← all systems · see it in The System
Competition for membrane molecules (vesicle competition)
Vesicles holding a high concentration of RNA (or rich in phospholipid) grow by taking lipid from empty ones.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: fatty acid (and phospholipid) molecules in the membranes and in solution between vesicles, the contested part of the pool; the winners' taking layer (membrane tension from an osmotic load, or the lower off-rate of a phospholipid-rich membrane) and the losers' giving layer (their relaxed membranes). Outside: what the RNA does inside, how the vesicles first formed, and division. |
| compete fns | fn:resource-denial-attrition |
| nested level | Built from lipid (pool), RNA-loaded or phospholipid-rich vesicles (winners), and empty or low-phospholipid vesicles (losers), with RNA as the osmotic driver. Embedded in an aqueous solution of fatty acids; it sits just below gate:abiogenesis, where the field says competition 'could emerge between cells' once replicators are encapsulated. |
| scale | molecular |
Measures (3) published science
| membrane transferred from empty to RNA-filled vesicles | ~25 % |
| measurement method | FRET between membrane-incorporated dyes |
| montmorillonite speed-up of vesicle formation (context) | 100 fold |
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (6) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Protocell via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for membrane molecules (vesicle competition) loss
- Lipid (amphiphile) via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for membrane molecules (vesicle competition) mixed
- RNA via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for membrane molecules (vesicle competition) gain
- Aqueous solution via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for membrane molecules (vesicle competition) even
- Empty or low-phospholipid vesicle (losing taker) via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for membrane molecules (vesicle competition) gain
- Lipid–RNA vesicle partnership via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for membrane molecules (vesicle competition) even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (2)
formed against (1)
same pair (1)
Notes published science
- The first Darwin-like contest between compartments needs no gene: RNA-filled vesicles, swollen by osmotic pressure, pull fatty acid out of empty neighbours, about a quarter of their membrane. The essay: 'this process does not require a chance increase in complexity.'
- The Szostak lab's own words: phospholipid-rich vesicles grow at the expense of poorer ones, 'suggesting the potential for an evolutionary arms race'. An arms race among bubbles, before cells.
- Its crystal twin is Ostwald ripening, the same bigger-takes-from-smaller shape in a sol. The vesicle version adds one thing: the contents, not the size, decide the winner.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
RNA sequence copying inside the vesicle
- L1: RNA strands built from nucleotide building blocks; RNA can store and replicate genetic information
- L2: Template-based replication: an RNA polymerase ribozyme synthesises RNA from an RNA template (primed template strands)
- L4: Copies made with measured fidelity (one ribozyme: 1.1% error per nucleotide); QT45 copies its complement and itself
- L5: Different sets of RNA strands had different replication outputs, raising or lowering their frequency (natural selection)
aqueous solution
- L1: Water carrying free fatty acids between membranes; fatty-acid protocells exchange small molecules and ions easily
- L2: Membrane state: tensioned (osmotically stressed) vs relaxed; phospholipid content
- L3: Contents set the tension: high RNA concentration creates the osmotic gradient
- L4: Net transfer: ~25% of membrane moves from empty to RNA-filled vesicles, relieving the tension
- L5: Outcome: loaded vesicles grow, empty ones shrink; with replicators inside, 'a primitive form of competition could emerge between cells'
osmotic pressure and membrane tension
- L1: The semipermeable membrane encapsulating solute; the osmotic gradient across it
- L2: Vesicles encapsulating high concentrations of RNA experience substantial osmotic stress: membrane tension
- L5: Uptake of fatty acid from unstressed membranes relieves the membrane tension caused by the osmotic gradient
Who fills each layer
Sources (4) published science
Protocell (Wikipedia, rev 1376700919, 2026-09-25) (behind its links)
RNA world (Wikipedia, rev 1378837125, 2026-10-06) (behind its links)