← all systems · see it in The System
Iron-sulfur surface metabolism (mineral centres and their organic ligands)
The iron-sulfur world hypothesis proposes that early life may have formed on the surface of iron sulfide minerals: a mineral base with catalytic transition metal centers catalyzed autotrophic carbon fixation, and the organic products, retained as ligands of the metal centers, defined an autocatalytic 'surface metabolism' in which the catalytic centers became autocatalytic by being accelerated by their organic products turned ligands.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| asymmetry | The organics cannot exist here without the centres (made and held by them), while the mineral exists without the organics but is consumed as its energy source (FeS to pyrite); the mineral side carries the energy, the organic side carries the acceleration. |
| boundary | Inside: the recurring loop between catalytic transition metal centres on an iron(-nickel) sulfide base and the small organic products they make from CO, CO2, HCN and H2S, retained as ligands for a flow retention time set by their bonding strength. Outside: the hydrothermal flow that feeds and washes it, the mineral bulk, products that wash out, and later lipid membranes and cells. |
| cheater | Unseen in the sources read. Candidates by shape: products that bind too strongly and block a centre without accelerating it, or mineral surfaces that catalyse hydrolysis of what they helped condense (pyrite catalyses both). |
| drive | driven |
| enforcement | none |
| flips when | Bonding strength vs flow: products that bind too weakly wash out before they accelerate anything; too strong and they stay as one bound state (Recombination). Also no oxidant: FeS with H2S gives pyrrhotite, not pyrite, up to 300 °C (Ying et al. 2007), cutting the energy step. Lipids then move the loop off the surface into closed cells. |
| joint output | An autocatalytic surface metabolism: a proposed primitive sulfur-dependent reductive citric acid cycle; demonstrated pieces include methyl thioacetate from CO, H2S and CH3SH on NiS/FeS (0.5% yield), pyruvate, alpha-amino acids and a peptide cycle. |
| knockout | unsourced |
| nested level | Built from an iron sulfide mineral (FeS, NiS, pyrite) and surface-bound small organics, in water; embedded in a volcanic hydrothermal flow (Wächtershäuser: about 100 °C, high pressure) or the micro-caverns of an alkaline vent (Martin and Russell). Below the first fold (epoch 5); proposed as the start of 'early evolution', feeding cellularization and gate:abiogenesis. |
| obligate | obligate |
| partners | sys:iron-sulfide-mineral, sys:surface-metabolite |
| recurrence | Continuous while the flow runs: each product that binds accelerates the next round of catalysis ('accelerated catalysts expanded the metabolism and new metabolic products further accelerated the catalysts'). The closed cycle itself is proposed, not shown. |
| regime | Start: proposed for the Hadean, before life (not dated in the sources read). End: cellularization, where lipid membranes anchored to the mineral base become self-supporting and closed cells leave the base; a fusion-type end, since the metal sulfide centres reappear inside enzymes (Ni-Fe-S clusters of CO dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase). |
| saturation | Unsourced as a ceiling; bounded by mineral surface area and the flow retention time; experimental yields are low (acetate 0.5%, tripeptides 0.10%). |
| scale | molecular |
| separability | Medium-low: the two are different kinds (mineral bulk vs small organics) with different turnover (organics wash out on a flow retention time; FeS is converted to pyrite), but while they work together the organics sit on the metal centres as ligands, i.e. inside one coordination bond, and the source calls the whole one 'pioneer organism' with a composite structure. |
Measures (14) published science
| pioneer organism setting (volcanic hydrothermal flow) | 100 °C (at high pressure) |
| Wächtershäuser's series of articles | 1988 to 1992 years |
| acetate yield, Huber and Wächtershäuser thioester experiment | 0.5 % (based on CH3SH input) |
| CH3SH input in that experiment | 8 mM |
| CO in that experiment | 350 mM |
| CH3SH and CO in that experiment vs highest measured in natural vent fluid | about 500 and 3700 times |
| dipeptide yield, sulfide experiments in water | 0.4 to 12.4 % |
| tripeptide yield, same conditions | 0.10 % |
| FeS (mackinawite) to pyrite with H2S without oxidant (Ying et al. 2007) | not possible up to 300 °C (gives pyrrhotite instead) |
| mackinawite reduces CO2 to CO (Farid et al.) | above 300 °C |
| reverse Krebs cycle intermediates promoted by Fe, Zn2+ and Cr3+ in acidic conditions | 6 of 11 intermediates |
| iron-sulfur carbon fixation (CO2 with H2S) | neutral pH, 100 °C |
| off-ridge alkaline vents vs black smokers | about 100 vs about 350 °C |
| life most likely emerged | 4.32 to 3.48 Gya |
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (7) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Amino acid via sys:aqueous-solution · Iron-sulfur surface metabolism (mineral centres and their organic ligands) gain
- Hydrothermal vent (alkaline, Lost City type, with black-smoker variants) via sys:aqueous-solution · Iron-sulfur surface metabolism (mineral centres and their organic ligands) gain
- Iron(-nickel) sulfide minerals (mackinawite, greigite, pyrite) at alkaline vents via sys:aqueous-solution · Iron-sulfur surface metabolism (mineral centres and their organic ligands) gain
- Lipid (amphiphile) via sys:aqueous-solution · Iron-sulfur surface metabolism (mineral centres and their organic ligands) gain
- Surface-bound small organic metabolites via sys:aqueous-solution · Iron-sulfur surface metabolism (mineral centres and their organic ligands) gain
- Hydrogen sulfide via sys:aqueous-solution · Iron-sulfur surface metabolism (mineral centres and their organic ligands) gain
- Ammonia via sys:electromagnetic-field · Iron-sulfur surface metabolism (mineral centres and their organic ligands) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
- Iron(-nickel) sulfide minerals (mackinawite, greigite, pyrite) at alkaline vents
- Surface-bound small organic metabolites
- Competition for vent precursor chemicals between surface chemical communities
Sits inside / holds (4)
- Iron(-nickel) sulfide minerals (mackinawite, greigite, pyrite) at alkaline vents
- Aqueous solution
- Hydrothermal vent (alkaline, Lost City type, with black-smoker variants)
- Alkaline hydrothermal vent
expressed by (6)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
floor filled by (1)
Notes published science
- The catalyst is fed by its own products: metal centres 'became autocatalytic by being accelerated by their organic products turned ligands'. A loop where the output becomes part of the machine.
- Retention by bonding strength is a selection rule before genes: what binds long enough to the mineral stays in the game, set by 'flow retention time in correspondence with their mineral bonding strength'.
- The mineral partner never fully leaves: nickel-iron-sulfur clusters still sit in the reaction centres of carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase, the key enzyme of the Wood-Ljungdahl pathway LUCA probably used.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
electrons from the mineral into carbon and nitrogen (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Electron transfer between redox couples: a single electron usually flows from the species being oxidised to the one being reduced
- L2: FeS and H2S as reducing agents: both are oxidised as the S-S disulfide bond forms in pyrite (FeS + H2S -> FeS2 + 2 H+ + 2 e-, or + H2)
- L3: Catalytic transition metal centres in the mineral base (mainly iron and nickel, perhaps also cobalt, manganese, tungsten and zinc) where the gases are fixed
- L4: Reducing power spent on carbon and nitrogen: CO2 reduction on FeS (mackinawite reduces CO2 to CO above 300 C); ammonia formed from nitrate with FeS/H2S as reductant; 15N2 fixed in conjunction with pyrite formation
hydrothermal water and the mineral surface it flows over (aqueous solution)
- L1: Volcanic hydrothermal flow at high pressure and about 100 °C carrying CO, CO2, HCN and H2S
- L2: FeS and H2S as reducing agents with pyrite formation: FeS + H2S -> FeS2 + 2 H+ + 2 e- (or + H2); the water-gas shift CO + H2O -> CO2 + H2 also runs in volcanic fluids
- L3: Organic products retained on or in the mineral base as ligands of the Fe/Ni centres, with a flow retention time set by mineral bonding strength (charge-mediated anionic bonding, preprint)
- L4: Ligand-accelerated catalysts close a cycle: a primitive sulfur-dependent reductive citric acid cycle (proposed); CO + H2S + CH3SH on NiS/FeS gives methyl thioacetate, an activated acetic acid analogue of acetyl-CoA
- L5: Joint output: ever more complex organic compounds, pathways and catalytic centres; amino acids and a peptide cycle; primitive lipids that lipophilize the base and then form membranes anchored to it (a semi-cell)
lipids gathering on the mineral into a membrane (hydrogen-bond network)
- L1: Water, in which amphiphiles self-assemble into micelles, lamellae and membranes
- L3: Primitive lipids made in the surface metabolism accumulate on or in the mineral base
- L4: Lipid membranes form; amphiphilic phospholipids in water self-assemble into a two-layered sheet with the tails inside, driven by the hydrophobic effect
- L5: While still anchored to the mineral base the membranes make a semi-cell, bounded partly by the mineral base and partly by the membrane
- L6: Further lipid evolution gives self-supporting membranes and closed cells; the earliest are pre-cells that allow frequent exchange of genetic material
Who fills each layer
- L2: Iron(-nickel) sulfide minerals (mackinawite, greigite, pyrite) at alkaline vents, Hydrogen sulfide
Sources (4) published science
Abiogenesis (Wikipedia, rev 1380994702, 2026-10-19) (behind its links)
Alternative abiogenesis scenarios (Wikipedia, rev 1376838071, 2026-09-26) (behind its links)