← all systems · see it in The System
Phonon
In condensed-matter physics, the quantum of a lattice's vibration: a quasiparticle of vibrational energy that oscillates at a single frequency, an excited state of one normal mode of an elastic structure, a boson whose motion involves every atom. Long-wavelength phonons are sound (quantised sound waves, as photons are quantised light); in crystals with more than one atom per cell they come in acoustic and optical branches (optical modes can couple to light: infrared-active or Raman-active). Phonons carry sound and heat, set heat capacity and thermal conductivity, scatter electrons (resistance) and bind them into Cooper pairs (conventional superconductivity), and exist outside crystals too, in glasses, liquids and superfluids.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: one quantum of one vibrational mode of a host's atoms, defined by its branch, wavevector (crystal momentum, up to a reciprocal lattice vector), frequency, polarisation and lifetime, with every atom of the host taking part. Outside: the host's ground state (absolute zero: no phonons), the electrons, spins, defects and boundaries that scatter it, and the probes that make and read it. At absolute zero no phonons are occupied, though the atoms keep their zero-point fluctuations (src:giustino-2017-electron-phonon). It is a phonon only while the mode is well defined: in a liquid only above the Frenkel frequency 1/tau for transverse modes; in a glass beside quasi-localized nonphononic vibrations that are not phonons. In a glass the word itself is contested (C-3781): in amorphous silicon only the lowest 4% of modes are plane-wave-like propagons (src:allen-1999-diffusons). |
| nested level | Built from the host's atoms and the forces between them; embedded in a crystal, glass, liquid or superfluid as one of its low-lying collective excitations (a kind of quasiparticle). |
| scale | atomic |
Measures (39) published science
| Rayleigh-wave frequency in NiPS3 (220 nm film, q = 0.0135 nm^-1, room temperature) | about 4.2 (measured); 4.6 (calculated) GHz |
| NiPS3 Rayleigh-wave phase velocity, 220 nm film, paramagnetic to antiferromagnetic | about 1920 to about 1815 (about 6% down) m/s |
| NiPS3 Rayleigh-wave phase velocity, 260 nm film | 1610 to 1500 (about 7.3% down) m/s |
| NiPS3 Néel temperature | about 155 K |
| NiPS3 Rayleigh-mode magnetoelastic softening (frequency) | about 0.23 (220 nm), about 0.30 (260 nm) GHz |
| NiPS3 effective modulus reduction implied by the velocity drop | about 12 % |
| NiPS3 c66 (DFT), non-magnetic to antiferromagnetic | 47.4 to 55.4 GPa |
| NiPS3 Rayleigh-mode softening, DFT plus finite elements | 0.54 (4.603 to 4.578 GHz) % |
| NiPS3 optical phonon (255 cm^-1) linewidth deviation at TN | about 0.3 cm^-1 |
| NiPS3 zone-centre phonon count | 8Ag + 7Bg + 6Au + 9Bu (30 modes) |
| MgB2 superconducting critical temperature (measured) | 39 K |
| IXS energy resolution at BL35XU | about 1.5 meV at 100 meV transfer; neutrons typically 5-10% |
| IXS sample size | micrograms; crystals about 10-100 micrometres across |
| x-ray and neutron probe energies against phonon energies | x-rays about 20 keV; neutrons about 20 meV; phonon transfers about 1-200 meV |
| graphene room-temperature thermal conductivity (first Raman optothermal measurements) | 3000-5400 W/mK |
| graphene thermal conductivity, isotope disorder 0.01% to 50% | about 2800 to about 1600 (at about 380 K) W/mK |
| share of graphene's heat carried by ZA phonons (Lindsay et al., BTE-IFC) | about 75 % |
| liquid heat capacity per atom (mercury), melting to high temperature | about 3 kB to about 2 kB |
| range of liquid relaxation times | 16 orders of magnitude |
| single-trip time of a phonon in the 2 mm channel | 500 ns |
| whole state transfer time through the phonon channel | about 700 ns |
| state transfer efficiency through the phonon channel (final remote population) | 0.68 (unidirectional); 0.15 (bidirectional) fraction |
| qubit frequency in the phonon link | 4.102 GHz |
| second sound in graphite | above 200 K |
| minimum phonon wavelength | 2a (twice the atomic spacing) length |
| Rayleigh-wave speed in metals; in the ground (shallow, deep) | 2-5 km/s; 50-300 m/s; 1.5-4 km/s |
| Rayleigh waves sensed by animals | below 20 Hz |
| gravitational mass carried by a magnitude-9 earthquake's sound wave (prediction) | about 10^11 (energy about 10^18 J at cs about 5 km/s); delta g about 10^-4 nm/s^2 kg |
| single SAW phonon energy lifetime (Satzinger 2018 resonator) | 148 ± 1 (dephasing time 293 ± 1) ns |
| one-phonon Fock state fidelity (Satzinger 2018, Wigner tomography) | 0.858 ± 0.007 (|0>: 0.985; superposition: 0.945) fraction |
| SAW resonance frequency and wavelength (Satzinger 2018) | 3.985 GHz; wavelength 1 µm |
| second sound velocity in graphite (measured, Huberman 2019) | about 3200 (3650 calculated) m/s |
| temperature at which graphite's TTG signal oscillates (second sound) | 85 (damped oscillations); 'above 100 kelvins' in the abstract K |
| earlier second sound in solids (heat pulse experiments, as listed by Huberman 2019) | '3 He' 0.42-0.58 K; Bi 1.2-4 K; NaF 11-14.5 K; SrTiO3 30-40 K reported and disputed |
| 13C content: isotopically purified graphite against ordinary HOPG (Xie 2026) | 0.07% against 1.10% |
| effective thermal conductivity gain from second sound, isotopically pure graphite, room temperature | nearly 10 above the diffusive limit % |
| share of amorphous-Si vibrational modes that are propagons / locons | lowest 4% / highest 3% (the rest diffusons) |
| zero-point displacement amplitude of an atom | about 0.1 Å |
| ballistic phonon heat transport in nearly perfect crystals | below about 10 K |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-3719 What causes the excess of slow vibrations found in every glass?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Allen, Feldman, Fabian and Wooten 1999 (sections read): 'excess modes' (the boson peak) are not a necessary ingredient to explain amorphous silicon's thermal-conductivity plateau, a simple crossover with heat carried by diffusons; other theories (Moriel refs 34-41) not read - C-3742 Which vibrations carry most of the heat in graphene?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a resolution by later work not read here - C-3760 Does sound carry mass?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: the commonly accepted statement that sound waves carry no mass (true at linear order, per the same paper); the authors themselves say, for the superfluid case, that the effect is 'completely equivalent to standard refraction' (gravity makes the pressure, and so the sound speed, depend on depth), then argue the mass reading still holds: the strongest form of the no-mass view - C-3775 Does magnetic order split one of NiPS3's vibrations in two?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a small splitting at TN reported by earlier Raman studies of NiPS3 and other MPX3 (their ref. 25, 36; not read) - C-3781 Does a glass have phonons?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a definition of 'phonon in a glass' that later work settles (not read) - C-3795 Does heat travel as a wave ('second sound') in strontium titanate?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: other authors argued the low-frequency Brillouin doublet does not support a second-sound reading (Huberman's account; those papers not read)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (18) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Phonon. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- conservation law plus closure (structural)
The balance law (-rho omega^2 u = div sigma) needs a constitutive law to close it: the stress is tied to the strain 'by the stiffness tensor c_ij', which first-principles DFT supplies; heat flux likewise needs Fourier's law Q = -k grad T, which breaks down when length or time scales approach those o - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (structural)
The structure predicts its members: p atoms per cell give exactly 3 acoustic and 3p-3 optical branches; group theory gives NiPS3's zone-centre set (8Ag + 7Bg + 6Au + 9Bu) and which are Raman-active, and 'all Raman-active modes are observed'. - same role, different builds (structural)
One job, reading a lattice's vibrations out as a dispersion, done by different builds: neutrons scatter off the nuclei, x-rays off the electron cloud moving with them (Baron), light by Raman and Brillouin-Mandelstam scattering at the zone centre (Ebrahim Nataj), ultrafast electron diffuse scattering - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
One diatomic-chain formula with a plus and a minus: the plus root is the optical branch (neighbours move against each other), the minus root the acoustic branch (they move together). Also: different bonds contribute 'with opposite signs' of dJ/du, so the same exchange-striction softens some optical - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (structural)
Phonons are 'extended vibrations emerging due to global symmetries' (Moriel): a uniform shift of the crystal costs nothing, so acoustic frequencies go to zero at long wavelength. A second cut: when the zigzag antiferromagnetic order sets in, the elastic tensor changes (c66 47.4 to 55.4 GPa; c35 chan - templating (structural)
The quantised harmonic oscillator is the module: each lattice mode is one, phonons are its quanta, and the photon gas is the same module ('This similarity is not coincidental, for it turns out that the electromagnetic field behaves like a set of harmonic oscillators'); both obey Bose-Einstein statis - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
Every hand-off pays a toll. Quantum-signal form: an excitation handed from a qubit to a single phonon leaves the far qubit excited at most 68% of the time (final remote population, unidirectional), 'limited mostly by phonon loss in the channel' (efficiency 0.68 per hand-off). Thermal form: three-pho - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
Each probe and each partner carves its own slice of the same lattice motion: optical phonons read short-range bond-scale spin correlations, acoustic phonons the long-range order; Raman sees zone-centre optical modes, Brillouin-Mandelstam scattering GHz acoustic modes near the zone centre, neutrons a - who opens the door (structural)
Doors of each kind: an open field for thermal phonons (any mode the temperature can fill); self-built physics doors (symmetry selection rules decide which modes light can see; Loudon's rule for surface Brillouin scattering); ports installed ahead of time by people (the unidirectional interdigitated - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
A phononic bandgap round a mechanical resonator: without it, 'the leakage of phonons out of this region through its supporting anchors would lead to rapid decoherence of both the mechanics and the qubit'; with it the device holds phonons long enough to resolve their number states. The without-the-ba - causal ceiling (partial)
A structural floor on what a lattice wave can be: 'There is a minimum possible wavelength, given by twice the equilibrium separation a between atoms'; wavevectors beyond the first zone carry no more information than their counterparts inside it. - holding / entrainment (partial)
The lattice's temperature sets how many phonons there are: thermal phonons are created and destroyed by random fluctuations with zero chemical potential, filled to Bose-Einstein occupation; none at absolute zero. The whole sets the count of its parts, though through the bath, not a held loop. - not-diluting wins (partial)
At the lowest frequencies the phonons' Debye density of states (omega^2) outlasts the glass's nonphononic modes (omega^4 tail) and dominates; at liquid temperatures the longitudinal mode survives at every frequency while transverse modes drop out below 1/tau. - The carry (partial)
The wait face: the remote qubit cannot settle until the phonon arrives; the 500 ns single trip sets most of the ~700 ns transfer. In liquids the relaxation time tau (16 orders of magnitude across liquids) is the wait that decides whether a shear mode can propagate (only above 1/tau). Second sound sh - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
A phonon's wavevector is only defined up to a reciprocal lattice vector: the whole lattice fixes the reference (the first Brillouin zone) against which each phonon's crystal momentum is read; ħk 'is not actually a physical momentum'. - trade one property for another (partial)
Probes trade along a dial: x-rays buy small samples and energy resolution independent of transfer, paid with Lorentzian tails; neutrons keep sub-meV resolution and short tails but need large crystals (MgB2's were too small for neutrons). - coordination-before-mapping (surface)
Every atom moves in step in a normal mode ('each phonon is a "collective mode" caused by the motion of every atom') with nothing but neighbour forces and no map: coordination at the done level, trivially met by springs (the lightning test). - partner-becomes-part (surface)
Magnon-phonon hybridization is named among the strong spin-lattice couplings of FePS3, CrBr3 and Cr2Ge2Te6 (references not read): spin waves and lattice waves mixing into one mode.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (19) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter) via sys:acoustic-wave · Phonon even
- Electron via sys:electromagnetic-field · Phonon mixed
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Phonon mixed
- Neutron via sys:residual-strong-force · Phonon mixed
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) via sys:thermal-energy · Phonon gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:acoustic-wave · Phonon even
- X-rays via sys:electromagnetic-field · Phonon even
- Antiferromagnet via sys:acoustic-wave · Phonon loss
- Cooper pair via sys:electromagnetic-field · Phonon even
- Seismic waves via sys:acoustic-wave · Phonon even
- Liquid via sys:matter · Phonon mixed
- Glass (amorphous solid) via sys:matter · Phonon mixed
- Crystal via sys:crystal-lattice · Phonon gain
- Magnetism via sys:crystal-lattice · Phonon mixed
- Superconductivity via sys:acoustic-wave · Phonon even
- Superconducting qubit via sys:electromagnetic-field · Phonon mixed
- Exciton via sys:thermal-energy · Phonon gain
- Semiconductor via sys:thermal-energy · Phonon gain
- Quantum spin chain via sys:thermal-energy · Phonon gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
- Normal mode
- Harmonic oscillator
- Crystal
- Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter)
- Light against heat for a recombining pair's energy
- Competition for the polariton population: leakage through the mirrors against thermalisation
- Competition for the electron pair: phonon-mediated attraction against Coulomb repulsion
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (28)
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
- Neutron star
- Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone)
- Quasiparticle
- Graphite
- Graphene
- Acoustic phonon
- Optical phonon
- Thermal conduction
- Brillouin zone
- Normal mode
- Harmonic oscillator
- Liquid
- Glass (amorphous solid)
- Crystal
- Superconductivity
- Second sound (superfluids)
- Umklapp scattering
- NiPS3 (nickel phosphorus trisulfide)
- Electrical resistivity
- Heat capacity
- Antiferromagnet
- Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter)
- Sound
- Condensed matter physics
- Semiconductor
- Exciton
Kinds (9)
- Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone)
- Quasiparticle
- Acoustic phonon
- Optical phonon
- Surface phonon (surface acoustic wave)
- Thermal phonon
- Itinerant phonon
- Superfluid phonon
- Phonon Fock state
wired (8)
- Electron
- Photon
- Neutron
- Atom
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Antiferromagnet
- Magnetism
- Exciton
Notes published science
- A magnet can change the speed of sound: when the nickel spins in a thin NiPS3 flake lock into a zigzag pattern below about 155 K, a sound wave running along its surface slows by 6-7% (from about 1920 to 1815 m/s), while the light-sensitive vibrations inside barely notice (src:ebrahim-nataj-2026-spin-lattice).
- Single sound particles can carry quantum information: a superconducting qubit launched one phonon down a 2 mm track; it took 500 ns (sound is that slow), and the qubit at the far end ended up excited at most 68% of the time, the loss mostly phonons lost along the track (src:dumur-2022-phonon-quantum-communication).
- Theory says sound has weight, and it is negative: beyond the simplest approximation a sound wave carries gravitational mass, about 10^11 kg for the wave of a magnitude-9 earthquake. Its pull would shift gravity by only about 10^-4 nm/s^2; when the paper was written atomic clocks and quantum gravimeters could detect changes down to fractions of a nm/s^2, so the authors hoped instruments would get there 'in the not-too-distant future' (src:esposito-2018-mass-of-sound).
- Heat can travel through a crystal like sound: in very pure graphite a pulse of heat sloshes back and forth instead of simply spreading out, and since 2026 this 'second sound' has been seen at room temperature, once the rare carbon-13 atoms were cut from 1.10% to 0.07% (src:xie-2026-room-temperature-second-sound).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: The phonon itself: every influence ends as a change in its frequency, velocity (dispersion slope), polarisation, crystal momentum or lifetime; each phonon a collective mode of every atom
- L5: Many phonons: the thermal phonon gas (Bose-Einstein statistics), its scattering and its transport regime (ballistic, hydrodynamic with second sound, diffusive)
- L6: The material's properties set by the phonons: elastic response and sound speed, heat capacity, thermal conductivity, electrical resistivity, superconducting pairing; the top floor the sources give
the phonon as condensed-matter physicists describe it (reader's view: the lattice, its displacements, the dispersion of its modes, the quantum, the phonon gas, the material properties it sets)
- L1: The host: N atoms or ions (about 10^23 in a sample) held near equilibrium by interatomic forces that are ultimately electric; a crystal first, but also glasses, liquids, superfluids and engineered structures (surface films, acoustic channels)
- L2: Displacement: a displaced atom pulls its neighbours and starts a wave; in the harmonic approximation the coupled motions separate into normal modes with a wavevector, a frequency and a polarisation; the shortest wavelength is twice the atomic spacing
- L3: Dispersion: frequency against wavevector inside the first Brillouin zone; 3 acoustic branches (atoms in phase, frequency to zero at long wavelength, slope = sound speed) and 3p-3 optical branches (unlike atoms against each other, finite frequency at the zone centre); the branch count and symmetries follow from the cell's atoms and point group
- L4: The phonon: the quantum hbar-omega of one mode, a boson, a collective motion of every atom, with crystal momentum (defined up to a reciprocal lattice vector), polarisation and a finite lifetime
- L5: The phonon gas: thermal phonons made and unmade by fluctuations, filled by Bose-Einstein statistics, none at absolute zero; scattering off each other (normal and Umklapp), electrons, spins, defects and boundaries sets ballistic, hydrodynamic (second sound) or diffusive transport
- L6: The material properties the phonons set: sound speed and elastic response, heat capacity (Debye T^3), thermal conductivity, the temperature-dependent part of electrical resistivity, phonon-mediated superconductivity; the top floor the sources give (nothing in a phonon reads, regulates or intends)
way in: Conduction electrons (electron-phonon coupling)
- L1: Electrons in the solid, screening the ions' potential
- L2: Electron-phonon coupling: matrix elements g that measure the strength of the coupling between the electron and phonon subsystems
- L3: Screening renormalises the phonons: Kohn anomalies in the dispersion, finite phonon lifetimes from the electron-phonon interaction
way in: Disorder, isotopes, defects and boundaries
- L1: Crystal defects, isotopes, sample surfaces and edges; the frozen disorder of a glass
- L2: Scattering off defects, isotopes and boundaries: isotope disorder cuts graphene's conductivity from about 2800 to about 1600 W/mK; boundaries dominate in the ballistic regime
- L3: In glasses: quasi-localized nonphononic vibrations beside the phonons, an excess over Debye's spectrum (the boson peak, in the THz range)
way in: Gravity (predicted coupling)
- L1: The gravitational field through the medium
- L2: Gravity compresses the medium unevenly; where the medium is denser sound runs faster (an ordinary equation of state)
- L3: Beyond linear order a sound wave carries a (negative) gravitational mass: it is acted on by gravity and sources a tiny field; predicted, not yet measured
way in: Heat (the thermal bath)
- L1: The lattice at a nonzero temperature: its energy fluctuates randomly about a mean
- L2: Thermal phonons created and destroyed by random energy fluctuations (chemical potential zero)
- L3: Bose-Einstein occupation of each mode, n = 1/(exp(hbar omega/kT) - 1); the Debye model's density of states
way in: Interatomic forces (the bonds that hold the lattice)
- L1: Van der Waals forces, covalent bonds, electrostatic attractions between neighbouring atoms, all ultimately electric
- L2: Harmonic approximation: the potential expanded to quadratic order about equilibrium, a set of springs (force constants)
- L3: The force constants set the dispersion omega(k) of every branch; first-principles theory computes them (density functional perturbation theory)
way in: Light (infrared absorption; Raman and Brillouin scattering)
- L1: Light falling on the solid: infrared, or a laser (532 nm in the NiPS3 work)
- L2: In ionic crystals the field pushes positive and negative ions apart and drives optical phonons (infrared active); Raman and Brillouin-Mandelstam scattering exchange energy with optical and acoustic phonons
- L3: Selection rules decide which modes light can make or see: Raman-active Ag and Bg modes, Loudon's rule for surface Brillouin scattering; the scattered light's frequency shift is the phonon's
way in: Magnetic order (spin-lattice coupling)
- L1: Ordered spins: in NiPS3 Ni2+ moments in a zigzag antiferromagnetic pattern below about 155 K
- L2: Exchange J between neighbouring spins depends on the atoms' positions: optical phonons feel the bond-scale derivative dJ/du (short-range correlations); acoustic phonons feel the uniform strain (long-range order)
- L3: Magnetoelastic renormalisation of the elastic tensor, in mixed directions (c66 up, c12 and c23 down, c35 flips sign; the paper's c_eff = c0 - lambda^2 chi_m): the Rayleigh surface wave of the NiPS3/SiO2/Si stack slows 6-7% across the Néel point (landing layer for the antiferromagnet walk's Rayleigh-wave route)
way in: Mechanical drive (impact, strain, piezoelectric transducers)
- L1: A localized impact or piezo-electric transduction at a surface; an earthquake's rupture
- L2: An interdigitated transducer turns a microwave signal into a surface acoustic wave
- L3: A surface acoustic wave (Rayleigh wave) running along the surface, its motion elliptical and confined to about a wavelength's depth
way in: Other phonons (anharmonicity)
- L1: The anharmonic part of the interatomic potential, beyond the springs
- L2: Three-phonon processes: two phonons combine into one (or one splits); normal processes keep crystal momentum, Umklapp processes fold it back into the first zone
- L3: Finite phonon lifetimes and temperature-dependent frequencies: cooling reduces anharmonic vibrations and stiffens the lattice
way in: Particle hopping in liquids (structural relaxation)
- L1: In a liquid each particle jumps between quasi-equilibrium positions, on average every tau (tau spans 16 orders of magnitude across liquids)
- L2: Below the Frenkel frequency 1/tau the liquid flows and holds no shear; above it, it supports transverse modes like a solid
- L3: Liquids differ from solids by the value of the Frenkel frequency only; the number of propagating transverse modes sets the heat capacity
way in: Quantum control (superconducting qubits)
- L1: A superconducting qubit excited by its microwave line (about 4.1 GHz)
- L2: A tunable coupler shapes the release of the excitation into a unidirectional transducer
- L3: One itinerant phonon: a short acoustic pulse travelling particle-like along a 2 mm channel (500 ns one way)
way in: Scattering probes (neutrons, x-rays)
- L1: A beam of neutrons (energy near the phonons', ~20 meV) or of x-rays (~20 keV) on the sample
- L2: Inelastic scattering: neutrons scatter off the nuclei, x-rays off the electron cloud moving with them; each event makes or takes a phonon
- L3: Energy and momentum transfer read out as a dispersion point; x-rays reach microgram samples and 1.5 meV resolution
way out: A tiny gravitational field (predicted)
- L1: A change in gravitational acceleration: about 10^-4 nm/s^2 for a magnitude-9 earthquake's wave
- L5: A sound wave carrying energy E carries a gravitational mass proportional to E (negative for ordinary equations of state)
way out: Absorbed by a qubit
- L1: The remote qubit excited (up to 68% population)
- L2: The remote coupler is timed to catch the shaped wave packet
- L4: The itinerant phonon arrives at the far transducer
way out: Electronic band gaps shifted (temperature and zero-point)
- L1: Band gaps and absorption edges move: most semiconductors redshift with temperature (Varshni effect; first measured by Becker and Fan 1949), some blueshift (inverse Varshni: copper halides, lead halide perovskites)
- L2: Fan-Migdal and Debye-Waller terms of the electron-phonon self-energy
- L6: The electron-phonon self-energy renormalises the electronic bands, even at T = 0 from zero-point fluctuations
way out: Electrons paired (conventional superconductivity)
- L1: Cooper pairs: resistance vanishes below Tc
- L2: An exchange of phonons gives a net attraction between electrons (Bardeen-Pines interaction)
- L6: Phonon-mediated pairing sets the critical temperature (coupling lambda, log-average phonon frequency, Coulomb mu*)
way out: Electrons scattered (resistivity)
- L1: Current slowed; energy to the lattice as heat
- L2: Electron-phonon scattering takes momentum from the current
- L6: The temperature-dependent electrical resistivity of metals and carrier mobility of semiconductors
way out: Heat carried and stored
- L1: Heat delivered to the colder side; heat tunnelling across nanometre gaps
- L3: Umklapp, defect and boundary scattering limit the conductivity
- L5: The phonon gas carries heat down a temperature gradient; in non-metals phonons are the main carriers
way out: Scattered light carrying the phonon's frequency
- L1: Light leaving the sample, read by an interferometer or spectrometer
- L2: Raman or Brillouin-Mandelstam frequency shift of the scattered light
- L4: A phonon made or taken by a scattering event
way out: Sound and elastic waves out (bulk and surface)
- L1: Sound in the solid; surface Rayleigh waves (seismic ground roll, surface acoustic wave devices)
- L3: Near-linear acoustic dispersion carries packets without breaking apart
- L6: The elastic constants set the speed: v proportional to sqrt(c_eff/rho)