← all systems · see it in The System
Competition for the protoplanetary disk (photoevaporation vs planet building)
The ignited star's radiation and wind strip the disk that would-be planets need.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the contested gas of the protoplanetary disk (mostly hydrogen and helium; dust only as it is left behind), the star's taking layers (UV and X-ray heating beyond the gravitational radius, stellar wind, accretion of the inner disk, jets) and the planets' taking layer (gas accretion onto cores of 5-10 Earth masses and up). Outside: the star's interior and fusion, the solids contest except as it is shaped, and the cores' interiors. |
| compete fns | fn:resource-denial-attrition |
| nested level | Built from the disk (pool), the young star and nearby massive stars (strippers), and growing planets (gas takers). Embedded in the young stellar object's disk phase inside a star-forming cluster; it runs alongside the competition for disk solids and sets its deadline (mean disk lifetime under 10 Myr). |
| scale | planetary |
Measures (13) published science
| mean lifetime of gaseous disks (Sun-like stars) | less than 10 million years |
| classical T Tauri stage | about 10 million years |
| disk mass (classical T Tauri) | 1-3 % of stellar mass |
| accretion onto the star | 10^-7 to 10^-9 solar masses per year |
| photoevaporation overtakes viscous accretion | 10^6-10^7 years |
| gravitational radius | ~2.15 (M/Msun)/(T/10^4 K) AU |
| Jupiter formation time in current models (the winner) | about 4 million or less years |
| oldest protoplanetary disk found | 25 million years |
| disks around young stellar objects | up to roughly 3-10 Myr |
| stars with near-IR excess in the Orion Nebula Cluster | ~80 % |
| mass loss of brightest ONC proplyds vs accretion and internal photoevaporation | up to ~1e-6 vs ~1e-8 solar masses per year |
| FUV environments of discs | below 1 to about 10^7 G0 |
| lifetime of photoevaporated dusty tails (W5) | 5 or less Myr |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Star
- Planet
- Protoplanetary disk (parent phase)
- Planetary system
- Giant planets (early contestants and shapers)
- Sun
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (5)
- Planet via sys:gravitational-field · Competition for the protoplanetary disk (photoevaporation vs planet building) loss
- Star cluster (open and globular) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for the protoplanetary disk (photoevaporation vs planet building) loss
- Star via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for the protoplanetary disk (photoevaporation vs planet building) loss
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for the protoplanetary disk (photoevaporation vs planet building) mixed
- Protoplanetary disk (parent phase) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for the protoplanetary disk (photoevaporation vs planet building) mixed
expressed by (4)
floor filled by (1)
Notes published science
- The field itself uses our word: the planetesimal process 'competes against the stellar wind, which drives the gas out of the system'. And the losers have a name: ice giants are 'failed cores' that began gas accretion too late.
- Photoevaporation strips gas but leaves dust, so the dust-to-gas ratio rises: the stripper may be helping the rival's other contest (the solids), and the source says it is 'not yet clear' which way it cuts. A Compete that might be a gift.
- The disk dies by Divide & Isolate: once photoevaporation cuts a gap at the gravitational radius, the inner disk drains onto the star and the outer disk is 'very rapidly cleared'. Cut the whole, and each piece goes fast.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
disk angular momentum (turbulent viscosity)
- L1: Net angular momentum: as the collapsing nebula densifies, random gas motions average out in favour of its net angular momentum, and rotation speeds up as the radius shrinks
- L2: Turbulent viscosity: generated by macroscopic turbulence whose mechanism is not well understood; the magnetorotational instability operates in an active zone but not in the dust-shielded dead zone
- L3: Viscous stresses transport momentum to the outer disk and mass to the protostar; viscous dissipation heats the disk
- L4: Accretion is possible only if gas loses most of its angular momentum, carried away by the small part of the gas drifting outward; solar-wind shedding and magnetic braking are other proposed sinks
dust grains (solids in the disk)
- L1: Small grains of rock and ice form as the disk cools in the T Tauri stage
- L2: Photoevaporation removes mostly the light gas (H, He), raising the dust-to-gas ratio
- L3: Grains collide and stick (Brownian motion or turbulence for small bodies); observed growth to ~1 cm on thousand-year timescales
- L4: Planetesimals: a dense mid-plane dust layer collapses by collective gravitational instability, or streaming instabilities concentrate particle swarms; from ~1 km mutual gravity takes over
- L5: Dust shields the disk mid-plane from energetic radiation, making the dead zone where the magnetorotational instability stops
electromagnetic field
- L1: UV and X-ray photons from the central star and from O/B stars nearby; the effect is noticeable only with sufficient radiation strength
- L2: Disk surface gas absorbs the radiation; mostly light elements (H, He) are affected, raising the dust-to-gas ratio
- L3: The gravitational radius r_g ~ 2.15 AU (M/Msun)/(T/1e4 K): outside it gas escapes the disk's gravity; the coefficient depends on the gas's degrees of freedom (0.25 for H+ in a field to 0.125 for water)
- L4: Crossover: after 10^6-10^7 yr viscous accretion falls below photoevaporation at r_g; a gap and an inner hole form
- L5: Outcome: the outer disk is very rapidly cleared; cores that have not reached runaway gas accretion stay ice giants or smaller
external FUV field from nearby massive stars
- L1: FUV from nearby O/B stars, from below 1 to about 10^7 G0; FUV-driven winds occur only at intermediate separations from the UV source
- L2: Disc material beyond the gravitational radius is heated and lost; the wind is launched from the disc edge at supersonic velocity; EUV photons reach an ionisation front close to the disc surface
- L3: Mass loss: the brightest Orion proplyds lose up to ~10^-6 solar masses per year against ~10^-8 for accretion and internal photoevaporation; once the disc is truncated the FUV sets the loss rate
- L4: Shortened disks with dusty cometary tails (Orion, NGC 2244, IC 1396, NGC 2264); lifetimes of 5 Myr or less
gravitational field
- L1: Gravity of the star and of growing cores on disk gas
- L2: Viscous accretion: gas accreted by the protostar only if it loses most of its angular momentum, carried away by the small part drifting outward
- L3: Core mass threshold of 5-10 Earth masses to begin gas accretion; runaway after ~30 Earth masses
Who fills each layer
- L3: Jupiter
Sources (5) published science
Photoevaporation (Wikipedia, rev 1376601253, 2026-09-25, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Protoplanetary disk (Wikipedia, rev 1372528294, 2026-09-01, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)