← all systems · see it in The System
Competition for disk solids (runaway and oligarchic accretion)
Larger embryos sweep up disk solids and planetesimals at the expense of smaller bodies.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the contested part of the pool (planetesimals of about 1 km and up in the disk midplane, and the smaller solids within reach) and the takers' taking layers (gravitational focusing, gas-drag capture by an extended atmosphere, collisions and mergers). Outside: the gas disk except as drag, the star, the takers' interiors (differentiation is the planet's), and dust below sticking sizes. |
| compete fns | fn:resource-denial-attrition |
| nested level | Built from planetesimals (pool and losing takers at once) and growing embryos/planets (winning takers). Embedded in the protoplanetary disk around a young star, inside a forming planetary system; it follows grain sticking and planetesimal formation and precedes the merger stage. The gas competition (sys:competition-disk-photoevaporation) runs alongside it in the same disk. |
| scale | planetary |
Measures (12) published science
| planetesimal size at onset of runaway accretion | about 1 km |
| runaway accretion duration | 10,000-100,000 (ends when largest bodies exceed ~1,000 km) years |
| formation time of Moon- to Mars-sized embryos (summary section) | 100,000-300,000 years |
| oligarchic stage duration | a few hundred thousand years |
| oligarch spacing | about 10 Hill radii |
| isolation mass, rocky planets | up to 0.1 (one Mars mass) Earth masses |
| embryos at end of oligarchic stage | about 100 count |
| surviving planets (simulations) | 2 to 5 on average count |
| embryos merged into Earth or Venus / thrown out | ~10-20 merged; an equal number ejected count |
| small bodies removed next to giants | 99 % |
| giant-core threshold for gas accretion | 5-10 Earth masses |
| pebble vs planetesimal accretion speed-up | up to 1000 times |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Gravitational field
- Planet
- Planetesimal / planetary embryo
- Protoplanetary disk (parent phase)
- Jupiter
- Dwarf planet
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (4)
- Planet via sys:gravitational-field · Competition for disk solids (runaway and oligarchic accretion) loss
- Planetesimal / planetary embryo via sys:gravitational-field · Competition for disk solids (runaway and oligarchic accretion) mixed
- Protoplanetary disk (parent phase) via sys:gravitational-field · Competition for disk solids (runaway and oligarchic accretion) gain
- Giant planets (early contestants and shapers) via sys:gravitational-field · Competition for disk solids (runaway and oligarchic accretion) loss
expressed by (3)
floor filled by (2)
Notes published science
- The rich-get-richer loop and its brake are the same pool: big bodies grow because they take first, then their own stirring of the leftovers slows them, letting smaller oligarchs catch up. The contest regulates itself into an evenly spaced field of ~100 embryos at about 10 Hill radii.
- Outcome odds from the sources: ~100 embryos go in, 2-5 planets come out; Earth and Venus each ate 10-20 embryos while an equal number were thrown out of the Solar System.
- The field's own word for the winner's end state is 'isolation': a planet that has cleared its neighbourhood orbits its star in isolation, and an oligarch's final mass is the 'isolation mass'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
collisions (contact and fragmentation)
- L1: Dust grains of rock and ice brought into contact by Brownian motion or turbulence (below about a kilometre, before self-gravity matters)
- L3: Sticking: grains collide and adhere to form ever-larger bodies; grains grow to centimetre size on thousand-year scales. The mechanics of collisions and sticking are intricate
- L4: Fragmentation: many planetesimals break apart in violent collisions (4 Vesta and 90 Antiope may have); a few of the largest survive and grow. Primitive meteorites are chunks of shattered low-mass planetesimals
- L5: Collisional grinding: leftover planetesimals (asteroids) grind each other down; debris-disk dust comes from planetesimal collisions and is removed by Poynting-Robertson drag, collisions and radiation pressure within hundreds to thousands of years
disk gas (drag)
- L1: The rotating, flattened gas of the protoplanetary disk (mostly molecular hydrogen) that solids orbit through
- L2: Gas drag: solids orbiting through gas feel a headwind; cm-to-m objects falling toward a massive body are slowed enough to spiral in. Bodies above about 1 km are not significantly affected (the planetesimal definition)
- L3: Streaming instability: drag feedback grows local concentrations that push back on the gas, so the headwind there is smaller; the concentration drifts less and isolated particles join it
- L4: Concentrations form massive filaments that fragment and collapse into planetesimals the size of the larger asteroids; gas drag in an embryo's gaseous envelope enhances its accretion
- L5: Dynamical friction from the gas disk prevents collisions between embryos; when it becomes insufficient the mergers begin. Disk dissipation (accretion, jets, photoevaporation) ends the gas floors
gravitational field
- L1: Mutual gravity of solids once a body reaches about a kilometre (smaller bodies rely on Brownian motion or turbulence to collide)
- L2: Gravitational cross-section of each body: bodies of 100-1000 km change the path of approaching rocks over several radii
- L3: Mass decides the winner: growth rate ~R^4~M^4/3 (runaway), then specific rate ~M^-1/3 (oligarchic)
- L4: Feeding zones: oligarchs spaced about 10 Hill radii by the remaining planetesimals, each growing to an isolation mass (up to 0.1 Earth mass for rocky planets)
- L5: Outcome: about 100 embryos, then chaotic mergers and ejections, leaving 2-5 planets and a belt of leftovers
Who fills each layer
- L2: TRAPPIST-1 system
- L3: Cosmic dust
- L5: Competition for the protoplanetary disk (photoevaporation vs planet building), Comet
Sources (5) published science
Planet (Wikipedia; metallicity and pulsar-planet passages) (behind its links)
Planetesimal (Wikipedia, rev 1374469069, 2026-09-12, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Protoplanetary disk (Wikipedia, rev 1372528294, 2026-09-01, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Clearing the neighbourhood (Wikipedia) (behind its links)