← all systems · see it in The System
Natural resource
Natural resources are resources that are drawn from nature and used with few modifications. On Earth they include sunlight, atmosphere, water, land, all minerals, vegetation and wildlife; some are renewable (natural processes restore them at a certain rate of use), many can only be extracted once.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | contested (C-686; C-692): direct, repeated procurement of one tool stone at Jojosi from ~220 ka; earlier use embedded in other activities |
| born precision | tens of thousands of years |
| boundary | Inside: the Earth's materials and energy flows that people draw on (sunlight, air, water, land, minerals, fuels, forests, fish and other wildlife), as stocks and renewal flows, together with what makes them a resource rather than just matter: what is known of them (identified or undiscovered), whether they can be taken at a profit with today's means (reserves), and the rules over who may take them. Outside: the Earth processes that form and renew them, the people, markets and states that take and use them, and the in-use stocks, wastes and emissions they become. |
| nested level | Built from parts of the Earth system (ore and fuel deposits, aquifers, forests, fish stocks, soils, the atmosphere); runs on human society's use (a material is a resource only relative to people who can value and reach it). |
| scale | social |
Measures (22) published science
| world forest area (2020) | 4.06 billion (31 percent of land) ha |
| forest lost since 1990 | 178 million ha |
| annual deforestation 2015-2020 | 10 million (12 million in 2010-2015) ha/yr |
| forest in protected areas | 726 million ha |
| monitoring wells analysed | about 170,000 (1,693 aquifer systems) wells |
| aquifer systems deepening faster than 0.5 m per year | 12 (210 of 1,693) % |
| aquifer systems with accelerating declines | 30 (of 542 comparable) % |
| aquifer systems with declines reversed | 16 (of 542) % |
| GRACE resolution limit | >150,000 km2 |
| fish stocks in the RAM Legacy database | 882 (635 with reference points) stocks |
| harvest rate in less-managed regions vs intensively managed | 3-fold greater, half the abundance ratio |
| stock abundance at maximum sustainable yield | 30-50 of unfished abundance % |
| recovery time of overfished stocks (below 0.5 BMSY) | 10 years |
| global in-use material stocks (2010) | 792 (±5%), 23-fold since 1900 Pg |
| recycling share of inflows to stocks | 12 % |
| planetary boundaries transgressed (2023) | 6 of 9 boundaries |
| forest-cover boundary (boreal/temperate/tropical) | 85/50/85 of Holocene potential % |
| age of the largest Pilbara iron ore deposits | 1.4-1.1 Ga |
| Jojosi hornfels procurement | ~220 to ~110 ka |
| Simon-Ehrlich wager | $1000 on five minerals, 1980-1990: all five real prices fell USD |
| formation time of fossil fuels (characteristic clock of renewal) | potentially millions of years |
| studies testing Ostrom's design principles | 91 (8 principles) studies |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-662 Why did so much coal form in the Carboniferous period?
booked: The map follows the 2016 finding of always-wet tropics and wide basins as the supercontinent formed, and keeps the older idea that fungi couldn't yet break down wood alongside.
the other reading: a lag between lignin-producing plants and lignin-degrading fungi let wood pile up (the evolutionary lag hypothesis Nelsen rejects) - C-663 Are shared resources always overused (the 'tragedy of the commons')?
booked: The map keeps both: the tragedy as a pattern, and users preventing it with their own rules, which is well supported across 91 studies.
the other reading: overuse is rational and inevitable without coercion or privatisation (Hardin 1968, via the encyclopedia); users often self-organise robust institutions (Ostrom 1990; Cox et al. 2010); the common pasture never existed historically as open access (encyclopedia, critics) - C-676 How old are Australia's giant Pilbara iron ore deposits?
booked: The map uses the 2024 direct dating of 1.4-1.1 billion years, and keeps the older estimate of about 2.2-2.0 billion years alongside.
the other reading: onset ~2.2-2.0 Ga during the Great Oxidation Event (phosphate dating, ore clasts before ~1.84 Ga); the paper keeps a ~2.0 Ga, largely eroded event - C-686 Did early humans make special trips for good tool stone?
booked: The map records the South African site showing repeated special trips for one stone about 220,000-110,000 years ago, and keeps the standard model of collecting stone on the way alongside.
the other reading: the standard model: Pleistocene hominins mostly collected stone while doing other things (embedded procurement) - C-690 Do natural resources make countries poorer (the 'resource curse')?
booked: The map records the statistical link but leaves the cause open, keeping contrasting cases such as Botswana and the Congo.
the other reading: resource dependence slows growth through Dutch disease, volatility, civil war and weak institutions; endowments and booms are endogenous; some resource exporters did well (the skeptics) - C-691 Do the prices of natural resources rise or fall over the long run?
booked: The map doesn't rule. It lists the rising-price, falling-price and discovery-offset views side by side.
the other reading: prices rise at the interest rate (Hotelling 1931); real commodity prices trend down (Prebisch-Singer, structuralist school); discoveries and technology roughly counteract demand (Frankel's reading; Simon wins 1980-1990)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Atmosphere of Earth
- Soil and leaf litter
- Infiltration, groundwater and aquifers
- Mineral and ore deposits
- Fossil fuel
- Forests
- Fish stocks
- Stock building against dissipative use for extracted materials
Sits inside / holds (4)
Trades with (valence) (18)
- Sedimentary rock via sys:natural-resource · Natural resource gain
- Market and trade via sys:natural-resource · Natural resource loss
- Farming (agriculture) · Natural resource loss
- Energy via sys:chemical-energy · Natural resource loss
- Earth via sys:earth-crust · Natural resource gain
- Sun via sys:electromagnetic-field · Natural resource gain
- Water cycle (hydrologic cycle) via sys:water-cycle · Natural resource gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Natural resource mixed
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:mental-representation · Natural resource gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:law · Natural resource gain
- Mineral via sys:earth-crust · Natural resource gain
- Habitat and ecosystem via sys:biosphere · Natural resource gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:earth · Natural resource loss
- Money via sys:human-society · Natural resource mixed
- Economy via sys:earth · Natural resource loss
- Institution (social) via sys:human-society · Natural resource gain
- Fishery via sys:earth · Natural resource even
- Sustainability via sys:earth · Natural resource mixed
expressed by (17)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Templating / Standardization
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Search/Foraging
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Deterrence
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (22)
- Market and trade
- Earth
- Sun
- Water cycle (hydrologic cycle)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Law (rules and law)
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Infiltration, groundwater and aquifers
- Money
- Planetary boundaries (safe operating space)
- Maximum sustainable yield
- Groundwater monitoring-well network
- Mineral reserve
- Community resource institution
- Mineral and ore deposits
- Fossil fuel
- Forests
- Fish stocks
- Renewable resource
- Non-renewable resource
- Economy
Kinds (11)
- Fossil fuel
- Renewable resource
- Non-renewable resource
- Perpetual resource
- Biotic resource
- Abiotic resource
- Common-pool resource
- Individual (private) resources
- Community resources
- National resources
- International resources
Notes published science
- Some 220,000 years ago, early modern humans at Jojosi in South Africa kept walking to one outcrop just to get one kind of stone (hornfels), and did so for over 100,000 years; millions of their flakes still pave the ground there (src:will-2026).
- Groundwater declines sped up in 30% of the world's regional aquifers, but in 16% they reversed: in Bangkok the water table came back after pumping fees and well licences (src:jasechko-2024).
- Earth's biggest iron ores in Western Australia turn out to be up to a billion years younger than thought (1.4-1.1 billion years), and their timing tracks supercontinents assembling and breaking up, which gives prospectors a map of where to look next (src:courtney-davies-2024).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
natural resource: Earth's stocks and flows to their use (reader's view)
- L1: The Earth's materials and energy flows: sunlight, atmosphere, water, land, minerals, vegetation and wildlife
- L2: Occurrences in nature: a concentration of material in or on the crust (ore, fuel), an aquifer, a standing forest, a fish stock
- L3: What is known: identified resources (measured, indicated, inferred) and undiscovered ones (hypothetical, speculative), continuously reassessed; for living stocks, scientific stock assessment
- L4: What can be taken: reserves (economic at the time of determination); for renewables, the yield the stock can sustain (MSY reference points)
- L5: The stock-flow balance: replenishment set against consumption (renewable while recovery outpaces use; non-renewable when it does not)
- L6: Rules and value: who has the right to use (property kinds, community rules, law) and what it is worth (prices, rents, national wealth)
- L7: Its path in the world: sustainable use or depletion, development or the resource curse, within or beyond planetary boundaries
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The stock-flow balance: how fast it renews set against how fast it is taken
- L6: Rules of use: rights, boundaries, monitoring, sanctions, collective choice (community, state, private or international)
- L6: Value and rent: world prices, the economic line, resource wealth
- L7: The path of use: sustainable use or depletion, development or the resource curse, inside or outside planetary boundaries
way in: Demand and extraction (people taking)
- L1: Indirect drivers: population, economy, society, politics, technology
- L2: Extraction: any activity that withdraws resources from nature (hunting, trapping, mining, drilling, forestry)
- L3: About half of what is extracted each year builds up or renews in-use stocks
- L4: In-use stocks (buildings, infrastructure, machinery) drive long-term demand for materials and energy
way in: Fossil-fuel formation (buried organic matter)
- L1: Plant matter accumulating in everwet tropical conditions and extensive depositional systems (Paleozoic coal, Pangea assembly)
- L2: Heat and pressure turn the organic matter into fuel (coal, oil, gas), over potentially millions of years
- L3: Discovery: the discovered fraction of reserves rises through time (Hubbert's model)
- L4: Recorded reserves, which follow discoveries, world prices and the exploration industry
way in: Geologic knowledge, science and technology
- L1: New geologic knowledge and progress in science and technology
- L2: Exploration confirms undiscovered resources and reclassifies them as identified
- L3: Undiscovered resources postulated by analogy with known deposits (hypothetical, speculative)
- L4: Predictive exploration targets from the link between giant ore deposits and the supercontinent cycle
way in: Ore formation (tectonics, hydrothermal fluids, the supercontinent cycle)
- L1: Global geodynamics create and focus energy drivers, hydrothermal fluids and chemical gradients
- L2: A deposit: a concentration from which extraction is currently or potentially feasible (the largest: BIF-hosted iron ore, formed 1.4-1.1 Ga)
- L3: Identified resources, with economic, marginally economic and subeconomic parts
- L4: Reserves: the part economically extractable at the time of determination
way in: Recharge (rain into aquifers)
- L1: Precipitation and recharge; droughts reduce recharge and raise abstraction
- L2: Aquifer storage: groundwater, the primary water source for many homes, farms, industries and cities
- L3: Monitoring-well networks read groundwater levels (about 170,000 wells compiled)
- L4: Aquifer-system trend: the median of the wells' trends within each aquifer system
way in: Regrowth (living stocks reproduce)
- L1: Natural reproduction and other recurring processes replace what was used
- L2: The stock and its productivity: yield highest at 30-50% of unfished abundance
- L3: Scientific stock assessment (half the reported global marine catch is assessed)
- L4: Reference points: BMSY and UMSY
way in: Rules of access (law, rights, community institutions)
- L1: Laws and regulations that restrict categories from extraction
- L2: Boundaries: who has the right to use and who does not (Ostrom's principle 1)
- L3: Monitoring by monitors accountable to the users (principle 4)
- L4: Graduated sanctions and conflict resolution (principles 5, 6)
- L5: Collective-choice arrangements: those affected can change the rules (principle 3)
way in: Sunlight, wind and other continuous flows
- L1: Solar energy, air, wind and water: continuously available, not noticeably affected by use
- L2: Renewable energy resources: solar, geothermal, wind
way in: Valuation (why people want it)
- L1: Valued characteristics: commercial and industrial use, aesthetic, scientific and cultural value
- L2: Nature experienced through the senses, valued as psychological ecosystem services
way in: World prices and interest rates
- L1: World price of the commodity; most producers are price-takers
- L2: Hotelling arbitrage: oil left in the ground must earn the interest rate
- L3: Discoveries follow world prices and the exploration industry's productivity
- L4: The economic line: profitable extraction established or assumed with reasonable certainty
- L5: Categories reassessed with shifts in economic and political conditions
way out: Depletion and its marks on the Earth
- L1: Seawater intrusion, land subsidence, streamflow depletion, wells running dry; 178 million ha of forest lost since 1990
- L5: Groundwater declines accelerated in 30% of regional aquifers; forest lost
- L7: Use beyond renewal: depletion as a sustainable-development issue
way out: Extraction into society (raw material)
- L1: Into in-use stocks: about half of each year's extraction
- L5: Mining, drilling, fishing, forestry
- L7: Withdrawal decided: extraction produces raw material, then processed to add value
way out: Nature experienced (sights, sounds, tastes)
- L1: Stimuli from the natural world through sight, hearing, taste, touch and smell
way out: Recovery under management (stewardship)
- L1: Stocks rebuild; aquifer declines reverse; forest in protected areas (726 million ha)
- L5: Fishing pressure reduced; pumping fees and well licensing
- L6: Intensive management: stocks above target or rebuilding
way out: Rent and revenue (wealth to states and owners)
- L1: Labour and land shift out of other traded goods (Dutch disease); outcomes range from Botswana to the Congo
- L6: Royalties and tax receipts raise spending
Who fills each layer
- L7: Fishery
Sources (26) published science
Tragedy of the commons (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Frankel JA. 2010. The natural resource curse: a survey. NBER Working Paper 15836 (not peer reviewed; short sections may be quoted with credit) (behind its links)
FAO. 2020. Global Forest Resources Assessment 2020: Key findings. Rome. doi:10.4060/ca8753en (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO) (behind its links)
Richardson K. et al. 2023, Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries, Science Advances 9:eadh2458 (PMC10499318) (behind its links)
Courtney-Davies L, et al. 2024. A billion-year shift in the formation of Earth's largest ore deposits. PNAS 121. doi:10.1073/pnas.2405741121 (PMC11295007) (behind its links)
U.S. Bureau of Mines and U.S. Geological Survey. 1980. Principles of a resource/reserve classification for minerals. Geological Survey Circular 831 (public domain) (behind its links)
Non-renewable resource (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Sedimentary rock (encyclopedia, WME cache enwiki-Sedimentary_rock.md) (behind its links)
Trade (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01, version 1382043984) (behind its links)
Agriculture (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01, version 1378829864) (behind its links)
Energy (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01, version 1378442640) (behind its links)
World Commission on Environment and Development (1987) Our Common Future, Chapter 2: Towards Sustainable Development (UN document A/42/427 annex) (behind its links)
Renewable resource (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Fossil fuel (Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)