← all systems · see it in The System
Fatty acid vesicles and prebiotic amino acids/peptides
Unmodified prebiotic amino acids bind to prebiotic fatty acid membranes and a subset stabilizes membranes in the presence of salt and Mg2+; short, basic, amphipathic peptides drive RNA binding to phospholipid and fatty acid membranes. 'Vesicles can be bound and stabilized by prebiotic amino acids even while in the presence of salt ions and magnesium ions.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| asymmetry | Strong: the membrane's gain is measured (vesicles kept against Mg2+ and NaCl); the amino acid's gain (co-localization, proposed peptide synthesis) is not, and amino acids persist free either way. Benefit also depends on the amino acid: hydrophilic serine and glycine give most, hydrophobic leucine binds most but gives least. |
| boundary | Inside: decanoic acid vesicle membranes and the amino acids (or short peptides) transiently bound at their headgroups, and what passes between them (binding one way, stabilization and lamellae the other). Outside: free amino acids in bulk, salts and Mg2+ (the rivals and stressors), RNA chemistry, and peptide synthesis. |
| cheater | Leucine: binds decanoic acid vesicles more strongly than serine or glycine yet 'provides no protection against the Mg2+' and does not increase lamellarity (it does protect against NaCl). Seen, at the level of a molecule kind. |
| drive | equilibrium |
| enforcement | none |
| flips when | Peptide hydrophobicity: hydrophobic residues insert into membranes with dye leakage (Kamat 2015), so the anchor can cost the membrane its contents. Chemistry: cysteine reacting with short-chain thioesters becomes a diacyl lipid (Cho 2025), ending the amino acid as a separate partner. Salt: protection against NaCl needed a 60 C heat cycle. |
| joint output | Fatty acid vesicles that stay ~10 um and closed in 10 mM Mg2+ and re-form as discrete vesicles after 300 mM NaCl (Cornell 2019); in the peptide form, membranes with RNA held at the surface (Kamat 2015). |
| knockout | Without amino acid, 10 mM Mg2+ replaces micron-scale vesicles with punctate structures, and after a 300 mM NaCl heat cycle flocs re-form 'in solutions without amino acid' (Cornell et al. 2019). Without the membrane, amino acids simply diffuse free (single fast diffusion coefficient). |
| nested level | Built from sys:lipid (the membrane) and sys:amino-acid (the bound building blocks), each persisting apart. Embedded in salty or Mg2+-bearing aqueous solution, plausibly drying pools; sits beside sys:partnership-lipid-rna-vesicle and points at gate:abiogenesis. |
| obligate | facultative |
| partners | sys:lipid, sys:amino-acid |
| recurrence | Binding and unbinding are continuous at equilibrium; the proposed loop (binding, stabilization, more binding) and wet-dry cycling would repeat it, and stabilization persisted through one drying and rehydration, but a multi-cycle series was not reported. |
| regime | Start: amino acids and fatty acids together in salt- or Mg2+-bearing water, plausibly drying pools (natural date unknown; laboratory 2019). End: dilution does not end it (structures persist), but loss of amino acid, peptide insertion with leakage, or fusion of cysteine into lipid does. |
| saturation | Only 3-6% of the amino acid binds; stabilization does not change vesicle size (206 vs 205 nm) or critical vesicle concentration; Mg2+ and NaCl limits beyond 10 mM and 300 mM not tested. |
| scale | molecular |
| separability | High: amino acids diffuse freely on their own and decanoic acid vesicles self-assemble without them; binding is transient (only 3-6% bound at a time), so the pair never fuses into one bound state. Exception: cysteine can react with thioesters to become a diacyl lipid (Cho 2025), where the partnership ends. |
Measures (16) published science
| salt concentration above which fatty acid membranes are unstable | > 200 mM |
| Mg2+ that converts ~10 um decanoic acid vesicles into punctate structures | 10 mM |
| NaCl that flocculates decanoic acid vesicles at room temperature | 300 mM |
| amino acid concentration used for stabilization | 10 mM |
| lowest serine concentration giving a significant turbidity increase | 1.25 mM |
| persistence of elevated turbidity with 10 mM serine | at least 4 days |
| fraction of amino acid bound to vesicles (diffusion NMR) | 3 (Gly), 3 (Ser), 5 (Leu), 6 (Lys) % |
| vesicles with >=4 lamellae, without vs with serine | ~10 vs > 30 % |
| hydrodynamic diameter without vs with 10 mM serine | 206 vs 205 nm |
| leucine to decanoic acid headgroup-region distance (REDOR) | < 5 angstrom |
| heating that disaggregates NaCl flocs | 60 C |
| decanoic acid in the test solution | 50 mM |
| shortest amphipathic peptide that localizes RNA | 3 amino acids |
| peptide length that can attach RNA to a vesicle membrane | 7 or fewer amino acids |
| peptide dose in FRET screen | 1 mM at 0.13 peptide:lipid molar ratio |
| FRET threshold for hits | > 5 % increase |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (6)
- Lipid (amphiphile) via sys:aqueous-solution · Fatty acid vesicles and prebiotic amino acids/peptides gain
- Ionic solutes (e.g. NaCl) via sys:aqueous-solution · Fatty acid vesicles and prebiotic amino acids/peptides gain
- RNA via sys:electromagnetic-field · Fatty acid vesicles and prebiotic amino acids/peptides gain
- Amino acid via sys:aqueous-solution · Fatty acid vesicles and prebiotic amino acids/peptides gain
- Aqueous solution via sys:aqueous-solution · Fatty acid vesicles and prebiotic amino acids/peptides mixed
- Magnesium ion (Mg2+) via sys:aqueous-solution · Fatty acid vesicles and prebiotic amino acids/peptides gain
expressed by (3)
formed against (1)
Notes published science
- Binding is not benefit: leucine binds the membrane hardest yet gives no protection against Mg2+, while weakly bound serine and glycine save the vesicles. The 'partner' that grips tightest is the cheater.
- The vesicles remember: structures formed while amino acid was briefly concentrated persist after dilution, so a drying pool writes its history into lamellae.
- Serine stabilizes by stacking membranes, not growing them: lamellae >=4 jump from ~10% to >30% while vesicle size stays 206 vs 205 nm.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
aqueous solution
- L1: Water carrying decanoic acid (micelles and vesicles), free amino acids, NaCl and Mg2+; in drying pools concentrations rise and fall
- L2: Transient binding: amino acids near vesicles show a second, slow diffusion coefficient; 3-6% bound; hydrophobic (leucine) and positive (lysine) bind most strongly; leucine within <5 A of the headgroup region
- L3: Headgroup occupancy: Mg2+ presumably binds carboxylate headgroups; serine (side-chain hydroxyl) and glycine (amine) may block it, leucine does not
- L4: Lamellarity: serine raises vesicles with >=4 lamellae from ~10% to >30%; turbidity elevated at least 4 days, from 1.25 mM serine; structures formed at transiently high concentration persist after dilution
- L5: Joint output: ~10 um vesicles kept in 10 mM Mg2+ and discrete vesicles re-formed after 300 mM NaCl, rather than puncta or flocs
electromagnetic field
- L1: Charges: cationic arginine or histidine residues, anionic RNA phosphates, anionic oleate headgroups, zwitterionic POPC
- L2: Hydrophobic residues (phenylalanine, isoleucine, tryptophan) insert peptides into the membrane, increasing membrane area and leakage of an encapsulated dye
- L3: Membrane-bound cations make the surface potential more positive (zeta potential); tunable by pH around the imidazole pKa ~8 and by ionic strength
- L4: RNA attracted to the membrane regardless of sequence (U15 and A15 alike); more arginines and more hydrophobic residues give more localization; a minimum number of arginines needed on oleate (R3F2 yes, RF3 no)
- L5: R3F3 crosses the bilayer and localizes encapsulated RNA to the inner membrane; R3W3 instead forms RNA-lipid-peptide aggregates
heat cycle (temperature)
- L1: Temperature of the pool, cycled between about 30 and 60 C
- L2: Heating to 60 C makes salt-flocculated decanoic acid aggregates disaggregate
- L3: On cooling to 30-32 C flocs re-form without amino acids, while serine, glycine and leucine leave many discrete bright vesicles
peptide synthesis in vesicles (catalysed dipeptide)
- L1: Fatty-acid vesicles containing an encapsulated dipeptide catalyst and its substrates
- L2: The catalyst forms a second dipeptide; the catalysed synthesis is more efficient inside vesicles than in free solution
- L3: The newly formed dipeptide binds to the vesicle membrane
- L4: Membrane-bound dipeptide gives the vesicle enhanced affinity for fatty acids, so it grows
- L5: Competition: vesicles carrying the catalyst grow at the expense of others, a partial model of heritable fitness
Who fills each layer
Sources (5) published science
Protocell (Wikipedia, rev 1376700919, 2026-09-25) (behind its links)