Valence: One Force in Many Forms
The generalised effect of what is experienced, at every scale, as positive or negative interaction with other systems: what it is, how we read it, and what 1,418 readings show.
Written 26 October 2026, before we began walking each way a system takes in its world (8 November 2026). The figures below will be re-measured when the re-walks are in, and rung 13, machine minds, which now has its first walks, will be added then.
Abstract. Valence is the direction of an interaction: the push or pull one system experiences from another, and the gain or loss that follows. We hold that it is one mechanic present at every scale, changing form as it climbs: charge and colour among particles, gravity among stars, affinity among molecules, gradient-following in cells, pleasure and pain in animals, value and sanction in cultures, reward in machines. The form changes; the mechanic does not. Because the force cannot be measured directly, we read it from its two shores. Every exchange between two systems in the Evopedia graph records, for each side, the sign (attract, repel, both or neutral), what crosses (matter, energy, information, structure, momentum), the net result for that side judged against what it needs to keep being itself (gain, loss, even or mixed), and the medium that carries it. We report what 1,418 such readings across thirteen rungs show. Seven in ten exchanges read differently from the two sides, so valence is always somebody's. The sign and the outcome come apart: a system can be pulled toward what costs it. And mutual gain climbs the ladder: both sides gain in 8% of exchanges below the fold into life, 19% in the first rungs above it, and 47% among human cultures and technology. Below life, Attack reads as Compete and valence is judged from the losing side; competitions are themselves systems, 223 of them so far. Valence travels only along a shared medium, and loses fidelity with each hop away from the medium it was read in. These are observations from the live record, labelled as ours; the figures will change as more systems are walked.
Contents: About this version · The claim · The mechanic · Forms by rung · How we read it · What the readings show · Below the fold · Valence travels · Where it becomes feeling · Valence and futures · What changed · Open questions · How to read the data
About this version
The 2025 note on valence was a survey, scale by scale, of where attraction and repulsion appear in nature, from quarks to the cosmic web. It argued from other people's results. This version replaces it. The framework has since been built into an engine that walks systems one at a time by the same method and records every exchange between them from both sides, with its source. So the evidence here is our own record, read live on the day of writing. No outside paper is cited. The 2025 note's table of forms survives, rebuilt on the engine's rungs and filled with counts.
Figures as of 26 October 2026: 1,418 exchanges between 1,066 systems on 13 rungs, 202 systems walked in full; 26 mediums; 223 competitions walked as systems; 1,332 sources.
The claim
Valence is the generalised effect of what is experienced, across scales, as positive or negative interaction with other systems.
That is the whole claim, and it is a claim about a force. Not a metaphor stretched from chemistry or from psychology, but one mechanic that appears at every scale and changes its form as it goes. An electron is pulled toward a proton; a star's gas is pulled into a black hole; a cell swims up a sugar gradient; a rat shares a cagemate's distress; a court is bound by a precedent it disagrees with; a learning machine follows its reward. In each the same thing is happening: another system acts on this one, and this one is moved toward or away, and is better or worse off for it. The underlying mechanic is present in all of them. What differs is the medium it rides on and the form it takes when it arrives.
A force that changes form cannot be measured with one instrument. Gravity has a meter; so does charge; pleasure does not, and a court's compliance does not. What every form shares is that it has two shores: the system acting and the system acted on, and each is moved. So we read valence from its shores. The engine records every exchange twice, once from each side, and that double reading is how the force is measured. It is not a replacement for the force. It is the only instrument that works at every scale.
The mechanic
Strip any valenced interaction to what it must have, and four things are always there.
- Two systems and a shared medium. Nothing acts on anything except through a medium both sit on: a field, a fluid, air, a written record, a nervous system. A system with no floor on the medium is not reached. This is why sense organs match the signals in their environment, and why a predator and its prey must share a medium before either can be moved by the other.
- Something crosses. Matter, energy, information, structure or momentum passes from one to the other. The record names which: of 1,418 exchanges, matter crosses in 575, structure in 559, energy in 448, information in 320, momentum in 87 (many carry more than one).
- A pull or a push, on each side. The sign of the interaction as each system experiences it: attract, repel, both, or neutral.
- A result, on each side. Each system is better or worse off for it, judged against what that system needs to keep being itself: gain, loss, even or mixed.
The third and fourth are both valence. The sign is the force as felt in the moment: the pull toward the sugar, the recoil from the heat. The result is the force as it lands: whether following the pull served the system or cost it. They usually agree. When they do not, the disagreement is the most informative reading in the record, and we return to it below.
Forms by rung
The 2025 note arranged valence by scale: subatomic, chemical, biological, ecological, gravitational, cosmological. The engine arranges systems by rung, the floor where a kind of system first exists, and reads the same form in each. Here is the 2025 table rebuilt on rungs, with what the record holds for each.
| Rung | What is there | The form valence takes | The medium it mostly rides | Exchanges | Attract (side A) | Read differently from the two sides | Gain for both |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | universal floor | expansion against gravity | spacetime | 13 | 62% | 77% | 23% |
| 1 | spacetime, gravity, dark energy | curvature; what keeps its density wins | gravitational field | 28 | 29% | 57% | 7% |
| 2 | fields and particles | charge, colour, flavour; coupling constants | the four fields | 219 | 30% | 63% | 5% |
| 3 | nuclei and atoms | binding energy; the Pauli push; confinement | strong and electromagnetic fields | 208 | 37% | 78% | 4% |
| 4 | stars and galaxies | gravity against pressure; radiation pushing gas | gravitational field, interstellar medium | 183 | 49% | 77% | 7% |
| 5 | planets and chemistry | affinity: bonds, solubility, surfaces | aqueous solution, mineral surface | 164 | 60% | 73% | 16% |
| 6 | life | gradients followed; nutrient and toxin; the first held preference | aqueous solution, metabolite pool, electrochemical gradient | 219 | 63% | 69% | 21% |
| 7 | animals with nervous systems | approach and withdrawal; the first fast signal of good and bad | electrochemical gradient, chemical signal | 92 | 59% | 80% | 13% |
| 8 | vertebrates | pain and reward circuits; alarm shared between bodies | electrochemical gradient, water, light | 76 | 64% | 75% | 24% |
| 9 | mammals | feeling as such; distress caught from a cagemate | electrochemical gradient, mental representation | 52 | 44% | 81% | 15% |
| 10 | primates | rank, grooming, coalition | mechanical contact, light, sound | 13 | 54% | 77% | 15% |
| 11 | humans and culture | value, sanction, meaning; a rule that binds its own courts | written record, air, mental representation | 135 | 76% | 48% | 46% |
| 12 | technology | reward and loss functions; a machine's score of good and bad | written record, electromagnetic field | 16 | 69% | 44% | 56% |
Exchanges by the rung of the system they were read from, 26 October 2026. "Attract" is the share of exchanges whose first side is booked attract (the rest are repel, both or neutral). Rungs 0, 1, 10 and 12 hold few exchanges, so their percentages are not yet stable. The form and medium columns describe what the walks found, not a ruling.
Read down the third column and the claim is visible. The thing being described never changes: another system acts, this one is moved, and is better or worse for it. What changes is the carrier and the dress. Below the fold into life the forms are the physical forces and their chemistry. At the fold, a system first holds a preference, following a gradient because what lies up it keeps the system going. From rung 7 the preference gets a fast channel of its own, and from rung 9 the record starts to call it feeling. At rung 11 the force is carried by words and records, and can bind a system against its own view. At rung 12 it is written down as a function and handed to a machine.
How we read it
Every exchange in the graph carries the same fields, filled from a source the walker read. Two of them are the two shores.
| Field | What it holds | Values |
|---|---|---|
| sign, side A and side B | the pull or push as each side experiences it | attract · repel · both · neutral |
| what crosses, side A and side B | what passes from this side | matter · energy · information · structure · momentum |
| net, side A and side B | the result for this side, against what it needs to persist | gain · loss · even · mixed |
| why | the reason for the two nets, from the source, including the absent-partner state | text |
| medium and carrier | what the exchange rides on, and the particular thing that carries it | a medium system; a carrier |
| floor, side A and side B | where on each system's stack the exchange enters and leaves | a floor number |
The reading rule for the net is the one that makes valence universal: judge each side against what that system needs to keep being itself. A star needs gas; a cell needs a gradient; a court needs to dispose of repetitive suits; a rule needs carriers. Gain and loss are read against that, not against an observer's idea of good. That is what lets the same four values be booked for a neutron and for a legislature.
Six readings from the record, one from each band of the ladder:
- Rung 2, electron and neutron, through the weak field. A free neutron decays into a proton, an electron and an antineutrino. The neutron's side is repel and loss; it loses matter, energy and itself. The electron's side is neutral and gain; it is created. One event, two valences.
- Rung 4, a galaxy's gas, through gravity. Cold gas falls into the galaxy's black hole; the hole grows until its own outflow stabilises it. The hole's side is attract and gain. The galaxy's side is both and mixed: it gains stars and a hole, and can lose its cold gas and go red.
- Rung 6, the mitochondrion and its host, in water. The organelle gives ATP at about thirteen times the yield of fermentation; the host gives protection, imported proteins and supplies. Both sides attract. The host's net is gain; the organelle's is mixed: it has lost most of its genes and cannot function alone.
- Rung 8, emotional contagion and fish, in water. An injured fish's skin releases an alarm substance its shoal-mates smell. The sender is already damaged and the substance is costly; the contagion's side is repel and gain, the fish's attract and mixed. Populations with the trait survive better.
- Rung 9, emotional contagion and mammals, through nerves. Rats show distress while a cagemate is shocked, through pain mirror neurons in the cingulate cortex. The mammal's net is mixed: others serve as sentinels, at the cost of sharing their distress.
- Rung 11, precedent and the courts, through the written record. The rule saves the courts work and binds them, sometimes against their own view; lower judges may state their disagreement and must still follow. Precedent's side is attract and gain; the courts' is both and mixed.
What the readings show
1. Valence is always somebody's
Of 1,418 exchanges, 994 read differently from the two sides: seven in ten. Only 221 are gain for both, and only 11 are loss for both. The free neutron's decay is loss for the neutron and gain for the electron; the mitochondrion's bargain is gain for the host and mixed for the guest. A single reading of an interaction, from nowhere in particular, would be wrong most of the time. This is the strongest reason the engine records both shores, and it is also the reason the force can be called universal without being called the same thing everywhere: it is one mechanic, and it is experienced from a side.
2. The pull and the result come apart
Both sides are booked attract in 510 exchanges, 36% of the record, and repel on both sides in only 52. In 106 the signs oppose: one side pulled, the other pushed. And the sign does not predict the result. The galaxy is pulled to feed its hole and can lose its gas for it. The host cell is pulled to its mitochondrion and gains; the mitochondrion is pulled to its host and pays with most of its genome. A court is bound by a rule it is drawn to use. The force as felt in the moment and the force as it lands are two layers of one thing, and a system can be drawn toward what costs it. Above the fold this is where interpretation, benefit and value begin to do their work: the system that can tell the pull from the result has something to think with.
3. Mutual gain climbs the ladder
| Band | Exchanges | Gain for both sides | Read differently from the two sides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rungs 0–5, below the fold | 815 | 8% | 72% |
| Rungs 6–10, life to primates | 452 | 19% | 74% |
| Rungs 11–12, culture and technology | 151 | 47% | 48% |
Both-gain exchanges as a share of all exchanges read at each band. The top band holds the fewest readings and the most recent walks, so the number will move.
Below life, one exchange in twelve pays both sides. In the first rungs of life, one in five. Among human cultures and their technology, nearly one in two. Partnerships are built as the ladder climbs, and the systems at the top are the ones that have learned to make exchanges that pay both shores. The asymmetry drops with it: at rung 11 the two sides agree about the outcome more often than not. We record this as an observation. It may partly reflect what has been walked so far at rung 11, which is heavy in rules and institutions built to serve their members; the next walks will say.
Below the fold
Before life, nothing holds a preference, so there is no one for an interaction to be good or bad to. Yet the record books gain and loss on every rung from zero. The reading rule that makes this honest is the one for Attack and Defend below the fold. An Attack Function is tested as Compete: one system's activity pushing another's valence negative, by taking from a shared pool, stripping, starving, breaching or outpacing. It is judged from the losing side: did another system's activity cost this one what it needs to persist? Aim, target and intent are value clauses, and they are dropped. Defend is tested as Preserve: holding a persisting state against disturbance.
A massive star uses up the gas that would-be stars need. From the small star's side it is starved, out-competed by a neighbour; its valence is negative and no one meant it. Compete is usually a triangle: two systems drawing on one pool. The engine treats each triangle as a system in its own right, built from its pool and its takers, sitting on a rung no earlier than its latest part, and walked like anything else. There are 223 of them. They are the structure through which valence does most of its work below life, and they are what any model of where a neighbourhood will move has to consume.
Valence travels
Valence reaches a system only through one of its ways in: a medium it has a path on. Each system's set of ways in is its own slice of the shared world. Of 1,418 exchanges, 1,413 name their medium; the five that do not are flagged. The most-travelled are the electromagnetic field, water, gravity, the weak field, the nuclear force, and sequential information, in that order. A medium carries; it never owns the valence it carries, and it is never credited with what the systems riding it do.
Two consequences follow, and both are rules the engine works by. First, a mechanism borrowed from one system into another should come from a donor whose medium is close to the target's, because value drops with every hop away from the sensory space it was read in. A pull measured in one medium and translated into another arrives smaller and blurrier. Machine systems that manage themselves show this as engineering: a human-level value such as acceptable downtime is translated through a model into what each resource is worth, and the translation's fidelity is set by the model at the boundary. Second, who opens the door matters. From the fold into life, the receiving system builds its receptor before the signal arrives; below life nothing waits. So above the fold valence can be anticipated, and a system can lie ready for a pull that has not yet come.
Where it becomes feeling
At rung 7 the record first books a fast channel dedicated to good and bad: the nervous system, carrying approach and withdrawal in milliseconds where chemistry took minutes. At rung 8 the walks find pain and reward circuits and alarm passed between bodies. At rung 9 the word the sources use is feeling: a rat distressed by a cagemate's shock, through neurons that fire for another's pain as for its own. From here the engine draws a medium of its own for the forms valence takes in minds: mental representation, with an affect floor where the sign and strength of a feeling live apart from the tissue that hosts them. Religion, language and emotional contagion run their exchanges on it. In the newer walks, emotions and thoughts are each their own way in for a person, meeting the senses in shared upper levels.
This is the same force. The electron does not feel the proton's pull, and the rat does feel its cagemate's shock, and the difference is real. But the mechanic has not changed: another system acts, this one is moved toward or away, and is better or worse for it. One reading, ours, is that feeling is what the mechanic is like from the inside of a system complex enough to have an inside. Where feelings come from is not settled, and other theories are kept beside this one. The 2025 note put it as pleasure and pain at the human level, reward and loss in simple life, attraction and repulsion in physics. The record agrees, and adds the rungs between, with their counts.
Valence and futures
The point of reading valence from both shores is not bookkeeping. A system's neighbourhood moves in the direction its valences point, and a model of where a system is going has to consume those readings: who is being pulled toward whom, who is paying, which pools are contested, and which exchanges have been made to pay both sides. The engine's models of system futures take exactly these as input. Each both-sides reading is a valence swap, and the swaps are the currency those models trade in. The climb in mutual gain up the ladder is, read this way, a trend in what the universe's systems have learned to build.
What changed since the 2025 note
| In the 2025 note | In the record now |
|---|---|
| Valence surveyed scale by scale from other people's results | Valence read from 1,418 sourced exchanges on 13 rungs, each from both sides |
| "Metaphorical but still force-like" at the ecological scale | One mechanic at every rung, with the reading rule that makes it literal: judge each side against what it needs to persist |
| Positive and negative valence as polarity | Two layers: the sign (attract, repel, both, neutral) and the net (gain, loss, even, mixed), which can disagree |
| Gravitational valence "always attractive" | At rung 4, half of first-side readings are attract; the rest are pressure, radiation and outflow pushing back |
| Valence as a driver of emergence, asserted | Mutual gain measured at 8%, 19% and 47% across three bands of the ladder |
| Attack and competition not distinguished | Below the fold, Attack reads as Compete, judged from the losing side; 223 competitions walked as systems |
| Range and mechanism per scale | Medium and carrier named on every exchange; value drops per hop away from its medium |
Open questions
We raise a structural question only when the data gives cause. Three things in the record are worth watching rather than ruling on. The climb in mutual gain may be partly an artefact of which rung-11 systems have been walked; the re-walks now under way will test it. The "both" sign, booked on 12% of first sides, marks exchanges where a system is pulled and pushed at once; whether that is one form or several has not been asked. And whether anything is conserved across a valenced exchange, as energy and momentum are across a physical one, is a question the record cannot yet reach; it would need the same interaction read in several forms, and that is what the ladder is for.
How to read the data
Every exchange carries its source and the revision read. The sign, net and medium are our readings of what the source describes, and are labelled as analysis. The "why" field quotes or paraphrases the source for both nets, and records what happens to each side when the partner is absent. Where a source says nothing about one side's gain or loss, the net is booked even after looking, and the why says so. When you build on a reading here, check the source first.