EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Lipid–RNA vesicle partnership

Fatty-acid vesicles that retain encapsulated RNA (no leakage detected after 19 h) while small solutes cross; vesicles encapsulating high concentrations of RNA experience osmotic stress that drives uptake of fatty acid from unstressed membranes, transferring ~25% of the membrane from empty vesicles to vesicles containing RNA. Described as 'cooperative interactions between the membrane and encapsulated contents'.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

asymmetryThe membrane's gain is measured (~25% growth); the RNA's gain (retention, parasite segregation) is inferred from compartment models. The vesicle can grow on micelle feed alone, so RNA depends more on the vesicle than the vesicle on RNA.
boundaryInside: the fatty-acid membrane of one vesicle and the RNA it encloses, and what passes between them (retention one way, osmotic load the other). Outside: the neighbouring empty vesicles and the free fatty acid in solution (the competition's pool), RNA copying chemistry itself, and division.
cheaterA parasitic RNA inside the vesicle that is copied by functional RNAs' activity and enjoys the retention without adding function (Mizuuchi & Ichihashi 2021); not yet seen in fatty-acid vesicles.
drivedriven
enforcementshared-fate
flips whenDivalent cations: RNA chemistry needs Mg2+, but fatty acid vesicles aggregate and precipitate below 1.5 mM MgCl2 and leak 27-fold more at 4 mM, so the partner's chemistry turns against the membrane. Also low RNA concentration: the osmotic edge needs 'high concentrations of RNA'.
joint outputA compartment that keeps its RNA and grows at its neighbours' expense: the loaded vesicle, where 'genomic fitness (i.e., replicative ability) would be translated into cellular fitness'.
knockoutWithout the RNA the vesicle is the loser: ~25% of the membrane moves from empty vesicles to vesicles containing RNA (Chen 2006). Without the compartment, 'short parasitic RNAs would quickly outcompete functional RNAs' (Mizuuchi & Ichihashi 2021, for compartments in general).
nested levelBuilt from sys:lipid (the membrane) and sys:rna (the encapsulated polymer), each of which persists apart. Embedded in an aqueous solution of fatty acids; it is the inside of the winning taker in sys:competition-vesicle-membrane, and it points at gate:abiogenesis, where genome and membrane become one unit.
obligatefacultative
partnerssys:lipid, sys:rna
recurrenceEach new osmotic load (more RNA, or RNA copied inside, proposed) re-tensions the membrane and drives another round of uptake; a full repeating cycle with division was not found in the sources read.
regimeStart: RNA encapsulated in fatty-acid vesicles (laboratory: Chen, Roberts & Szostak 2004; natural date unknown). End: either fusion into a unified cell (the genome+membrane transition owned by gate:abiogenesis) or dissolution by divalent cations, lysis or leakage.
saturationThe gain stops when the membrane tension is relieved (~25% transfer in the experiment); greater membrane stability also decreases dynamics.
scalemolecular
separabilityBoth persist apart: fatty acid vesicles form and grow on micelle feed without RNA, and RNA exists free in solution. Retention lasts at least 19 h; the transfer's timescale was not reported, so dissociation time vs cycle time is not settled.

Measures (6) published science

membrane transferred from empty to RNA-filled vesicles~25 %
RNA leakage from mixed fatty-acid vesiclesnone detected after 19 h
calcein retention>95% for at least 3 h
MgCl2 at which fatty acid vesicles aggregate and precipitate< 1.5 mM
dye leakage increase at 4 mM Mg2+ (MA:GMM 2:1)27 fold
energy captured during membrane growth as a pH gradient (membrane alone, context)~12 %

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (3)

Sits inside / holds (3)

Trades with (valence) (5)

expressed by (6)

formed against (1)

same pair (1)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

aqueous solution

  1. L1: Water carrying free fatty acid between membranes; small solutes and Mg2+ cross the fatty-acid membrane
  2. L2: Selective retention: the membrane keeps encapsulated RNA (no leakage after 19 h) and >95% of calcein for at least 3 h, while small molecules exchange
  3. L3: Retained RNA at high concentration sets an osmotic gradient; a charged genetic polymer is much more effective at driving membrane uptake
  4. L4: Tension drives uptake of fatty acid from unstressed membranes: ~25% of membrane moves from empty vesicles to RNA-containing ones, relieving the tension
  5. L5: Joint output: a compartment that keeps its RNA and grows at its neighbours' expense; genomic fitness would be translated into cellular fitness

fatty-acid bilayer membrane

  1. L1: Fatty acids, simple amphiphilic molecules, in water
  2. L2: Self-assembly: hydrophobic tails shielded from water give bilayers, vesicles and micelles
  3. L3: Permeability: Mg2+ permeates the fatty-acid membrane and equilibrates within seconds to minutes, while encapsulated RNA is retained; low divalent-cation levels can make pure fatty acids precipitate
  4. L4: Growth by incorporation of feedstock (fatty acid micelles) or of membrane taken from other vesicles
  5. L5: Multiple cycles of growth and division

sequential information (RNA genome and ribozyme)

  1. L1: RNA as genomic material: it can act as both information carrier and enzyme
  2. L2: Catalysis inside the compartment: the hammerhead ribozyme (self-cleavage or ligation) is active when encapsulated in vesicles; external Mg2+ activates its self-cleavage ([Mg2+]1/2 about 9 mM for the construct)
  3. L3: Copying: laboratory RNA polymerase ribozymes synthesise RNA from activated monomers under very specific conditions (6 nt in 1996; 14 nt for Round-18 in 2001); a self-replicating ligase ribozyme was described in 2002
  4. L4: Compartment selection: parasites that replicate on others' function are repressed if segregated from functional RNAs; compartments must grow and divide to avoid accumulating parasites
  5. L5: Genomic fitness (replicative ability) would be translated into cellular fitness

Who fills each layer

Sources (9) published science

Chen, The Emergence of Cells During the Origin of Life, Science 314, 1558-1559 (2006) (GE Prize essay; summarises Chen, Roberts & Szostak 2004)
Chen, Salehi-Ashtiani & Szostak, RNA Catalysis in Model Protocell Vesicles, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 127(38), 13213-13219 (2005) (behind its links)
Mizuuchi & Ichihashi, Primitive Compartmentalization for the Sustainable Replication of Genetic Molecules, Life 11(3), 191 (2021), doi:10.3390/life11030191 (behind its links)
Protocell (Wikipedia, rev 1376700919, 2026-09-25) (behind its links)
Error threshold (evolution) (Wikipedia, rev 1177192156, 2023-09-26) (behind its links)
RNA (Wikipedia, rev 1379398403, 2026-10-09) (behind its links)
Abiogenesis (Wikipedia, rev 1380994702, 2026-10-19) (behind its links)
Zhu & Szostak, Coupled growth and division of model protocell membranes, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 131(15), 5705-13 (2009), read via BioNumbers record 113226 (behind its links)
Ribozyme (Wikipedia, rev 1378749830, 2026-10-06) (behind its links)