← all systems · see it in The System
Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode)
Lopsidedness is the m = 1 (one-sided) distortion of a galaxy's disc: its light, gas or motions are heavier or reach further on one side, the photometric or kinematic centre sits off the geometric centre, and the outer isophotes are asymmetric left to right (Omonov et al. 2026). It is measured as the Fourier amplitude A1 of the m = 1 term of the disc's azimuthal surface density, by HI asymmetry (maps and global profiles), and kinematically by rotation curves that rise more steeply on one side. About 30% of nearby discs have A1 >~ 0.1 in stars, more in HI; the phase is nearly constant with radius, so it reads as a global mode (Jog & Combes 2009). Its origin is contested.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Lopsidedness (the m = 1 mode) |
| born at | the earliest read: severely lopsided quiescent discs at z = 2.91 (RO-1001); over 60% lopsided at 1.5 <~ z <~ 3 (observations cited by Dolfi 2024) |
| born precision | z = 2.91 (group redshift) |
| boundary | Inside: the disc's one-sided excess of stars, gas or velocity, as an m = 1 Fourier term with its amplitude A1(r) and phase phi1(r), typically growing outward (to at least 3.5 scale lengths in S4G) with nearly constant phase; its kinematic face (one side's rotation curve rising more steeply); its nuclear face (an off-centre nucleus, as in M31). Outside: the axisymmetric disc it is measured against (the m = 0 term), the m = 2 bars and arms it couples to, and the halo and surroundings that may force it. The edge is a threshold on a continuous amplitude (A1 > 0.1 in Jog & Combes, 0.2 in Zaritsky & Rix) and depends on the centre and aperture chosen. |
| nested level | A mode of the disc of a disc galaxy: the m = 1 rung of the disc's Fourier ladder (m = 2 is bars and two-armed spirals); set in the dark matter halo's potential, forced from outside (tides, accretion, ram pressure, halo asymmetry) or grown from inside (self-gravity). |
| scale | galactic |
Measures (32) published science
| m = 1 Fourier amplitude A1, deduplicated compilation | mean 0.157, median 0.117, sigma 0.133 (N = 442); log-normal (mu, sigma) = (-2.20, 0.87) fraction of m = 0 |
| A1-A2 coupling | A2 = (0.29 +/- 0.05) A1 + (0.11 +/- 0.01); Spearman 0.501 (N = 302); median A2/A1 = 0.90 dimensionless |
| median A1 by morphological type | ~0.07 (E/S0) to ~0.37 (Sm/Im); Kendall tau 0.234 fraction of m = 0 |
| median A1, fast vs slow rotators | ~0.06 (Vrot >~ 150 km/s) vs ~0.19 (Vrot <~ 60 km/s); Spearman -0.432 (N = 387) fraction of m = 0 |
| TNG50 vs observed median A1 | observed / TNG50 = 1.44; Spearman with M*: -0.395 observed, -0.445 TNG50 (888 simulated discs) ratio |
| median A1 per stellar-mass bin | 0.294 at log M* 9.25 (N = 22); 0.186 at 9.75; 0.114 at 10.25; 0.074 at 10.75 (N = 65) fraction of m = 0 |
| fraction of disc galaxies lopsided (stars, nearby) | ~30% with A1 >~ 0.1 (several surveys); ~30% with A1 >= 0.2 at R > 1.5 scale lengths in 60 field spirals (Zaritsky & Rix) fraction |
| fraction lopsided in global HI profiles | 50% of ~1700 (Richter & Sancisi 1994); ~75% (52 of 78) of isolated spirals (Haynes et al. 1998) fraction |
| kinematically lopsided fraction (WHISP) | 36% of 70; mean potential perturbation 0.056 fraction |
| fraction lopsided in TNG50 (z = 0) | 10-30% over observers' radii; 58% at larger radii (1435 discs) fraction |
| fraction lopsided in TNG100 | 8% (161 of 1912 discs) against ~30% observed fraction |
| fraction lopsided at high redshift | over 60% at 1.5 <~ z <~ 3 (observations cited); ~60% at 1.5 < z < 2 in TNG fraction |
| mass lopsidedness of z = 2.91 quiescent discs | 1.6 to >3 ratio of the two sides' mass |
| halo-to-disc amplification | disc isophote ellipticity >= 4 times the potential lopsidedness; a few % halo asymmetry gives ~10% disc lopsidedness ratio |
| Milky Way halo lopsidedness fit (outer HI thickness) | epsilon_1 = 0.2, epsilon_2 = 0.18, sigma_HI = 8.5 km/s (model A) dimensionless |
| winding time of aligned lopsided orbits | t_wind = 2 pi / Delta(Omega - kappa), ~5 times the material-arm winding time on a flat rotation curve |
| winding time at 15 kpc (Baldwin et al. 1980) | ~2 Gyr |
| lifetime of aligned-orbit lopsidedness (Baldwin et al. 1980) | 1-5 Gyr |
| lifetime of interaction-triggered m = 1 modes | about 1 Gyr |
| age of lopsidedness at A1 ~ 0.2 (tidal reading) | about 1 Gyr since the interaction |
| characteristic lifetime of lopsidedness (assumed) | 0.5 Gyr |
| post-merger decay of m = 1 | 500-850 Myr; ~2 Gyr for a delayed merger |
| self-gravity slowing of differential precession | ~10 times slower than local free precession factor |
| extra stars formed per lopsided event | ~1e9 Msun |
| precession rate of M31's eccentric nuclear disc | 36.5 +/- 4.2 km/s/pc |
| group vs field amplitude | about twice as high in groups; typical A1 ~ 10% ratio |
| pattern speed of merger-triggered lopsidedness | -3.5 (model gSadE006ret33, after first pericentre); -5.3 (gSadE001dir33); negative = retrograde km/s/kpc |
| measured precession rate of M31's eccentric nuclear disc | 0.0 +/- 3.9 km/s/pc |
| damping time of weakly damped m = 1 modes | tens to hundreds of crossing times (King models, 0.67 <= c <= 1.5) |
| Milky Way disc reflex motion against the outer halo | 32 +/- 4 km/s toward (l, b) = (56, -34) deg (+/- ~9-10 deg) |
| persistence of tidally offset Magellanic discs | almost 2 Gyr |
| A1 from one-sided accretion (simulations) | mean A1 0.11-0.21 for 3-9 Msun/yr, filament offsets 15-40 kpc, t = 2-4 Gyr fraction of m = 0 |
Open contentions (8) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-3373 What makes disc galaxies lopsided?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: tides, fly-bys and minor mergers (Ghosh 2021; Mapelli 2008: flybys ~20%; Zaritsky & Rix 1997); asymmetric cold-gas accretion (Bournaud 2005; Lokas 2022; Kalita 2022); an off-centre disc or lopsided, triaxial, high-spin halo (Jog & Combes 2009; Zaritsky 2013; Varela-Lavin 2023); internal instability of self-gravitating discs (Saha 2007; Omonov 2026); ram pressure on the gas (Mapelli 2008); a dark-matter wake (Kipper 2020); mechanisms that change with cosmic time: interactions and accretion more effective at high z (Dolfi 2024); an off-centred disc orbiting in the halo, spinning retrograde (Levine & Sparke 1998; Noordermeer et al. 2001); a weakly damped m = 1 mode of the halo itself (Weinberg 1994); a satellite's pull dislodging the disc from the centre of mass, caught in the Milky Way (Petersen & Penarrubia 2021) - C-3520 Over what part of a galaxy's disc should lopsidedness be measured?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: 1.5-2.5 Re (Omonov 2026); 1.5-2.5 Rd (Bournaud 2005; Zaritsky 2013; Zaritsky & Rix 1997 as cited by Zaritsky 2013) - C-3521 Are galaxies in groups more lopsided?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: group environment raises lopsidedness; environment matters little; internal structure dominates; Omonov 2026: massive galaxies, more often in dense environments, are less lopsided; environment data not in the compilation - C-3522 Is a galaxy's lopsidedness long-lived or made again and again?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: long-lived slow modes; repeatedly regenerated transients; free sloshing lasting only a dynamical timescale (Kornreich 1998 via Jog & Combes); weakly damped halo modes lasting tens to hundreds of crossing times (Weinberg 1994); minor-merger lopsidedness lasting at least 1 Gyr (Walker 1996 via Bournaud 2005); tidally offset Magellanic discs lasting almost 2 Gyr (Pardy 2016); at nuclear scale, a measured near-zero precession (Lockhart 2018) fits the slow-mode side - C-3523 Can a lopsided pattern in a galaxy be absorbed at a resonance?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: no ILR (slow prograde pattern); an ILR exists (negative pattern speed, Ghosh 2021) - C-3524 Do lopsidedness and spiral arms rise together?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: stronger arm patterns in less lopsided galaxies and no link to bars (Zaritsky 2013, S4G 167 galaxies); no lopsidedness-bar correlation in TNG100 (Lokas 2022) - C-3527 Why is the Pinwheel Galaxy lopsided?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: weak fly-by encounters in the group (NGC 5477, NGC 5474) shape the asymmetry (Mihos 2013; encyclopedia); internal or halo origin; a recent encounter with a massive companion looks unlikely (no long tails, Mihos 2013); older reading: M101 as an isolated lopsided galaxy (Jog & Combes 2009) - C-3528 How fast does the lopsided disc at the heart of Andromeda turn?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: rapid precession (models); near-zero precession (Keck IFS kinematics)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (13) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
One job, making a rotating disc heavier on one side, done by unrelated drivers: tides, one-sided gas accretion, a lopsided halo or dark-matter wake, ram pressure, or the disc's own instability (C-3373). - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (structural)
The axisymmetric disc (m = 0, no preferred direction) is broken at a named cut, the m = 1 phase angle; afterwards gas surface density and star formation peak on that side (0.3-0.5 raised at phi = 0, more HII regions on M101's SW). - templating (structural)
The same m = 1 (one-armed, eccentric) mode mathematics serves galactic discs, nuclear discs round black holes (M31's eccentric disc precessing at 36.5 km/s/pc), differentially rotating stars (a dynamical one-armed instability that triggers a weaker m = 2 bar) and temperature-graded protoplanetary-li - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Lopsidedness is often imposed from outside (tides, halo, accretion) and decays in 0.5-1 Gyr, yet self-gravity can hold a slow global m = 1 mode long-lived; the two phases are shown in different sources, not in one galaxy. - outside-to-inside (partial)
An asymmetry in the surroundings (the side accretion streams arrive from) becomes the disc's own stellar asymmetry: at z = 2.91 the lopsided side marks where streams hit, and the major axes align with the feeding filaments. - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
Some discs are unstable to m = 1: slowly growing ground-state modes in exponential discs, lopsided instabilities in counter-rotating discs; amplitudes log-normal as expected for exponential growth of a seed. The balance point (the axisymmetric disc) is named; saturation is not. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
One process, angular momentum transport by the m = 1 mode, runs either way: where the free precession Omega - kappa flips from retrograde to prograde the flow reverses; a halo sets it outward only if the lopsidedness is leading. - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Self-gravity plus differential rotation build an m = 1 mode independently in stellar discs (slow global modes), rotating stars and gas discs with a temperature gradient; in the star the m = 1 mode drives a secondary m = 2, as A2 scales with A1 in galaxies. - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
Each tidally induced one-sided pattern is erased by phase mixing: the ordered asymmetry handed to the disc ends up as spread-out orbit phases (thermal-like form); no per-hand-off efficiency given. - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Lopsidedness is defined only against a centre: the photometric, kinematic and geometric centres disagree, the shifted centre of mass acts back on the old centre, and A1 is a true lopsidedness only if the phase holds across radii. - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (partial)
Each tracer carves its slice of the same disc: HI lopsidedness larger and more frequent than stellar; ram pressure reaches only the gas channel; A1 grows with the radius measured (58% at larger radii in TNG50). - The carry (surface)
Overflow passed on to the next order, at most surface: a strong m = 1 gives the higher harmonics non-zero amplitude (A2 has a part that scales with A1, by non-linear coupling or geometric projection); no capacity per order is sourced. - who opens the door (surface)
Every crossing into the mode is opened by gravity or gas pressure: open field (tides, ram pressure) or self-built (the disc's own potential catching accreted gas); no port.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (11) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Galactic disc via sys:gravitational-field · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) gain
- Interstellar medium via sys:gravitational-field · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) even
- Galaxy via sys:gravitational-field · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) gain
- Supermassive black hole via sys:interstellar-medium · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) even
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) even
- Galaxy group (e.g. the Local Group) via sys:gravitational-field · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) gain
- Intracluster medium (ICM) via sys:intracluster-medium · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) gain
- Dark matter halo via sys:gravitational-field · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) gain
- Spiral arm via sys:gravitational-field · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) mixed
- Gas accretion onto galaxies via sys:intergalactic-medium · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) gain
- Galactic bar via sys:gravitational-field · Lopsidedness of galactic discs (the m = 1 mode) mixed
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (11)
- Galactic disc
- Spiral arm
- Star
- Gravitational field
- Interstellar medium
- Supermassive black hole
- Galaxy group (e.g. the Local Group)
- Intracluster medium (ICM)
- Dark matter halo
- Gas accretion onto galaxies
- Galactic bar
Kinds (12)
- Spiral arm
- Morphological (stellar) lopsidedness
- HI (gas) lopsidedness
- Kinematic lopsidedness
- Off-centred nuclei and eccentric nuclear discs
- One-armed spirals
- Sloshing centres of advanced mergers
- Lopsided bars
- Magellanic spirals (offset-bar, one-armed dwarfs)
- Disc instability
- Non-axisymmetric structure of a disc galaxy (Fourier m = 1, 2, ...)
- Galactic bar
Notes published science
- Half or more of all spiral galaxies are lopsided: one side of the disc reaches further, or spins up faster, than the other. In the gas it is often obvious; in old stars an untrained eye may miss it, because the effect grows toward the faint outer disc (src:swaters-1999, src:jog-combes-2009).
- A galaxy can be pulled lopsided by something you can't see: a few percent asymmetry in the dark matter halo is enough to make the disc about 10% lopsided, so astronomers can read the invisible halo's shape from the visible disc, as long as the disc has settled. Our own Milky Way has not: its disc is moving at about 32 km/s relative to the outer halo, knocked off-centre by the Large Magellanic Cloud (src:jog-combes-2009, src:petersen-penarrubia-2021).
- The disc at the very heart of our neighbour Andromeda is lopsided too: an eccentric disc of old stars a few parsecs across, wrapped round its black hole. Models had it turning at 36 km/s per parsec, but when it was finally measured it was barely turning at all (0.0 +/- 3.9). Lopsided galaxies themselves are spread in a log-normal way, which their authors read as a small seed being amplified by the disc (src:lockhart-2018, src:salow-statler-2004, src:omonov-2026-lopsidedness).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
lopsidedness as galactic dynamicists and surveys describe it (reader's view)
- L1: The disc in its halo: stars and gas on near-circular orbits in differential rotation, an exponential stellar disc with HI reaching further out, inside the dark matter halo's potential
- L2: A forcing or seed: tidal encounters, fly-bys and minor mergers; asymmetric gas accretion from filaments; a lopsided or triaxial halo, an off-centred disc or a dark-matter wake; ram pressure on the gas; or an internal instability (self-gravity, counter-rotating stars)
- L3: The orbit response: eccentric orbits aligned on one side, the disc's centre off the halo's, a rotation curve rising more steeply on one side (kinematic lopsidedness); a few % halo asymmetry becomes ~10% disc lopsidedness
- L4: The disc's susceptibility: low central stellar density, extended, gas-rich, late-type discs with shallow potentials and slow rotation are the most lopsided; deep potentials (fast rotation) damp it
- L5: The m = 1 pattern: A1 growing outward with nearly constant phase (a global mode), the centre offset, one side of the disc heavier and further-reaching; in the nucleus, an off-centre black hole and eccentric disc (M31); with winding phase, one-armed spirals
- L6: Persistence and coupling: winding by differential precession (about 5 times slower than material arms), slowed about tenfold by the mode's own self-gravity into a slow, global mode; no inner Lindblad resonance to absorb it; amplitudes log-normal (multiplicative growth of a seed); coupled to the m = 2 term
- L7: What lopsidedness does back to the galaxy: one-sided star formation and HII regions, gas carried inward to young central stars and growing black holes, angular momentum carried outward, outside-in quenching in some early discs; and, read by astronomers, a record of halo shape and assembly history
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: The disc's susceptibility: how far a disc gives way to any m = 1 push, set by potential depth (A1 falls with rotation speed), central stellar density and disc extent; late-type, gas-rich, extended discs give way most
- L5: The global m = 1 pattern: A1 rising outward, phase nearly constant, the centre offset; one side heavier
- L6: Persistence against winding and coupling to m = 2: slow precession, self-gravity, no ILR, log-normal growth
- L7: What the mode does to the galaxy: one-sided star formation, inflow to the centre and black hole, angular momentum outward, quenching in some early discs
way in: Asymmetric gas accretion from filaments
- L1: Cold gas flowing in along filaments
- L2: Gas landing on one side of the disc: the lopsided side marks where accretion streams hit
- L3: Asymmetric star formation from the new gas builds a lopsided stellar disc
way in: Ram pressure from the surrounding gas (gas only)
- L1: The hot gas a galaxy moves through in a group or cluster
- L2: Ram pressure on the disc gas as the galaxy moves
- L3: Lopsided gas (HI) while the stars stay nearly symmetric
way in: The dark matter halo: lopsided, triaxial, off-centre or wake-distorted
- L1: The halo's gravitational potential the disc sits in
- L2: A halo asymmetry: an m = 1 (and m = 2) distorted halo, as fitted to the Milky Way's outer HI; an asymmetric high-spin halo; a dark-matter wake behind a moving galaxy; a disc lying off-centre in the halo and spinning retrograde to its orbit about the halo centre (Levine & Sparke 1998); a weakly damped m = 1 mode of the halo itself (Weinberg 1994)
- L3: The disc responds: a few % potential asymmetry gives ~10% disc lopsidedness and a kinematic offset (mean perturbation 0.056 in WHISP)
way in: The disc's own self-gravity (internal instability)
- L1: The disc's stars and gas, self-gravitating
- L2: A small seed perturbation; counter-rotating stars with many retrograde orbits
- L3: Slowly growing or near-stationary global m = 1 modes, the precession cut about tenfold by self-gravity; multiplicative growth of the seed
way in: Tides from companions, fly-bys and minor mergers
- L1: The gravity of passing or merging galaxies
- L2: An encounter: a fly-by, a pericentre passage of a 1:10 satellite, an interaction with a more massive neighbour
- L3: The disc and halo shifted off-centre; m = 1 amplified after each pericentre, then phase-mixed within about 0.5-1 Gyr
way out: Asymmetric light and 21-cm emission (what is read)
- L1: Photons reaching telescopes: near-infrared, optical, radio 21-cm
- L5: The lopsided pattern in near-infrared starlight and HI; fades as phase mixing erases it
way out: Inflow to the centre, angular momentum outward
- L1: Gas reaching the nuclear region and the central black hole
- L3: Torques of the lopsided potential: angular momentum carried outward (if leading, with a halo), gas funnelled inward
- L7: Younger central stars, more metal-poor central gas, more powerful AGN in more lopsided hosts; central starbursts with quenched discs at z ~ 3
way out: One-sided star formation
- L1: The disc gas and the stars it forms
- L3: Effective gas surface density raised 0.3-0.5 on the heavy side; molecular gas there turns unstable
- L7: More HII regions and young stars on the overdense side (M101's SW); about 1e9 Msun extra stars per lopsided event (Rudnick et al.)