← all systems · see it in The System
Mixed-species biofilm cross-feeding (syntrophy)
Syntrophy, syntrophism, or cross-feeding is the cooperative interaction between at least two microbial species to degrade a single substrate, typically by the transfer of one or more metabolic intermediates between metabolically diverse species living in close proximity.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| asymmetry | Strong: the fermenter cannot run its step without the sink (obligate, 'obligatory interdependency'), while hydrogen-consuming organisms include methanogens, sulfate reducers and acetogens, so the sink side has alternatives; under standard conditions the methanogen's reaction carries most of the free energy. |
| boundary | Inside: the recurring transfer of metabolic intermediates (H2, formate, electrons; shared siderophore-iron) between two or more metabolically diverse species in close proximity, and the joint degradation it makes possible. Outside: each partner's own metabolism and regulation (the cells), the matrix that holds them (the biofilm), and outside takers such as siderophore non-producers. |
| cheater | Siderophore non-producers: cells that produce little to no siderophores yet take up the iron complexes (P. aeruginosa within a species; in mixed communities, microbes that utilize xenosiderophores made by others). No cheater of the H2 loop itself is described in the sources read. |
| drive | driven |
| enforcement | unknown |
| flips when | Hydrogen partial pressure rises (removal fails), stopping fermentation; for the siderophore loop, iron limitation and non-producer frequency rise until cheaters outcompete producers; in dense communities cheaters are fitter (yeast invertase case). In eukaryogenesis models, rising oxygen strengthened a syntrophy until one partner engulfed the other. |
| joint output | Degradation of a single substrate neither partner completes alone: ethanol to acetate and methane (co-culture dG0' -113 kJ per reaction); likewise propionate, butyrate, benzoate, amino acids and oil hydrocarbons in other pairs. |
| knockout | Fermentation of these organic compounds cannot occur in fermenting microorganisms unless the hydrogen concentration is reduced to a low level by the methanogens (src:wp:syntrophy). |
| nested level | Built from two or more cell species (here a proton-reducing fermenter and an H2-consuming methanogen) through the aqueous medium; embedded in the biofilm (a 'syntrophic community') or other anoxic settings (rumen, sediments, digesters). Sits at the first fold into life (epoch 6). |
| obligate | mixed |
| partners | sys:syntrophic-fermenter, sys:methanogen |
| recurrence | Continuous: every turn of the fermenter's metabolism releases H2 that the methanogen removes, for as long as substrate flows. |
| regime | Start: not dated in the sources read (biofilms, the usual container, from about 3.25 Gya). End: substrate exhaustion or H2 build-up; collapse of public-good production under cheating; or fusion by engulfment (proposed in syntrophic models of eukaryogenesis), where the partnership ends as a transition. |
| saturation | Unsourced as a ceiling; the shared energy is bounded by the coupled reaction (-113 kJ per reaction under standard conditions) and the reactions run close to thermodynamic equilibrium. |
| scale | cellular |
| separability | High: two species, a bacterium and an archaeon, each a cell with its own membrane and division; Methanobacillus omelianskii was regarded as a pure culture until it turned out to consist of two organisms. Dissociation time vs cycle time not given in the sources read. |
Measures (8) published science
| organism S alone (2 ethanol + 2 H2O to 2 acetate + 2 H+ + 4 H2) | +9.6 kJ per reaction (dG0') |
| methanogen M.o.H (4 H2 + CO2 to methane + 2 H2O) | -131 kJ per reaction (dG0') |
| co-culture (2 ethanol + CO2 to 2 acetate + 2 H+ + methane) | -113 kJ per reaction (dG0') |
| propionate oxidation with formate release | +65.3 kJ/mol (dG0') |
| butyrate oxidation with formate release | +38.5 kJ/mol (dG0') |
| earliest biofilms in the fossil record | about 3.25 billion years ago |
| hydrogen hypothesis of eukaryogenesis (Martin and Mueller) | 1998 year |
| E. coli cheater/cooperator microfluidic patch | 8500 x 100 x 15 micrometres |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (1) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Mixed-species biofilm cross-feeding (syntrophy). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- who opens the door (structural)
a port installed ahead of time: the methanogen's H2 uptake (hydrogenase), which keeps the H2 partial pressure low enough for the coupled reaction
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (6) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell) via sys:aqueous-solution · Mixed-species biofilm cross-feeding (syntrophy) gain
- Cell via sys:aqueous-solution · Mixed-species biofilm cross-feeding (syntrophy) loss
- Biofilm via sys:aqueous-solution · Mixed-species biofilm cross-feeding (syntrophy) gain
- Syntrophic fermenter (partner species, a cell) via sys:aqueous-solution · Mixed-species biofilm cross-feeding (syntrophy) gain
- Methanogen (partner species, a cell) via sys:aqueous-solution · Mixed-species biofilm cross-feeding (syntrophy) gain
- Methane (CH4) via sys:aqueous-solution · Mixed-species biofilm cross-feeding (syntrophy) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (7)
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
floor filled by (3)
formed against (1)
same pair (1)
slides to (1)
Notes published science
- Methanobacillus omelianskii was taken for a single pure-culture organism until it turned out to be two: a bacterium and a methanogenic archaeon. A partnership so tight it passed as one identity.
- The fermenter's step is uphill (+9.6 kJ) and only runs because the partner pulls hydrogen away (-131 kJ); together the co-culture is downhill (-113 kJ). The joint output is literally a sign flip of free energy.
- Syntrophic models of eukaryogenesis read this same partnership shape as the road to the eukaryotic cell: dependence deepens until one partner engulfs the other. Fusion, the partnership's end, as a major transition.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
biofilm spatial structure
- L1: EPS matrix holding species in close proximity; some biofilms have water channels that distribute nutrients and signalling molecules
- L4: Psl exopolysaccharide trails left by cells guide later cells' exploration and microcolony formation in P. aeruginosa biofilms
- L6: In a spatial setting interactions are local and cheaters are segregated, so cooperators and cheaters can coexist; limited dispersal (population viscosity) keeps relatives together so help goes to kin
diffusing metabolic intermediates (aqueous solution)
- L1: EPS hydrogel, many times its dry weight in water; species living in close proximity; the matrix traps extracellular enzymes as an external digestion system
- L2: The fermenter oxidises the substrate (2 ethanol + 2 H2O to 2 acetate + 2 H+ + 4 H2); reverse electron transport is prominent in syntrophic metabolism
- L3: Interspecies hydrogen transfer, interspecies formate transfer, or direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET, as in Geobacter with Methanosaeta or Methanosarcina)
- L4: The methanogen consumes H2 (4 H2 + CO2 to methane + 2 H2O), keeping the partial pressure low, turning the positive Gibbs free energy into negative
- L5: Joint output: the single substrate degraded to acetate and methane; in other pairs complete mineralisation of alkanes, benzoate and amino acids
direct interspecies electron transfer (conductive contact)
- L1: Electron transfer without any electron carrier such as H2 or formate, reported in co-cultures of Geobacter metallireducens with Methanosaeta or Methanosarcina
- L2: Donor side: two porin-cytochrome complexes (PccF, PccG) in Geobacter were important for DIET, and electrically conductive pili were needed in co-culture with Methanosarcina acetivorans
- L3: Acceptor side: an outer-surface c-type cytochrome serves as the electrical connect in M. acetivorans and M. subterranea; M. barkeri lacks outer-surface c-type cytochromes, and having them does not by itself confer DIET capacity
- L5: The electron-accepting partner strongly affects the donor's physiology: conductive pili are needed with M. acetivorans but not with M. barkeri, and PccG matters more with Methanosarcina
siderophore-iron exchange
- L1: Released siderophores sequester scarce iron and form a complex; the compounds are not restricted to their producer
- L3: The Fe(III)-siderophore complex is recognised by cell-specific outer-membrane receptors; in Gram-negative bacteria TonB-dependent receptors bring it into the periplasm and ABC transporters into the cytoplasm
- L4: Release inside: the complex is usually reduced to Fe2+, which has little affinity for the ligand; catecholates such as ferric-enterobactin need enzymatic degradation
- L5: In Pseudomonas aeruginosa the pyoverdine synthesis pathway is regulated by quorum sensing, which coordinates behaviour by population density
- L6: As long as an organism has a receptor for the siderophore-Fe(III) complex it can take it up; cheaters that skip production can outcompete cooperators and lower group fitness