sequences of the overlap regions'); virus groups settle at different points (dsRNA viruses under a quarter overlap, about three-quarters of retroviruses and ssDNA viru - who opens the door (structural)
The gene's promoter is a port written in its sequence before any reader arrives: 'The promoter is recognized and bound by transcription factors that recruit and help RNA polymerase bind'; chromatin opens or closes the door from outside ('regulate whether a particular region of DNA is accessible'). - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
In prokaryotes transcription and translation can overlap in the cytoplasm; in eukaryotes the nucleus holds the primary transcript, which is spliced before export, and split genes are 'rare in bacteria and archaea'. Partial: the two cases are shown side by side, not the without-the-barrier test. - conservation law plus closure (partial)
Allele frequencies at a locus 'necessarily sum to unity'; genotype frequencies p², 2pq, q² follow only with a second assumption about mating (Hardy-Weinberg). Partial: the closing assumption is named in the article's model, not in our quote. - coordination-before-mapping (partial)
An operon's genes are 'expressed together or not at all' under one promoter, coordinated by a repressor reading a metabolite, with no stand-in for the world. Partial: coordination of a few genes, not of a body. - lightning (partial)
Whole-genome duplication: a sudden doubling followed by 'a relatively short period of genome instability, extensive gene loss, elevated levels of nucleotide substitution and regulatory network rewiring'; two such events (2R) on the vertebrate line to humans. Partial: no stored difference released is - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (partial)
Mendel's series A + 2Aa + a predicts which dominant-looking plants are hybrids, a class that 'can only be determined by the following generation'; the human gene list still has gaps the catalogues disagree on (Salzberg 2018). Partial. - not-diluting wins (partial)
Mendelian segregation gives each allele half the gametes; a driver that 'end[s] up in more than 50% of all the gametes' does not dilute at the split and spreads. Partial: the shape is density held while others thin; here it is a share held above the fair split. - partner-becomes-part (partial)
A toxin-antidote selfish element, in conflict with the rest of the genome, gives its host a fitness benefit 'either during their initial evolution or by being co-opted by the animals following their selfish spread'. Partial: the source does not show a fused inheritance, since the element already sit - The carry (partial)
The wait: a long gene must be transcribed end to end before its message is finished; the 2.24 Mb dystrophin gene's primary transcript 'takes 16 hours to transcribe'. The source gives the time, not a rate-limiting claim, so this is booked as the wait's settling time, not as a bottleneck. Overflow pas - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Dominance is read only against the pair at a locus: an allele is dominant where 'the heterozygote is indistinguishable from one of the homozygotes'; the same allele can read differently against a different partner (ABO: six common alleles). Partial. - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (partial)
Each gene hears only the factors its own promoter and enhancers bind, out of the same nucleus; strong and weak promoters take different slices of the same factor pool. Partial: the sources describe binding, not the full set of what each gene hears. - nested ladder (surface)
The gene's history as successive readings: 'first as a dimensionless point on a chromosome, then as a linear segment within a chromosome, and finally as a linear segment in the DNA molecule that encodes a polypeptide chain'. Surface: each rung is more concrete, but none is shown to imply the ones be
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (18) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci via sys:sequential-information · Gene even
- RNA via sys:base-pairing · Gene even
- Cell via sys:aqueous-solution · Gene gain
- DNA and genes via sys:dna · Gene gain
- Chromosome via sys:dna · Gene gain
- Protein via sys:sequential-information · Gene gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Gene even
- Natural selection via sys:gene-pool · Gene mixed
- Mutation via sys:dna · Gene mixed
- Transcription factor via sys:aqueous-solution · Gene gain
- Meiosis via sys:chromosome · Gene gain
- Chromatin via sys:chromatin · Gene mixed
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring) via sys:genealogy · Gene gain
- Evolution (biological evolution across time) via sys:gene-pool · Gene mixed
- Genetic drift via sys:genealogy · Gene mixed
- Gene expression via sys:aqueous-solution · Gene gain
- Genome via sys:sequential-information · Gene gain
- Selfish genetic element via sys:dna · Gene loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (7)
Sits inside / holds (4)
expressed by (12)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Scheduled Build-and-Dismantle (On-Demand Structure)
floor filled by (23)
- DNA and genes
- Mutation
- RNA
- Ribosome
- Chromosome
- Protein
- Natural selection
- RNA polymerase
- Transcription factor
- Meiosis
- Spliceosome
- Chromatin
- Organism (the living thing, as biology describes it)
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring)
- Gene pool
- Genetic drift
- Gene expression
- Enhancer
- Promoter (core and proximal)
- Exon
- Intron
- Allele
- Genome
represents (1)
Kinds (12)
- Protein-coding gene
- Non-coding gene
- Split gene (exons and introns)
- Operon
- Overlapping gene
- Pseudogene
- De novo gene
- Selfish genetic element
- Essential gene
- Mendelian gene (the unit of heredity)
- Molecular gene (the transcribed sequence)
- Evolutionary gene (Williams)
Notes published science
- Your genes are mostly gaps: about half of the human genome is introns, the stretches inside genes that get cut out of the message (src:hube-francastel-2015). And the cutting is not perfect: each intron is mis-spliced about 0.7% of the time (src:pickrell-2010). A gene with dozens of introns, like the 79-exon dystrophin gene, would at that average rate get only a bit over half its messages right (our arithmetic), and the dystrophin gene takes 16 hours just to be read once (src:wp:dystrophin).
- The Human Genome Project set out to locate 'the estimated 100,000 human genes'. The real number of protein-coding genes came in near 20,000, and in 2018 the main catalogues still disagreed on hundreds of them: 'we don't yet know how many genes we have' (src:salzberg-2018).
- Humans and chimpanzees differ by about 1.5% in matching DNA letters, but by at least 6% in which genes they have at all: since the split, our lineage gained 689 genes and lost 86, a 'revolving door' of gene birth and death (src:demuth-2006).
- Your body is a mosaic: by middle age it holds more than 10^16 mutations, and in the gullet of an older person, cells carrying a mutation in the cancer gene NOTCH1 can make up most of the lining, yet that mutation is several times more common in normal tissue than in esophageal cancer (src:lynch-2010, src:martincorena-2018).
- Bacteria and your immune system solved the same problem with unrelated tools: stressed bacteria switch on sloppy copying enzymes, and your B cells aim a dedicated enzyme (AID) at antibody genes, mutating them 100,000 to 1,000,000 times faster than the rest of the genome (src:wp:sos-response, src:wp:somatic-hypermutation).
- In Lenski's 50,000-generation E. coli experiment, half the populations evolved into mutators and carried 96.5% of all the point mutations; later the load of bad mutations favoured antimutator alleles and the rate fell again (src:tenaillon-2016).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Transcription and RNA processing: the gene's DNA used as template for a complementary RNA; capping, splicing (introns out, exons joined, often in alternative combinations), cleavage and polyadenylation
- L5: The gene product: a protein, or a functional RNA (rRNA, tRNA, microRNA, ribozyme)
- L6: The trait: alleles at the locus and the phenotype they give, dominant or recessive, together with the environment
- L7: The gene across generations: copies passed to daughter cells and offspring, alleles segregating and recombining, their frequencies shifted by selection and drift; the Mendelian gene as unit of heredity (and, contested, of selection)
the gene as geneticists describe it: from the DNA at its locus, through its regulatory sequences, transcription unit, transcript and product, to the trait it shapes and the allele passed on (reader's view)
- L1: The DNA at the gene's locus on a chromosome, packed on histones in chromatin; chromosomes as the carriers of Mendel's paired factors
- L2: Regulatory and signal sequences: promoter (strong or weak), enhancers and silencers, operators, start and stop codons, splice sites, cleavage and polyadenylation sites; whether regulatory sequences belong to the gene is contested
- L3: The transcription unit: a linear stretch of DNA; exons, introns (often much larger than exons, sometimes holding other genes) and untranslated regions; in operons several coding regions in one unit; overlapping genes sharing sequence
- L4: Transcription and processing: RNA polymerase copies the template strand into a complementary RNA; splicing (alternative in 92-94% of human genes, about 0.7% error per intron); cleavage and polyadenylation
- L5: The product: a protein (via the genetic code) or a functional RNA; on a functional definition only a transcript with a shown function qualifies
- L6: The trait: alleles at the locus, dominant or recessive, give phenotypes; most alleles change little or nothing
- L7: The gene across generations: copied into daughter cells, one copy per gamete, segregating 3:1 and assorting, reassorted by crossing-over; allele frequencies shifted by selection and drift; read as the unit of heredity, and by gene-centred views as the unit of selection (contested)
way in: Chromatin: histone packing and marks
- L1: Histones and nucleosomes the DNA is packed on
- L2: Chemical modifications of the histones
- L3: The region accessible or not for expression
way in: Conditions: nutrients, temperature, stress, cell cycle, cell role
- L1: External environment (nutrients, temperature, stresses) and internal environment (division cycle, metabolism, infection)
- L2: A regulator's state changed by metabolites: an operon repressor active or inactive
- L3: The active repressor binds the operator at the start of the operon and blocks transcription
way in: Mutation: copying errors and damage
- L1: Errors of replication and repair, and mutagenic change, arriving at a per-generation rate (high per generation in humans, low per cell division)
- L2: A changed sequence: single-nucleotide changes, insertions and deletions up to several thousand base pairs
- L3: A new allele at the locus
way in: Natural selection on carriers
- L1: The environment the carriers meet
- L2: Differential survival and reproduction of carriers; phenotypes meet the environment
way in: New genes: duplication, transfer and birth from non-genic DNA
- L1: Errors in replication and repair, retrotransposition, polyploidy, capture by selfish elements; plasmids passed between cells and species
- L2: A copied gene, a transferred gene, or an open reading frame in ancestrally non-genic DNA (ORF first or transcription first)
- L3: A new locus: a duplicate (often free from selection), an orphan, a de novo gene, an overprinted frame
way in: Random genetic drift
- L1: Finite populations: which copies get passed on is partly chance
- L2: Where drift is strong (small effective populations, many eukaryotes) it outweighs weak selection on a gene
way in: Readers: transcription factors and RNA polymerase
- L1: Transcription factors and RNA polymerase in the nucleus (in the cytoplasm in prokaryotes)
- L2: The promoter, recognised by transcription factors that recruit RNA polymerase; a consensus such as the TATA box; strong and weak promoters
- L3: Enhancers and silencers kilobases away bind activators or repressors and loop the DNA to the promoter
way in: Recombination and segregation in meiosis
- L1: Homologous chromosomes paired in meiosis
- L2: Crossing-over swaps lengths of DNA between non-sister chromatids
- L3: Linked alleles reassorted; genes close together seldom separated (linkage)
way out: Copies passed on
- L1: The gene's DNA in daughter cells and offspring
- L7: One copy of each gene per gamete; one from each parent in the fertilized egg
way out: Products made (proteins and functional RNAs)
- L1: Products at work in the cell: enzymes (lactase digesting lactose), rRNA and tRNA in translation
- L5: Protein or functional RNA made
way out: Regulators sent back to genes
- L1: They bind other genes' promoters, operators and transcripts
- L5: Products that regulate: repressors, transcription factors, microRNAs, riboswitches
way out: Traits the organism carries
- L1: The carrier's traits meet its world (flower colour, stem length, antibiotic resistance)
- L6: The phenotype: observable characteristics